To ask the First Minister how the Scottish Executive intends to promote an inclusive system of higher education in Scotland. (S1F-394)
Official Report · Chamber
Higher Education
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Wallace LD 4
- Allan Wilson Lab 2
- John Swinney SNP 1
- John McAllion Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsThe Executive is determined to remove barriers to wider access and participation for those groups that are currently under-represented in higher education. We have, therefore, proposed a new £50 million student support package for 2001 that will include access payments of up to £2,000 for students from low-income families. We have also announced a £10 million mature student bursary fund. The overall package offers real improvements to the support that is available to under-represented groups.
I thank the Deputy First Minister for that reply. Does he agree that an inclusive higher education system means that many more students from manual-labouring family backgrounds must be encouraged to go to Scotland's universities? Does he also agree that every Scottish university—including the University of St Andrews—must play its part in the process?
I certainly agree with that. That is why the Executive has taken some of the measures to which I have referred. Only yesterday, my colleague Nicol Stephen, the Deputy Minister for Enterprise and Lifelong Learning, attended a conference that was sponsored by the Scottish network for access and participation and the Scottish Higher Education Funding Council. They made the very point that Allan Wilson makes. The question is not only about access. We must also ensure that there is an improved retention rate when the people about whom Allan Wilson speaks go to university. We must try to provide the support and infrastructure that will ensure that the objectives of retention and access, to which he referred, are achieved.
link
Will the Deputy First Minster tell Parliament how an inclusive system of higher education will be created when students will, under the Executive, have to start paying back-end tuition fees when they start to earn £10,000 per annum, which is lower than the average wage in Scotland? Will he also explain when his support for the £10,000 threshold began? I am startled to read that the Liberal Democrat higher education spokesman, Dr Evan Harris, has said that the Liberal Democrats have never supported a threshold as low as £10,000.
I will take this opportunity to put Mr Swinney right on one or two matters. For a start, there are no back-end tuition fees. [Members: "Yes there are!"] The SNP does not like it, but we have abolished those fees.
There is a £10,000 threshold, but we examined closely the possibility of introducing a £25,000 threshold, as recommended by Andrew Cubie and his committee in their report. That would have required the setting up of an entirely new bureaucracy and might have led to the need for students to make two sets of payments. I do not believe that Mr Swinney would support money being used to fund a bureaucracy when it could be used to support higher education.
Most students in Scotland will pay less in repayment of loans than would have been the case under the Cubie proposals. They will also pay less than they would in the situation that existed before we abolished tuition fees and introduced graduate contributions and support, through access awards, for students from the poorest families.
There is a £10,000 threshold, but we examined closely the possibility of introducing a £25,000 threshold, as recommended by Andrew Cubie and his committee in their report. That would have required the setting up of an entirely new bureaucracy and might have led to the need for students to make two sets of payments. I do not believe that Mr Swinney would support money being used to fund a bureaucracy when it could be used to support higher education.
Most students in Scotland will pay less in repayment of loans than would have been the case under the Cubie proposals. They will also pay less than they would in the situation that existed before we abolished tuition fees and introduced graduate contributions and support, through access awards, for students from the poorest families.
Does the Deputy First Minister agree that the major problem with access to university for young people who come from low-income families is that they cannot afford to go? If he does agree, will he accept that there is little prospect of our university education system ever being genuinely inclusive until the core problems of student poverty and student debt are tackled through the reinstatement of a realistic maintenance grant on which students can live?
It is clear that efforts must be made to tackle student poverty. That is why the Executive is taking the biggest step forward that has been taken in this country for years towards doing that. Mr McAllion will acknowledge that the £2,000 access award that is targeted at the families who have the lowest incomes is a big step forward. As I have said, student loans for the majority of Scottish students will be less under our proposals than they would have been had we not been here to implement them.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Diligence Statement · 20
- Local Economic Development Debate · 55
- Local Government Statement · 17
- Business Motion Business motions · 49
- Roads (A8000) Questions · 6
- Roads (A77) Questions · 6
- Scottish Economy Questions · 8
- Schools (Repairs) Questions · 8
- Volunteers Week Questions · 6
- Road Safety (Children) Questions · 6
- Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 13
- Health Services Questions · 11
- Anorexia Questions · 4
- Voluntary Sector Questions · 8
- Fuel Excise Duty Questions · 10
- St Andrew's Day Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Higher Education First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Waiting Lists First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Laidlaw & Fairgrieve Ltd First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Points of Order Procedure · 6
- Learning Disability Review Debate · 23
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Women's Pay Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.