To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will direct the Deer Commission for Scotland to suspend any further mass cull of deer and from whom it has sought advice on the issues involved, other than its own advisers and the Deer Commission for Scotland. (S2O-2148)
Official Report · Chamber
Deer (Culls)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Environment and Rural Development
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 4
- Fergus Ewing SNP 2
- Jamie McGrigor Con 1
- Nora Radcliffe LD 1
The record
8 contributionsMinisters will consider shortly a report on the conduct of the recent culls at Glen Feshie and in particular the role of the Deer Commission for Scotland. This follows a meeting with the Scottish Gamekeepers Association. The report will draw on advice from a number of sources including the state veterinary service and the Food Standards Agency Scotland.
We shall be reflecting on the conclusions that are to be drawn in the light of that report. However, given the statutory obligation that is placed on the Deer Commission for Scotland by the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 to take action where it is satisfied that serious damage could be caused to agriculture, woodlands or the natural heritage, or where there is a risk to public safety, the options available are unlikely to include the ordering of a suspension of culling.
We shall be reflecting on the conclusions that are to be drawn in the light of that report. However, given the statutory obligation that is placed on the Deer Commission for Scotland by the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 to take action where it is satisfied that serious damage could be caused to agriculture, woodlands or the natural heritage, or where there is a risk to public safety, the options available are unlikely to include the ordering of a suspension of culling.
I think that the minister is aware that nearly 900 deer have been culled in Glen Feshie, partly under the use of emergency powers. I think that he is also aware of possible further culls that are planned in other areas of the Scotland. The issue has raised serious concerns about whether the culling was carried out in a proper and humane way.
Can I put to the minister a suggestion that I intimated to the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development last week for a way to break the impasse between the Deer Commission and the Scottish Gamekeepers Association? I suggest that the minister appoints a committee, comprised of three people, one of whom would be nominated by the Scottish Gamekeepers Association, another of whom would be nominated by the Deer Commission and the third of whom would be an independent person nominated by the minister after consultation and who would act as a chair. The committee would have the remit of examining what happened at Glen Feshie, the lessons to be learned and the issue of deer management. Will the minister give serious consideration to that suggestion as a means of breaking the logjam on this issue, which is of great concern to many people in Scotland?
Can I put to the minister a suggestion that I intimated to the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development last week for a way to break the impasse between the Deer Commission and the Scottish Gamekeepers Association? I suggest that the minister appoints a committee, comprised of three people, one of whom would be nominated by the Scottish Gamekeepers Association, another of whom would be nominated by the Deer Commission and the third of whom would be an independent person nominated by the minister after consultation and who would act as a chair. The committee would have the remit of examining what happened at Glen Feshie, the lessons to be learned and the issue of deer management. Will the minister give serious consideration to that suggestion as a means of breaking the logjam on this issue, which is of great concern to many people in Scotland?
I recognise the constructive contributions that Fergus Ewing has made to the consideration of this matter, but regret his tendency to refer to the situation as a "mass cull." If he examines the numbers, he will agree that a comparison between the number of deer that have been culled during the process that we are discussing and the 700,000 or so deer that are culled each year demonstrates that he is displaying a slightly hyperbolic tendency. However, he has made a serious contribution.
As I said in my original answer, I want to see the report that we have called for. That report will inform me and other ministers of the nature of the cull and, in particular, will address some of the issues that have been raised about how that cull was carried out. I look forward to advice from the veterinary people and from the Food Standards Agency.
Once I have reflected on that, Fergus Ewing's suggestion will still be on the table. I can undertake only to consider it along with the options that I have for responding to the findings of the report. I am anxious that the statutory obligations of the Deer Commission, given to it under the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996, be carried out properly. It is important that ministers are satisfied of that.
As I said in my original answer, I want to see the report that we have called for. That report will inform me and other ministers of the nature of the cull and, in particular, will address some of the issues that have been raised about how that cull was carried out. I look forward to advice from the veterinary people and from the Food Standards Agency.
Once I have reflected on that, Fergus Ewing's suggestion will still be on the table. I can undertake only to consider it along with the options that I have for responding to the findings of the report. I am anxious that the statutory obligations of the Deer Commission, given to it under the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996, be carried out properly. It is important that ministers are satisfied of that.
Does the minister agree that red deer herds are an important and historic part of Scottish national heritage and that deerstalking and deer watching bring in money for tourism? Does he agree that this noble animal should not be reduced to the status of vermin because some people want to save money on fencing?
If I thought that Fergus Ewing was indulging his hyperbolic tendency, Mr McGrigor is most certainly indulging his. Mr McGrigor should be careful when talking about the occasions on which the Deer Commission uses its emergency powers and the level to which it uses them. It does not do so frequently. The Deer Commission spends a great deal of its time trying to engage with landowners to arrange management agreements for the maintenance of sensible numbers of deer consistent with our environment, bearing in mind the danger to that environment that deer can pose.
There is no suggestion that the Deer Commission, or myself and other ministers, do not regard deer as being an important species. To say that we or the Deer Commission regard them as vermin is wide of the mark. If the conditions in the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 for imposing a cull are met, that is a different matter. Mr McGrigor should be careful that he does not go too far on that matter.
There is no suggestion that the Deer Commission, or myself and other ministers, do not regard deer as being an important species. To say that we or the Deer Commission regard them as vermin is wide of the mark. If the conditions in the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 for imposing a cull are met, that is a different matter. Mr McGrigor should be careful that he does not go too far on that matter.
Is the minister content that there are mechanisms in place to ensure that any deer carcase that has not been gralloched immediately will be condemned as being unfit for human consumption?
That important point is why, in calling for a separate report, we have sought not only veterinary advice but the advice of the Food Standards Agency. We wish to be informed as to how the cull was carried out and how the animals were transported. That will be an important consideration in assessing the impact of that cull.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Apr 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 April 2004 Debate · 1
- European Union Constitution Debate · 176
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Sustainable Scotland (Cabinet Sub-committee) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Prisons (Sanitation) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Hepatitis C (Ex Gratia Payments) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Identity Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Sustainable Development Strategy Questions · 6
- Deer (Culls) Questions · 8
- Peatlands (Damage) Questions · 8
- Environmental Justice Questions · 8
- Climate Change Questions · 4
- Outdoor Access Code Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Waiting Times (General Practitioners) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Decentralisation) Questions · 6
- Diabetes Questions · 6
- Ambulance Service (Call-out Rates) Questions · 6
- Maternity Services (Oban) Questions · 17
- Health and Community Care Questions · 1
- Amateur Sports Clubs (Rates Relief) Questions · 4
- School Closures Questions · 20
- Small Claims (Limits) Questions · 4
- Sport for All Questions · 6
- Homelessness Questions · 4
- Scottish Executive (Public Relations) Questions · 4
- Reducing Reoffending Debate · 63
- Business Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 39
- TransBus International (Jobs) Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.