I would like to—[Interruption.]
Official Report · Chamber
Cabinet
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David McLetchie Con 4
- Jim Wallace LD 4
- Sir David Steel 2
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
11 contributions
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. We want to hear the question.
Presiding Officer, it is becoming more like the women's institute every day. [Laughter.]
To ask the First Minister whether he has any plans to reshuffle his Cabinet. (S1F-382)
To ask the First Minister whether he has any plans to reshuffle his Cabinet. (S1F-382)
No.
Thank you. Perhaps the Deputy First Minister might like to offer himself as a prime candidate for reshuffle when the First Minister returns, because his record so far on law and order is one of abject failure. Apparently, he is about to compound that by raising the age of criminal responsibility from eight to 12 and by treating 16 and 17-year-old offenders as children and not adults, a move that has been described by the Scottish Police Federation as laughable. Instead of adopting such cloud nine ideas, why does he not come back to earth and give the police the support they deserve to deal with neds on the ground?
The chamber may have been thinking that Mr McLetchie would use his question about reshuffles as a preliminary to announcing his own reshuffle. We see Tory front benchers in fighting form—they are fighting each other. When Mr Murray Tosh says that there is a split between the militants and the mainstream, our real concern is that Phil Gallie is in the mainstream.
I deeply regret the fact that Mr McLetchie trivialises the very serious issue of youth crime. He knows that one of the first things the Executive did was to set up a youth crime review. A study has been completed, and the outcome and our response to it will be published tomorrow. Sam Galbraith will make a statement on it at a conference. The issue of the age of criminal responsibility has been raised in this Parliament on a number of occasions. There is ECHR case law on it. We think it should be studied and we are inviting the Scottish Law Commission to do that. There is no proposal on it, as Mr McLetchie suggested.
Mr McLetchie is also well aware that a considerable amount of crime is committed by young people aged from 18 to 24. They are responsible for inflicting a lot of misery on a lot of communities and our intention is to tackle that effectively. It is perfectly clear that the range of options for tackling that problem until now—including those options that were brought in during the 18 years when his party was in power—have not been successful. That is why a responsible Government should look at the issue and try to devise an effective response.
I deeply regret the fact that Mr McLetchie trivialises the very serious issue of youth crime. He knows that one of the first things the Executive did was to set up a youth crime review. A study has been completed, and the outcome and our response to it will be published tomorrow. Sam Galbraith will make a statement on it at a conference. The issue of the age of criminal responsibility has been raised in this Parliament on a number of occasions. There is ECHR case law on it. We think it should be studied and we are inviting the Scottish Law Commission to do that. There is no proposal on it, as Mr McLetchie suggested.
Mr McLetchie is also well aware that a considerable amount of crime is committed by young people aged from 18 to 24. They are responsible for inflicting a lot of misery on a lot of communities and our intention is to tackle that effectively. It is perfectly clear that the range of options for tackling that problem until now—including those options that were brought in during the 18 years when his party was in power—have not been successful. That is why a responsible Government should look at the issue and try to devise an effective response.
We take crime very seriously—that is why the incidence of crime fell consistently under our Administration during the 1990s and has risen during the minister's, over the past couple of years. As we have pointed out repeatedly, Mr Wallace's justice budget has been slashed while he has stood by, police numbers have been cut and prisons are being closed. We now have the final piece in the jigsaw—the master plan; fiddle the crime figures by raising the age of criminal responsibility and pretend that the 4,000 crimes that are committed in a year by eight to 11-year-olds do not happen. Is that the Liberal Democrat idea of justice? Is that why, on all the law and order issues, the police agree with us and the criminals agree with Mr Wallace?
I am genuinely disappointed that Mr McLetchie trivialises such a serious subject, which we as an Executive are treating seriously.
Never mind the claptrap—answer the question. [Interruption.]
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order.
We recognise the importance and seriousness of youth crime. As I indicated, there have been calls for a review of the age of criminal responsibility and that is what we are asking the Scottish Law Commission to examine. We also want to tackle youth crime effectively.
On the police, Mr McLetchie will be well aware that it is some three weeks since I announced an £8.9 million increase in this year's police budget, which had already been increased by more than the rate of inflation for this year. The extra money will allow the employment of more than 300 police officers, in addition to those who will be employed by the Scottish Drugs Enforcement Agency. It is clear that the Executive takes law and order seriously, but we are not into solving the problems of law and order by sloganeering—we want to solve them by taking effective measures.
On the police, Mr McLetchie will be well aware that it is some three weeks since I announced an £8.9 million increase in this year's police budget, which had already been increased by more than the rate of inflation for this year. The extra money will allow the employment of more than 300 police officers, in addition to those who will be employed by the Scottish Drugs Enforcement Agency. It is clear that the Executive takes law and order seriously, but we are not into solving the problems of law and order by sloganeering—we want to solve them by taking effective measures.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Diligence Statement · 20
- Local Economic Development Debate · 55
- Local Government Statement · 17
- Business Motion Business motions · 49
- Roads (A8000) Questions · 6
- Roads (A77) Questions · 6
- Scottish Economy Questions · 8
- Schools (Repairs) Questions · 8
- Volunteers Week Questions · 6
- Road Safety (Children) Questions · 6
- Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 13
- Health Services Questions · 11
- Anorexia Questions · 4
- Voluntary Sector Questions · 8
- Fuel Excise Duty Questions · 10
- St Andrew's Day Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Higher Education First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Waiting Lists First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Laidlaw & Fairgrieve Ltd First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Points of Order Procedure · 6
- Learning Disability Review Debate · 23
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Women's Pay Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.