Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Young Offenders (PE1155)

Tuesday 3 March 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 17 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Our next petition is PE1155. I welcome Margaret Curran to the committee. The petition is from Elizabeth Cooper and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the law to ensure that young people aged between 10 and 18 who are charged with serious offences are tried by the criminal justice system rather than the children's hearings system. We have considered the petition before, but Margaret Curran may want to add her views on behalf of the petitioner.

Margaret Curran Lab Glasgow Baillieston
link

Thank you, convener—and I applaud your stamina in going through issues of substance. I will speed up.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We had better watch for what is known as a Des moment.

Margaret Curran Lab Glasgow Baillieston
link

I promise to be brief and to the point.I thank you for your focus on the petition. My constituents want me to communicate a few simple points. They appreciate what the Public Petitions Committee has done so far, in facilitating a meeting with a civil servant working with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. However, it is fair to say that my constituents have been left frustrated by the current position.As I am sure the committee knows, the civil servant said that the Government does not want these attackers to go to adult prisons. My constituents do not want them to go to adult prisons either. They do not think that that would be appropriate. However, what is unacceptable to my constituents is that nothing happens. I will quote from a letter that was written to me. It says that the people"who attacked my 13-year-old autistic son asked him for a kick of his ball and, because he asked for his ball back, they hit him with a brick. The oldest of the two who attacked him smashed his face against a slatted fence and then dragged his face along the fence, breaking his nose and then fracturing his cheekbone. They jumped on his back and his head. When he shielded himself under a fallen tree, they dragged him out and whipped him up and down his body with a rubber hose."That attack has had serious consequences, as I am sure committee members will appreciate. For example, the victim now spends all his time in his room and never goes out. The attack has had lasting and appalling effects.All that my constituents are saying is that something should be done. They are saying not that the young people who perpetrated the attack should go to an adult prison or that we should lock them up and throw away the key, but that, in the interests of both the attackers and the victim, we cannot walk away from this crime and we must do something about it. Essentially, my constituents have been told, "Sorry, but there is not much that we can do." They ask the committee, through me, to agree with them that that is not acceptable and something should be done about it.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I have every sympathy with the family of the victim of this appalling attack and share their concern about the fact that nothing was done.We need to be clear about the terminology. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend the law to ensure that young people aged between 10 and 18 who are charged with serious offences are tried by the criminal justice system rather than the children's hearings system. However, people are not tried by the children's hearings system—they come to a hearing and are asked whether they accept the reasons for their referral to the panel. If they do not accept the terms of the referral, they should automatically be sent to court for trial.It is not the place of any member of the committee to make observations on the case that Margaret Curran described or to suggest why certain things did not happen. However, I hope that one or two issues will be addressed in the children's hearings bill that is to be introduced in June. My experience on a children's panel comes from more than 20 years ago, but the situation is still the same. Because of a paucity of social workers, children's panels have a continual problem finding social workers to take up cases. There is also a shortage of good secure accommodation. Sometimes panels would like to send someone to secure accommodation but find that there are no spaces. That is why some young people end up in jails, which should not happen.The issue is about more than legislation—we need to find the money that is required. I am sure that the Government will have been reminded time and again of the problems that I have highlighted. The question is, will those problems be addressed in the discussions leading up to the introduction of the children's hearings bill?

Margaret Curran Lab Glasgow Baillieston
link

Robin Harper has made some serious and significant points. I understand that it is not for us to prejudge what a children's panel heard. We understand why ministers do not get involved in individual cases—we cannot have politicians deciding the outcome of cases. However, the family in this case thinks that it is illustrative of a bigger problem in the system. That is the context in which they view the petition. Their frustration comes from the fact that, without providing a proper explanation for its decision, a children's panel can decide to take no further action in a case that has been referred to it. All of us would challenge the decision to take no further action in such instances.Like Robin Harper, I would like children's panels to have many disposal options. I am not saying that the young people who carried out the attack that I have described should necessarily go to secure accommodation—that may or may not be appropriate—but doing nothing is certainly not appropriate, because that attack has had many ramifications locally. The Cooper family want the court system to examine such cases, because if it did they would not have felt abandoned. That is a real issue.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I know that all members are appalled by the serious assault that was carried out on the young man in this case, as described by our colleague Margaret Curran.Was any reason given that can be alluded to why the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service did not proceed with a criminal charge? Of course, young people who are charged with serious offences can be tried by the courts and not dealt with by the children's hearings system.

Margaret Curran Lab Glasgow Baillieston
link

I have not been given a proper reason. The only reason that I was given was that it was deemed appropriate that the referral was made to the children's panel. When I tried to work out why the children's panel took the decision not to instigate any further action, I was told that that was confidential.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Would it be useful to ask the Government whether it has any plans to instruct the COPFS in extreme cases such as the one in the petition to give reasons why it feels that it is inappropriate to proceed through the criminal justice system and instead to deal with them—or not, as the case may be—through the children's hearings system? The Government is entitled to consider that and perhaps even to ask the Crown Office to act in that way.The difficulty is that the prosecutorial system is independent of the political system—it absolutely has to be. However, as a bare minimum, we should ask for an explanation of the route taken by the COPFS to be conveyed to the person who has been assaulted and their family, if at all possible.As we all know, the Lord Advocate has discretionary powers in deciding whether to prosecute children—they have been prosecuted before, usually in relation to sexual offences. I agree that that discretion should be retained—it should not be changed.My only suggestion is that we write to the Government to ask whether it has the power to seek such a response from the Lord Advocate and, if it does not have the power, whether it is contemplating changes that would require the COPFS to provide an explanation. I do not know whether that matter is intra vires, but we should at least ask the question. After hearing what Margaret Curran said, I am sure that we are all appalled by what the victim and his family have had to go through. The least we can do is ask the question.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I echo what Bill Butler said. We should write to the Government to ask it to consider the options for requesting, requiring or advising the Lord Advocate to explain her decision in cases that are perceived to be serious, and to consider whether, in serious cases—all sorts of definition problems spring to mind—the children's panel should be required to give reasons for its decisions.As a parent, I sympathise deeply with the petitioners. We cannot turn the clock back and we cannot change our children, but we want to know why people did or did not do the things that we would think were appropriate. It does not seem entirely unreasonable to ask and to expect an answer, given that we are talking about very serious cases. That does not take away from the people who have to use their discretion, and who have the right to use their discretion. That is absolutely fair, because it is one of our protections. However, it is important that reasons are given when they can sensibly be given.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

I want to look at the other side of this. Should victim support be examined? Was any help offered? Could we do anything locally to give the young person support now?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will wrap up in a minute. Are there any final points from committee members? There is broad agreement that we want to keep the petition open and pursue issues relating to the guidelines or the understanding of the Procurator Fiscal Service and the relationship with the children's hearings system. Most of us want a children's hearings system that works well, that is credible and that has the consent of the public. We recognise that it is the most appropriate place to handle most issues relating to youngsters. However, in this case of extreme violence, there is a worry that something seems to have slipped through the net and that there was a lack of appropriate sanctions to give a strong message to the perpetrator that their conduct was unacceptable and to reassure the family that the system dealt with the case sensibly. There will be an opportunity to raise issues about the principles and the philosophy of the children's hearings system in our debates in the chamber on the proposed children's hearings bill.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I would be happy to keep the petition open if only to allow us to have more discussion about the role that the children's panel plays. It has been an important part of the system that the deliberations are kept confidential, but it is important to stress that it is not just the decision of the three panel members. They try to reach their decision with the agreement of the parents, the young people concerned, social workers and anyone else who is involved in the case. The decision is not the responsibility of one person or the three panel members.There are other things to consider about the way in which panels come to their decisions. Because panels are not courts and do not try people, the victims do not necessarily appear before panels. In fact, I would be surprised if that happened. The cases are considered in isolation. The panels on which I sat never met a victim.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I support what you said in summing up the debate, convener, but I would like to reiterate a point that other committee members have raised.In the case that Margaret Curran has highlighted, the victim's parents sought assurances about the action that had been taken but were told that they could not be given that information because it was confidential. If we are to have an open and transparent system, there must be transparency about the outcomes of the children's hearings system. Victims and their parents should be able to find out why children's panels reach certain decisions. Not being allowed to know why a decision was made has implications for the victim, which relate to whether they should take further action—a private prosecution or whatever—against the individuals concerned in order to highlight their situation.There is also an issue about openness and transparency in reaching decisions. I would like that point to be reinforced when we write to the cabinet secretary or whoever on the issue. Also, in drafting the proposed bill that will set up the children's hearings agency, we must ensure that that issue is addressed in the agency's guidelines, so that information is forthcoming and the decision-making process is not closed.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Okay. I think that there is broad agreement on that. Do you want to add any final points, Margaret?

Margaret Curran Lab Glasgow Baillieston
link

I will be brief. It is important that I clarify that the family and I were told that they could not be given information because the perpetrators were already subject to supervision orders. However, the point remains valid. The family could not be told the reasons behind the decision, and nor could I. I asked to be told privately, but that was not permitted. We could not be told whether the existing supervision orders would be increased or otherwise influenced. We had no indication at all of what effect the crime would have on the activities—I would not use the word punishment—that were to be undertaken or even any knowledge of what interventions were being made. They were deemed to be social work interventions and therefore private and confidential.It was a thorny issue for me, which is why, ultimately, we came to the committee—we could not grapple with the situation at all. The reality on the streets is that Martin, the young man in question, is in his room every night and the young lads who did this to him are out on the streets showing great bravado. The consequences for the community and for the credibility of the children's panel are significant. It would be fair to say that Mrs Cooper has lost confidence in the children's panel, and in any intervention in this serious case. Perhaps that would not be the case in a less serious situation.Mrs Cooper will appreciate the committee's reaction to the petition because you have taken it so seriously. Victim Support Scotland was involved, but it is fair to say that it was not of enormous benefit. If people want to pursue that point, I would be happy to speak to them about it.If we do not get a reaction from the children's panel or the adult system, we need to come to terms with the fact that there is a gap for which our communities are paying the price.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

There is broad agreement among committee members on how to pursue the matter. I thank Margaret Curran for her contribution on behalf of the family, who have come today. I know that they were not able to speak to the committee directly, but I hope that their MSP has articulated their concerns.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 3 March 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 4
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 43
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 25
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 21
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  26. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.