We return to item 1. The first objection for the committee to consider is from the New Town, Broughton and Pilrig community council. Before we take evidence, I point out that Dr T Robinson will not give oral evidence on behalf of the community council, despite having provided a witness statement. I ask members to disregard his witness statement and any rebuttals to it that the promoter provided.
Official Report · Committee
Consideration Stage
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ian Mowat 135
- Malcolm Thomson 70
- Bill Aitken Con 51
- Alan Welsh New Town, Broughton and Pilrig Community Council 43
- Stuart Turnbull Jacobs Babtie 40
- Steve Mitchell Environmental Resources Management 38
- Aileen Grant City of Edinburgh Council 24
- David Todd Dublin Street Residents Association 22
- Brian Evans Gillespie’s llp 17
- Jeremy Purvis LD 10
- Andrew Oldfield 5
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 5
- Malcolm Thomson QC Counsel for the Promoter 1
- Andrew J Oldfield Mott MacDonald 1
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 1
The record
469 contributions · showing 1–200There has been a change of witness: Mr David Todd will provide evidence instead of Michael Dawson. In common with all cases in which a substitution of witnesses occurs, the new witness is bound by the original witness statement.The community council has not rebutted Aileen Grant's witness statement and will therefore not be able to question that witness.The first witnesses for the promoter are Aileen Grant, Andrew Oldfield, Steve Mitchell, Stuart Turnbull and Brian Evans. Mr Evans replaces Karen Raymond. Before we commence evidence taking, the witnesses must take the oath or make a solemn affirmation.Brian Evans, Andrew J Oldfield, Steve Mitchell and Stuart Turnbull took the oath.Aileen Grant made a solemn affirmation.
Each witness is bound by the terms of their oath or affirmation.The first witness will be Brian Evans, who will address the impacts on the world heritage site. I welcome Malcolm Thomson QC, who will question on behalf of the promoter, and Mr Ian Mowat, who will question on behalf of the community council. Mr Thomson, please proceed.
Mr Evans, will you deal briefly with the question of why, from your perspective, the tramline should pass along Queen Street rather than round the north side of St Andrew Square?
St Andrew Square is the complement to Charlotte Square. The particular genius of the world heritage site in Edinburgh is the relationship of the High Street, with architectural monuments at either end, and George Street, with the two squares at either end. The relationship between the old town and the new town—the medieval and the renaissance—with vistas and monuments that are related to the topography make the place extremely special. As St Andrew Square is one of the two squares and is extremely special, there should be minimal intrusion into it in the pursuit of modern life. The square is not perfect: St Andrew Street and St David Street run north to south from Princes Street down to Queen Street and they therefore run right through the space, whereas, on the north and south of the square, the streets are truncated by buildings at either end. In my view, it would achieve a better composition to bring the tram on a direct alignment along St Andrew Street and St David Street and to return it along Queen Street and Princes Street.
Is that the reason for the apparent inconsistency, in that it is acceptable to have trams passing along two sides of St Andrew Square, while it is unacceptable to have them on a third side?
In principle, yes. One of the key aspects about St Andrew Square is its symmetry. Therefore, to have trams passing on one side in one direction and on the other side in the other direction would retain symmetry and would minimise intrusion into the square.
There have been two iterations of the design manual so far. The first one was published around March of last year and a second edition was produced recently. Am I right that you were involved in the preparation of the first draft, but not the second draft?
That is correct.
So any questions that concern the current draft specifically would be better directed to Ms Aileen Grant.
Indeed.
In paragraph 4.2 on page 5 of your witness statement, you make a comment that has been picked up by the objectors. You state:"In accordance with Prior Approvals, the promoter undertakes to consult with the appropriate statutory consultees and the objector as part of the detailed design and construction processes."Will you clarify precisely what you mean by that undertaking?
It has always been my understanding that the promoter wishes to undertake full consultation with all parties during the design and development of the system.
Does that include the present objectors?
Yes.
Does the undertaking relate to the detailed design process, the finalisation of the design manual and the prior approvals process?
It is my understanding that the promoter wishes to consult, but I cannot in any way guarantee that.
Again, that may be a question for Ms Aileen Grant.
Indeed.
Does Mr Mowat have questions for this witness?
Yes.Mr Evans, I see that you have great experience as a chartered town planner. In your view, what is currently the main east-west/west-east route for road traffic through central Edinburgh?
My personal understanding—I am not a traffic planner—is that Queen Street is the main route.
Thank you. In your witness statement, you say that it is important not to break up "long vistas". Paragraph 3.9, which deals with plans to mitigate visual intrusion, states:"This is of particular relevance given the long vistas afforded along Queen Street, leading into York Place and Picardy Place and the setting of the Scottish National Portrait Gallery."Will not that long vista be broken up by the fact that the tram, which I understand will have overhead wires, will turn into that vista at the eastern end of Queen Street?
The centre of Edinburgh, and the new town in particular, is a composition of vistas. There is a vista along virtually every street. In my opinion, some of those vistas—for example, the view down Castle Street to the castle—are more iconic than others. I agree that there is a vista along Queen Street. One would wish to minimise intrusion into any of the vistas in Edinburgh's first Georgian new town.
If the placing of the tramline was such that it turned a little earlier, in the north side of St Andrew Square rather than in Queen Street, would that break up any vista in St Andrew Square?
In my opinion, it would be detrimental to the design set piece that is St Andrew Square.
If tramline 1 were not also planned to come down into Queen Street—we know that it is planned that tramline 1 will do that—would you still think it wise to extend tramline 2 from St Andrew Square into Queen Street?
It is not really my place to say. My role is to consider the unique heritage quality of the townscape for all of line 1 and the relationship between line 1 and line 2 in the world heritage site. That has been my principal concern, but I have also had to consider the character and qualities of that area in a vibrant competitive modern city. It is not my position to seek to have a tramline situated in one place or another. I consider and evaluate the consequences of the route and give advice, from a townscape point of view, about the best way of introducing such a line.
Is it not the case that the City of Edinburgh Council planning committee insisted back in 2003 that only two sides of St Andrew Square should be used?
That may well be the case, but I do not have the paper in front of me. My opinion as an urban designer is that the minimum amount of intrusion should be made into St Andrew Square for the reasons that I gave when Mr Thomson introduced my evidence.
Will not the greatest intrusion come from running the tram along the west side of St Andrew Square such that, from George Street, people will see the tram and its overhead wires on St Andrew Square? Will not that break up the vista?
Yes. If one is standing in George Street looking east, a tram passing through St Andrew Square will pass through that vista. However, whereas on one hand Edinburgh's world heritage site is of international importance, on the other it is home to many people and many businesses and is a principal visitor attraction not just for Edinburgh but for the entire nation. Therefore, in considering any introduction of a transportation system into Edinburgh, one needs to consider how one can achieve a system that is efficient for those who live and work in and visit the city in the most elegant and simple way and how one can minimise intrusion into the internationally famous work of art and dream of great genius that is central Edinburgh. There will be an intrusion into the vista, as there is when a 52-seater visitor bus comes into it, although I distinguish clearly between objects such as vehicles that will come and go and other things that are permanent. Particular attention must be paid to the permanent infrastructure associated with the trams, its quality and the minimisation of its intrusion.
I turn to the permanent infrastructure. You say in your evidence that the design manual aspires to minimise clutter by ensuring that the overhead line and electrification poles are kept to a minimum in the city centre around listed buildings. Surely the best way to keep them to a minimum is to use ground rail electrification. Would you, as a planner, not prefer to see that? You might be aware of the example in Bordeaux, which we believe is now working at 99 per cent efficiency.
It is plain that a tram without overhead line electrification will be less intrusive than a tram with overhead line electrification.
So you, as a planner, would prefer to see written into the bill an insistence on not using overhead rail but ground rail, at least in the central area.
My role has been to advise on the best integration of a tram system into the city centre. There are many things to consider in achieving that. We have to bear it in mind that, with the introduction of a tram system, it might also be possible to effect reduction in clutter in other aspects of street scene, which is an important aspect of the system. As an urban designer and planner, I concur: what is characterised popularly as a wireless system would have less intrusion into the world heritage site than a system with overhead line infrastructure.
I have a final question. If an amendment were proposed that, like the one that we heard about under an earlier agenda item, would alter the limits of deviation, in this case so that the tram ran around the north side of St Andrew Square—for reasons relating to the residents and congestion, to which we will come—would you regard that as a complete disaster or a decision that you would prefer not to have been taken but which was acceptable in planning terms?
I would consider it to be extremely unfortunate. I believe that the design set piece of St Andrew Square, Charlotte Square and George Street creates a relationship into which we should seek to minimise intrusion. I would consider a decision to route the tram around St Andrew Square and turn it into a tram roundabout to be regrettable.
The next witness is Aileen Grant, who will address the design manual and the impact of the tramline on the world heritage site.
Miss Grant, please give us an update on the status of the design manual.
A report was made to the planning committee last week, on 16 June, in which we presented an updated draft of the tram design manual. It was fairly substantially refined in the light of increased knowledge on the part of the promoter, which was shared with us in planning and with transport colleagues. That draft has been agreed by the planning committee and can now go out to consultation. The consultation process has not yet started, as the committee asked us to tidy up a few points in the document. We are just doing that, and we hope that the document will go out to public consultation next week at the latest. The situation has moved on a little bit.
Am I right in thinking that the consultation process will include Historic Scotland, the World Heritage Trust and community councils, among others?
Yes. In planning consultations we normally send copies of documents to the community councils. The planning committee specifically asked us to include all community councils and not to differentiate between those whose areas will be affected directly by the tram and those whose areas lie outside the tram routes, so we agreed to send copies of the draft design manual to all the community councils. Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust are also on our consultation list, but we have agreed that we will meet them to go through the document in a bit more detail after they have had a chance to look at the new, refined version.
Will you consult amenity bodies such as the Cockburn Association?
Yes. We are just compiling our list of consultees at the moment. We will not necessarily catch everybody, but if we get requests for extra copies we will be happy to forward them or invite further comments from other organisations. It will be a wide consultation.
I am thinking about what Mr Evans said about consultation at the prior approval stage. How could those objectors—the community councils—be involved in a prior approval process?
One of the difficulties is that planning authorities have no procedures set down for prior approval processes. That is why we took a procedure note to the planning committee in November 2003. We obtained comments from Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust and reported back to the committee in February 2004 on the procedure. In that procedure note, we say that, when we receive prior notification applications, we will put them into our computer system with our particular tag on them so that it is clear that they are to do with tram prior approvals. We also say that we will include them in our weekly list of planning applications as part of the planning register. I understand that that weekly list is sent out to all community councils and that it is the task of the planning conveners of community councils to check the list for current applications. We also have a planning and building control portal that will contain all the details of prior approvals when they are received. They will receive all the usual publicity that planning applications have.
So any concerned citizen needs simply to go to the right portal or to scan the weekly list if they want to have an input to the prior approval process.
Yes, that is right. That will be the baseline for all prior approvals. The procedure note also suggests advertisement, in certain circumstances, on the basis of how the approval links to what is in the design manual. In other words, if it complies fully it is unlikely that we would advertise it but, if it does not comply with the terms of the design manual, we would advertise the prior approval in our usual weekly advert in the local newspaper. The procedure is a bit like the way in which we treat development that is contrary to development plans—in other words, if it complies with the manual, we would not advertise, but if it does not, we would advertise to invite wider comment.
I want to change tack and deal with whether the tram should go round the north side of St Andrew Square or along Queen Street, which is a completely different issue. It can be seen from your written statements that the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust and Historic Scotland have not been specifically consulted on that matter. Why have they not been consulted?
That issue was first addressed in the planning committee's report in August 2003, when there had been discussions about the routing of the trams. Great concerns were raised in my department about the impact on St Andrew Square and there was a joint meeting, the result of which was encapsulated in the planning committee's report. That report recognised the sensitivities of St Andrew Square, but said that complying with the requirements would be sufficient to minimise the impact on the square and would mean that the character of the area and the world heritage site would not be materially affected. There were no formal discussions with the World Heritage Trust or Historic Scotland in arriving at the principles for St Andrew Square. They have seen the various planning committee reports, but we have not specifically asked for their views on trams running on the north side of St Andrew Square because we ruled that out in the first instance. We did so because of our concerns about the impact on the setting of the listed buildings on that side of the square and about the severance of the square, which is highlighted in the local plan as being of townscape significance and landscape importance in the new town.
I take it that over the months and years in which the tram project has been considered, you have had discussions with Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust about the intervention of trams in the new town.
We have had a number of on-going discussions about routing the trams with regard to St Andrew Square in particular. Those discussions are partly linked to on-going work on the public realm in St Andrew Square and trying to put that in the context of the likelihood that there will be trams here in the longer term, so we should ensure that we are not doing something now that will cause conflicts later on. There have been many informal discussions with Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust, but we have not at any time mentioned using the north side of the square. All the discussions have been based on using only two sides of the square.
Against that background and at this stage in the proceedings, can the committee make any safe assumptions about Historic Scotland's position in particular?
I feel that Historic Scotland would strongly resist the occupation of any additional space in the square or the taking of the north or the south side of the square into the tram route.
What about the World Heritage Trust?
I think that it would feel even more strongly about the matter. However, that is only my feeling—we have not asked those bodies for their views.
So this committee could not safely assume that Historic Scotland would not object if there were a proposal to run trams around the north side of St Andrew Square.
I advise that it could not. A number of issues—not least the setting of the buildings on the north side of the square—are involved. When we asked Historic Scotland for its views on the prior approvals process, it raised the issue of the setting of category A listed buildings, for which it has a different statutory duty—it is a statutory consultee under the planning process. Running trams on the north side of the square would affect the setting of the category A listed buildings on that side. For that reason alone, Historic Scotland would be concerned.
Thank you.
Mr Mowat, I note that you have not issued a rebuttal.
I would like to make a plea. We had no particular quarrel with Miss Grant's first statement, but she then submitted a statement that rebutted evidence that was given by Mr Welsh and the Dublin Street residents association, with which we take issue. I asked Mr Evans about the planning process and he said that he was not really aware of the council planning meetings, but Miss Grant is. It would be extremely detrimental if we were not able to cross-examine her on the points that she has made today, rather than on her original statement.
I think that it would be in order to proceed on that basis, Mr Mowat.
Thank you.Miss Grant, you indicated that Historic Scotland and the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust have had discussions with you about the two sides of St Andrew Square that are affected. Were they also in discussion with you about the part of Queen Street that is affected and about the Scottish National Portrait Gallery, which the line is planned to run past?
No, we have not had detailed discussions with them about that. The focus has been very much on St Andrew Square.
I am astonished that such discussions have not taken place. The Scottish National Portrait Gallery is an A-listed building. I thought that you suggested that all A-listed buildings are of concern.
The discussions that we have been having are based on the limits of deviation that have been presented to Parliament. The specific focus on St Andrew Square has arisen only because there are current proposals for St Andrew Square, which are under discussion by the council. We are trying to ensure that the current proposals do not conflict with what might happen in the future if the tram gets consent. That is the reason for the focus on St Andrew Square. It is not driven by planning; it is driven by other projects. We have brought Historic Scotland into that discussion to ensure that all parties have an input.
That is a bit concerning. Are you suggesting that other projects that the council has in mind for St Andrew Square are affecting where you feel the tram should go?
No, I am not saying that. We are basing it on the limits of deviation that have been submitted. We are saying that those projects need to recognise the tram, not vice versa.
I am puzzled. You say that there has been so much discussion with Historic Scotland and the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust about your plans for St Andrew Square and the tram plans for St Andrew Square, but none about the passing of tramline 2 along Queen Street and past the Scottish National Portrait Gallery.
The details of what happens with the tram route will be submitted to the planning authority at prior approval stage. We are in a stage of preparation for receiving those prior approvals, but nothing can formally happen on that detailed design until after Parliament has come to a decision. It was only because there was work going on in St Andrew Square that, under central Edinburgh traffic management arrangements and because of various other issues to do with the square, it was in order to ensure that current projects recognised what was likely to happen with the tram. We have tried to ensure that joined-up thinking is going on at this stage, so that we do not do work now or next year that might have to be undone in a couple of years' time. That is the reason for the focus on St Andrew Square. We expect to have more detailed discussions in the run-up to the prior approval process, so we expect to be engaging with Historic Scotland and the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust over the arrangements in Queen Street, Picardy Place and Princes Street. All those spaces are sensitive. In the new version of the draft design manual, we have indicated that we hope to have joint working with a design working group, which will involve Historic Scotland and the Edinburgh World Heritage Trust, as well as Transport Initiatives Edinburgh and ourselves, in working through some of the detailed design issues. That group has not yet met, but that intention signposts the way in which we shall be taking forward the detailed design process. We and TIE are having a workshop in a couple of weeks' time to discuss how the detailed design working arrangements, and our own working arrangements, will go forward, because we have to plan for the next stage.
If I can précis what I think you have said to us, you have said that the planners in TIE took the view that putting a line down more than two sides of St Andrew Square would create considerable difficulties and have an adverse impact. They decided that internally, without any discussion with anyone else. They then let Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust know what they are thinking. The World Heritage Trust and Historic Scotland probably said, "Thank God it's not more than two sides—we can maybe live with that." Is it the case that you came to the view first, without going to the outside bodies?
That was in August 2003, when the initial consultation plans from TIE were in the public domain. That was our response to those consultation plans. Because we were not acting as the planning authority, we were effectively giving a considered planning view to the council. We have specialists in the department who deal with listed buildings and conservation areas; it was a collective view from within our department. I have checked my notes and I do not think that we involved Historic Scotland at that stage.The view was in the planning committee's reports, so it was in the public domain. It was available for discussion as a result of that, but to my knowledge there was no subsequent discussion with Historic Scotland on that point. There had been no suggestion about using the north side of St Andrew Square until I saw those papers from the objectors.
Mr Mowat, I am getting a little bit concerned that we are drifting back towards preliminary stage issues.
I see that, but I would like to put what is probably my second last question. Do you understand that the bill sets the limits of deviation, so that once the bill is passed we cannot legally change the route? The route is fixed when the bill is passed. Is it not right to have the consultations before the bill is passed?
I made that point in the planning committee's first report. The planning committee is well aware of the position. We gave a planning viewpoint on the proposals that came from TIE. We made the planning committee aware that there could be no changes. Hence, we have focused the discussion on the proposed limits of deviation. I agree with what you said.
So you would see no room to revisit that if strong reasons—matters of amenity, congestion and noise vibration—suggested that it would be better that tramline 2 did not come down to Queen Street?
Can I interrupt you again, Mr Mowat? I am sorry, but that is not the remit of this witness.
Okay. I will stop.
Do members have any questions for the witness?
From your perspective, what would be entailed if the committee sought to change the alignment?
Such a change should be publicised for wider comment. TIE initially published its consultation plans and then there was a period of objection. The Parliament should have a comprehensive perspective on any concerns—of which we could currently not be aware—that might be raised by a changed route. In addition, I suggest that Historic Scotland and the World Heritage Trust should be consulted on any proposed change.
But those are things that you have not done.
The issue has just been raised today.
As far as I understand it, you have not done those things yet, even on the limits of deviation that have been in the bill and in the proposals for a very long time. You have not even discussed the matter with the Scottish National Portrait Gallery.
As a planning authority, we are not at liberty to suggest alternatives. Because we are not the planning authority with this particular proposal, we have commented only on the proposals put forward by TIE. We have expressly kept ourselves away from any negotiations with objectors because we will be the planning authority at the later stage. There is a Chinese wall in that we are trying to stay separate in this process.
I think that Historic Scotland was an objector at one stage but has withdrawn its objection.
That is right.
Has it ever objected to the proposal in the bill that the line should run along Queen Street and past the museum?
In informal discussions, it raised no objection to that route.
What about in its formal objection?
No, not as far as I remember.
Has there been any objection from the museum authorities?
No, not as far as I am aware.
So they are not objectors in the process.
No, they are not.
Thank you, Ms Grant.
The next witness is Mr Oldfield, who will address the use of rail track and preserved rail routes. Before we begin questioning Mr Oldfield, I would welcome clarification that his witness statements and rebuttals are relevant to line 2 and not line 1, Mr Thomson.
That is as it should be, is it not, sir?
Yes.
Because we are concerned with line 2.
Yes. Would you like to begin your examination?
Thank you, sir. Mr Oldfield, what is your professional view on an alternative to overhead power lines? We have heard reference to the Bordeaux experience and the suggestion that the system there enjoys a 99 per cent success rate at the moment.
I must say that I find that rather surprising. I am aware that an article has been published saying that that system is 97 per cent to 99 per cent reliable but, since the system came into operation, it has been most unreliable and only that article has contradicted that position. The system relies on a power supply that, when the vehicle passes over a certain section of track, re-energises and allows the vehicle to move on. The problem with the system in Bordeaux is that the energising system has been prone to water ingress and failure; so, in order to overcome that, it has been necessary to fit a battery traction system. I believe that the system is particularly problematic in the winter and that weather conditions such as those that we might experience in Edinburgh are particularly relevant to its performance.It is worthy of note that about 390 of the 400 or so light rail transport systems that operate in the world do so on overhead line electrification traction systems. That is a proven form of technology and there are very few proven forms of technology for non-wire traction systems.
Thank you, Mr Oldfield.
I will take you back to your rebuttal statement and away from overhead electrification. It has been suggested that inadequate consideration was given to running the tram system along the existing heavy rail line between Haymarket and Waverley. You said that you had "no knowledge" of evidence that the line could carry that traffic. You were pointed to the work of David Low of Heriot-Watt University. I do not know whether you are aware of his work, but I am advised that it suggests that the work that is going ahead to increase track capacity at Waverley station would make it possible to run trams along the existing rail line. Do you agree that it would be possible to run trams through the centre of town, avoiding the roads?
We did not consider that in great depth. We were aware that there were capacity issues and that considerable work would be required to overcome them. Indeed, on-going work is being undertaken by Network Rail. There are a number of issues about using that alignment. Some of them are about the type of vehicle and railway safety, and some of them are about on-going capacity aspects. We spoke to Network Rail about the matter and it indicated that it would be impossible to run light rail on the line as well as the planned heavy rail systems.One of the technology issues is that combining heavy rail and light rail on heavy rail infrastructure leads to many complications. We would have to implement a new type of traction system on the light rail vehicles, which would add weight and cost and take up space. We would also have to implement a train protection warning system on the light rail vehicles, which is complicated and costly and, again, takes up space. We have difficulty with the crash-worthiness of the type of vehicle that we are talking about using in Edinburgh as a light rail vehicle. One other scheme in the UK—the Tyne and Wear metro—operates in conjunction with heavy rail, but it uses a different type of vehicle. The metro vehicle is much sturdier than the vehicle that we propose to use in Edinburgh.Also, if the tram went through that section of alignment on heavy rail, we would need to find somewhere for the tram to stop to allow passengers to get on and off. It would be difficult to find anywhere for that at Haymarket or Waverley stations other than by using existing platforms. If we used existing platforms, that would take capacity from the heavy rail infrastructure. In addition, we would need the light rail vehicle's floor boarding height to be compatible with the station platforms. That would mean that all the platforms elsewhere on the route would have to be raised, so there are a number of technical issues.It is also my understanding that the capacity of the section of the heavy rail system that is mentioned in the proposal is limited by the Calton twin tunnels. Theoretically, they could accommodate a four-track formation. They have accommodated that in the past, but I understand that in recent years there has been a collapse in one of the tunnels and there is now buttressing that would preclude the operation of a four-track formation. It is not clear to me how much work and cost would be associated with the reinstatement of that capacity.
Thank you. I return to the overhead wires that you mentioned at the beginning. You gave the reasons why you think that other schemes would not be reliable enough. If you put in the overhead scheme, the pantograph would have to be as high as a double-decker bus, would it not? The overhead wires would have to be much higher than normal. As I understand it, the trams will be single deckers, but double-decker buses will have to run under the tram lines.
Tramways elsewhere in the UK operate at a standard overhead line electrification height of over 5 metres and double-decker buses run underneath them.
What about open-top tourist buses? Would they be safe?
There would be issues with those. One of the things that we are considering, which is potentially an aesthetic consideration, is raising the height of the OLE. By raising it, it may become less obtrusive.
Presumably one of the attractions of running trams along Princes Street is that there are plenty of stops near to where there are plenty of potential passengers, whereas—apart from the difficulty of running light rail along the heavy rail track and getting suitable stops—the line down in the Mound cutting would not be as accessible.
Yes, you have picked up on an omission from what I said. One of the aims of the scheme is to provide accessibility on the street in the city centre; it would not do so as effectively if it went along the heavy rail alignment through Waverley.
Most of the double-deck tram systems in the United Kingdom—certainly prior to the first world war and during a large part of the 1920s and 1930s—had open top upper decks, did they not?
Yes.
After that frank admission, do you wish to re-exam, Mr Thomson?
I have covered the only matters that I might have raised.
Thank you, Mr Oldfield. The next witness is Mr Mitchell, who will address the matter of noise.
I wonder whether Mr Mitchell could first of all update us on the noise insulation scheme's progress.
Yes. The bill makes provision for a noise insulation scheme. Section 4.4 of the noise policy that we produced in March addresses that scheme. At that time, we were still looking into what the scheme should be for noise insulation. We have made some progress since then. We have agreed, with technical officers from the City of Edinburgh Council environmental and consumer services department, the essence of what the noise insulation scheme should be. It will be very similar to the noise insulation scheme that is used in England and Wales under the Noise Insulation (Railways and Other Guided Transport Systems) Regulations 1996. There will be an additional clause to make provision for noise insulation to be offered specifically to address the possibility of wheel squeal occurring on bends.In my rebuttal of Mr Welsh dated 6 June, I discussed wheel squeal; I do not intend to repeat that unless I am asked specifically about it.
I would be grateful if you did not.
I will not. Needless to say, the noise insulation scheme provides us with a mitigation measure if wheel squeal happens, which we do not expect. We will have a back-up facility, subject to finalisation of the noise insulation scheme, which I am confident will happen shortly.
My only other point is about the suggestion that you have ignored relevant European Union directives.
Again, I have tried to address that in my statement, but I notice that it is an outstanding point from Mr Mowat's rebuttal document, so perhaps I should touch on it. I believe that Mr Thomson is referring to directive 2002/49/EC, the so-called environmental noise directive. In essence, I do not believe that that directive has implications for the tram planning at this stage. The directive requires member states to map noise in major conurbations and to produce at strategic level action plans for those conurbations to address environmental noise. That is all some years in the future. The first round is due in 2007 and is likely to be delayed in this country for various reasons. At that point, the Scottish Executive, as the competent authority, will be required to produce a noise map of Edinburgh. The Scottish Executive is likely to let contracts to do that work in 2007 or 2008. That will need to include the tram, if it is operating at that point; indeed, future rounds of noise mapping and action plans will need to include the tram, just as they will include every other significant transport noise source in the city. I do not believe that the directive has any implications at this stage, but we have certainly not ignored the matter.
In your rebuttal statement to the Dublin Street residents association, you say: "I note"—as if it is of some importance—that"none of these residents have objected to the tram proposals in their own right."You emphasise that the residents have simply represented their objections through their association. Do you attach importance to that?
No; I have simply noted it. That quotation should be read in the context of a comment that I have already made. In my experience, it is quite common for people such as the Dublin Street residents association, who are living in already noisy situations, to express concerns about additional noise. People will fear that the noise level, which is already very high, will get worse. It is simply of note that individual residents have not objected in their own right.
So, as far as you are concerned, the committee should not attach any importance to the fact that the objection has come from a residents association, rather than from individuals who make up that association.
It was not a point that I was trying to make strongly for any particular reason; it was merely an observation.
In your rebuttal statement, you produce a helpful table, which specifies the ambient level of noise and the tram noise. You cite planning advice note 56, which I understand is the standard that we should all use for noise in urban areas. My understanding is that PAN 56 requires that daytime noise not exceed an average of 55dB, and that it does not exceed 45dB at night. The tram projects' noise during construction and during operation will be considerably higher than that.
I am afraid that you are not correct to say that PAN 56 requires that transportation noise be less than 55dB or anything else. PAN 56 serves predominantly to give planning guidance on the development of new housing in already noisy situations. It says that, for levels of below 55dB during the day, noise need not be considered as a planning issue. The guidance that it gives on the introduction of new sources of noise, such as in the case before us, is more general. I think that I quoted some sections of PAN 56 in my original statement.That planning guidance is relevant. In fact, it is one of the only planning guidance documents that we have in relation to noise in this sort of case. There are no standards in the planning system in relation to tram noise, however. Nowhere in this country are there written statutory requirements for noise to be limited. What matters in this particular case is clearly illustrated in table 1 in the rebuttal, which you mentioned. On Queen Street—a five-lane highway and one of the noisiest roads in the city—tram noise will be insignificant compared with the existing noise levels.
That is clearly what you are trying to show. With regard to the night-time measurement, at what period in the night did you do that measurement? Was it between 11 pm and 7 am?
Do you mean the baseline measurement or the predicted level?
Both.
The baseline measurements at York Place, just up the road, were carried out between midnight and half past 12, if I remember correctly. We measured the baseline condition that is shown in the second column of table 1. The predictions apply to the same time. We have considered the noise in two ways: we also considered the change in the ambient noise level in the last hour of service, up to half past 12 at night.
I put it to you that those roads will be much quieter at between 5 and 6 in the morning than they would be at 12 o'clock to half past 12 at night.
I think that that is unlikely. We have done various surveys in Edinburgh in the morning—by which I refer to times around 5 o'clock—as well as at night and we find that there is a pattern. The noise level can, in fact, be slightly higher in the morning than it is at night.Because I have been asked the question, I will refer to a document that is not before the committee. "The National Noise Incidence Survey 2000/2001" examined several hundred sites in England, Wales and Scotland. It considered the pattern of noise throughout the day and there was a clear pattern that noise levels at 5 or 6 in the morning are a few decibels noisier than those between midnight and 1 o'clock in the morning. Furthermore, even if York Place were an unusual, quirky road for some reason, which big main roads tend not to be, the table that is before members estimates the existing night-time noise level at 65dB and the tram noise level at 57dB—8dB quieter than the existing noise level. Even if there is some tolerance in the existing noise level, the tram noise will still be substantially less than the existing noise, so the conclusion that the additional tram noise would be insignificant holds firm.
Is additional noise always insignificant when it is of a different type—for example, a higher-pitched noise rather than the low rumble of a lorry?
We generally consider transportation noise to be a type of noise; a tram vehicle passing by in its noise envelope—its temporal distribution, for example—is not dissimilar in character to a bus or heavy vehicle.If wheel squeal should occur, which might be what Ian Mowat refers to, it is a characteristic noise. That is why I am pleased to say that if it occurs—I do not expect it to—we have the option of offering noise insulation to properties along the route if necessary.
You mentioned that before. What does noise insulation amount to in practice?
Noise insulation under the regulations that apply in England and Wales is clearly defined, so we ought to submit that document to the committee. In fact, I think that the committee has asked for it and we are in the process of producing a copy, if we have not done so already. It is a 20-page document that describes the insulation package. We do not want to reinvent the wheel; there would be the same package here. The most appropriate form of noise insulation is secondary glazing, which is a completely separate sheet of glass that is put inside next to the existing glazing. In most cases, it does not require the existing glazing to be altered. The existing glazing is left intact and a secondary panel is put in with an air space inside the window reveal.
If the tram noise is generally as you predict, but there is also from time to time wheel squeal as the trams come down North St Andrew Street and into the bend—which is nearly as tight as a bend can be for a tram—on to Queen Street, you would not say, "On average, the noise isn't higher than 3dB more than existing noise and thus we will not give properties any insulation." You are going to say, "We accept that there will be a noise problem from time to time and we will pay for the appropriate noise insulation."
First, I have not predicted that there will be wheel squeal; in answer to your question, I predicted that there will not be wheel squeal. If it does occur, you are correct that the noise would not be an average value—it would be what we call a peak value or maximum level. Our discussions with the council are along those lines. It is recognised that such a noise can be a short event so that is the right way to capture, measure and quantify it. You also said that the bend is as tight as it can be for a tram to go round, but that is not the case. Trams quite happily traverse many bends that are substantially tighter than that.
Is not it the case that because the tram comes down a slope into the bend, there is an increased risk of wheel squeal on that bend?
That makes the geometry of design more complex. However, the advice that I have had is that there is nothing particularly unusual in the design, which is why I feel that there will be no wheel squeal on those bends.
Just to clarify, the LAmax tram noise level is 74dB for day and night in your table. That is not wheel squeal; that is the maximum noise level of the tram.
That is the maximum noise level that I have predicted, but as I said, I do not predict that there will be wheel squeal.
What is the characteristic decibel level of wheel squeal?
Wheel squeal varies enormously—as you might imagine—but it could be above 80dB in the location that we are discussing. However, as you said earlier, it also has a character that makes it more noticeable, so the problem is not just its level, but its character. That is why I am pleased that we have a list of measures—which I have been asked not to repeat—that we are committed to taking in the design process to avoid that happening. To deal with wheel squeal in the unlikely event that it occurs, we have four measures, including the offer of noise insulation if necessary.
An environmental statement forms part of the papers that are before the committee. The environmental statement for tramline 1—I apologise for using it, but the environmental statement for tramline 2 stops at Princes Street, so it is awkward—contains a list of possible curve-related noise at various parts of tramline 1, one of which is York Place. The receptors that may be affected by noise are listed as being commercial, which I presume means buildings such as offices. Do you accept that the receptors include residential as well as commercial concerns? I think that the relevant table is table 38—I am afraid that I could not find it today if you asked me to, but you may recall it.
I accept that. I understand that some residential properties lie around that corner, particularly on upper floors.
I also noted in tramline 2's environmental statement that the Noise Insulation (Railways and Other Guided Transport Systems) Regulations 1996 (SI 1996/428) require promoters to offer noise insulation in rooms of a dwelling that are exposed to construction noise that is in excess of 68dB in the daytime and 63dB in the night. A table in tramline 1's statement shows that at York Place, the noise from daytime enabling work would be 84dB and the noise from track laying would be 71dB. We can probably assume that levels at Queen Street will be the same as those at York Place, which is next to it. Do you plan to offer noise insulation during construction?
No—the regulations that you cite relate to operation of a system, not to its construction.
I am pretty sure that the regulations relate to construction.
I am pretty sure that they do not.
Oh dear. That is a technical matter. Will you undertake to check that?
I do not need to check it; I have worked in acoustics for 17 years; I know for a fact that the regulations do not relate to construction.
I presume that there are some regulations that relate to construction noise.
Yes. Section 60 of the Control of Pollution Act 1974 deals with that.
I may have quoted the wrong text. I am sure that I have read a table about noise levels during daytime for enabling work and laying tracks that put the noise level at York Place at 84dB.
You probably have. That is our prediction of construction noise in that area. The 1974 act and the Environmental Protection Act 1990, which superseded the 1974 act to an extent, recognise that essential construction works must take place, so they do not limit noise during construction, which is temporary, as it will be in this case. The noisy work will last a matter of months at most. If the noise level that we have talked about for enabling works is 84dB—I have not checked it, but that could well be the figure—it will last for more like days or weeks of enabling before the track work comes through.The 1974 act does not set noise limits because to do so could preclude essential construction work. It requires the use of the best practicable means to minimise noise disturbance. That is enshrined carefully in the chapters on noise and vibration in the code of construction practice.
I think that that is right. I am sorry if I got the wrong reference.
All that the 1996 regulations say is that if noise insulation is to be offered for the operational phase, it may as well be installed before construction work happens, but that relates more to highways. That is mentioned, but no regulations mention limits for construction noise.
Does TIE propose to take the reasonably practicable measure of offering noise insulation during the construction period for the people who are likely to be affected?
I do not think that we do, because the levels that you just cited—the 68dB LAeq, 18hr and the 63dB LAeq, 6hr—will not be exceeded by the tram's operation.
Okay, so no mitigation at all will be available. What if the noise levels become unbearable during construction? What can a dweller who lives 7m or 8m from the centre line of the road do? What can he refer to?
I am not sure that the residents in question will be 6m or 7m from the centre line of the tramline. As I understand it, the tram is likely to travel down the centre of a five-lane highway.
We are entering the realms of speculation.
I know. I thought that there was a regulation that regulated such matters, but I have been told that there is not. I want to know what regulates levels of construction noise.
As I have just said, the Control of Pollution Act 1974 and the Environmental Protection Act 1990 are the relevant legislation.
What do those acts require?
The 1974 act requires use of the "best practicable means" to minimise noise disturbance. That may sound like a fudge but, as I have explained in my witness rebuttal statement, it is not; it is a tried and tested method of ensuring that the contractor does everything possible to control noise. According to the 1974 act,"‘practicable' means reasonably practicable having regard among other things to local conditions and circumstances, to the current state of technical knowledge and to the financial implications."Section 60 of the act contains the test of "best practicable means". The City of Edinburgh Council will have a very powerful enforcement mechanism in section 60 notices. There is also the code of construction practice, which is—if you like—a voluntary scheme. It contains a list of noise control measures that can be contractually required of the contractor.
I know that the objectors are concerned that the tramline project could overrun its budget; that is a concern of everyone. There is a great worry that financial considerations may loom largest if that happens.
Where are you going with this?
Mr Mitchell has mentioned that financial considerations are part of the best practicable means test. There is a concern that, when it comes to minimising noise disturbance, TIE will be able to say, "Sorry, we just don't have the money to do this; if we do it, the tramline won't get built." Can you assure me that that will not happen and that each case will be looked at on its merits? I can well understand that there are certain things that you just could not afford to do—things that would cost hundreds of millions of pounds, but would achieve only a small result. It is a question of proportionality: the test will be proportional and will not apply to the overall budget.
I can assure you that matters will be dealt with case by case. If one of your residents complained about construction noise, the council's environmental and consumer services department would be statutorily required to respond to that complaint through the processes that are defined in the 1974 act.In the case of the properties in question, ambient noise levels and whether the owners have already chosen to have noise insulation to protect them—I suspect that some may well have done so—will be considerations. In other words, I am saying that although I accept that such a construction project will cause some disturbance to people—it is inconceivable that the tramline could be built without people hearing construction noise and being disturbed or affected by it—I do not think that the location under discussion will be particularly badly affected, mainly because it is already very noisy there and I am sure that people will have taken steps to live comfortably in that noisy environment.
The last issue that you address is tram vibration, which is associated with noise. You mention three steps for reducing tram vibration with on-street running. One is embedding the rail in rubber and another is isolating the slab that it is in. The third measure would not be possible on-street, so there are really only two options. Are you considering adopting those tram vibration reducing measures in the city centre section?
The street-running sections of the tram will run on a rubber-embedded rail. That is a standard design that offers vibration isolation. Within several metres of the track, systems that have those measures in place meet the standard that we have set ourselves for vibration, which is in the noise and vibration policy—I forget which section. We have set ourselves vibration standards that are taken from the British Standard 6472. We have set our targets using the most stringent standards in that British Standard. We can do that because, within four or five metres of that kind of track and operating at those kinds of speeds, we will meet those standards. If the conditions elsewhere are different, other track forms are available that can do the job better if necessary.
One concern that the Dublin Street residents association has expressed, which may be known to many people in Edinburgh, is that an old railway tunnel runs underground from Princes Street down the line of Dublin Street, emerging at Scotland Street. As the committee may know—
I will have to interrupt you again, Mr Mowat. As you will appreciate, we have a volume of papers in front of us. Where does this evidence feature?
The question is whether—
Can I maybe just finish, Mr Mowat? It might speed things up a bit if I do. Where in the original objection was this material raised?
Which original objection? It is mentioned in the Dublin Street residents association evidence. However, it is fair to say that it was not mentioned in the original letter that was written two years ago.
Right. That is fine. You will appreciate the problems that we have in finding it. Carry on.
Have you considered the possible impact of the tramline on the old tunnel?
I am not quite sure what the question is.
Have you considered the possible impact of vibration from the construction and operation of trams on the old tunnel?
No, at this stage I have not.
Well—
I can say that a general discussion of damage to structures is to be found in the environmental statement, which talks about the levels that we get from trams in terms of the unit of peak particle velocity. Those levels are not high enough to damage structures at the sort of distances that we are interested in. If trams were to be in the business of damaging structures, the 400 systems that I think Mr Oldfield referred to earlier would have caused all sorts of problems all round the world. Trams do not produce enough vibration to damage structures.
Okay. I have no further questions.
Basically, we will not be able to consider that evidence because it was not in the original objection. You were allowed a fair amount of latitude, Mr Mowat. I move to questions from the committee.
I seek clarification on the code of construction practice. As far as you are aware, are the decibel levels that are indicated in the code part of the contract for the construction of the tramline? Will they be policed if contractors go over the levels during the construction period?
I think that the member is asking me about the contractual obligations of the code.
Yes.
My understanding is that the code of construction practice will become a contractual requirement of the main contractor, although I do not have the fine detail. If the contractor is in breach of the noise limits, it will be in breach of contract.
Thank you. In answering Mr Mowat's questions or in any of your evidence on the alignment south of the Scottish National Portrait Gallery, would any of your evidence have been different in principle if the alignment was all within St Andrew Square?
That is a very wide question. The member is asking me to recap on what I have said in the last half an hour or so and to consider the questions for a different alignment.
You could get back to us on that.
In general terms, I think that there would be no difference in most of my answers. They are, however, not immediately before me for me to process them in my mind.
If you wish, you could reflect on the question and come back to us. I am not sure whether that is in order.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Edinburgh Tram (Line Two) Bill Committee Wednesday 22 June 2005 Bill debate · 1
- Consideration Stage Evidence session · 1
- Proposed Route Changes Committee business · 5
- Consideration Stage Evidence session · 469
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.