Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Pesticides (Maximum Residue Levels in Crops, Food and Feeding Stuffs) (Scotland) Amendment (No 2) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/306)

Wednesday 5 September 2007 Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Subordinate legislation 22 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

22 contributions
Roseanna Cunningham SNP The Convener · Perth
link

I invite the minister to introduce his officials and to make opening remarks on SSI 2007/306.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link

I will make opening remarks on both sets of regulations, but I will deal first with SSI 2007/306.Thank you for giving me the opportunity to attend the meeting. My appearance today proves that in life one can experience everything from both sides, although I am not sure that I am looking forward to this part of my role. Mr Taylor and Mr Greenslade will be able to answer questions on the regulations that I cannot.I carefully considered the discussion that took place in the committee at its most recent meeting and I want to make a couple of opening points. We use pesticides because we have all become used to being able to buy food that we want all year round at a reasonable price. Pesticides allow us to do that. They also make fruit and vegetables less unsightly and increase yield. All pesticides must be shown to carry no unacceptable risk to humans, animals or the environment. Tiny amounts of pesticide can remain in and on our food, which is why a maximum residue level is set for each pesticide. MRLs are not food safety limits; their purpose is only to check that good agricultural practice is being followed. They represent the maximum amount of pesticide that is expected in or on a product, if a pesticide has been applied. Most MRLs are set by European Union directives and require transposing, which is what the amendment regulations that we are considering do. The regulations are the latest in a long line of such instruments.The committee's principal concern seemed to be that the average cost of the MRL was thought to be £11,629, as is stated in the regulatory impact assessment. The RIA attempts to assess the cost of the whole programme for MRLs and presents that in terms of an average cost. However, that cost is not exclusive to the establishment of each MRL; indeed, it is incurred whether or not an MRL is set. The costs are met by the multinational companies that develop and manufacture pesticides, such as DuPont, BASF and Bayer. To put the figure of £11,629 into context, the agrochemical manufacturers estimate that the overall cost of bringing a new pesticide to the market is £130 million.We have received no complaints at all that the cost of supporting MRLs for any active substance is too high. The cost is not met by individual farmers, except in so far as it is rolled up in the total cost of producing new pesticides, which is vastly higher than the MRL sum that is borne. I hope that that explains the issue about which the committee was concerned.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP The Convener · Perth
link

Thank you. Members may have specific questions on this SSI, but I have a question on something that you said. You talked about the rolled-up costs that are involved in bringing new pesticides to the market. Do you mean that the result of that would be that, rather than the alarming figures to which you referred, there would be a cost of just 1p or 2p extra on a bag of whatever it was that a farmer wanted to buy?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

That is indeed what we mean. The rolled-up cost is the total cost involved in developing a new product or in bringing an existing product to a new market.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Absolutely, but that cost is a tiny part of the total cost of developing such products.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

I was waiting for John Scott to come in first because I think he originally raised the issue. I was going to move us on to another angle.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I seek further clarification on the £11,000 figure. I am sorry for not being more aware and for not understanding fully your explanation of that figure, but to what does it refer?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

With your permission, Mr Greenslade will explain that even more adequately than I did.

Charlie Greenslade Scottish Government Rural Directorate
link

The £11,000 is an indicative figure that is based on the average cost of constructing an MRL. The amount of money that is involved in doing that work is expended by the companies concerned prior to bringing the product to the stage at which it is approved and can be marketed. The £11,000 is an indicative figure only; it is not an isolated figure for setting an MRL.We recognise that the regulatory impact assessment could be better in some respects. When we update it, we will make it a little bit clearer.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

My question is more of a strategic one on an issue that I tend to raise whenever a pesticides SSI comes before us. It concerns the overall monitoring of pesticides legislation, which is done incrementally as things come out of Europe. Do you plan to look more strategically at pesticides use and, in particular, the links with human health? Do you plan to monitor the impact of pesticides? WWF has raised that issue in the past and I wondered whether there had been any progress on it.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

A considerable number of activities have been undertaken to monitor the use of pesticides. Sarah Boyack is right that monitoring cannot be done individually but must be done incrementally. Mr Taylor will say a word or two about how that is done and about the current situation.

Michael Taylor Scottish Agricultural Science Agency
link

There is an annual United Kingdom surveillance programme for pesticides residues in foodstuffs, which is conducted by five laboratories around the UK. The Scottish Agricultural Science Agency is the participating Scottish laboratory. The programme costs about £2 million a year to deliver and we recover some of that cost from industry via a levy. In the programme, foodstuffs are bought from retail outlets across the UK and tested for residues of pesticides.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

That is interesting. I would be interested to see a summary of the programme's annual report. However, I was thinking not only about residues in foodstuffs but about residues in humans. There have been calls for longitudinal studies on the cumulative impact of pesticides. Has any progress been made on that issue?

Michael Taylor Scottish Agricultural Science Agency
link

That refers to toxicological investigations, which SASA and the other labs concerned with pesticides residues in foods do not undertake.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

So there are no current plans to do such investigations.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

We will be happy to find out from other people—particularly the health ministers—more information for Sarah Boyack on the matter that she has raised. We will come back to the committee about that.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP The Convener · Perth
link

I want to pick up on Charlie Greenslade's comments on the drafting of the information that we receive. All committees have commented on that and I think that they will continue to do so. Some of the information that we receive from the Executive is drafted in such an opaque fashion that it is almost useless. Today, we have seen an example of the confusion that can arise when information is not given to us in an immediately understandable way. I hope that that point gets taken on board.

Roseanna Cunningham SNP The Convener · Perth
link

As there are no further questions about SSI 2007/306, do members agree to make no recommendation to Parliament on the regulations?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 99
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. Work Programme Procedure · 50

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.