Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Scottish Class Action Procedure (PE1234)

Tuesday 3 March 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 43 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

43 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Item 3 is consideration of five new petitions. Members have copies of the petitions and all supporting information.The first petition is PE1234, by Peter Brown, on behalf of Leith Links residents association, which calls on Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to instigate under Scots law a class action procedure, or similar, which would correspond with the legal systems of many other countries, including England and the United States.The petitioner, Peter Brown, and Robert Kirkwood are present for the petition. Two members of the Scottish Parliament, Shirley-Anne Somerville and Malcolm Chisholm, are interested in the petition and are present to participate in the discussion. I invite Peter Brown or Robert Kirkwood to make an opening statement, after which we will have a question-and-answer session.

Peter Brown Leith Links Residents Association
link

Good afternoon. As the main petitioner, I thank the committee for the opportunity to present the petition. I live in the Leith Links area of Edinburgh and am a member of the Leith Links residents association, which has provided a focal point for the needs of Leith Links residents over the past decade on a number of local issues. Having an increasing portfolio, the association's committee sought assistance from non-committee members, which is how I come to be here today as the main petitioner.Our petition calls for the introduction of a class action procedure in Scots law, to bring it into line with many other legal systems worldwide, including those of England and the United States of Edinburgh—sorry, the United States of America. I am getting above myself. Our ground for this call is the accessibility of natural justice for the common person. Members will be familiar with the petition's content, so my statement will provide background on how the LLRA has concluded that a class action procedure offers the best solution to at least one of its tasks in hand.The LLRA has not found the present democratic system to be particularly supportive of groups of residents like us, who have endured years of misery due to the poor infrastructure and mismanagement of Seafield sewage works. It therefore seemed worth our while to try to attack the problem from another direction, using the process of law.The ex-sheriff, Ian Hamilton QC, has recently attempted to pursue legal action against the Royal Bank of Scotland through the small claims court. However, it has just been ruled that the complexity of the case requires that the action take place in a higher court. Mr Hamilton has subsequently dropped the case because he cannot afford the legal costs and has told journalists that his case could be dealt with efficiently only through a class action. The community of Leith around the Seafield sewage works has had to drop legal action against Scottish Water for similar reasons.In 2001, the LLRA approached an Edinburgh law firm with a view to pursuing legal action against Scottish Water. We were advised that our case was strong and that the company's practice of creating clouds of foul-smelling hydrogen sulphide contravened Scottish legislation on nuisance and European legislation on the right of individuals to enjoy their communities' environment. However, we were further advised that the community could not be represented in a class action, that representation could not be offered on a no-win-no-fee basis, that only an individual or a small group of people could be represented and that the fees would be high.A way forward was nevertheless suggested, which was that a member of our community who was on benefits could apply for legal aid and represent our concerns in court. We were told that if the outcome of the case was favourable, that would make it easier for pressure to be applied on behalf of others for Scottish Water to settle. A member of our community who is on benefits was subsequently chosen and an application for legal aid was made. However, it was turned down and, as happened with Ian Hamilton, the case was dropped.What I have described, and the following, represent reasons why court procedure rules should be changed to allow class actions in Scotland. First, existing procedures do not provided sufficient or effective access to justice for a wide range of citizens. Secondly, existing legislation is effective in part, but could be considerably improved to promote better enforcement of citizens' rights, while protecting defendants from non-meritorious litigation. Thirdly, evidence exists that meritorious claims are not being pursued. Fourthly, effective collective actions promote market efficiency, and benefit individual citizens, business and society as a whole. Equally, such actions are effective mechanisms through which individual rights can be upheld.I thank you for your attention and I commend the petition to you.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you, Peter. I invite Shirley-Anne Somerville to speak, then Malcolm Chisholm.

link

I am here in support of the petition. As has been said, the petition is based on work on the Seafield stench, which has been a long-running saga in Leith. However, the chaos that is hitting the financial system at the moment brings home to us that the issue of class actions should be important to us all. The reasons for class actions not existing in Scots law are unclear. I do not believe that justice for all should be blocked because some claims may be frivolous. That could be said about a variety of things in the legal system, but it does not get away from the fact that natural justice should be part of the system.There are a number of practical difficulties, but they have been overcome by other countries. This issue seems to be a great example of the legal establishment deciding that something is too much hassle for the legal establishment. Again, that is not a reason for ignoring the plight of the people in Leith. The LLRA cannot find a solution to the issue in the current legal system. If a residents association that is as active as the LLRA cannot do so, I assume that nobody else can, which means that thousands of individuals are left without a voice. I urge the committee to explore this issue further so that we can assist places like Leith.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Would Malcolm Chisholm like to add anything?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I assume that Robert Kirkwood will also be called to speak.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I would not want to supplant him; he has been campaigning on the issue for many years, as has Susan Deacon, who formerly represented the constituency that includes Seafield. There is a specific local issue, but there is also a more general issue, which is perhaps what the Parliament will focus on primarily. It is unacceptable that consumers and others should be given rights that they cannot effectively enjoy, which is what happens in Scots law at the moment. I was not well informed about this matter in the past. It came up in previous sessions of Parliament, and a decision was made by the Court of Session Rules Council not to change the procedures.I am disappointed that we should be listening only to the views of lawyers on this issue, but that was the view that was taken by the previous Administration. It is right that politicians should express a view on the matter because it seems to be incredible that Scots law has no procedure like the one that is proposed.The proposal would make a great difference. As we know, many people simply cannot afford to take action, which is against the interests of justice. Consumer Focus Scotland put the matter well in its submission to the review that is being carried out by Lord Gill. It said:"We believe that the introduction of a class actions procedure … would:• increase access to justice• provide an effective remedy, allowing people to exercise their legal rights• save time and money, both for parties and the courts• avoid inconsistent decisions in similar cases• act as a deterrent to unlawful/unfair behaviour by businesses".In general, there is a strong argument for the proposal. Members will also understand the nature of the long-running saga of the Seafield sewage works. That case highlights how beneficial to local residents it would have been if the suggested course of action had been open to them.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I will invite questions from the committee members—Robert Kirkwood can come in on the back of them if he wants.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I am sympathetic to the petition and the petitioners' case. I take the points that were made by Shirley-Anne Somerville and Malcolm Chisholm about the benefits of a class action arrangement for the parties involved and for the courts. Do the petitioners think that it would be appropriate to wait until Lord Gill has concluded his review before we do anything with their petition? I hope that the issue that we are discussing will be dealt with in the report. I am not suggesting that we wait forever—I think that that report is imminent.

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

We are aware of the review, and wanted to put down a marker, rather than start the process after Lord Gill has concluded his review, in case he was to decide that the course that we favour is not appropriate. The order in which the matter is dealt with is not important from our point of view.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It is the objective that is important.

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

Exactly.

Peter Brown Leith Links Residents Association
link

We wanted to make it clear that although until now the arguments have involved legal people, the issue involves the interests of citizens. It should not be regarded as being simply a legal matter.

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

I think that since lawyers cannot make money out of selling houses any more, they appear to be gathering around this action and giving it a lot of support. Since class actions have been possible in England, two communities south of the border have successfully pursued litigation against water treatment works—one at Mogden, in London, and another at Sandon Dock, in Liverpool, where six teams of lawyers are representing 3,500 people. As a result of the litigation in Liverpool, United Utilities, the water treatment company, has invested £100 million in upgrading the water treatment works. They were so persuaded by the case that was put that they realised that it was in their interests to produce a modern water treatment works. The same thing happened in Mogden where, under the threat of litigation, a major investment was made in the water treatment plant. Last week, I spoke to both sets of lawyers, who told me that the water companies are willing to settle rather than go through litigation, because of the strength of the argument.That is in contrast to what has happened here. Only £20 million is being invested in Seafield. One of the reasons why a more expensive option was not chosen was the fear of a prolonged court case—Scottish Water made it clear to the council that it would appeal any decision that a more expensive option should be pursued.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Obviously, there have been positive outcomes in Liverpool and London. I hope that there will also, if things progress as most people wish, be positive outcomes north of the border, including in Leith.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Earlier, you outlined a case in which one of the poorest members of your community went to the Scottish Legal Aid Board for help in his attempt to seek redress against a public company for making his or her life a misery, but was denied legal aid. Were any reasons given for the denial of legal aid, or was it simply denied?

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

It was simply denied. There appear to be no reasons why; it simply seemed to be regarded as a case that was not worthy of legal aid. We were then left with a bill of £1,000 for an advocate's opinion plus the bill for the application for legal aid, which means that the cost of that little process came to more than £1,500—at least it would have, had we paid the advocate, but we refused to do so, because it became clear to us that he had not read the documents.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I find the position of SLAB to be pretty incomprehensible.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

The paper that you helpfully provided us with from Consumer Focus Scotland points out that, under the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, the Lord Advocate may raise an action in the public interest but the procedure has never been used. I suppose that that sort of thing might not be terribly unusual in the world of the law. Have you explored that issue? Do you know why that power has never been used? It strikes me that some of the actions that we are talking about would have been in the public interest.

Peter Brown Leith Links Residents Association
link

I have not investigated that, although I read the document to which you refer. I accepted the situation, because the act was passed a long time ago. That question is a good one, however.

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

If someone who is suffering cannot even get legal aid to help them address a problem, it suggests that that problem is not regarded as being serious enough for that kind of action. I do not know how you would go about persuading the legal profession that it was.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

My position is that the office of the Lord Advocate is not quite the same as the legal profession, although I acknowledge the connections. The Lord Advocate ought to be perfectly capable of doing something in the public interest without having to worry what lawyers think about it. If the power has not been used, it has not been used.

Robert Kirkwood Leith Links Residents Association
link

On the public interest, we were surprised that environmental services had never served an odour abatement order on the Seafield sewage works in 40 years. The reason that was given was that it was not in the public interest to do so.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

That is an interesting perspective on the public interest.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I notice that the papers that you have submitted suggest that the reason for the refusal to introduce a class action procedure might be that the Scottish Law Commission's report was considered by the legal profession, whose findings became law. It seems a bit unfair that the proposal for a class action procedure was turned down because the legal profession did not think that it was a good idea.

Peter Brown Leith Links Residents Association
link

I have no legal or political background, but Leith Links residents association wanted help about a year ago, so I took the case on. I scratched the surface and found information. I got a bit of help from Lachlan Stuart—I forget which body he works for—who contacted the Court of Session Rules Council. The people he contacted said that everybody who had been involved in the decision had moved on and that they therefore did not know the details of why the council rejected the 1996 Law Commission recommendation that a class-action procedure should be introduced.I had to dig in the information that came back to find anything of substance. I mentioned four points: as I said in the petition, they all seem to be superficial and none of them answers the question. However, each one screams at me that it was just the Rules Council saying that it was not convenient. Who are they? They are the legal profession. The rejection had nothing to do with justice.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

It seems unfair that the legal profession should act as judge and jury in such a situation.

Peter Brown Leith Links Residents Association
link

That is how it seemed to me.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

There is broad sympathy for the petition among committee members, and a couple of other parliamentarians have expressed their support for it. The question is what we should do. I take on board what Robert Kirkwood said about waiting for the Gill review's conclusions. Although Lord Gill's report is imminent—I think it will be published in the spring this year—I suggest that we make Lord Gill aware of the petition and keep it open. After we see his report, we can revisit the issues that the petitioners have raised and deliberate on whether the report provides some of what the petitioners hope for. I am open to committee members' views about what we do next.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

This is a situation in which, if the law is an ass, it has wandered off over the horizon leaving not a trace. We should write to the Scottish Government and ask ministers to consider introducing a class-action procedure as the petitioner requests after they have read the Gill report.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I welcome the opportunity to discuss the petition. It is unfortunate that the Leith Links residents association cannot take a class action on the issue that it has raised, but it has raised Scottish society's need for a class-action procedure. Some of the concerns that it has expressed have been raised by other organisations over the past couple of decades. I hope that Lord Gill's review will take the issue forward. Instead of just holding the petition until the review is completed, it might be worth our while to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice to find out whether Lord Gill has indicated to the cabinet secretary whether class actions will form part of the review and, if not, what actions the cabinet secretary will take to ensure that class actions become part of the formal legal proceedings that can take place in Scotland. As the petitioners and the papers that are before us indicate, there is clearly a need for a class action procedure, not only for Leith Links residents association, but for other organisations in communities throughout Scotland that find it impossible to take legal action against public bodies because such action fails the public interest test. The issue is whether the public interest test as it is being applied is working in favour of the public interest.Rather than hold off until after Lord Gill's review is before us, we should ask the cabinet secretary whether the review will contain issues relating to class actions. If it will not, we should, as I said, ask whether the cabinet secretary will look to introduce a class action procedure in Scotland.

link

I can provide clarification on one of John Wilson's points: the matter is being considered as part of the review.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The clerks sigh in relief. However, it will still be necessary for the committee to get that clarity for our records.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

In response to Shirley-Anne Somerville's point, I acknowledge that class action forms part of the review, but it would be interesting to get an indication of whether Lord Gill is bringing forward proposals on class action. The discussion on class action was part of an on-going debate, hence we have a review. However, Lord Gill can review the matter but still come back with the recommendation that no action should be taken on it. I want to find out whether, if Lord Gill eventually says that no action should be taken, what action the Cabinet Secretary for Justice would propose to take in the light of the review.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I tend to agree with both the convener and John Wilson—I do not think that you are in disagreement. I think that we can keep the petition open and that we should write to the cabinet secretary because it would be helpful to get an initial indication of the Government's approach if Lord Gill were to come up with a specific proposal on class actions.As Mr Kirkwood said, the committee should put a marker down on behalf of the petitioners, in relation to not only the petition but to previous instances when the ability to instigate a class action would have been appropriate, including in high-profile disasters such as Piper Alpha or consumer issues such as Hoover's reneging on free transatlantic flights—I hope that the convener did not accept Hoover's promise at the time. These are serious issues.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

What's Hoover? I am too young.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You vacuumed up that question.To get back to the point, convener, which you made me stray from, I think that John Wilson is correct and you are correct. The committee should put a marker down.It might be useful in writing to the cabinet secretary to ask what actions, if any, Governments have taken as a result of the Scottish Law Commission class action report of 1996.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do any members who spoke on the petition have any other points?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Are we allowed to contribute to the general discussion?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Obviously, I am pleased that members are responding positively, not only by keeping the petition open but by writing to the Scottish Government. The cabinet secretary would not say it, but I accept that the Government of which I was part perhaps did not handle the issue properly if it just contracted the issue out to lawyers. It is important that politicians take an active role in the decision. It seems obvious that we should listen to lawyers on the issue, but the final decision ought to be for politicians. It would be helpful if the committee could be as positive as possible about the content of the petition and send out the message that Parliament will take a strong interest in what happens.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Committee members have indicated that they wish to process the petition as effectively as possible. I note the recommendations that members have made. We should also bring the petition to the attention of Lord Gill—he should be made aware of it even though he is in the final stages of producing his report. The petitioners will be notified when the petition is brought back before the committee. Although they may not have an opportunity to speak to the committee directly, the elected members who have expressed an interest in the petition will be happy to come back at a future date. I hope that we will be able to make progress on the issues that the petition raises and that what I propose is to the petitioners' satisfaction.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 3 March 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 43
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 25
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 21
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  26. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.