Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Prisons (Sanitation)

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 29 April 2004 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
To ask the First Minister how the Scottish Executive will respond to the legal judgment regarding sanitation in prisons. (S2F-844)

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
We have received Lord Bonomy's judgment on the petition of Robert Napier against Scottish ministers and we are considering it carefully.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
Does the First Minister agree that those whom we incarcerate for their crimes should be held in humane conditions in our prisons and that it is harder to rehabilitate prisoners who are held in overcrowded conditions with no sanitation for up to 23 hours a day? Does he believe that a balance has to be struck, as the victims of crime are struggling to understand the judgment, which could mean that more prisoners may be entitled to compensation although there are other priorities? Will he assure Parliament that at least progress will be made on ending slopping out in Scottish prisons because it is the right thing to do? Will he also note the view of Her Majesty's prisons inspectorate for Scotland that overcrowding in our prisons causes more damage to tackling offending behaviour and that it is not just about ending slopping out, but about looking at other conditions in our prison system?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
Pauline McNeill raises three issues. First, we remain committed to ending slopping out and tackling overcrowding, both of which are important, not least for their contribution towards tackling reoffending. Secondly, we are absolutely committed to tackling reoffending patterns in Scotland, which has one of the worst records in Europe for reoffending. We need a new approach to custodial and non-custodial sentences to tackle that. Thirdly, I agree with Pauline McNeill that we need to strike a balance between compensation and investment in support for victims and witnesses. At the same time, we must realise that our prisons have to be fit for the 21st century.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link
Will the First Minister tell Parliament what the Executive's financial liability is estimated to be as a result of Lord Bonomy's judgment? Will he apologise to the Scottish people on behalf of those who were responsible for not taking the opportunity to address the issue in 1999, as Lord Bonomy has said that they could have done, instead of creating a situation in which millions of pounds will have to be taken out of public services and paid into the pockets of convicted criminals?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
As I said, we are currently considering the judgment and we will give our view once we have done that properly. I make no apology for using resources in 1999 to establish the Scottish Drug Enforcement Agency. The millions of pounds that matter most to ordinary Scots are the more than £50 million in 2002-03 that the Scottish Drug Enforcement Agency was responsible for taking from drug dealers and putting back into the pockets of Scottish taxpayers. That is the action and the priority that the people of Scotland expect us to apply. As Pauline McNeill said, we have to balance that with tackling reoffending and the conditions in our prisons.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link
When the First Minister and his colleagues get round to considering Lord Bonomy's judgment in detail and accept that it is a judicial keelhauling of the Scottish Executive, will he say why it was not thought appropriate in 1999 to deploy some of the year-end surplus revenue—a very considerable amount of money—to meet what most people in Scotland would now regard as the essential public sector obligation to provide sanitation in our prisons?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
I have already answered that point. In 1999 we believed—and I believe today—that we were right to use resources to support new programmes for victims and witnesses and to establish the Scottish Drug Enforcement Agency. That agency has been responsible for record levels of seizures from drug dealers in Scotland and record numbers of arrests of drug dealers, and has set an international example that is being copied elsewhere. We were right to use resources to establish the Scottish Drug Enforcement Agency and the people of Scotland will support that view rather than the views of the Tories and the nationalists that we should have used the money for something else.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link
Does the First Minister agree that the prison building and refurbishment programme has to be implemented as speedily as possible? Can he indicate when there is likely to be an end to slopping out in Scotland's prisons?

Jack McConnell Lab The First Minister · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
As we have made clear this week, the target date for ending slopping out in Scotland's prisons will follow the creation of those new prisons, which are fundamental to establishing the new practice. Among other things, the establishment of the new prisons will depend on planning permission for the two sites that have been provisionally identified. In both cases, planning decisions remain outstanding.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 April 2004 Debate · 1
  2. European Union Constitution Debate · 176
  3. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  4. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  5. Sustainable Scotland (Cabinet Sub-committee) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  6. Prisons (Sanitation) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  7. Hepatitis C (Ex Gratia Payments) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  8. Identity Cards First Minister’s Questions · 6
  9. United Kingdom Sustainable Development Strategy Questions · 6
  10. Deer (Culls) Questions · 8
  11. Peatlands (Damage) Questions · 8
  12. Environmental Justice Questions · 8
  13. Climate Change Questions · 4
  14. Outdoor Access Code Questions · 4
  15. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  16. Waiting Times (General Practitioners) Questions · 8
  17. National Health Service (Decentralisation) Questions · 6
  18. Diabetes Questions · 6
  19. Ambulance Service (Call-out Rates) Questions · 6
  20. Maternity Services (Oban) Questions · 17
  21. Health and Community Care Questions · 1
  22. Amateur Sports Clubs (Rates Relief) Questions · 4
  23. School Closures Questions · 20
  24. Small Claims (Limits) Questions · 4
  25. Sport for All Questions · 6
  26. Homelessness Questions · 4
  27. Scottish Executive (Public Relations) Questions · 4
  28. Reducing Reoffending Debate · 63
  29. Business Motion Business motions · 6
  30. Decision Time Decision time · 39
  31. TransBus International (Jobs) Members’ business · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.