To ask the Scottish Executive whether it can confirm with certainty that seed contaminated with genetically modified seed was not planted and harvested in 1999. (S1O-1879)
Official Report · Chamber
Genetically Modified Organisms
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 4
- Ross Finnie LD 4
- Sir David Steel 3
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
- Robin Harper Green 1
The record
13 contributionsOn the contrary, Advanta Seeds UK made it clear when it notified the UK Government on 17 April that the affected seed was produced in 1998 and was sold and sown in both 1999 and 2000. The 1999 crop will have already been harvested.
Clearly, that is a highly regrettable development of which we had no knowledge. It is important that I inform the Parliament that the advice that the Food Standards Agency Scotland has given me is that there is no food safety implication arising from the possible entry into the food chain last year of oil from the affected crop. I have also taken steps to seek preliminary advice from the Advisory Committee on Animal Feedingstuffs, which also confirms that there is no added risk from feeding material to animals from any contaminated crop. Finally, I have sought advice from the Advisory Committee on Releases to the Environment, which has also confirmed that there is no added risk to the environment from any seeds sown in 1999.
Clearly, that is a highly regrettable development of which we had no knowledge. It is important that I inform the Parliament that the advice that the Food Standards Agency Scotland has given me is that there is no food safety implication arising from the possible entry into the food chain last year of oil from the affected crop. I have also taken steps to seek preliminary advice from the Advisory Committee on Animal Feedingstuffs, which also confirms that there is no added risk from feeding material to animals from any contaminated crop. Finally, I have sought advice from the Advisory Committee on Releases to the Environment, which has also confirmed that there is no added risk to the environment from any seeds sown in 1999.
That is absolutely shocking—even more shocking than what we learned last week. We now know that in 1999 almost double the number of hectares were planted with GM contaminated seeds and harvested. That material is now in the food chain for animals as well as humans, because rape seed husks are used as animal feed.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Please ask a question.
We know how badly the minister and the Parliament were treated, but what will Mr Finnie do about the incompetence of the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food? We all remember the ministry's secrecy and almost criminal incompetence over BSE.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. That is enough.
Will the minister ask for an ordering of checks on the fields and for the production of—
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. I remind members that, according to standing orders, questions must be brief.
I am sure that no one in the chamber would want to underestimate the very serious nature of the failure of Advanta Seeds UK to notify anybody. However, I suspect that in 1998, even Advanta Seeds UK did not know that the crop was contaminated.
In no way do I wish to underestimate or understate that problem, but it is not helpful for Dorothy-Grace Elder simply to ignore what I previously said, which were not my words—[Interruption.] Members should bide their time. If they want an answer, I will give an answer. On the question of public safety, we must be absolutely clear that the independent advice from the Food Standards Agency Scotland is that what has happened does not give rise to a health risk in the food chain. The preliminary advice from the Advisory Committee on Animal Feedingstuffs is the same.
Having been alerted to this serious problem, we are prosecuting the matter in three ways. First, as members will be aware, because of public concern that the bodies concerned did not involve people other than scientists, the Agriculture and Environment Biotechnology Commission was established in early June. It includes farmers, consumers and representatives of environmental bodies. They have been asked to give independent advice, not on last year, but on steps that have to be taken to improve the regulatory process.
Secondly, with regard to making progress in Europe, we have collaborated with MAFF over the past 10 days and we have already promoted an order in Europe to try to change the regulatory procedure for the examination of imported seeds, to give member states much greater powers to reject seeds that are or are not contaminated.
I apologise for the length of my answer, Presiding Officer, but it is an important matter. It is being announced today in the House of Lords by Baroness Hayman that the interim committee—[Interruption.] The issue that we are dealing with is that we are promoting proposals that would allow us to take far greater care and to reject seeds that have a tolerance level of less than 0.5 per cent. Those crops might be perfectly safe, but we have adopted the precautionary principle. The one issue that is clear is that as far as the Executive is concerned, there is no licence to sell those crops. Having acquired the knowledge that the problem existed and that there was no licence to sell those crops, the proper action to take was for us to require the destruction of the crops this year.
In no way do I wish to underestimate or understate that problem, but it is not helpful for Dorothy-Grace Elder simply to ignore what I previously said, which were not my words—[Interruption.] Members should bide their time. If they want an answer, I will give an answer. On the question of public safety, we must be absolutely clear that the independent advice from the Food Standards Agency Scotland is that what has happened does not give rise to a health risk in the food chain. The preliminary advice from the Advisory Committee on Animal Feedingstuffs is the same.
Having been alerted to this serious problem, we are prosecuting the matter in three ways. First, as members will be aware, because of public concern that the bodies concerned did not involve people other than scientists, the Agriculture and Environment Biotechnology Commission was established in early June. It includes farmers, consumers and representatives of environmental bodies. They have been asked to give independent advice, not on last year, but on steps that have to be taken to improve the regulatory process.
Secondly, with regard to making progress in Europe, we have collaborated with MAFF over the past 10 days and we have already promoted an order in Europe to try to change the regulatory procedure for the examination of imported seeds, to give member states much greater powers to reject seeds that are or are not contaminated.
I apologise for the length of my answer, Presiding Officer, but it is an important matter. It is being announced today in the House of Lords by Baroness Hayman that the interim committee—[Interruption.] The issue that we are dealing with is that we are promoting proposals that would allow us to take far greater care and to reject seeds that have a tolerance level of less than 0.5 per cent. Those crops might be perfectly safe, but we have adopted the precautionary principle. The one issue that is clear is that as far as the Executive is concerned, there is no licence to sell those crops. Having acquired the knowledge that the problem existed and that there was no licence to sell those crops, the proper action to take was for us to require the destruction of the crops this year.
Can the minister tell the chamber when he expects to be in a position to offer definitive advice to farmers on the disposal of the crop that is currently in the ground?
That depends on when we receive the text from Brussels. It is being discussed in Brussels today. I hope that it will be only a matter of days before we receive the final text, which will confirm beyond doubt that even applying force majeure, and even if there are leaks, farmers will be able to recover their arable area payments compensation this year.
Given that last year's and this year's plantings qualify as a gigantic farm-scale trial, is it the intention of the Scottish Executive to monitor or partially audit the affected fields and their environs for the effects of possible gene flow, seed drop and pollen spread?
I intend to do two things. First, we are in discussions with the National Farmers Union to try to put in place a system so that once we have the advice that Mr Johnstone referred to, indicating to farmers what they should do, we will in the first instance, as part of trying to assure the public that these particular crops have been removed, have a process of inspection. Secondly, we are in discussions with the regulatory authorities about how they should monitor the fields that have been used, because clearly there is, as I think Robin Harper is alluding to, the prospect that volunteers will emerge. That will form part of the advice that will have to be given to farmers.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Diligence Statement · 20
- Local Economic Development Debate · 55
- Local Government Statement · 17
- Business Motion Business motions · 49
- Roads (A8000) Questions · 6
- Roads (A77) Questions · 6
- Scottish Economy Questions · 8
- Schools (Repairs) Questions · 8
- Volunteers Week Questions · 6
- Road Safety (Children) Questions · 6
- Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 13
- Health Services Questions · 11
- Anorexia Questions · 4
- Voluntary Sector Questions · 8
- Fuel Excise Duty Questions · 10
- St Andrew's Day Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Higher Education First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Waiting Lists First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Laidlaw & Fairgrieve Ltd First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Points of Order Procedure · 6
- Learning Disability Review Debate · 23
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Women's Pay Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.