Members will recall that, following the Parliament's agreement to last week's business motion, the Sea Fishing (Transitional Support) (Scotland) (No 2) Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/116) and the Fishing Vessels (Decommissioning) (Scotland) Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/87) will be debated by the Parliament tomorrow morning.I am grateful to the minister for volunteering to come and answer members' questions and to assist us in our deliberations prior to the debate in the chamber. I am sure that he is aware of the committee's views on the instruments, given our recently published report on the current issues affecting the Scottish fishing industry.I think that I am right to say that the minister is also able to answer questions about the instruments that will implement restrictions on days at sea. However, as that is the subject of our next agenda item, I suggest, and ask, that members restrict their comments under this item to the two affirmative instruments that we are discussing.I welcome Ross Finnie, Minister for Environment and Rural Development. I thank him for coming and invite him to introduce his officials before he makes his opening remarks. It is worth pointing out that, as we have a full agenda, I intend to move on to the next agenda item at around 4 o'clock.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Sea Fishing (Transitional Support) (Scotland) (No 2) Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/116) Fishing Vessels (Decommissioning) (Scotland) Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/87)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 31
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 8
- Richard Lochhead SNP 8
- Alex Fergusson Con 6
- Paul Cackette Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 5
- Robin Weatherston Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 5
- Jamie McGrigor Con 5
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
- Rhoda Grant Lab 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Donald Carmichael Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 1
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
- Margaret Ewing SNP 1
The record
80 contributionsI am joined by Robin Weatherston, the depute head of the sea fisheries division in the Scottish Executive, Paul Cackette, from the Office of the Solicitor to the Scottish Executive, Ewen Milligan, from the sea fisheries division, and Donald Carmichael, the head of the sea fisheries division. Robin is more concerned with the technicalities that make up the statutory instruments.I have one or two introductory comments to make. As the convener rightly said, there are two instruments to consider under the affirmative procedure. The instruments back the support package that we announced on 28 January. One instrument deals with the decommissioning scheme; the other deals with the transitional support scheme.In general, the decommissioning scheme follows the approach taken by the successful 2001 scheme. It defines a fairly wide catchment of eligibility and will permit us—once applications have been received and decommissioning bids have been evaluated—to take informed decisions about the number and balance of vessels to be taken out of the fleet to allow us to meet our fishing mortality effort reduction target.Following discussion with the industry, we have made some special provisions—notably, to extend eligibility to under-10-year-old vessels and to allow access to a 20 per cent grant premium for vessels that are subject to the cod recovery measures and which must reduce their fishing effort by 25 per cent or more. Those measures are likely to increase the unit cost of decommissioning, but they will allow us to consider for grants the vessels that contribute most to the cod fishing effort. They will also provide us with much greater flexibility in choosing the vessels that may be considered for decommissioning.I am aware of some of the concerns that exist and which the committee expressed in its report. There has been some commentary on the number of vessels to be removed. At the outset, I want to make it clear that there is no predetermined number of vessels. The aim is simply to reduce fishing effort on cod by 15 to 20 per cent, to promote sustainability and to protect our position on days at sea. That is the right approach.In giving evidence to the committee, I want to make it clear that both support schemes require European Community state aid approval. We cannot take decisions on grants or pay out money until such approval has been received. My officials are already pursuing that.The transitional aid proposals are set out in an enabling statutory instrument. They are intended to give serious transitional support to those who are directly affected by the changes that have been agreed. Because of the haste and difficulty with which the scheme has been introduced—on which I may be able to expand in response to questions—some of its fine detail is not set out in the statutory instrument. There is flexibility in some of the detail and arrangements of the scheme, and there is benefit in being able to adjust the scheme in the light of experience. The scheme is novel and breaks new policy ground. We do not pretend that the exercise has been easy and are grateful to those in the industry whom we have consulted and with whom we have discussed the detail of the scheme in an attempt to make it workable.Together, the two measures represent a package that is designed to support the industry through the current challenges and to enable it to move towards a sustainable future. They are not alternatives. Some have argued that, without transitional aid, further decommissioning would be unacceptable, and we have accepted that. By the same token, transitional aid without the effects of restructuring would not be acceptable in conservation terms and would certainly not be acceptable to the European Commission.I have provided a broad outline of the proposals and am happy to address the questions that members of the committee put to me.
We are relatively short of time, so I will ask three questions together. They are not related, except that they are all about the transitional scheme. They are essentially technical questions.First, what is meant by"historic activity of the vessel in respect of which the application was made"in paragraph 7(2)(a), under the heading "Rate of payment"? I do not think that that is a new phrase, but it would be useful if you could put something on the record about it.Secondly, the definition of "historic activity" in paragraph 7(3) refers to"recorded landings of sea fish in respect of a vessel".Does that include landings of fish at foreign ports?Thirdly, under the heading "Powers of authorised officers", paragraph 10(6)(b), states that an authorised officer may"inspect any document and, where any such document is kept by means of a computer, have access to, and inspect and check the operation of, any computer".In many instances that will require the disclosure of confidential information that is held by the owner of the computer to protect the information on the computer from access. What arrangements will be made to ensure that any information revealed as a result of the proper inquiry of an authorised officer—such as the disclosure of passwords—and which is not germane is not disclosed to any other party? What arrangements will be made to assist the owner of that computer to reinstate adequate security after an authorised officer has perforce breached that security?
Your first two questions are related to the question of what will constitute historic activity. We are working in close collaboration with the industry to establish two elements that will, I hope, answer Stewart's questions. We have been examining the records for the past year of vessel dependency on income from white fish. We have also been gathering data on vessels that used the relevant gear referred to in annexe XVII, which is closely related to that point. For example, we note those which have done so on an historic basis and those which have so in comparable six-month periods. Clearly, the use of those gears in comparable periods takes proper account of the most likely impact on those vessels of the measures that are about to come into force. Is that approximately what you meant, Stewart?
It is indeed, minister. When you say that are looking at income derived from those white-fish species to which the restrictions apply, do you mean all or only some white-fish species? Also, are you looking at something more subtle than income?
The definition of historic activity in paragraph 7(3) combines the time spent, the gear deployed and the recorded landings. The recorded landings tend to show income dependency. We are examining how to factor them in fairly and equitably. The key element of our discussions with the fishing organisations has been to try to determine that from their perspective, so that we do not put an interpretation on figures that would not warrant such examination. Those are our broad parameters. We must ensure that the transitional aid targets those who will be most likely to need it as a consequence of the measures that are being evolved. That is why we must be sure that the historic activity of a vessel justifies aid. Also, we want to try to set criteria that will not invite a host of appeals; we are trying hard to prevent people from feeling that selections have been subjective.
Would it be fair to say that you are seeking to address the change in income derived from white fish between this calendar year and the previous one?
It is not possible to define that precisely. We are using that information as a proxy so that we can be sure about the categories of vessel that we use. Annexe XVII does not talk about that, nor does it talk about historical activity. It further narrows selection to the use of gear. In other words, if we start with historic activity in terms of income and white-fish landings, we must then refine the definition to include gear. The issue of days at sea then arises, because some areas will be hit much harder than others by the restriction on days at sea.
I recognise and understand the fact that you are using objective measures as a proxy for something that you cannot get a firm grip on. However, there have been indications that white-fish prices are down again this year. To what extent will the transitional aid reflect both that and fact that catch volumes are down, perforce because of the new arrangements?
We chose the phrase "historic activity" because there are tremendous fluctuations for a variety of reasons. The only reasonable proxy that we can use is, as you were right to point out in your question, to have a definition of "historic activity". Everyone is suffering from the changes that were brought about by the regulation and those that are being effected in the marketplace. If we get the first bit right, I would hope that the proportionate change would reflect whatever is going on.
I am sure that there is more in that, but we have to move on.
In arriving at the totality, we include Scottish vessels' activity and their landings in foreign ports. It would be inequitable to deprive fishermen by defining fishing activity in a way that excludes foreign landings.I will ask Paul Cackette to answer your third question, which was on disclosure of confidential information, authorised officers' being affected by that and how we would remedy breach of the disclosure.
The provisions on what authorised officers can do are, in the Executive's view, necessary for the full enforcement of the order. However, by virtue of that, they are necessarily also intrusive.
Hence my question.
It is certainly correct that with those rights come responsibilities. An authorised officer will be obliged to exercise the powers in a way that is appropriate and necessary for pursuing the purposes for which access to information is taken. That begs the question how the practice is to be enforced or policed. Paragraph 10 of the scheme deals with civil and criminal liability and states that "An authorised officer shall not be liable in any civil or criminal proceedings"for anything done when exercising those powers, provided that the officer was acting in good faith, there were reasonable grounds for the action taken, and that it was taken with reasonable skill and care.The corollary is that if such an officer used information where he or she was not acting in good faith, the grounds for accessing that information were not reasonable or there was no exercise of reasonable skill and care, they would not enjoy the benefit of that protection. They would be liable if a person who suffered loss because of their actions were to start proceedings. They would not enjoy the benefit of that protection in circumstances where they went too far. Stewart Stevenson gave the example of the use of passwords. It is difficult to know how the powers will be used in practice. It would surprise me if a password would have to be disclosed by a person in order to allow an authorised officer to get hold of information on a computer. I would have thought that that could be protected. In any event, passwords can be changed. I would not have thought that the disclosure of a password would be necessary if a person were co-operating, or assisting, with access to information on a computer.
I will be brief, but I want to close off this line of questioning. If the officer becomes aware of a potential breach of a law not within their purview, such information would not be passed to any other party.
The officer would not have powers under the scheme to disclose such information. The powers of any other citizen, if they were to discover such information, would be—
Do not let us go there, because that is too difficult for today.
There might be other duties in relation to serious offences. The scheme does not permit the officer to disclose such information, but I would not say that the officer would never do so.
I know that almost all members want to put questions. I will extend the time that is available as much as I can, but members should bear in mind, in questions and answers, that we are up against a time limit.
I have a couple of questions, which I will ask together to save time. My first question is whether the grant premium could be used to give the crews some form of redundancy money. A vessel owner who bids for decommissioning money could look to the premium to give security or financial benefit to crews to tide them over while they find alternative employment. If a balance is left in the decommissioning scheme after the required number of boats have been decommissioned, is there an opportunity for the Executive to come back, rebalance it—perhaps by putting more money into the transitional aid scheme—and open it up to onshore businesses as well? Those businesses will suffer because of decommissioning and the days-at-sea legislation.
It is not just a matter of the premium. In a sense, the scheme is entirely novel and, to an extent, we are rather dependent on the good will of the recipients. It has proved to be extraordinarily difficult to find a proxy to assess the potential numbers of crew involved or the potential level of expenditure—and therefore the potential real need for transitional support—other than the proxy of the vessel and, in particular, the vessel capacity units. Therefore, it gears up in terms of the size and scale of the operation of the respective vessels.It is our clear policy intention, with the co-operation of the industry, that the scheme should not assist just one person—that is, the owner of the vessel. By using the proxy of the vessel, the intention is to give some transitional support so that the vessel owner can, if they have decided to stay in the industry, make some payments to retrain crew and perhaps also assist with some onshore facilities. I do not know whether Paul Cackette or Robin Weatherston want to talk about the enormous drafting difficulties, but I will run on quickly because of the pressures on time.The premium arrangements and the under-10-year arrangements are designed to give the maximum possible opportunity, because—I repeat—we do not have a fixed number of vessels in mind. It is quite clear from talking to various ports and associations that they take a different view. Some now take the view that bids from some of the larger vessels may now be inappropriate, because of the changed circumstances with stocks.As Rhoda Grant will be aware, given that it took £25 million to decommission 10 per cent of the fleet, grossing that up to 15 to 20 per cent will get close to £40 million. The scheme aims to be as flexible as possible, so as not to leave us in the impossible position where vast numbers of vessels have to be taken out. Given that the scheme introduces flexibility and the 20 per cent premium, and that we are allowing vessels under 10 years to come into the scheme, it is simply not possible at this point to speculate as to whether our rough-and-ready calculation, grossed up from last time, will produce any money. We have to have people focusing in, but it might be for somebody else to do that. At the moment, it is difficult to envisage not using an amount that is very proximate to £40 million to achieve that 15 per cent, having put in those flexibilities.On the crew issue, I think that it is impossible to define the issue legally, but Robin Weatherston may be able to provide an answer.
It is difficult to predicate money for a particular purpose. As the minister said, our calculations suggest that £40 million will be needed to remove—
No. Rhoda Grant's question was about defining how much of the premium might be used on transitional support to guarantee amounts for redundancy.
None of the premium is related to transitional support. The amount of transitional support—Interruption.
Could you speak a little more closely into your microphone? Many people are having trouble hearing.
Yes, sorry.I am not sure whether there is some confusion. None of the premium is related to the transitional support payments, the amount of which remains to be decided. We may be at cross purposes.
The definition of decommissioning is quite clear. A premium will be paid only to those persons who qualify under the other part of the regulation—that is, if they are able to demonstrate that, as a result of the scheme, their effort is reduced by more than 25 per cent. There is no reason why that should not happen by rote, but I am afraid that it is difficult for us to prescribe how persons should allocate their moneys under the scheme.
I have one small supplementary, which goes back to the rebalancing that you talked about in the decommissioning scheme. You expect to take the money available. I am not asking you to say that you will definitely move any money left over into a transitional aid scheme, but I wonder whether you would be willing to reconsider the matter if that money should be available.
Things are certainly speculative at this stage. However, at the moment, we have to indicate a clear measure of intent to the Commission and demonstrate some relationship between the percentage reduction that we are seen to achieve and the amount of money ascribed to the task. The Commission has required us to make both declarations.
You will be aware of Scotland's huge concern that the bulk of the cash in the aid package will be allocated to decommissioning. Every single fishing community and most organisations that have spoken on the issue have pointed out that there is far too much emphasis on decommissioning. Why are you not listening to them?
I am listening to them. However, we should go back to the start of this matter and remember that, in November, we tried to engage the Commission in a longer-term cod and hake recovery plan. We placed on the table our belief that any plan should encompass a range of measures such as real-time closures of spawning grounds, wider and extended use of selective gear, some degree of effort limitation and some element of decommissioning. However, the only two elements that the Commission was interested in were effort reduction and decommissioning.Because those were the only two elements on the table, the focus of negotiations was extraordinarily narrow. We had to make it clear that, although we disputed the way in which the measures—particularly effort limitation—were being prescribed, we were committing ourselves to some form of decommissioning because of the conservation element. I accept that the sheer arithmetic of such an approach means that we end up spending substantial sums to ensure that we secure the conservation objective. However, I know of no other policy instrument that allows us to do that. It is not that we are not listening to communities and organisations; instead, we are trying to do what the Executive has consistently tried to do, which is to balance meeting conservation objectives with trying to sustain our communities. The Executive has committed £50 million to that end.
You said that, initially, one of the options was an element of decommissioning. The difficulty that most people have with the aid package is that almost all the money is being allocated to decommissioning, rather than some money being allocated to a small decommissioning scheme. I understand that you have received 15 separate responses to your consultation on transitional support. Of all the responses that you have received on that issue and indeed on the statutory instruments on decommissioning, how many agree with your tactic of splitting the allocation 80 per cent/20 per cent?
This is not a question of tactics. We are trying to implement decisions that have been agreed with the Commission. People are deeply concerned about how we move forward and how we try to secure improvements to the present scheme. To be blunt, the prospects for any improvements would be almost zero if we went back to the Commission—as we would like to do—to express our disappointment at the fact that it did not discuss with us real-time closures and improved or increased use of selective gear while at the same time we proposed to remove from the table the decommissioning proposals that were discussed in November and December and that were then made into technical regulations. Changing our tactics with the Commission would prejudice and put at risk what has already been achieved, even though that has serious flaws.
Are you saying that the EC will accept only a 15 per cent reduction in effort through decommissioning?
No.
So that is not the case.
No. The Commission has said that there will be a 65 per cent reduction in effort. The Commission calculated back from the figure for our average number of days at sea—which is 240—and took off 65 per cent, which left us with seven days at sea a month. We tried to move the Commission from that figure by using a slightly different basis. It has operated on the basis of adding to days at sea to take account of other measures such as previous and future decommissioning, which is how we got from seven days to 15 days a month. That was part of the negotiations, and to renege on that would put us in further difficulties in any future negotiations.
In January, you told the Parliament that the future decommissioning scheme, not the one that has gone by, would be worth two days out of the 15 days. That implies that, without that decommissioning scheme, which we are now considering, we would still have 13 days, not 15 days. Is it not the case that there are ways of reducing effort other than by decommissioning?When I asked you a parliamentary question about the impact on the reduction of effort in the white-fish fleet of the transfer of white-fish licences to the pelagic sector, you said that you could not work that out because it would"take some time and resources and could only be undertaken at likely disproportionate cost."—Official Report, Written Answers, 25 February 2003; p 3081. Is it not the case that you did not take that factor into account when you worked out the effort reductions for the white-fish fleet and that there are options other than using 80 per cent of the aid for decommissioning? For example, it would be more sensible to have a much smaller decommissioning scheme and to put the rest of the cash into transitional aid for the onshore sector and the fleet.
The matter is simple. You are right that, instead of having an element of decommissioning we could have taken the whole thing in days-at-sea restrictions. I do not think that the figures of two or five days necessarily reflect the percentages of effort reduction, which was one of the arguments that we had with the Commission. However, if we took decommissioning off the table in the negotiations with the Commission, the prospects of Scotland making serious progress towards an improved longer-term package would be narrow. Such a move would ignore completely the nature of the negotiations that took place in December.
You miss the point, minister. You told the Parliament that the future decommissioning scheme was worth only two days out of the 15 days. That means that if there were no decommissioning, we would still get 13 days. If there were only a limited decommissioning scheme, would that not make up the difference of two days? How do you balance the £40 million decommissioning package with those two days at sea from the Commission?
I agreed that the figure of two days was a result of the way in which the matter was calculated. The calculation to work out the number of days at sea from the 65 per cent reduction is done on a crude percentage basis—I know of experts who dispute that that is the correct way of doing it. The figure of two days represents the percentage change that would result from a 15 per cent reduction in effort. If we removed that reduction, we would have to add back the greater percentage of days at sea. The Commission sought a target of a 65 per cent reduction in effort. It would have been a dangerous starting point to ignore the conservation element that was required in the package.
I have one final question.
Briefly, please, Richard. Other members want to ask questions and you have had your fair share of time.
If, under decommissioning, the vessel and licence are taken back, but not the quota, surely that is not a conservation measure, but a purely economic one to allow people who want to leave the industry to do so. In fact, if the quota is not taken back, how will decommissioning be even an economic measure? The remaining boats in the fleet will not be able to enjoy the quota that has been left behind after the vessels and licences have been taken away from skippers or boat owners.
Any fishing boat or vessel engages or indulges in a variety of actions, not the least of which under the current policies are discarding and other activities that contribute to fishing effort. It is easier to measure such activities in terms of individual vessels rather than a collection of vessels. A larger quota in the hands of a single vessel, if it makes the vessel more viable, removes the pressure on the vessel to engage in activities such as discarding. There is no doubt that the scientific evidence suggests that larger quotas have a material impact on the total effort as measurable in any particular vessel's activities. I dispute strongly the point that decommissioning does not reduce effort.We have covered the economic issues before. The Government issued the licences without a charge, but the market and trade in those licences were set up by the industry, which leads to the awkward situation that value is attributable to licences. That situation is attributable to a trade that is entirely in the hands of the fishing industry—Government does not engage in the trade. Equally importantly, as the committee's excellent report points out, we must watch carefully the outcome of the Shetland case before we adjudicate on the state-aid implications of Government intervention.
Could you clarify what catchment area of vessels you are targeting for decommissioning? Is it the 500 vessels that trawl for demersal fish? Is it the 300 hybrid vessels that fish for white fish and prawns? Or is it the 180 dedicated white-fish boats?
It is all vessels—the 500 demersal ones and an element of the 300 hybrid ones. However, when making their bids, they would have to demonstrate that they engage in a reasonable amount of white-fish and cod activity, so that in aggregate—
Cod or white fish?
It is specifically in relation to cod. In effect, that means, as I said, that the 500 demersal vessels, and the other 300 vessels, are eligible for the decommissioning scheme. Without a shadow of a doubt, all those vessels are technically eligible for the scheme but, in assessing the bids, we want to achieve a 15 per cent reduction in cod fishing.
How many vessels do you expect to decommission in this round?
I have repeated ad nauseam that I have no fixed figure in mind. I have listened to all sorts of organisations, which have expressed a variety of views. Some want to keep the numbers to a minimum. I listened to those views and that is why I extended two important provisions from the previous scheme into the new scheme. There will be a 20 per cent premium for those who demonstrate a reduction in effort of more than 25 per cent and I have included vessels that are under 10 years old. Therefore, the range and ability within each port will be much broader than previously, which could reduce the number of vessels that might be involved.
I regard the quotas—or, rather, the lack of quotas now—as the main problem; what will happen to them, bearing in mind the fact that there is a lot of quota left over from the previous decommissioning round? As far as I am aware—you can correct me if I am wrong—the new regulations forbid the transfer of time or days at sea from a vessel that is decommissioning. Therefore, even if fishermen could get more quota in order to increase their incomes—which have been halved by the slash in quotas—they will not have the days at sea or the time in which to catch that quota. What will happen to the quotas that cannot be used?
There are two separate issues. There is the issue of transfer liquidity within the market, which Richard Lochhead raised. I have had interesting discussions about that with people in the industry, particularly those on the financial side. However, the issue that Mr McGrigor raised arises from the current regulations' inflexibility on the days-at-sea regime, which is one of the matters that we raised with the Commission. We have consistently pointed out to the Commission that some aspects are not helpful. However, the regulation in annexe XVII, as it is currently written, does not provide for economic transfer. Robin Weatherston might have a comment.
What the minister said is correct. It remains to be seen what will succeed annexe XVII and how the days-at-sea restrictions will impact on that and the ability of fishermen to take their quotas.
As members will know, some Commission members have now wakened up to the fact that many of the points that we put to the Commission are valid. Those points are now under consideration.
When will the Commission let you know its answer to those points?
I think that there might be a new annexe XVII within a couple of weeks. However, that would only be a proposal and would have to be adopted either by the Council of Ministers or by the Commission. We also hope that in a similar time scale the Commission will kick-start a discussion on a substantive successor regime to the interim regime, which is what annexe XVII is meant to be. We hope to see some movement in the next couple of weeks.
Minister, you have persistently said that you do not know and cannot know how many boats will be decommissioned. If that is so, how can you be so sure that the decommissioning costs will be £40 million? If you have no plan for the number of boats, how can you have a fixed plan that £40 million must be set aside for decommissioning?
The calculation is done not on the basis of the number of boats, but on the basis that the previous scheme decommissioned about 10 per cent of fishing effort in the fleet and cost £25 million. A rough-and-ready calculation shows that the decommissioning costs will be close to £37.5 million and we have added into the pot the mix that we will include in the scheme: vessels under 10 years of age will be included and we will extend the scheme to those that will be eligible for the 20 per cent premium by virtue of the fact that the reduction in their aggregate effort will amount to more than 25 per cent as a consequence of the measures. I am not in any way claiming that this is an exact science, but that is a not unreasonable assumption to make on the basis of the previous scheme.
The Scottish Fishermen's Federation has provided us with a briefing today. It disputes your methodology, which you have said is crude. The SFF states:"On recent precedent the budgeted sum of £40m would be sufficient to remove at least 150 and perhaps as many as 170 vessels from the fleet. If, as has been stated, the scheme should concentrate on dedicated whitefish vessels, catching cod, the scheme would eliminate all but a few dozen vessels from the white fish fleet. Since neither the Executive nor the Commission has ever stated that the intention is to annihilate Scotland's capacity to operate a white fish industry it must be assumed that the budgeted figures result from a miscalculation."That seems to be a measured and careful formulation from the SFF.
No, it is not. With all due respect—
If I may finish, please.The SFF concludes:"A carefully targeted decommissioning programme of no more than £25 million could achieve the required reduction in fishing effort."There must be a difference of opinion between the SFF and the Scottish Executive. How can you be so confident that you are right and it must be wrong?
The first scheme took out 10 per cent of fishing effort; no vessels in the previous scheme were under 10 years old and the 20 per cent premium rule did not exist at that time. By the way, we are not focusing exclusively on the 180 vessels. The notion is that we are targeting deliberately the decimation of the 180 dedicated vessels, but that is not the purpose of the scheme. As I said directly in response to Jamie McGrigor, those eligible for the scheme are those engaged in fishing effort on cod. Theoretically, more than 500 vessels are in that category. I repeat that we have introduced two distinct elements: vessels under 10 years and vessels that will qualify for the 20 per cent premium. Given that it cost £25 million for a 10 per cent reduction, it seems to me that to get a reduction of about 15 to 20 per cent it is not unreasonable arithmetic to provide for a cost of £40 million.
I hear what you say, but I repeat that the SFF, which is entitled to be taken seriously, does not agree with that approach.You said that the committee produced an excellent report last week. That report had all-party agreement and called for rebalancing and for decommissioning cash to go to crews and onshore creditors. Is it not pretty easy to devise a scheme that can provide for direct payment of the decommissioning grant to individuals other than the single owner or owners of a boat and to secured creditors, crews and other creditors? Even now, should you not consider that approach?
I am bound to say that I disagree that such a measure would be simple.
I said not that it would be simple, but that it would be possible.
Depending on the structure under which a vessel is owned, it might be possible to establish the persons who are affected as the result of a charge and to disclose the nature of a secured creditor. That might not disclose the amount in every case. Establishing the ordinary creditors could involve considerable difficulty, not to mention potential dispute. I hear what you say and, as I said to Rhoda Grant, we depend heavily on the good will of those whom the scheme affects. However, to specify in an equitable manner the range and nature of persons involved and providers of disparate services to the vessel owner throughout a harbour would be extraordinarily complex and time consuming.
You will not be surprised to hear me mention displacement. I would appreciate it if you outlined your intentions and how they will be implemented.
We are considering that issue carefully while we draw up the detailed arrangements and the conditions that will be attached to transitional aid. Ministers will have to make final decisions on those matters, but we are acutely alive to the possibility that vessels that previously fished for white fish on a given number of days might elect to diversify into prawn or shellfish fisheries or other fisheries on which others depend.
What will finally be put before me is a range of options that will include a potential penalty on those who receive transitional aid because they do not enter a prawn fishery, for example. Should they seek to supplement that aid by displacing activity into the prawn fishery in Alasdair Morrison's area, they would be subject to retention or recovery of payments.
I was a critic of the Executive's first decommissioning scheme two years ago. I felt so strongly about the fact that no aid was available for a tie-up scheme that I voted against the scheme. Richard Lochhead focused his questions on the fact that £40 million, or 80 per cent, of the aid is for decommissioning, but only £10 million, or 20 per cent, is for transitional measures or a tie-up scheme. Only two years ago, no aid was available for what are now called transitional measures—they are a tie-up scheme, in effect—and all the money would have gone to a decommissioning scheme as a result of the first vote in Parliament, but that was tweaked by the second vote, which made me much happier. However, now, up to £10 million is available for the transitional scheme and tie-up measures. What convinced you of the benefits of putting together such a package with both elements at the same time, which we did not have two years ago?
It was the nature of the measures that emanated from the December council meeting, which not only had an element of conservation about them, but clearly had two elements that bore down extraordinarily heavily on the white-fish fishery—a combination of the days-at-sea regime and the swingeing reductions in TACs. It seemed to me that, in those extraordinary circumstances, it was impossible to allow fishermen time to assess the immediate nature of the days-at-sea restriction and the ramifications of the reductions in quota. It was essential to have two elements to the package to allow both those who might want to take advantage of a conservation measure and those who might want support to weather the storm to come to a more orderly and considered view.
You have hinted that the decommissioning scheme has been worked out by rule of thumb and that you are basing the amount of effort that is being taken out on the previous scheme from two years ago, so that the amount comes to roughly £37.5 million. It seems to me that there may be some slight flexibility to move funding from one part of the scheme to another. Will there be any chance of increasing the scheme by more than the £10 million? I appreciate the need for at least £37.5 million to go into the scheme. Is there any chance of getting more than the £10 million, which, nonetheless, is a lot more than we got two years ago?
As I said earlier—I cannot remember whether it was to Richard Lochhead or to Rhoda Grant—we are obliged not only to confirm the policy intention regarding effort reduction, but to give an indication to the Commission of the monetary sum that we have ascribed to the scheme. For the moment, the Executive's commitment is to provide £50 million. I appreciate the fact that members want to press me about what flexibility there might be, but I would not want to raise hopes unnecessarily. We must simply proceed on the basis that I have outlined.This is not a precise science, and I have spoken to the SFF, which has a desire for a much lower measure. We have included the two measures that make the scheme slightly different monetarily, to give greater flexibility and to help people who want to reduce the number of vessels: we have included vessels that are less than 10 years old and vessels that will qualify for the 20 per cent premium. It is very difficult to rule in or rule out what you suggest. We must indicate to the Commission our earnest intent in both regards.
I hope that Margaret Ewing will forgive me for not having welcomed her as a visiting member to the committee.
Thank you, convener. These days, I am beginning to feel as though I am a permanent fixture on the Rural Development Committee.I hope that I misunderstood the minister when he seemed to say that the SNP is opposed to decommissioning. The SNP is not opposed to decommissioning. Our party policy has been very plain. The dispute is about the distribution of the package that is before us. We want recovery, not redundancy.Let us return to paragraph 10 of the SSI on transitional support. I have read many statutory instruments in my life, but the powers of authorised officers are the most draconian that I have ever seen. Paragraph 10(1) states:"An authorised officer at all reasonable hours and on producing, if required to do so, some duly authenticated document … may exercise the powers specified in this paragraph."Elsewhere, the instrument states that an officer has a right of entry to premises where they have "reasonable cause to believe" that something is "a relevant document", even if the premises are somebody's dwelling house, and that"an authorised officer … may be accompanied by such other person as the officer considers necessary".There is a whole series of measures that I find draconian.Can the minister tell me what the cost will be of paying those authorised officers? Is there a contingency fund to pay for the supplementary people who might be needed? Who would they be? Would any training be given to them?
We envisage that, almost without exception, the authorised officers will be members of the Scottish Fisheries Protection Agency. We do not intend to engage additional people. The activities of the SFPA in relation to the order will be contained entirely within the SFPA's current budget. The powers might seem draconian, but they have to be spelled out in detail.
The powers are considered necessary, but there are a number of qualifications, one of which I alluded to earlier and others of which were referred to in the question. We must always try to balance the need for effective enforcement with a respect for the privacy of individuals.
That brings us to the end of our consideration of the schemes. I thank the minister and his officials for answering our many and varied questions and invite them to remain for the next item on the agenda.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 4 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 84
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 80
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 65
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.