We had a useful discussion at our away day in Dunkeld. There was not much disagreement about the proposed work programme, which is always beneficial.Flooding is such a big issue for Scotland that we must give it some attention, notwithstanding what the Executive is doing. I hope to pop in to the flooding summit meeting next week; I think that you hope to do that, too, convener. The summit is the start of an Executive process, but Parliament has a role in exposing and airing the issues in public in a way that the Executive would find it difficult to do. The summit could not compare with an inquiry by this committee over several months.We need to expose to public scrutiny people's experiences of flooding throughout Scotland and what is happening to our climate by way of rainfall changes, so that people understand the issue better. At another level, we also need to expose how well regulation and current legislation is working, and how our local authorities and others perform on flood management. We must consider a range of issues. For example, is the current budget for flood protection measures adequate?Flooding affects all parts of Scotland. I reflected yesterday on a report on my own area in the Highlands and Islands. There have been major flooding incidents on the east coast in the past couple of years—and before—in Inverness, Elgin, Rothes and Forres. East Sutherland has also been badly affected by flooding incidents, as has Easter Ross and the Black Isle. There was also a major flooding incident in Dingwall about a year ago. On the west coast, the community of Coull, next to Fort William, has been affected by coastal and other forms of flooding. In the north, Thurso has been affected by flooding, as has Kirkwall in the Orkney Islands.Many communities out there have a lot of experience of flooding and they are anxious and fearful about what might happen in the future. Because of the weather that we have had this summer, the water table in Scotland is extremely high, as everybody knows, which means that the potential for flooding this winter will probably be even greater than normal, because the land cannot cope with much more water, given how much is already in it.For all those reasons, we should give attention to the issue of flooding. I have no problem with your suggestion, convener, about deciding on the fine detail of our call for evidence once we see what the Executive is focusing on. However, we should not be put off doing our job as a Parliament in scrutinising and exposing to public glare the important issues.I will pick up quickly on some other points. On the Crown Estate, I wonder whether it would be worth while taking evidence in the near future, from one or two people at the most. I alluded previously to the report that was commissioned by the local authorities in the Highlands and Islands and by Highlands and Islands Enterprise, which are serious organisations. The issue of the Crown Estate will rattle around out there and it will come to ministers. We should inform ourselves about the issues involved.Pages 5 and 6 of our work programme paper legitimately list agencies that are of relevance to our potential work. However, the Crown Estate is not listed, although it is relevant to our work. We should find out a bit more about it, but that would not require a big inquiry at this stage. We should just inform ourselves, then decide what we want to do.Paragraph 12 of our work programme paper is about fishing, and the clerks have recorded that we could hear evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment—I agree with that—and perhaps from others. However, I would definitely like to hear evidence from others. Prior to hearing from the minister, we need to hear evidence about fishing stocks and the science involved. I hope that we can firm up slightly the proposal in paragraph 12.Following on from what Sarah Boyack said about coastal management, in paragraph 18 we should add to the list of bullet points the need to examine water catchment management. We must consider how changes that take place upstream in the water, hills and uplands can affect flooding and flood management. Finally, I hope that we can add to the bullet points in paragraph 20 a specific point about planning guidance and its impact on rural housing.Subject to what I have said, I think that we have a good work programme. I hope that, for the reasons that I have set out, we can proceed with flooding as a major theme.I have a final thought, which is on green spaces in an urban context. We have a rural focus in this committee, but we are also an environment committee in the wider sense. We need to keep sight of and at some point address issues around green spaces in urban Scotland.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Peter Peacock only · show everyone- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 23
- Peter Peacock Lab 7
- Bill Wilson SNP 6
- John Scott Con 5
- Mike Rumbles LD 4
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Andrew Mylne Clerk 1
Peter Peacock’s contributions
7 contributionsPerhaps we can inform ourselves at some point about the issues involved. I am not making a specific proposal for an inquiry.
Just for the record, I support doing the inquiry into flooding, ahead of the inquiry into rural housing.
In my experience, few people can marry policy awareness with financial skill, but that is what we really need. The budget exercise is technical, so we need somebody who can strip out the figures.
It is difficult, but there must be people who fit. I presume that the Finance Committee has a list of advisers who might be available.
I agree that we need to have somebody who understands rural affairs and the rural economy, but with the qualification that they must also be able to count.
Mike Rumbles was right when he talked about what we should consider as part of our budget scrutiny. If we stick to the two issues that have been identified, our focus will be quite narrow. We should consider the issue from the outside, given that organisations comment on the budget and how departments work. There are two key areas. First, what discretion is there in the system for ministers—as opposed to what ministers must do? Also, given this committee's business, what discretion exists around European funding and how does that relate to domestic funding? That is a crucial area that we need to understand.Secondly, we need to understand more about the nature of the total spend. How much is underspent each year, and how much is potentially available for a variety of uses? We should consider the overall pattern of spending, whether the department targets spending effectively, and what discretion ministers have.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 99
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 50
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.