Item 1 on the agenda concerns an item of subordination legislation—the draft SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003. The scheme replaces the 1997 farm woodland premium scheme. Copies of the instrument have been circulated to members. It is an affirmative instrument and the Parliament must approve it before it can be made.The Subordinate Legislation Committee reported on the draft instrument in its 19th report of 2003 and made a number of comments. An extract from the report has been circulated to members. A motion in the name of Ross Finnie invites the committee to recommend to the Parliament that the instrument be approved. The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development is here to move the motion. I welcome him and his officials.Before we debate the motion, it is customary for us to take time to clarify any purely technical matters or to allow explanation of detail while the officials are at the table. Officials cannot participate in debate once the motion has been moved. I invite the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development to introduce his officials and to make some opening remarks. When all the points that members raise have been clarified and explained, we will debate the motion.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003 (draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Allan Wilson Lab 23
- Fergus Ewing SNP 16
- Alex Fergusson Con 14
- David Henderson-Howat Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 14
- Jim Johnstone Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 4
- Rhoda Grant Lab 2
- Elaine Smith Lab 2
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
The record
84 contributionsOn my left is David Henderson-Howat, from the Forestry Commission, whom most members will know. On my right is Jim Johnstone from the Scottish Executive. Immediately behind me is Sandra Sutherland from the office of the solicitor to the Scottish Executive. I hope that we will be able to answer any questions or deal with any queries on the draft SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003.I would like to put the scheme in a wider context. As the convener in particular will be aware, two forestry grant schemes have been in place in Britain since the late 1980s. They are the Forestry Commission's woodland grant scheme, which provided grants for planting trees and set environmental and sylvicultural standards, and the farm woodland scheme. Since 1992, the agriculture departments have operated the farm woodland premium scheme, which provides for continuing annual payments to compensate for farming income that is forgone when planting on agricultural land takes place under the woodland grant scheme. The farm woodland premium scheme provides payments for 10 to 15 years, depending on the type of trees that are planted. Currently, the scheme supports more than 50,000 hectares in Scotland.Following devolution, the launch of the Scottish forestry strategy provided an opportunity to review UK-wide forestry grants schemes and to focus more on Scottish needs. We established a steering group to undertake that review. The group included the main forestry, agricultural and environmental land-use bodies in Scotland—the Scottish Landowners Federation, the National Farmers Union of Scotland and others. The steering group held a public consultation and saw the results of an evaluation of the schemes, which was undertaken by independent consultants. From that, the group made recommendations to ministers, which we accepted and announced in June last year at the Royal Highland Show. The committee will recall—I think that members referred to it at that time—that I sent a copy of the steering group's report to the committee for information.The key changes that were recommended by the steering group included: closer links with wider Executive policy priorities; scope being allowed for targeting in priorities; a more integrated approach; better community involvement; increased focus on management of existing woodland; consideration of relaxing farm woodland premium scheme area limits; and simplifying the payment categories.The group saw no need to merge the farm woodland premium scheme and the woodland grant scheme, provided that they operated seamlessly from the applicant's perspective. To that end, the steering group recommended that the new woodland grant scheme should be renamed the Scottish forestry grants scheme and should include expansion, stewardship and restocking as key elements, and that the farm woodland premium scheme should become the Scottish forestry grants scheme farmland premium.Under the Forestry Act 1979, the forestry commissioners have power to operate the core Scottish forestry grants scheme and no provision is made for subordinate legislation. The detail of the core Scottish forestry grants scheme was announced in January, and the Scottish forestry grants scheme farmland premium is the focus of attention today.The draft SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003 retains substantial parts of the previous scheme, so it is hoped that from the industry's perspective, change will be kept to a minimum. We have updated some definitions and references to make them consistent with usage in Scotland and in the Executive. For example, land use definitions will be made consistent with those under the rural stewardship scheme and farm woodland premium scheme payment categories will be simplified from the previous seven to the proposed four.I assure the committee that scheme area limits—especially the 40-hectare limit on unimproved land, which was a concern for some steering group members—will be kept under review in the coming year as we assess the impact on take-up of the changes to the core Scottish forestry grants scheme. We will increase individual limits under the scheme when to do so is sensible. Participants in the new scheme will have access to an independent statutory appeals process, which is the same process as is used for other departmental grant schemes.As I said, applicants' proposals for the premium scheme must meet the environmental and sylvicultural criteria of the core Scottish forestry grants scheme in order to become eligible for the premium scheme, which achieves its environmental benefits through that and through requirements on participants to maintain the woodland for double the period for which payments are provided—up to 30 years—while the trees mature.Both schemes are co-financed by the European Commission and, under rural development regulation 1257/99, the changes to the schemes that arose from the review were put to the European Union and approved in detail by the committee on agricultural structures and rural development at its November meeting. The draft statutory instrument is consistent with the steering group's recommendations and with the detailed Scottish rural development plan, which has been approved in the European Union.The scheme will continue to provide support for what we hope will be well-designed woodlands that support farming and which provide environmental and economic benefits, as well as the wider public benefit, in what might otherwise be fragile rural areas. It is worth remembering that more than half of the woodland that is currently being supported is on formerly unimproved land, at an individual limit of 40 hectares per owner. The scheme remains a real alternative to continued agricultural production, especially where such production might be marginal or in remote areas.I commend the draft scheme to the committee.
Thank you for your introduction and for introducing your officials. I am afraid that my fading eyesight no longer allows me to read name-plates at such a distance, although I know Mr Henderson-Howat.I repeat that we are having a clarification session before we have a debate on the subject. This is an opportunity for members to ask any technical questions that they might have.
Although I broadly welcome the scheme, I have a few points to raise with the minister. You said that, following the steering committee's recommendations, the new schemes were designed to achieve several purposes—for example, promotion of quality sylvicultural practice—and closer links with the Executive's policy priorities. What precise differences are there between the new SFGS farmland premium scheme and its predecessor?
Although the previous scheme was simple to manage, it was—it is arguable—open to differing interpretations about the eligibility of different operations. We aim to target grant payments in order to achieve policy outcomes and to deliver value for money, which might not previously have been such a high priority. The scheme will also provide applicants with greater certainty about grant eligibility than they have had in the past.All the grant applications will require careful thought and some might have to be priorities. However, that is the right approach given that public money is being used to create forest assets for the long-term future. That is the principal difference between the schemes to which I would draw attention. There are other differences in relation to new plantings and the reasons why the scheme might be changed. Part of the criticism is that the scheme is too complex, but the previous simpler approach did not define the output so well and it left greater scope for less value for money.David Henderson-Howat might want to add to that.
It is useful to distinguish between the element of the Scottish forestry grant scheme that flows from the old woodland grants scheme and the element that we are talking about now, which is the farmland premium. That flows from the old farmland and woodland premium scheme.The farmland premium is similar to the old farmland woodland premium scheme, except that there are different land categories with different rates per hectare per year, which is a slight simplification. The minister has outlined the greater differences between the old woodland grant scheme and the Scottish forestry grant scheme.
I am really trying to get at the precise differences. I do not think that I have quite got there, although the official said that there are slight differences between the new scheme and the farmland woodland premium scheme, which was, I understand, an environmental scheme.We are all in favour of more value for money and of such schemes delivering improved environmental standards. However, it is not clear to me what are the precise differences between the two schemes and how those differences will ensure value for money and higher environmental standards.
David Henderson-Howat might want to come in on that, but I make the point that in order to qualify for the farmland premium, someone would first need to apply for the revised woodland grant scheme. That differs significantly from the previous situation and it is important in terms of value-for-money considerations.On new planting, the scheme will lead to better designed and more productive woodland and will, perhaps, expand the area of native woodland beyond that which existed previously, creating a sort of riparian woodland. When I sent out the revised scheme, I understood that it would not come before the committee for consideration, but I expected some comments; I was surprised when there was none. This might be the opportunity that we did not have at that time to go into the matter in greater detail.
Perhaps I could explain the exact numbers. Under the old farmland premium scheme there were three rates of payment. If, for example, a farm was outside a less-favoured area, there was a payment of £300 per hectare per year for arable land or £260 per hectare per year for other improved land. Now, £300 per hectare per year is available regardless of whether land is or is not arable. Similarly, for disadvantaged areas the figures were £230 and £200, but all payments will now be £230. For severely disadvantaged areas the payments were £160 and £140, but now the rate will be £160. There has been a move to single rates of payment and there is no longer any distinction between arable land and other improved land. The payment for unimproved land is the same as it was previously, at £60 per hectare per year.
I suppose that one welcomes simplification; any scheme that is unduly complicated tends to be subject to criticism. However, I cannot see how increasing the rates—which is, no doubt, welcome to those who receive the grants—can achieve the objective of obtaining value for money. If, as you have just said, grant rates per hectare are going to go up in every case, I do not see how that squares with the minister's assurance that the new schemes will ensure value for money. Perhaps you could explain that.
I should have added that the farmland premiums are based on forgone income from agriculture and are also based upon independent studies. The farmland-premium element is based on the arithmetic that is carried out on farmland incomes. It was a slightly by-and-large approach.
I understand that the aim of the scheme is to encourage diversification into forestry—encouragement is needed, otherwise that ain't gonna happen. However, with respect, I do not understand how you can maintain that you will achieve value for money while increasing grants.
As you know, there were arguments in support of increasing the grants further, but that would have reduced payments to those who are already in receipt of the premium which, in many instances, is given to people in remote and marginally farmed areas: crofting counties, for instance, might have seen their share of the premium being reduced consequentially. We felt that keeping the payments at the proposed level will give greater benefit to more prospective beneficiaries. That is an important consideration, and is one that we should not dismiss lightly in terms of Executive policy and where we target agricultural support.
I will make one other point. For historical reasons, there are two legislative bases for the schemes: the woodland grant scheme and the farmland premium scheme. However, in contrast to earlier reviews, both of those schemes were reviewed together. In the past, under Great Britain arrangements, there would be a review of the woodland grant scheme, two years later there would be a review of the farmland premium scheme and so on. The review that led to the Scottish forestry grant scheme looked at the totality of both schemes. I understand what Mr Ewing says about the farmland premium scheme, but when one considers it in the totality of the Scottish forestry grant scheme package, all the points that the minister made about targeting come into play.
That is the critical point—we cannot consider the farmland premium scheme in isolation from the Scottish forestry grant scheme as a whole, which targets and distributes support better. To consider one scheme without considering the other—which we are unfortunately required to do in this process—gives a disjointed view. We must consider the farmland premium scheme in its wider context rather than in isolation.
Fergus Ewing has indicated that he would like to move on, but I want to pursue the difference between the scheme and its predecessors. I notice that the objectives of the scheme are to provide not only economic and environmental benefits, but social benefit. I do not argue with that, but will not one of the effects be—to put the matter rather simply—urbanisation of the scheme because the more social benefit that will result from a plantation, the more likely it is to receive support under the scheme? The minister mentioned that, at present, 40 per cent of the scheme is used for unimproved land, but it is likely that that percentage will become smaller because of that added objective.
It would be inaccurate to describe that as "urbanisation of the scheme". We want to ensure that we target and prioritise the available funds to achieve the greatest public and social benefits. It is clear that the vast majority of funds will continue to be targeted at the more marginal and remote rural areas, but creating social benefit through the judicious use of grant is an Executive objective. We must ensure that, where feasible and especially with the locational premiums, we use the money to provide maximum benefit. That cannot be described as urbanisation, but as better and more targeted use of available resources to achieve the best social and public benefits.
We must remember that the scheme is intended purely for the creation of woodlands on farms and crofting land.
I do not question that, nor do I question the good intentions behind the objective of social benefit, but I am considering its possible effect. I do not think that the minister disagrees entirely that the effect might be to bring woodland that is planted under the scheme away from unimproved poorer land and on to better land. Is that a likely impact of the scheme?
I suspect that the convener might be talking about locational premiums. As with any grant scheme, a limited pot of funds is available for the farmland premium scheme. Locational premiums provide an important means of giving extra support for forestry in areas in which we have identified a particular need, either for indicative forestry strategies that have been drawn up locally, or for other purposes. Rather than detract from existing priorities, those extra sums provide added incentive.
The locational premium that is targeted at central Scotland, for example, will undoubtedly help urban and peri-urban forestry initiatives in that part of Scotland. On the other hand, the locational premium that is targeted at Grampian will clearly help more rural parts of Scotland.
I want to raise a matter that has caused controversy in my constituency, although there is no reason why the minister should have heard about it. I dare say that I will write to him about it when I receive more responses. A general question arises from the matter, so I will take this opportunity—probably the only one that will be left to me in this Parliament—to raise it in principle.There has been some controversy in the Glencoe area of my constituency about afforested land which, I am told, benefits from the woodland grant. It has been alleged that there has been a mass slaughter of deer there, which I am investigating. I cannot say whether the story is true, and I await a response from the people on the other side of the argument. I raise the matter because there has been local publicity about it.How can control of deer be made a condition of the new grant, or indeed, the previous schemes? How do ministers ensure that there can be a cull but no slaughter? If it is alleged that culling goes beyond what is required, what mechanisms does the Scottish Executive environment and rural affairs department use to ensure good practice?
I do not want to comment on specific incidents—the member would not expect me to—but I will consider his representations on that matter. I assure him that my officials will certainly investigate the allegations.Mr Ewing's question is relevant—the deer management plan would be the most appropriate mechanism in such a hypothetical situation. Good deer management will be a condition of grants in any future woodland grant scheme. That is how I envisage the system working in such situations. That is, to a certain extent, a good example of the point that I made earlier about having a better system of grant management than that which existed previously. One can tie that system to outcomes such as proper deer management, as opposed to simply make payments for unspecified management purposes that might or might not provide the outcomes or the benefits that were originally sought. That is one advantage of the new scheme over the previous scheme.
The deer management plans are developed according to the needs of particular areas. That is done in consultation with the Deer Commission for Scotland, so that there are agreed culls and so on.
I was aware that that was broadly the approach, and it is obviously sensible. Is there any mechanism to check whether deer management is proportionate?
The purpose of developing a deer management plan is to have an agreed cull that is set in a context that is—to use Fergus Ewing's word—"proportionate" to what is necessary to protect the crop.
I have a constituent who is extremely emotional and concerned about deer, which have a proud place in Scotland, especially in the Highlands. That constituent is a lifelong experienced shepherd and has been involved with, and is knowledgeable about, the Glencoe area. He has strongly held views about what would happen if a cull became a mass slaughter. What mechanism is there to ensure that proper management is not exceeded and that deer are not killed outwith season and wholly disproportionately? How can that be policed? Is it policed at all? Does anyone check it?
The Deer Commission for Scotland should check whether there is a basis for deer management such as that which the member describes, or such as that which has been described to the member.
I am grateful for that. That information is useful for the case that I mentioned.I will move on, if I may.
Please do. No other member has caught my eye.
I am quite happy to give way to other members. I do not wish to hog the floor, as it were.Another aspect of sylvicultural practice and woodland management that has been highly controversial of late is deer fencing. This seems like a good opportunity to raise that issue. For decades, deer fencing was used to keep deer out of forests and to protect trees and prevent them from being destroyed in their early stages. The deer fencing was previously marked in such a way as to draw attention to the existence of the fencing to prevent the possibility—or likelihood—of birds flying into it. It seems that that practice, which perhaps served us well for several decades, is now being abandoned in many areas. Does the Executive have a clear policy on the matter? If so, can we hear what it is?
The Scottish forestry grants scheme makes reference to the Forestry Commission's guidance on deer fencing, which goes into the question in a lot of detail. As Mr Ewing pointed out, there is a bit of a dilemma. On the one hand, the fencing is obviously desirable to keep the deer out of the crop—the trees. On the other hand, fencing can cause problems, such as deaths of capercaillie and black grouse. The guidance note deals with the circumstances in which fencing is an appropriate tool to use to protect the crop. It also deals with situations in which fencing is not appropriate, because of concerns about blackgame and capercaillie, so that the question is one of managing the deer in such a way as to protect the crops. Where such marking is appropriate, we can contribute towards the cost of marking fences under the Scottish forestry grants scheme.
I suppose that there is a balance to be struck. I take Fergus Ewing's point that, historically, the fencing regime has been a success for the development of immature woodlands. However, in the period that I have been doing this job, several of Fergus Ewing's colleagues have been vociferous about the other side of the same coin, which is the devastation that deer fencing can reek among the indigenous capercaillie population and on black grouse and other low-flying species. His colleagues have been rightly concerned that previous fencing policies and strategies contributed towards the decline of those species.Clearly, we have a commitment to the conservation of those indigenous species as well as to the protection of immature forests and woodlands. Striking the appropriate balance is important to us.
If I may pursue that point, we all want to see the capercaillie survive as a species. Some time ago now, we received evidence, I think from the Scottish Gamekeepers Association, that gamekeepers do not feel that the measures that have been taken will succeed. I accept the minister's point about the argument that my colleagues have pursued, but we are all concerned to achieve the objective. What evidence is there that deer fences have caused the death of capercaillie?
The short answer is that scientific papers provide evidence that birds such as capercaillie have suffered death from flying into deer fences. That is not the only factor influencing the decline of those populations but, where the population is precarious, that factor could tip the balance. That is why the issue needs to be treated with such seriousness.
I do not know about Fergus Ewing's personal experience, but in addition to the empirical evidence that David Henderson-Howat has mentioned, I can certainly provide anecdotal evidence from my visits to areas that have fencing for deer. I have seen the physical evidence of birds that have perished on such fencing because the birds are unable to see the fencing when they are in flight.As David Henderson-Howat says, that is not the only factor that contributes towards the decline of the black grouse, for instance. The decline of the heather moorland habitat is probably of much greater significance than deer fencing, but I accept the distinction that has been drawn. Deer fencing is a contributory factor, and, in areas in which a population is reaching perilously low levels for its continuation as a species—as in the case of the capercaillie, which is a species indigenous to Scotland—we must take on board the concerns of those, including colleagues, who make representations that deer-land fencing needs to take account of birds' needs as well as the land manager's needs.
Could we have the benefit of copies of the scientific papers that David Henderson-Howat mentioned? The matter is one of great controversy, so it would be useful to see the source evidence. I agree that issues of habitat and predators are far more concrete and realistic threats to the future of birds that we wish to survive.
I am sure that we can share the information that we have with the committee. In fact, we would be pleased to do that. I know of no one in the conservation field who argues that deer fencing is the sole contributor to the decline of the bird populations that we have discussed. However, where it contributes at the margins, it is an important consideration in the wider conservation debate.
I take that as an indication that you or somebody else will forward to us the papers that exist.
Certainly. We would be pleased to do so.
I have a general question about forestry and direction. The scheme covers 10 or 15 years, depending on the species that is planted. What happens beyond that period, given that trees become more mature at that point? What support will be available for the social and recreational use of forests when the trees reach 10 or 15 years old? What support will be available to allow visitors—for example, walkers, cyclists and even school trips examining the forest environment—into the forest? The support that we give to forestry is not very joined up. Tree planting is helped through different schemes, but the schemes that allow people to enjoy a forest and manage it in its mature years come from a different area. Is there a way that we can join those up? How can we pull them together to ensure that we get the maximum benefits?
New planting has a role to play, given the impact over the longer term. As I said in response to the convener, part of what we seek to do through the scheme is to improve the quality and setting of urban and post-industrial areas, such as my and Elaine Smith's constituencies, and to improve the diversity of the farmed and—in Rhoda Grant's region—crofting landscape. The change in the basis on which we support new planting is an example of the joined-up thinking that Rhoda Grant seeks, and aims to influence habitats and landscapes over the longer time that woodlands take to come to maturity.In the short term, we have said that the premium will be reviewed within the first 12 months of its operation. It will be interesting for whoever is Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development to see how it has operated and what impact the new scheme has on the way in which funds are prioritised and directed compared with the old scheme.
I should add that, although we pay for 10 or 15 years, the farmer is obliged to maintain the woodland for 20 or 30 years. Quite a long period of maintenance is involved.
As I said in my preamble, beyond the immediate period of payment, the land manager enters into a longer-term commitment to the objectives that have been set in the medium term.
That is the period that I am most concerned about—when the funding runs out and investment is being sought to allow people, especially those close to urban areas, to use the areas for recreational purposes. That could mean quite a big investment, as it involves creating footpaths, visitor facilities and disabled access. I know that some local enterprise companies are happy to assist farmers with that, in the interests of business generation and pulling people into an area, but that route might not be open to them if they have applied to the scheme. Are people pointed in the right direction and given guidance on how to go about making the forest accessible and maintain it once the payments under the scheme finish?
That is precisely one of the areas in which we have improved on the previous scheme. Page 26 of the applicants booklet deals with woodland recreation, for which the new scheme offers significant scope. The purpose of the grant is to improve the social value of woods and forests by developing facilities for informal recreation in a way that is commensurate with likely demand. We set out the criteria within the scheme to encourage applications that would seek to extend pathways, provide better disabled access and give people more opportunity to go out and enjoy woodlands and forests in a way in which they have not been able to in the past, and to redirect resources in favour of those recreational users. In the past, public money has gone out of the door without the same level of scrutiny being applied to its ultimate use or public or social benefit.
I have a question on payments. In the past few years, I have had occasion to write to the minister on behalf of several constituents throughout the South of Scotland to bring to his attention payments through the scheme that were anything up to four months late. Can you give an assurance that the situation will be addressed under the new scheme? Frankly, the position is not good enough.
We would want to do everything that we could to eradicate late payment. Jim Johnstone can outline the steps that are being taken.
Up until two years ago, we paid using a manual system, but now we are using a fully computerised system. It experienced some teething problems, but should be operating fine now. Certainly, the vast majority of the payments that were made in October and November, which are the months in which we make payments, were on time. Hopefully, they will all be on time when we next make the payments.
After the first year, I was told that the problem was down to a changeover in the system, which is why I was surprised when the same thing happened the next year—strangely enough, it involved the same people. Are you confident that those difficulties will nor occur this year?
I am confident.
I hope that, should I be spared and find myself in a position where I might be called upon to write next year, I do not have to.
Paragraph 5, on page 4 of the draft scheme, is headed "Restrictions on approval of application: general", and sub-paragraph (5) refers to ministers not approving applications. Sub-paragraph (5)(c) specifies:"where the trees, other than nurse trees, are intended to be used as Christmas trees."The definition of nurse trees on page 3, under paragraph 2, is as follows:"‘nurse tree' means a coniferous tree which is planted to provide protection to tree seedlings and which is removed from the land within 10 years of planting".Does paragraph 5(5)(c) mean that the nurse trees can be used as Christmas trees? Is there any restriction on how many nurse trees may be used? Is one nurse tree provided for each tree seedling? May several nurse trees be provided for each tree seedling? Do you intend there to be a mixture of trees?
The basic answer to that is yes, although David Henderson-Howat will go into that in more detail.
Essentially, the grant scheme is not intended to provide a grant for people who are planting Christmas tree plantations. On the other hand, it is accepted that, to create mixed woodlands, it is sometimes sensible to plant a mixture of conifers and broad-leaves so that the conifers can act as nurse trees and help the broad-leaves to develop. At a certain stage, the thing to do is to remove the conifers so that the broad-leaves can continue to grow. In those situations, the scheme is saying—in legal language—that if a person is cutting young conifers that have served as nurse trees, there is no problem selling them as Christmas trees.
I am still curious whether that might give rise to a loophole for people to get grants and produce Christmas trees. That is why I was asking how many nurse trees are allowed for each seedling.
I do not think that that would be a problem. There is a requirement on the farmer to maintain the woodland satisfactorily for 30 years. If, for example, the farmer left only a very small scatter of trees across the ground, it would be clear that the woodland had not been kept in existence for 30 years as required.
The minister will recall that he was one of the first people to be notified, on Friday, of the successful community purchase of the North Harris estate. I am sure that he will join everyone else in wishing everybody all the very best with that. The people of north Harris will develop and transform that part of the island beyond the scope of socioeconomic and cultural renewal. One of the areas that they will explore and positively pursue is that of crofter forestry. I appreciate that the Executive is examining the regeneration of existing woodlands but, in crofter forestry, we are trying to replace trees that were burned down by the Vikings a thousand years ago on their brief visit—on their tour de force of the Hebrides. What can I tell the people of north Harris over the next few weeks, as they get down to electing their trustees and putting in place what will be, in effect, the landowner? Can you or your officials give us guidance on crofter forestry?
I share your enjoyment at the advancement of community ownership in Harris, which has been occasioned by the support that the crofters there have received from this institution since its establishment. Crofter forestry has probably been the greatest quiet success of our strategy, with more than 1,700 crofters at the last count involved in forestry schemes. The new Scottish forestry grants scheme provides for continued grant support at existing levels. Had I listened to some industry voices, which sought to increase the grant per hectare, those 1,700 recipients would potentially have had their grant withheld, which would have been to their disadvantage. I was concerned—as I know Alasdair Morrison and the committee are—to ensure that the success of the crofter forestry grant scheme is continued and that it is not affected by any reduction in the premium, which could have been brought about if the maximum amount of hectarage for which grant might have been payable had been increased.
I urge Alasdair Morrison's constituents in north Harris to get in touch with our conservancy office in Dingwall so that we can send out a woodland officer to help them with the way forward.
Excellent. The minister is free to make a personal contribution to the North Harris appeal that was launched recently. I have a leaflet about it that I pass to members now.
It is nice to see someone who never misses an opportunity.
I have a couple of technical questions for the minister. I notice that the existing woodland grant scheme is administered by the Forestry Commission and that the farm woodland premium scheme is administered by SEERAD. Some years ago, I had occasion to assist a client with such matters. The ground in question was in receipt of grants under other schemes. This question occurred to me at the time, and now I have the opportunity to ask the minister: would it not be simpler if one body were to administer both schemes rather than having two bodies administering two different schemes and two sets of paperwork?
I admit that that occurred to me, too. Basically, the steering group that we set up with the industry—perhaps your client was involved in it, I do not know—believed that there was no need for a merger, provided that the process operated seamlessly. That is what we seek to do. That is the answer to the question. Had the steering group, which was representative of the industry and other stakeholders, regarded the situation as a problem, I would certainly have taken that on board and acted to implement the recommendations, but that was not the industry's response.
I hear what the minister says. My anecdotal experience is that the schemes were administered fairly swiftly and efficiently, which is always pleasant, so perhaps there is no problem in practice. It just seemed to be simpler to have one body rather than two bodies dealing with what are essentially the same matters. Perhaps that might ease the problem that the convener mentioned earlier about the delay in payment of the grant.
I do not want these two gentlemen beside me to start fighting over who might implement such a scheme. Each of them implements different aspects of the same scheme. They appear to do so seamlessly without undue delay and in an effective and efficient manner, to such an extent that the industry did not come back to us and propose a single scheme. That is good enough for me.
I have a final question. The Executive note states that both of the existing schemes will close for applications in February—so no schemes are available at the moment. Despite the fact that the statutory instrument, if passed, will come into force from 1 April, the Executive note says that the new schemes will open in June. Where there are civil servants, there must be reasons, so will you explain why no applications will be accepted for the next three months?
As I understand it, it is to test the computer system that was referred to previously.
At the moment, a lot of work is being done on developing the computer systems for the new scheme. The other point is that, because there are differences between the old and the new schemes, there has been a flood of applications in recent weeks up until the closure. The staff in the conservancy offices have much of the hump of applications from the old scheme to process over the coming weeks. Then, we need to train those staff to use the computer software for the new schemes. That four-month gap was discussed with the industry some months ago; it certainly was not sprung on the industry. There has been several months' warning that the four-month gap would happen. Agents have known about it and responded accordingly.
So, do you have a target date by which you would expect timeous applications that are submitted before June to be processed? Do you have a target for when first payments will be paid under the new scheme?
Under the new scheme, we will receive applications from the middle of June. The short answer on when payments will start to be paid is that that will depend on the nature of the applications. In the case of the most straightforward applications, involving the restocking of clear-felled land, payment will begin as soon as the planting has taken place in the autumn.
I am sure that we would not want the crofters to wait.
We would not. The new computer system will be in place by the beginning of next year and will, I hope, expedite the cases of late payment to which the convener referred. Although the introduction of any IT system is fraught with difficulty, the objective is to expedite and make more effective the payment and grants system, as well as to ensure that public money is well accounted for.
I think that members have exhausted their questions, so we will move on to debate the motion. I thank the Executive officials for taking part and for answering the committee's questions. I invite the minister formally to move motion S1M-3905, in the name of Ross Finnie.
Motion moved,
That the Rural Development Committee, in consideration of the draft SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003, recommends that the scheme be approved.—Allan Wilson.
I put on record my congratulations to the minister on introducing the statutory instrument. The scheme will come into force on the day after the day on which it is made, or on 1 April, if later. On many occasions, instruments have been brought before the committee that have been implemented before we were asked for our approval. This way is the right way to do things when there is not a rush. I understand that there are far more important issues to the nation, which we will discuss later, and I understand why those instruments have been dealt with as they have. Nevertheless, I put on record the fact that I think that this is the appropriate way in which to proceed, and I thank the minister for that.
I do not wish to take anything away from those congratulations to the minister, but, as the instrument had to be considered under the affirmative procedure, the Executive would have been in a bit of bother if it had not brought it to the committee at this stage.
There have been many occasions on which we have been presented with material that has been—
Indeed. We have had problems in the past.
Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister and his officials for taking part in the meeting. I invite them to withdraw and join us for coffee for the next 15 minutes if they would like to do so. We cannot move straight to the next item on the agenda, as Ross Finnie cannot be with us until 3.15.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 4 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 84
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 80
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 65
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.