The purpose of this agenda item is to follow up the discussion that took place at our away day on 14 August and formally to agree the committee's work programme for the next year or so. Members have a note of the issues that were discussed at the away day. The paper contains other points about our future workload, which are up for discussion.Sarah Boyack was unable to attend the away day, so she has had no opportunity to express a view. With the committee's indulgence, I will allow her to comment first, so that her contribution can be recorded.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Roseanna Cunningham only · show everyone- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 23
- Peter Peacock Lab 7
- Bill Wilson SNP 6
- John Scott Con 5
- Mike Rumbles LD 4
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Andrew Mylne Clerk 1
Roseanna Cunningham’s contributions
23 contributionsThank you.Of course, at the away day we discussed both food policy and land reform. If I am not misrepresenting the discussion on food policy, it was decided that because there was relatively broad agreement across the board on taking the issue forward, and given that a number of groups were pursuing parallel courses of interest, it would probably be surplus to requirements for us to conduct a major inquiry at this stage, although that is not ruled out for specific aspects of food policy at a future date. John Scott, who is one of the members interested in food policy, may wish to contribute at some point, but not just yet.There was also a brief discussion on land reform. It was felt that it could be premature to launch major post-legislative scrutiny, but we did not rule it out and we said that we would want to come back to it. We are thinking of it being a fairly major piece of work.We made a strong distinction between major pieces of work and smaller pieces of work. We discussed the possibility of having much smaller-scale investigations, perhaps over one or two meetings. Three specific issues that may be handled in such a way were raised and are noted in the work programme paper: the role of the Crown Estate, the applicability of the Scottish index of multiple deprivation to rural areas, and ticks and tick-borne diseases. We did not make a decision about priorities or timing, but noted that those three issues are amenable to shorter-scale consideration by the committee.I anticipate that members will wish to raise similar issues that could be addressed in the same way—I have one myself and I know that at least one other member also wishes to contribute one. I will not ask for additions to that list at the moment, but I advise that the best thing to do is immediately to notify the clerks of such issues, because we intend to have regular update discussions on the work programme in the months ahead. We will return to this topic, because we will want to adjust our work programme. Emergency issues might also arise, for which we will want to find time.I think that I speak for the committee when I say that we take on board the suggestion about coastal flooding. I also have a point about the flooding inquiry. I am sorry that I am speaking for such a long time, but we need to address a process issue: members might be aware that the Executive has called a major flooding summit for next Monday, 10 September. As the Executive is moving quickly on the matter, the committee could issue a call for evidence today. However, as we are not fully aware of where the Executive is going with flooding, that might be a little premature. It might be wise for us to defer that call until our next meeting. What the Executive says or does not say might allow us to clarify more usefully how we want to focus our inquiry or, indeed, whether we wish to invert the order of the inquiries and start with rural housing as opposed to flooding. I throw out those issues to the committee.I am aware that I have spoken for longer than a convener should in such circumstances, but background issues needed to be on the record. John Scott wishes to speak, followed by Peter Peacock. I invite other members to indicate whether they wish to speak.
I assumed that that matter would be subsumed into the agricultural regulation inquiry. I might be wrong, but it was my assumption that we would examine it.
Are you suggesting that as a subject for one of the smaller-scale investigations?
I can advise you that we are aware of the report on the Crown Estate and have formally asked for copies of it for the committee. Once we receive it, we can decide whether we want to examine the issue more closely.Paragraph 12 in our paper relates to the fisheries council. I think that I am right in saying that we have pencilled in two meetings on that, so it would be possible to do what you suggest.I was not suggesting that we should not do a flooding inquiry; I was merely saying that, given that it looks as if the Executive will take a fair bit of action on flooding, we could start the rural housing inquiry now and begin the flooding inquiry in November/December—in other words, we could invert the proposed order of those inquiries. That is as far as I was going; I was not saying that we should not do the flooding inquiry. It would be equally valid to wait until the next committee meeting to make a final, more focused decision.
None of us is short of good ideas. I have one of my own. Now that the waste electrical and electronic equipment directive is in force, I have become aware of issues to do with its practical implementation that have arisen in my constituency. Our difficulty is not coming up with good ideas; it is prioritising them and working out the best way to proceed with them. I remind committee members that this year we have a big opportunity in that we have the space and time in our work programme to examine a variety of topics. Not all the work that we do has to take the form of a nine-month or a 12-month inquiry. We have had a useful discussion of subject matter.I want to pick up on Sarah Boyack's comment on the use of reporters. We discussed a variety of working methods at the away day and we anticipate using all the potential methods, including the use of reporters, as and when appropriate. That will be for the committee to decide as we discuss specific issues.
We will discuss that, but at the moment we are just talking about the subject options.I should flag up that rural housing involves overlapping remits. The Conveners Group away day was on Monday but, unfortunately, the convener of the other committee concerned was not there, so I was not able to have a conversation about our intentions. We will need to have such a conversation, although it will not preclude our doing an inquiry on rural housing. Such conversations will be necessary because a number of the issues that we want to tackle might form part of the remits of other committees.Do members agree to the work priorities for the remainder of the current parliamentary year as laid out in our paper, which include three major inquiries?Members indicated agreement.
We must agree a remit and programme for the conduct of our first inquiry, which we have agreed will be on flooding. I suggest that we should have a scoping paper prepared for the next meeting, which should take on board current Executive initiatives. That will give us a much clearer idea of how the Executive is approaching the arguments and how it intends to handle matters, which will help us to ensure that, although some of our discussions may take place in parallel, we do not end up simply doing the same work side by side.
No—we have just agreed that we are sticking with that order: flooding, then housing.
We have agreed that we will go ahead with a flooding inquiry first. We will have to get a scoping paper for our meeting on 19 September. Having said that, with the committee's agreement, we will begin preparatory work on the rural housing inquiry so that, when we come to make the formal call for evidence at the end of the year, we can take an informed view. We will return to general work programme and review issues on a regular basis. The scrutiny of relevant annual reports is covered in paragraphs 24 to 29 of the work programme paper. I invite members to consider whether they wish to make that a specific agenda item when annual reports by relevant non-departmental public bodies and Executive agencies are published. Do we want that to be an item on our agenda, or do committee members wish simply to be alerted when annual reports are published? I am in the hands of the committee. Members might feel that the annual reports of some bodies ought to be placed on our agenda automatically, whereas others do not require to be. It is not an all-or-nothing approach. Some organisations might fall into one category; others might fall into the other.
Are we content with that approach? We should clear our approaches to such matters now, so that we do not get ourselves into difficulties as we go along. Petitions are not mentioned in the work programme paper, but I invite members' views on how we should consider them; should we include petitions on our agendas periodically—for example, quarterly—rather than whenever they are referred? I have experience of the former way of doing it, which works extremely well. Some committees have moved to that system. I strongly recommend that approach, but I am in the committee's hands. Members indicated agreement.
We will deal with petitions on a grouped basis and the relevant meetings will have a long petitions item on the agenda. Mike Rumbles asked about a budget adviser. I seek views on whether the committee should appoint a budget adviser. The Finance Committee assumes that subject committees that scrutinise big-spending departments will appoint advisers. It does not expect every subject committee to have a budget adviser, but it strongly encourages such an approach as it wishes to achieve greater co-ordination in committees' work on the budget. I can also advise members that the Finance Committee hopes and recommends that committees will mainstream financial scrutiny in their round-the-year inquiries. That would be a new thing for committees, which have generally concentrated their inquiries on policy issues. There are therefore questions about the budget advice that we might require throughout the year. We will perhaps need to come back to that. It is for us to decide whether to appoint a budget adviser for this year. I understand that five committees have already agreed to appoint budget advisers. The only other committee that has not yet done so is the Local Government and Communities Committee, although it might have done so by now.
We do not know for certain—that committee has not yet made a formal decision on the matter.I seek an indication rather than a vote, but are members generally in favour of appointing a budget adviser?Members indicated agreement.
In that case, we need clarity on what we envisage the role would be and what expertise is considered to be most important. For example, would we prefer someone with a public finance or accountancy background or somebody with a working familiarity with the relevant sector, in the way that there are health economists? Such a person would perhaps be better than those who are more generally financially qualified.
I am advised by the clerk that the Finance Committee's adviser, Professor David Bell from the University of Stirling, can provide general economic expertise, so we might be better to focus on a subject expert. Do members agree that we should go for someone who has subject familiarity rather than simply financial knowledge?
I know that it is a tall order.
There is an adviser database to which we can refer, although I am not sure whether it will throw up enough names to allow us to make an informed choice.
There are health economists, which is the kind of person we need. We need a rural economist, if we can find such a person.We need to have a discussion about structuring our budget scrutiny. Two specific ideas were proposed at the committee's away day: Mike Rumbles raised issues about the scrutiny of the budget that was announced towards the end of May 2007—he believes that he has identified a missing £400-and-something million—and, secondly, that we examine the new entrants scheme. However, we should do a bit more than that, as that would be an extremely narrow approach, so we need to have a brief discussion about a further focus for the budget scrutiny, as that will help us when it comes to finding a budget adviser. Do members have any comments on that? If not, those two issues will be taken on board and we will end up making up something behind the scenes.
The first I heard of the mainstreaming notion was at the Conveners Group away day on Monday. I think that conveners will have to discuss the matter further, for the reason that you give, which was immediately identified as an issue on Monday. If we are to mainstream budgetary considerations, we must have budget advice all year round, which has implications for committee budgets. We must proceed on the basis of this year's budget scrutiny, but mainstreaming must be addressed.
That is useful. The approach would give the committee a clearer basis for approaching financial scrutiny all year round.
That issue will be subsumed into our inquiry into flooding rather than included in separate budget scrutiny, although we could flag it up in our budget scrutiny. You have given us a prime example of how we can mainstream financial scrutiny into a year-round inquiry.
Yes. I am not sure whether we have identified two extra strands for our budget scrutiny. We are talking about quite broad consideration of the budget, so we will not necessarily seek an adviser who has expertise in agriculture. We need someone who can stand back and consider the budget headings in several areas—in effect, a rural affairs economist. We need flexibility across the board.Our discussion has been helpful in enabling us to arrive at such decisions. We have agreed to try to find a budget adviser who will assist us on the basis that we have discussed.
We will try to expedite the process.I thank everyone who contributed to the away day. Members who attended will remember that we received presentations from a number of people, who took time to speak to us and help to inform our work during the coming year. We are extremely grateful.On the scrutiny of annual reports from NDPBs, I reiterate that we can exclude some reports, which will fall into the remit of other committees. For example, we do not expect to scrutinise reports from Audit Scotland—the Audit Committee will do that—or to carry out overall scrutiny of European Union matters, although we will do work on individual EU issues. EU scrutiny is undergoing changes because of recent changes to how committees operate. We will have access to a European officer and regular Euro-bulletins will be provided—as of this month, I think—which will flag up various matters. A process is proposed, which is similar to the petitions process, whereby the clerks will prepare relevant updates quarterly. The aim is to raise issues at an early stage so that we do not find that we know nothing about a matter until it appears in the form of a directive—which has, unfortunately, happened in the past.We have agreed a forward work programme. If members are happy, we will proceed on that basis. I remind members that the work programme will reappear on the agenda fairly regularly, so we will come back to it and adjust it as needs must.The committee's next meeting will take place on Wednesday 19 September at 10 am.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs and Environment Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 99
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 50
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.