To ask the Scottish Executive whether there will, as a matter of urgency, be a presumption against school closures. (S2O-02170)
Official Report · Chamber
School Closures
Health and Community Care General Questions
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Peter Peacock Lab 7
- Christine Grahame SNP 4
- George Reid 4
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
- Susan Deacon Lab 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
- Rhona Brankin Lab 1
The record
20 contributionsLocal authorities have a duty to consult fully on any school closure proposals and must take responses to consultations into account before coming to decisions for which they will be held locally accountable. There is guidance on such matters and I have made it clear that authorities should apply a test of proportionate advantage to such proposals.
As the minister is aware, there is a presumption against the closure of primary schools in England. All proposed closures must be referred to the minister, under guidance from 1999. The Scottish guidance is dated 1988. Does the minister recall his written answer on this issue in 1999? When asked whether he had any plans to change the criteria under which proposed closures of rural schools were referred to ministers, he said:
"We have no such plans."—[Official Report, Written Answers, 2 July 1999; S1O-133.]
In a written answer five years later, he said:
"we will prepare guidance".—[Official Report, Written Answers, 1 April 2004; S2O-1886.]
Given that it took five years to reach that point, and given that 11 schools in the Borders and Midlothian are under threat of closure, will the minister declare a moratorium in case another five years pass before we see the guidance?
"We have no such plans."—[Official Report, Written Answers, 2 July 1999; S1O-133.]
In a written answer five years later, he said:
"we will prepare guidance".—[Official Report, Written Answers, 1 April 2004; S2O-1886.]
Given that it took five years to reach that point, and given that 11 schools in the Borders and Midlothian are under threat of closure, will the minister declare a moratorium in case another five years pass before we see the guidance?
I have made it clear in the past that decisions on closures are essentially local decisions. It is increasingly clear that the SNP does not support local democracy or the ability of people to make decisions locally. It is remarkable that Christine Grahame makes the proposition that she does. She is prone to waving bits of newspaper about, so I will reciprocate. I have here a headline from The Press and Journal on a ban on rural school closures that John Swinney announced as part of SNP policy at a recent conference of the Countryside Alliance. However, I have another piece of paper that has a headline from the Brechin Advertiser—for those members who do not know, Brechin is in Angus—about the closure of a school. Angus Council is controlled by the Scottish National Party. It is a pity that, when John Swinney promised the Countryside Alliance that he would not close schools, he did not tell it that his own members were closing schools in Angus.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Just occasionally, it is possible to have a second supplementary.
The position is that the minister has a responsibility. He has said that he will issue guidance for local authorities. Scotland is already 10 years behind England. There have been few closures in England, but there have been 35 closures in Scotland per year.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question.
The rural school is the heart of the community. The minister should be ashamed that, five years on, he has had to change his mind—and he still has not delivered the guidance.
It is interesting that the SNP increasingly looks to England for inspiration on educational policy. I repeat what I have said in the past: such decisions are difficult. They require to be taken and to be given proper weight locally. We should not listen to what the SNP says but should look at what it does with the limited opportunities that it has for power in Scotland.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. I might be mistaken, but I think that Ms Grahame had a second supplementary question. How appropriate was that, given that other members are waiting to ask questions?
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Second supplementary questions are allowed at my discretion; I use them very sparingly and I use my judgment on when to allow them.
Does the minister agree that a primary school plays a huge part in the local community in urban as well as rural settings? Does he acknowledge that there are significant concerns in many city areas—including some within my constituency—about the prospect of losing a local primary school? Furthermore, does he agree that, although capacity and cost are factors that affect local authorities' decisions in such matters, educational, social and safety considerations must be paramount? Can he assure us that he will work with local authorities to ensure that that is the case?
I am happy to respond to that. Susan Deacon makes the good point that any primary school is a big part of any community in Scotland. That is the case almost by definition. I recognise that parents have concerns about such matters. That is why I am particularly keen that local authorities are clear with their communities about the considerations that they must take into account in arriving at what are very difficult decisions.
Parents often think that purely financial motives drive the process but, as well as weighing up the possible financial benefits, authorities should consider the potential impact of the closure of a school on the community. They should examine how it would affect the community's fabric and the services that it receives and take into account the educational impacts on individual children and the wider social impacts. That is where the test of proportionate advantage—which Brian Wilson talked about when he was an education minister and which I am keen to continue to promote—is important. It allows that set of considerations to be properly balanced in public so that parents can see what is happening and councillors can come to proper decisions.
Parents often think that purely financial motives drive the process but, as well as weighing up the possible financial benefits, authorities should consider the potential impact of the closure of a school on the community. They should examine how it would affect the community's fabric and the services that it receives and take into account the educational impacts on individual children and the wider social impacts. That is where the test of proportionate advantage—which Brian Wilson talked about when he was an education minister and which I am keen to continue to promote—is important. It allows that set of considerations to be properly balanced in public so that parents can see what is happening and councillors can come to proper decisions.
Does the minister accept that there is a case for strong, updated guidance that supports rural schools that are viable not just because they are centres of educational excellence, but because it would be a tragedy to rip the heart out of small, fragile rural communities?
That point is very emotive, although I understand why people make it. In rural areas, it is often the case that small rural schools are amalgamated within a rural context and that the amalgamated school continues to sustain the wider rural community. Patterns of population change are a fact of life. We are experiencing the biggest decline in school populations that any of us has seen. In some parts of Scotland, the school population will decline by up to 40 per cent over the coming decade. That means that it is necessary to consider the proper way in which to sustain education in the long term, which is in all children's interests.
I have made clear that I regard the test of proportionate advantage to be important. I will be happy to illustrate that more fully for local authorities. As we move forward, I will help them to understand the requirements that we support in applying such tests in individual circumstances. I remind Lord James Douglas-Hamilton that the guidance that we are operating was brought in by his Government in 1981 and that he did not choose to change it while he was education minister.
I have made clear that I regard the test of proportionate advantage to be important. I will be happy to illustrate that more fully for local authorities. As we move forward, I will help them to understand the requirements that we support in applying such tests in individual circumstances. I remind Lord James Douglas-Hamilton that the guidance that we are operating was brought in by his Government in 1981 and that he did not choose to change it while he was education minister.
I want to build on that theme. The parents of the children at the schools in my constituency that are faced with closure, which are in the Borders and Midlothian, have told me that they want the issue to be considered on a non-partisan basis. They want parents to be involved all the way through the process, they want wider consideration of the rural areas and they want any issue to do with schooling to be considered on educational grounds. Will the minister meet me and some parents who are genuinely interested in exploring opportunities with his department and the Environment and Rural Affairs Department, so that there is proper co-ordination in dealing with the fragile rural communities that I represent?
I would be happy to meet Jeremy Purvis. I hesitate to widen the invitation, because he will appreciate that there are many instances like the one to which he refers throughout Scotland. I am happy to meet members of Parliament to discuss issues in their constituencies without necessarily widening the invitation to include parents.
The key point is that local authorities should consider properly the issues at local level and pick up the points that Jeremy Purvis and others have made today, and that he has made previously. We take these matters seriously. I am happy to ensure that in the work that we do to illuminate for local authorities what we expect of them, we build in issues about sustainable rural communities and the Executive's wider agenda.
The key point is that local authorities should consider properly the issues at local level and pick up the points that Jeremy Purvis and others have made today, and that he has made previously. We take these matters seriously. I am happy to ensure that in the work that we do to illuminate for local authorities what we expect of them, we build in issues about sustainable rural communities and the Executive's wider agenda.
I welcome the minister's comments. I seek reassurance that when the new guidance is published it will refer specifically to rural schools, because the existing guidance relates to every school.
Generally, guidance that we issue on education matters applies to all schools. However, in relation to the point that I have just made to Jeremy Purvis, we are keen to have joined-up policies in the Executive and to ensure that the Education Department is working in tune with Ross Finnie's department on sustainable rural policies. Therefore, by definition, any circulars that we issue to further illuminate how we want things to be done will have to refer to the rural dimension of life and to sustainable rural communities.
George Reid
The Presiding Officer · Ochil
link
Question 4 is withdrawn.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Apr 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 April 2004 Debate · 1
- European Union Constitution Debate · 176
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Sustainable Scotland (Cabinet Sub-committee) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Prisons (Sanitation) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Hepatitis C (Ex Gratia Payments) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Identity Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Sustainable Development Strategy Questions · 6
- Deer (Culls) Questions · 8
- Peatlands (Damage) Questions · 8
- Environmental Justice Questions · 8
- Climate Change Questions · 4
- Outdoor Access Code Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Waiting Times (General Practitioners) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Decentralisation) Questions · 6
- Diabetes Questions · 6
- Ambulance Service (Call-out Rates) Questions · 6
- Maternity Services (Oban) Questions · 17
- Health and Community Care Questions · 1
- Amateur Sports Clubs (Rates Relief) Questions · 4
- School Closures Questions · 20
- Small Claims (Limits) Questions · 4
- Sport for All Questions · 6
- Homelessness Questions · 4
- Scottish Executive (Public Relations) Questions · 4
- Reducing Reoffending Debate · 63
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 39
- TransBus International (Jobs) Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.