Our next item of business relates to the Sea Fishing (Restriction on Days at Sea) (Scotland) Order 2003. Richard Lochhead has lodged a motion inviting the committee to recommend that nothing further be done under the order. The Subordinate Legislation Committee reported on the order in its 18th report of 2003 and made a number of comments. An extract from the report has been sent to members.Again, I propose that we have a question-and-answer session to clarify purely technical details. When that is complete, we will move to the debate on the motion, in which officials cannot take part. Minister, would you like to make any opening remarks?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Sea Fishing (Restriction on Days at Sea) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/56)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 19
- Alex Fergusson Con 14
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 6
- Richard Lochhead SNP 5
- Jamie McGrigor Con 5
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
- Irene Oldfather Lab 3
- Donald Carmichael 1
- Robin Weatherston 1
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
The record
65 contributionsThis is a difficult issue. We have to focus on the purpose of the instrument and the law that underpins it. Clearly, there is a huge political debate about the issues that surround annexe XVII in relation to the total allowable catch and quota regulations and, as Donald Carmichael indicated, there are outstanding issues. We must concentrate for a moment on where the order stands in relation to European Union law and on where the Scottish Parliament stands in relation to the instrument. The need for the order flows from the requirements of annexe XVII of the fisheries council regulation 2341/2002. In terms of domestic law, there is no question but that the Scottish Parliament has an obligation to transpose that and to make orders that provide for implementation of the days-at-sea regulations. I particularly want to draw the committee's attention to additional matters. Some issues are at the discretion of member states and can give advantages to the industry in terms of the implementation and application of annexe XVII. In particular, in drawing up the instrument to transpose the arrangements into domestic law, we have provided—as is only just possible within the instrument—four additional features: we have created a two-month rather than a one-month effort management period, which offers fishermen more flexibility to manage their fishing operations; we have arranged for the transfer of days from one management period to the next; we have arranged for the transfer of days between vessels in order to facilitate a more efficient and viable operation across the fleet; and we have incorporated in the amendment order procedures for fishermen to make representations to ministers about any decisions to deduct fishing days as required by annexe XVII. If we left things as they stand, we would not be carrying out our obligation to transpose the arrangements and we would not be affording our fishermen those limited but nevertheless important additional flexibilities in translating the arrangements into domestic legislation. It must be remembered that annexe XVII has direct effect. Even if we did not introduce the domestic legislation and enforcement provisions, fishermen would still technically be covered by the generality of annexe XVII.Of course, there is another issue, which is that we must try to create a different atmosphere and encourage the Commission to bring forward as quickly as is humanly possible not just amendments to annexe XVII, but provisions that would take us beyond the interim measures. In the circumstances, it would be imprudent for us to send out a signal that we are unwilling or reluctant to meet our European obligations and that we wish to annul the instrument. Doing so might send out the wrong message to the Commission when we are trying to build greater confidence with those with whom we have spoken in recent days.I understand the inherent dislike that many members have for the measures that the order provides for. We wish to improve matters and we continue to pursue that, but, with all due respect, there is a risk of shooting the industry and ourselves in the foot if we decide to annul the instrument. As I said, doing so would remove important flexibilities and rights of appeal and would leave our fishermen simply implementing the generality of annexe XVII without those flexibilities and rights of appeal. I hope that I have set out the general position. As always, I will be happy to take questions.
I thank the minister and remind members that questions should be put for the purposes of clarification and explanation—we will have a debate later. As the motion is in the name of Richard Lochhead, I invite him to put questions to the minister.
I will say why I lodged the motion for annulment. Unfortunately, we are having a retrospective discussion of the order—its practical arrangements are already in force. We have no alternative but to lodge a motion of annulment, as no other options exist to ensure that the committee has the opportunity to express a view. In moving the motion, I understand that I must question the minister.
You will move the motion later and we will have a debate later—this is a question-and-answer session involving the minister and his officials.
In that case, will the minister say whether it is guaranteed that Europe will make the necessary changes to the legislation and that we are not relying simply on Europe's word, given that it has often broken its word in the past? Do the proposed amendments address all the concerns that the industry has expressed since the arrangements were put in place at the beginning of February?
I regret that I do not think that I can give absolute guarantees that account has been taken of every proposed change. Perhaps Donald Carmichael can outline the areas in question.This might not be the final word on the matter. We have made considerable progress. As I said to the committee when I appeared before it last time, the people who have been dealing with the changes were by and large not involved in the December negotiations and appear to have been better able to understand some of the serious flaws in the original draft. Donald Carmichael might like to discuss the broad areas in which we think we might have made some progress, although we have not seen the draft measures.
The general aspiration that has underpinned all our discussions has been to achieve greater economic and commercial flexibility. The following examples are merely illustrative. First, we have been pressing for a more flexible definition of a fishing day—why not just have a 24-hour period? We have also been pressing for more flexible arrangements under which vessels would be allowed to transfer days. Although those arrangements would have to be subject to appropriate limits, a number of smaller boats might be able to transfer days that they do not need to bigger boats, for example.We have pressed for sensible arrangements to take account of breakdowns or what the lawyers call force majeure. We have also pressed for a solution for the nephrops fishermen, who are inadvertently caught by the regulation because they use twin rigs and nets of 100mm mesh size. Those examples illustrate the sorts of issues that we have been discussing. As I said, the indications are that the Commission will produce a bit of paper either this week or next week. I cannot guarantee when that will happen, but the indications are that the Commission will shortly produce something that will be helpful in the areas that I specified.
Given that the issue was down for discussion in committee today, it is wholly unsatisfactory that officials have not yet seen the draft and that we are having to work on the basis of a hypothetical situation. Perhaps the minister can comment on the time scale for the draft. Donald Carmichael has just said that we will see it in the next week or two, but what about the debate tomorrow in the chamber? All the SSIs that are before the committee today are interlinked in that respect.I also want to ask the minister about the time scale for the measures. Once the SSIs are passed by the committee and the Parliament, the powers that are granted in relation to the days-at-sea measures are in place until the end of the year. Is the minister confident that those powers will be replaced on 1 July as the industry and everyone else was led to believe?
I will take the last point first. The whole process is about rebuilding confidence and bridges with the Commission. As Donald Carmichael said, in addition to engaging on a regular basis with the Commission on the particular issues that relate to annexe XVII, we have been very much in the vanguard of pressing the Commission to bring forward alternative proposals for discussion.I cannot give a guarantee about the time scale. As I indicated earlier, however, we will spare no effort in supporting the introduction of the measures, although whether we will support the detail is a different matter. We will engage with the Commission in the way that we attempted to engage with it on a cod recovery plan during October, November and the earlier part of December.I regret that there is no draft. As I said, we have to deal with what is a very unsatisfactory situation as we find it. I take Richard Lochhead's point that lodging a motion for annulment was the only way of securing a debate. My plea to the committee is that we try to discuss the progress that has been made. We are trying to establish with the Commission that we take seriously what it is doing, albeit that we are highly critical of it. Given that we are trying to do that, not implementing the measure would give out entirely the wrong signals. We are in the extraordinarily difficult position of trying to secure further amendments while not wanting to give out the signal to the Commission that we are seeking in some way to dilute its efforts in respect of annexe XVII. I understand the concerns of all members about the process. I, too, have concerns. It would have been enormously helpful for the Commission to have produced the draft. It has not done so, but that is not for want of trying by my officials.
I remain convinced that the main problem that the fishermen face is a lack of quota. I am sure that the minister is aware that an average trip for a dedicated white-fish vessel is about nine days. Nine cannot be fitted into 15 more than once, nor can eight be fitted into 15 more than once. I take on board what the minister said about having a two-month plan, which would presumably bring us to 30 days, but does he understand that that would basically change the whole complexion of the white-fish industry and the way in which it works?
Yes, I understand the point perfectly, but that will not happen by my design. We have received all sorts of representations on the issue. I am bound to say to Jamie McGrigor that we have tried to interpret the regulation within the flexibility that is available for a domestic legislature so as to address the point that he made at the outset of his remarks. We are introducing the two-month period to overcome the near impossibility—indeed, the impossibility—of getting nine to divide into 15. I do not suggest that implementing the two-month period is the answer, but it will introduce a welcome flexibility for a large number of vessels. That is one reason why I think that we should adopt the measures, albeit that they may need to be amended in the light of what we have been discussing.
Will the minister clarify whether, if a vessel did three trips in two months that amounted to 27 days, the three days that were left over could be handed on to another boat?
The simple answer is yes. Inevitably, things are more complicated than that because of controls on capacity and so on, but the domestic legislation that we propose would allow that sort of flexibility.
Is there a danger that, in any future negotiations with Brussels on the common fisheries policy—if it still exists—the days-at-sea scheme will be considered to be the track record? In future times, might Brussels consider the catching capacity of Scottish vessels under that scheme to be the historic record and so think that the capacity is less than has been the case?
I seem to recall raising that issue in December. I said that, if a new regime is introduced, any measures should not be used for the purpose to which Jamie McGrigor refers. We were, and remain, alert to that possibility. Given the nature of the discussions that we are having, and if there is to be a continuation of effort and we move away from a crude days-at-sea scheme to a kilowatt-days scheme, I hope that what the member suggests will not be the case. I think that we will move into different territory at that stage.
Last, given the fact that we have had such enormous quota cuts, why was it necessary to have a days-at-sea scheme at all?
The issue was twofold. First, there was a need to start on a plan for cod recovery, which clearly involved effort limitation. That was part of the annexe to the quota cuts. One could argue—as Jamie McGrigor has argued—that the nature of the cuts meant that we were in a different situation. However, two quite separate debates were going on. One debate was about a recovery plan that contained other elements and sought to reduce effort by not less than 65 per cent, and there was another, separate debate concerning the relationship between all the species and the need for a further reduction in cod. I share Jamie McGrigor's analysis that, at the end of the day, it is best if the impact on the fishermen is evenly distributed between days at sea and quota. Possibly, the impact should come more from quota.
I think that Mr Carmichael mentioned that one of the things for which the minister is pressing is recognition of the fact that the nephrops fleet, which uses twin rigs and 100mm nets, has inadvertently been caught in a measure that is intended to limit cod-catching efforts. The minister is aware that, of the 400 tonnes of fish landed at Mallaig in about the past year, only 4 tonnes have been cod. Therefore, the bycatch is not only minimal but virtually de minimis.What response has been received from the Commission on the specific proposals that Robert Stevenson of the West of Scotland Fish Producers Organisation and Hugh Allen of the Mallaig and North West Fishermen's Association have made? Will those people be consulted? Will you meet them to discuss any response that you receive from the Commission on the need for particular measures to allow the nephrops fleet to continue?
With the prospect that the Commission would not make such a proposal, we consulted the industry on the unfortunate measures that might have to be taken to remove the clearly unintended effect of nephrops fishermen being taken into the gear restrictions by their using 100mm mesh. As Fergus Ewing knows, we have consulted extensively the nephrops fisheries on the west and east coasts on what changes might be made to the gear to get them out of that restriction. However, as Fergus Ewing will tell me, and as I appreciate, many nephrops fishermen are unhappy about that prospect because it drives them down an anti-conservation and anti-quality road.We have been heavily engaged in the consultative process. Once we get proposals on all the issues—not only the nephrops fishery but the other matters—we will want to engage with those affected. I hope that we get a clearly and simply worded exemption, which would avoid us having to take action that might force us to take anti-conservation measures. The fact that we have had to contemplate anti-conservation measures has concentrated minds wonderfully in Brussels.
My last question is general. A great many fishermen and their wives have stated that fishing is an inherently dangerous activity and that the automatic consequence of a restriction on the number of days on which one is permitted to fish will result in fishermen feeling that they have to continue fishing in weather in which they would hitherto not have done so. Does the minister accept that a consequence of the scheme will be to increase the already risky nature of fishing and the possibility of serious mishap or fatality? Does Commissioner Franz Fischler take that factor into account at all? It seems to me that there is an attitude of complete intransigence on that aspect. As the minister knows, I have raised the matter in every fishing debate, but I have yet to hear the minister comment on it. I would also like to know what response he receives when he raises that argument with the commissioner.
Such cases have been brought to our attention. Notwithstanding the absence of clear authority in the instruments, my position and that of my officials is that, on questions of safety, it is clear that the guidance is to put safety first.Perhaps Donald Carmichael's earlier response, in which he referred to breakdowns and talked about force majeure, was not entirely clear. I am sorry—we should perhaps have expanded on it. At its heart were instances in which the rules' total inflexibility could, as Fergus Ewing rightly says, force fishermen to go to or remain at sea in circumstances that are simply not safe. We are pressing that issue, and we are trying to interpret the rules as sensitively and compassionately as we are able. We are doing that off our own bat. I am bound to say that I would prefer to have legal cover, but we are not letting that interfere with us giving guidance. We are quite unequivocal. There is nothing between Fergus Ewing and myself because we both realise that safety is paramount.
I would expect nothing less. Will you comment on what Franz Fischler said when the matter was raised with him?
In the regular discussions that we have had in Scotland and in Brussels about amendments to the current regulations, the issues of safety, breakdowns and force majeure have been considered. We will be bitterly disappointed if those issues do not form part of the amendments.
One hopes that the onus will not be on the fishermen to prove that they qualify for exemption in those circumstances.
I would like clarification of something that the minister said earlier. As a member state, do we have a legal obligation to implement the measures? Would failure to transpose them into legislation leave us open to infraction proceedings? Could infraction proceedings lead to financial penalties? If that were the case, would the money come out of the United Kingdom budget or the Scottish block grant?
The answers to that would be yes, no, yes, yes and no.
Thank you, minister.
The regulations have the same legislative effect as any other piece of EU legislation. The constitutional position is somewhat anomalous because of the quite proper right to lodge—as Richard Lochhead has done—a motion of annulment. If passed, that motion would lead us into an interesting constitutional position, because the Scotland Act 1998 clearly obliges us to implement the regulations.Notwithstanding those difficulties, I appeal to members to understand that there are additional flexibilities in the regulations. We also appear to be getting movement from the Commission, although it has not been made clear whether the Commission will use its own powers or send the issue back to the agriculture and fisheries council that is to be held in March, which is slightly disappointing.In theory, not implementing the measures would lead to infraction, but we ought not to go there.
Did you say that any money would not come out of the Scottish block grant? I understood that although the infraction proceedings would be against a member state, the money would come out of the Scottish budget.
If we voted against implementing the regulations, I suppose it would, yes, because we would have caused the mischief—it would have been at our hand.
My first point is about a significant constituency interest. Do you intend to add Macduff to the list of designated ports? Landings there exceed those at several ports that are on the designated list. I will not name them because that would allow you to take them off the list.Alternatively, will you reinstate the four-hour notice procedure that existed previously? I draw the minister's attention to another order that is before the committee today, SSI 2003/88, which continues to allow such provisions of prior notice in relation to unsorted herring. Why are the people of Macduff being denied that right?
We are conscious of the administrative burdens that are arising as a result of the changed arrangements. We are trying to take an overview. You will not be surprised to hear that Macduff, although it is almost the only case that we should be considering, is not the only case that has been put to us. We are considering the issue carefully, but there are enforcement and other issues for us to consider through the SFPA. Representations have been received, and we understand the issues that have been put to us. We are reviewing the implications. It is a question of resources—if we do it, how do we regulate and enforce it?The issue does not relate solely to Macduff. If we were dealing with only one port, the decision would not be difficult, but we have received representations from several ports. The matter is under active consideration at the moment.
It does not appear that you would need extra resources to police lower cod landings—including at Macduff—in the current year than you needed last year, when higher aggregate cod landings were permitted. I ask you to consider that.I want to clarify the definition of "unused days" that appears in SSI 2003/56. The arithmetical definition is quite clear. However, I want to focus on vessels that are steaming without gear on board. Would a vessel that was steaming without gear ever find that that time counted towards days at sea for the purposes of the SSI?
The paragraph to which Stewart Stevenson refers indicates that the word "days" relates to days in a designated area with gear. The obverse of that is that the answer to the member's question must be no.
So the clock would start ticking from the moment that a fishing vessel collected its gear from a non-fishing vessel stationed in an area, for example.
That raises an interesting question about what the person was doing when they left port. The question treads slightly on an evasion issue. Why would someone act as Stewart Stevenson describes?
I suggest the word avoidance.
Indeed. The matter would have to be decided by the facts on the day. A choice would have to be made. I must think carefully about the circumstances in which someone would act as the member has described. I understood Stewart Stevenson's initial question and follow where he has gone from there, but I cannot deal with the member's second point directly. Earlier, Donald Carmichael indicated that there might be more flexibility in the clock ticking from port. That might reduce the pressure on people to adopt a strategy of avoidance. A more flexible definition of when a day begins would be of assistance in that matter.
I am concerned that gear might be left at ports that are the shortest possible steaming time from the fishing grounds that are to be exploited. That could disadvantage Scottish ports in a variety of ways. An appropriately flexible interpretation of the regulations is necessary to avoid disadvantaging Scottish ports and hence Scottish onshore industries that are ancillary to fishing.
Before we debate the motion, I would like the minister to clarify an answer that he gave to an earlier question from Irene Oldfather. If we are found to be infringing European legislation and are penalised financially for that, who will have to pay the penalty? Will it be paid from the UK budget or from the Scottish block grant? I think that you said that you supposed it would be paid from the Scottish block grant, but I am not absolutely clear about that.
If the infringement is a United Kingdom matter, the penalty will fall on the UK Treasury. However, if the Scottish Parliament is responsible for the breach, people will come to us in the first instance.
We move now to debate the motion. Under parliamentary procedure, we are allowed 90 minutes for that, although I hope that we will not need all that time. I invite Richard Lochhead to speak to and move motion S1M-3967.
I will be relatively brief, because we have discussed many of the issues, at this meeting and previously.As I said earlier, it is unfortunate that we are taking a retrospective approach to the statutory instrument. The arrangements have been in place since 1 February, yet only now in March is the committee able to express its views. A motion of annulment is the only option that is open to a committee member to ensure a proper debate and an opportunity for the community to express a view, with the minister present for that debate.I do not think it is right for the committee to endorse legislation that was, in effect, foisted upon Scotland at the fisheries council in December without notice, without consultation and without a great deal of thought having been given to it. The SSI is a draconian measure, and the Minister for Environment and Rural Development himself, Ross Finnie, has on numerous occasions referred to the measures as "crude". He has also referred to them as "inequitable" and "unfair". For that reason, we should not even contemplate endorsing this legislation.Back in December last year, the industry was hoping for breathing space that would allow the science to be updated with regard to white-fish and other stocks, and allow the cod recovery plan to be put into place further down the line, but we ended up with a delay before the cod recovery plan could come forward. If everything goes according to plan, it will be in place in July. In the meantime, the draconian days-at-sea measures have been put in place. What we have as a result is a dog's dinner, and the situation is causing problems and a huge amount of concern among fishing communities. As I will illustrate, that is unjust and has ramifications not only for the white-fish fleet but for other parts of the catching sector and for the onshore sector. There is a huge issue around the measures, which will have ramifications throughout our fishing communities and the fishing industry.The measures are unjust, because the white-fish fleet in Scotland, which uses the biggest mesh in the North sea, gets the fewest fishing days per month. Furthermore, our white-fish fleet has had imposed on it cod recovery measures that couple management of cod with management of other white-fish stocks. Other countries that fish the North sea—and, indeed, that fish the Scottish fishing grounds—have managed to decouple those stocks from the management of cod.We have been left with regulations that are, as many of us have said today, dangerous. We do not have a guarantee at present. We have not even seen the Commission's draft amendments to the days-at-sea regulations that would allow our fishermen to operate in a safe environment at sea. We know that there have been a number of times over the past few weeks when fishermen have felt obliged to stay at sea in bad weather because they would otherwise have had their allocated days infringed.The days-at-sea legislation that is under discussion is ill thought out—it is a dog's dinner. There was absolutely no consultation of the fishing industry before the measures were imposed upon Scotland by Europe. The regulations may well end up being in place until the end of the year; that is legally possible if we approve the measures today and it would be the most unfortunate outcome for the Scottish fishing industry and our fishing communities. I do not think that we in Scotland should merely accept everything that Europe throws at us, especially given that the regulations will be so disastrous for our fishing communities. Please support my motion. The last thing the committee wants to do is to endorse the legislation before us.I move,That the Rural Development Committee recommends that nothing further be done under the Sea Fishing (Restriction on Days at Sea) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/56).
I invite the minister to respond, after which we will have an open debate.
Two separate matters arise from Richard Lochhead's remarks. Much of what he says is directed at a debate on how we arrived at our conclusions at the Council of Ministers in December. That is not quite the issue that is before us now, however. This is not the time or the place for us to rehearse an argument that was effectively concluded at the December council. We have to consider carefully what is a most difficult and awkward choice—I agree with Richard Lochhead to that extent. We accept or leave ourselves open to either failing to implement the European legislation or—perhaps even worse—to its being requested that we continue to implement the European directive as it stands, which is capable of being enforced without being translated into domestic legislation.We have stated clearly to the Commission that we seek further amendment on key areas. On the bad side, I hope that the regulation will not remain as it stands until December. However, if it does, I would prefer that our fishermen had the opportunity, which the regulation provides, to have a two-month rather than a one-month effort management period. I also hope that the fishermen will have a transfer of days from one management period to the next. They should also have a transfer of vessels to facilitate efficient and viable operations throughout the fleet. Crucially, there should be procedures for fishermen to make representations on and appeal against decisions that relate to the reduction of fishing days as required by annexe XVII. Not all of those options are open to them under the Council regulation, but they are available through the instrument.I acknowledge that the choice is difficult. However, the matter is about difficult choices; the measures are not simple and I appeal to the committee to recognise the legal obligations. The committee should also recognise that, if the argument is balanced, we require that careful consideration be given to our message to the European Commission about our desire to extract from it considerable changes and, indeed, a revised regime. I do not believe that we would be giving the right message by annulling the instrument today.
I wish to oppose Richard Lochhead's motion. It will be the height of irresponsibility to follow the course of action that he has suggested. Paragraph 3.1 of the regulatory impact assessment states:"Member states have a legal obligation to implement and enforce the measures."Whatever we think of the UK member-state negotiations with the European Council, the fact is that they took place. The restrictions were the result of the negotiations, whether or not we agree with them. As far as I am concerned, whether we think it could have been handled better or worse is not the issue.The question is simple: should we flout EU regulations, as Richard Lochhead proposes? If the committee decides to follow Richard Lochhead's route, there will be a crisis. The fishing industry will be thrown into further crisis, but more important, it would throw us into a constitutional crisis. In my view, that is what is behind Richard Lochhead's motion. We would have a constitutional crisis because Richard Lochhead would have us throw out the regulations on the ground that if the Scottish Parliament threw them out, the UK Government would have no option but to step in and use Westminster's powers to override the Scottish Parliament. The issue would then grow and take on far greater proportions than we would have thought it could. I am not impressed by Richard Lochhead's arguments. He is using party political rhetoric to get us into a position that will cause a constitutional crisis. It is clear that negotiations have taken place with member states and that we are where we are. The minister said that it was unfortunate that Richard Lochhead lodged his motion. In fact, the minister acknowledged that Richard had little option but to lodge the motion if he wanted a debate, which is absolutely true. However, before the debate took place, we had 34 minutes of questions to the minister, and Richard Lochhead managed to ask many questions of the minister and his officials. It was quite important for him to do that, but that was the committee's opportunity to discuss the matter. In fact, there is a debate in the Parliament tomorrow about the subject. I feel very angry that Richard Lochhead has used the committee to lodge his motion. By doing so, he is trying to politicise the issue even more and make it into some sort of constitutional crisis. I will certainly not support the motion, and I hope that other members will not do so either.
I shall withhold my support from the order for a number of reasons, the first of which is absolutely nothing to do with party politics and everything to do with the vital interests of people in my parliamentary constituency. I asked the minister about the position of Macduff, where 200 jobs might be under threat if trawlers have to divert from the town to land their catches at Fraserburgh and/or Peterhead. Both ports have maintenance facilities that fishermen will inevitably use in preference to Macduff, where they have previously landed their catches. If for that reason only, my constituents would expect absolutely no less of me than to withhold support from the order.My second reason for withholding support is based simply on the evidence of the detailed construction of the orders. I will focus on one aspect—the powers of sea fishery officers—because it is possible to see how different expressions of the same principle across the various orders indicate a measure of haste, imprecision and risk in their drafting. I probably have not found all the references in that respect, but article 14 in the Sea Fishing (Restriction on Days at Sea) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/56) contains a definition of where a fishery officer may exercise his or her powers, whereas article 16 contains a second—and different—definition of where those powers may be exercised in relation to "fish and fishing gear". Furthermore, in the Sea Fish (Prohibited Methods of Fishing) (Firth of Clyde) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/79), the definition in article 4 of sea fishery officers' powers in relation to fishing boats differs again. I should also point out that there is a reference to "any relevant … fishing boat" for reasons that might not be clear. Finally, the Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Community Quota and Third Country Fishing Measures) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/88) contains yet another variation in the definition of such powers in article 7 and of powers in relation to "fish and fishing gear" in article 9.All those examples—and possibly the exclusion of Macduff—indicate haste. I was not at all convinced that the town's exclusion this year under the new arrangements was justified on the basis of additional effort; indeed, there is less effort. For those reasons, I will withhold my support from the order to which Richard Lochhead's amendment refers.
When Richard Lochhead claimed earlier that he had lodged the motion to allow us to have a debate, I disagreed. After all, we often have questions about SSIs and the minister has never refused to come before us to answer them. However, I realised that Richard might be indulging in some political posturing and felt that that would be okay because he would not force the matter to a vote. At best, what he is doing would remove an appeals procedure from our fishing communities and would at worst leave us open to even more draconian measures than those that we face at the moment. Furthermore, he is asking Parliament to act illegally. I cannot believe that he is doing that. As a result, I ask him to seek to withdraw the motion, because it puts us all in an extremely difficult position. By agreeing to it we would not be supporting our fishing communities and, indeed, we would be sending the wrong signals to Europe.
For once, I do not believe that Richard Lochhead is indulging in political posturing. Mike Rumbles mentioned a "constitutional crisis", but that would not mean much to people in Shetland, Fraserburgh and Peterhead because we are talking here about a fishing crisis, rather than a constitutional crisis. It is entirely wrong that the days-at-sea scheme—which is, after all, part of Mr Fischler's obsession with the cod-recovery plan that is bringing the Scottish fishing industry to its knees—should be supported by Parliament. Why do not we ask Mr Fischler what has happened to the hake-recovery plan that seems to have disappeared from the agenda? There was also to be a moratorium on hake.The days-at-sea scheme is unnecessary because of the enormous quota cuts. If 100 vessels decommission in this round, that will be equivalent to a loss of 900 days at sea to Scotland's fishing industry under the terms of the deal that was done. We have already given up 900 days at sea. The scheme compromises the safety of vessels and changes the complexion of the whole white-fish fishing industry. We have no idea how long the scheme will last; it is hoped that the measures will not last beyond July, but I have my doubts. If one takes the fact that that would be a five-month period, two does not go into five, just as nine does not go into 15. February and March make two; April and May make two; and June is on its own. The fishermen will lose out on the two-month scenario on one of those combinations of months. For that reason, I would find it extraordinarily hard to support any days-at-sea scheme of this kind.
I begin by applauding Richard Lochhead; he has, at least, demonstrated an element of consistency in that he has been consistently irresponsible. None of us will forget his infantile posturing on the streets of Brussels while the two ministers tried to secure a good deal for Scotland and for the UK. He has consistently undermined the genuine steps and efforts that have been undertaken on behalf of our fishing communities. Today, he has again demonstrated beautifully his failure to understand the most basic of simple facts and has flown in the face of the indisputable facts that have been presented by officials and Ross Finnie this afternoon. It is not often that I find myself in agreement with Mike Rumbles, but I agree that his doing so was tawdry and purely partisan—the worst type of low-grade politics. Is it any wonder that the youngest political party in Scotland is targeting Richard Lochhead's constituency? His conduct is irresponsible in the extreme, and it is for purely political reasons. He certainly does not have in mind the best interests of the fishing communities.
I think the combination of decommissioning and restriction of effort is an extraordinarily crude approach to preserving cod stocks. It has been tried and failed off Grand banks, Newfoundland, where 10 years after a ban on fishing, cod still has not recovered. The combination also compromises safety, as the minister has acknowledged, although I did not get the sense from the minister that the Commissioner has acknowledged that—Mr Fischler really must express an opinion on that before it is too late.Science underlies the measures and when he was here recently, Mr Elliot Morley wrongly imputed that we were intent on ignoring scientific evidence—an extraordinarily puerile allegation that is completely untrue. Tony Hawkins, former director of Fisheries Research Services, said in Aberdeen on 11 February that the science in relation to the separation of stocks is "poor and uncertain". Therefore, we rely to an extent on evidence that is by necessity "poor and uncertain". That is the verdict of the man who used to work for the minister.I turn to specific points on the unfortunate statutory instrument. I wonder whether the regulations could have been set out differently because, as they are, the onus is placed on skippers to prove that they are not committing a crime. It is assumed that they will have been committing a crime unless they can prove certain factual circumstances in their defence. That is a pretty punitive approach, and I wonder whether it is strictly necessary.Margaret Ewing referred to the huge powers that fisheries officers will have; that has been commented on already. Irene Oldfather asked the sensible question what would be the consequence if the order were annulled. I notice that the minister did not respond by saying that an automatic infraction would result; rather, he said that annulment might in theory lead ultimately to that. That is entirely different from what has been represented. I know that if the minister seriously believed that the consequence of annulment of the order was automatic infraction, he would have advanced that clearly, but that was not the form of words that he used in responding to questions.In any event, given that the minister has indicated that there have been four additional attempts to ameliorate the harsh and oppressive results of the measure—two months rather than one month, the ability for vessels to carry forward up to 20 per cent, the transfer of days from one vessel to another, and the appeal process—we do not need to be a rubber stamp. Those changes also demonstrate that other measures could have been taken to ameliorate the measures—measures which have been remarked on by other members in the debate. For all those reasons, it would not be correct to endorse the statutory instrument.I finish by saying that members who have chosen in their remarks to personalise the issue and to attack members in the way that they have demean themselves. I suggest that they should cease playing the man and start playing the ball in future.
Before I ask Richard Lochhead to wind up, it is only right to give the minister the opportunity to answer the—Interruption. I apologise, Irene. Minister, I must keep you in suspense a moment longer.
I will make my remarks brief. Parliament has a responsibility—which is discharged by my own European Committee—to examine the transposition of legislation from the European Union into Scottish and UK law. We take that responsibility seriously, and I can assure the committee that where there is late transposition or non-transposition, we hold the Executive to account. That is why I was interested to hear the minister's response to the four questions. It is clear to me that we have a legal obligation, that we will be open to infraction proceedings if we do not transpose the legislation—I disagree with Fergus Ewing on that—and that financial penalties will be imposed. It is also my understanding, which was confirmed by the minister, that any fine that might be imposed upon us would be paid out of the Scottish grant. We must regard that seriously. On that basis, I cannot vote for Richard Lochhead's motion.
I apologise for nearly missing you out, Irene. I am intrigued by your reference to your own committee. The thought of this being "my own" committee is one that fills me with horror. Nonetheless, I am fond of the committee. Before I ask Richard Lochhead to wind up, I give the minister an opportunity to address the many points that have been put during the debate.
Most of the arguments have been well rehearsed, but I will make one or two quick points. First, I am bound to say that it is not for me to determine whether, should the committee annul the instrument, the European Commission will commence infraction proceedings at 5 o'clock tonight or at any other time. That is a matter for the European Commission, therefore my remarks as a Scottish minister cannot be construed as indicating whether or when the Commission will proceed in that way. The fact is that we would be in breach of law, as Irene Oldfather just said.Secondly, on the further exemptions that we have introduced into SSI 2003/56, which are not in the regulation, I say to Fergus Ewing that I do not believe that there is a variety of approaches. We are somewhat constrained in how we can interpret the legislation, but we have interpreted it as flexibly as we can. I remind all members that the four additional flexibilities will not exist if the instrument is annulled.Notwithstanding the fact that we can rehearse the December debate again and again and again and again, we have to decide today whether, in these extraordinarily difficult circumstances, our fishermen would be better operating under the regulation as it is, or whether they would be better operating under the instrument as transposed into domestic legislation, with the additional flexibilities. I submit humbly to the committee that it would be much better for our fishermen to have the advantage of that domestic translation.
Thank you. I ask Richard Lochhead to wind up on the motion in his name, and to indicate whether he wishes to press or withdraw his motion.
It is always a thrill to listen to Alasdair Morrison's pro-Richard Lochhead speeches. He must be the only politician on the Government benches who consistently blames the Opposition spokesperson for a crisis facing a key Scottish industry.The thrust of all my comments in the debate has been that the committee should not, for the reasons that I outlined in my introductory remarks, endorse the legislation. Parliament and the committee should not give a damn what Europe thinks because, quite clearly, Europe—in the form of the European Commission and Franz Fischler—does not give a damn what the Parliament or Scotland thinks. On that note, I press my motion, in order that the committee can vote and express a view.
The question is, that motion S1M-3967, in the name of Richard Lochhead, be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
Division list (how members voted)
AgainstGrant, Rhoda (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)Morrison, Mr Alasdair (Western Isles) (Lab)Munro, John Farquhar (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)Oldfather, Irene (Cunninghame South) (Lab)Rumbles, Mr Mike (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD)Smith, Elaine (Coatbridge and Chryston) (Lab)AbstentionsEwing, Fergus (Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber) (SNP)Fergusson, Alex (South of Scotland) (Con)Lochhead, Richard (North-East Scotland) (SNP)McGrigor, Mr Jamie (Highlands and Islands) (Con)Stevenson, Stewart (Banff and Buchan) (SNP)
The result of the division is: For 0, Against 6, Abstentions 5.
Motion disagreed to.
I thank the minister and his officials for attending, and invite them to withdraw.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 4 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 84
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 80
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 65
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.