PE1061 has been in our system for a while, and Annabel Goldie has expressed a willingness to speak about it. The petition is from Mr and Mrs Mark J Lochhead and Mr and Mrs Henry McQueen Rankin. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to ensure that measures taken by communities to tackle antisocial behaviour in urban residential areas are not restricted by the duty of a local authority to uphold access rights under the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003.I welcome Annabel to the committee. She will know that the petition has been in the system for longer than I have been convener of the committee. If she would first like to explain why she has expressed an interest in the petition, the committee will then explore the options.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 (PE1061)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 7
- Annabel Goldie Con 5
- Nanette Milne Con 3
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- Fergus Cochrane 1
- Nigel Don SNP 1
The record
19 contributionsThank you, convener, not only for allowing me to address the committee, but for your understanding in moving the petition further up the agenda. I have been asked by Mr and Mrs Lochhead to speak to the committee on their behalf. They are in the public gallery. With the indulgence of the committee, I will read a brief statement so that it will appear in the Official Report.My constituents Mr and Mrs Lochhead have requested that I speak to you about their experiences in trying to prevent antisocial behaviour in the lane beside their home. The case has brought to the forefront the difficulties faced by local residents and councils in the effort to find a balance between curbing antisocial behaviour and upholding public rights of access for the local community.Mr and Mrs Lochhead first approached my office in January 2007. For a number of years, they had suffered from antisocial behaviour in the lane. This behaviour intensified with the arrival of the summer months. There was verbal abuse and physical damage to their property. The damage included vandalism to Mr and Mrs Lochhead's car and house. For example, the living-room window was broken and the cost borne by my constituents to replace it was £987. I am informed by my constituents that damage to their neighbours' property included graffiti on their garden shed and vandalism to their car. There was also verbal abuse over the garden fence.I am informed by Mr and Mrs Lochhead that the lane is private and owned to the mid-point by my constituents and their neighbours. It was originally used for services—refuse collection and so forth—but over the past few years it developed into an area for people involved in intimidating behaviour. My constituents' health—and, I am told, their neighbours' health—suffered as a direct consequence of the stress caused by the activities in the lane.My constituents inform me that the problem has been on-going since 2003 and that they have been in contact with the council since February 2003. Mr and Mrs Lochhead were informed by the council that the lane between their home and the neighbouring house must be available for public access, even though my constituents maintain that the lane is private. The lane is very narrow; I think that I am correct in saying that it is about a metre wide.Mr and Mrs Lochhead felt that the only way to stop people gathering and creating problems near their home was to fit a gate, thereby preventing access. The council informed my constituents that planning permission was required for the erection of the gate. Retrospective permission was therefore sought, but was denied on the ground of access legislation.I can see the point made in the council's submission on the petition in August this year. The council said:"Closure of paths does not address the root of the problem of anti-social behaviour."We accept that the council's role is to consider the wider consequences of path closures and the effect on the community as a whole. However, it is easy to see why my constituents, who are living with this problem day and night, felt that lane closure was the only option. My constituents felt that the council should not enforce the right of access when the effect of refusing planning permission for the gate was detrimental to their enjoyment of their home and their desire to live in a quiet and safe neighbourhood.My constituents wish to have the gate locked "24/7". Mr and Mrs Lochhead inform me that antisocial behaviour still takes place in the lane during the daytime. They believe that the only way to prevent this occurrence is to lock the gate.Mr and Mrs Lochhead and their neighbours undertook a public inquiry, which was a great financial burden to them. The reporter concluded that the gate should remain, provided that Mr and Mrs Lochhead and their neighbours ensured that the gate was opened between 8 am and 8 pm, 365 days a year.The logic behind the decision was that the closure of the gates after 8 pm should help to prevent antisocial behaviour during the night, yet opening the gates during the day would continue to provide legitimate access to local residents. Although paragraph 19 of the council's submission to the committee appears to agree with that stance, it is clear that the council is uneasy about how it will sit with the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003. That is where national guidance for councils might be helpful.My constituents inform me that other councils have taken different actions in similar situations. It has caused my constituents considerable frustration because they feel penalised for living in their particular council area. They inform me that some residents of the Glasgow City Council and East Dunbartonshire Council areas benefit considerably from being able to keep their gates locked 24 hours a day, seven days a week.A local councillor in my constituency suggested to them that national guidance on the issue of lanes would be helpful and would ensure consistency throughout Scotland. The council's further-comments document of 2008 that was submitted to the committee states in the last paragraph that national guidance would be useful and indeed, might ensure that councils and residents are able to find solutions to minimise the risk of antisocial behaviour while still providing access.Mr and Mrs Lochhead have stated to me that they wish the gates to be locked 24 hours a day, seven days a week. They inform me that all people who require legitimate access to the lane have keys, therefore my constituents see no reason to keep the gates unlocked. Mr and Mrs Lochhead believe that having the gates locked would bring palpable benefits to their neighbours and them.I realise that the committee cannot deliver a specific solution to a petitioner's problem, but it has a powerful capacity to direct others in the need to find such a solution if there is a public interest that is broader than the individual plight of the petitioners. The petitioners highlight that broader public interest. The petition paints a graphic illustration of the law of unintended consequences. The architects of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 wished to facilitate access of the Scottish public to rural and remote parts of Scotland for purposes of leisure and recreation. I am certain that they did not intend that urban property owners should be obstructed by the act in protecting themselves and their property against the modern-day plague of antisocial behaviour. The consequence of that legislation seems to be a statutory nonsense. The anomaly becomes all the more ludicrous when different local authorities choose to interpret the act in different ways. Either the legislation requires to be amended or the guidance clarified to serve the ends of both common sense and consistency of application.
Thanks very much. Are there any immediate observations from committee members?
The committee had significant sympathy with Mr and Mrs Lochhead's plight when the petition was discussed before. I cannot remember—perhaps the clerks will help—whether we have been in touch with the Government to ask about potential guidance. If different local authorities are dealing with the matter in different ways, it would be sensible to have Government guidance to help them.
I recall a previous committee meeting after which we issued a letter to the Scottish Government asking that specific question. I recall the Government coming back to us to say that it had no plans to issue guidance on the matter. I would have to double check, but that is my recollection.
As you well understand, Annabel, the committee is concerned not to be seen as an arbiter in cases of difficult and complex unintended consequences, levels of interpretation or lack of clarity about legislative framework, which leads to people interpreting it in a more difficult way that is to the detriment of the issue raised by the petitioners. However, we are concerned that the petition has been in our system for a while. What I feel are fairly sensible solutions do not seem to have been arrived at. Has there been a full community safety assessment of the residents in that area or the nature of the offences? Have the police engaged with the local authority about using other grounds to address the issue, so that it is not seen as a dispute relating to the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003? It is almost bizarre that we are considering a petition to do with antisocial behaviour because of an interpretation of that act. The petition is about antisocial behaviour, community safety and people feeling secure in their own properties. We want to try to resolve those issues. I invite Annabel Goldie to respond to that before we explore ways for the committee to help.
My constituents and I understand and sympathise with the fact that it is not for this committee to deliver a specific solution. That is why I said that I believed that the petition raised an issue of broader public interest. The Minister for Environment, Mr Russell, sent me a letter in March, which I can make available to the committee via the clerk. When I raised with the minister the issues confronting my constituents, he said that he was aware that the Public Petitions Committee was considering the matter. He said:"The Committee will consider further what actions are being taken by the Scottish Government to ensure that measures taken by communities to tackle anti-social behaviour in urban residential areas are not restricted by the duty of a local authority to uphold access rights under the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003."We are dealing with an issue of broader public interest. It is clear that, throughout Scotland, there are conflicting views about how to interpret the act. We would all accept that that is not satisfactory. We all want to anticipate that legislation that is passed by this Parliament is both uniform and universal in its application. It is clear that that is not the case at present.
We all acknowledge that we cannot deal with the individual case in question, but can we write to the Government to reflect the experience of these petitioners, to say that we are concerned about how the act is operating and to ask the Government to review it? In so far as we are able to influence the Government, we can say that we think that the act needs to be looked at and that perhaps the Government should issue appropriate guidance.
That is helpful.
I get the impression that the act is not operating in the spirit in which it was intended to operate. Perhaps we should ask the Government whether it thinks that the act is operating as intended. I do not think that it is—the rest of the committee would probably agree.
We should also write to the local authority concerned. We should raise with it the concerns that have been expressed about behaviour in the area and ask whether better guidance from the Government would help it to resolve the issue.
Perhaps we could write to the local authority to ask what other approaches to tackling ASB in similar situations in the area have been used and whether they have been successful. If they have been successful, we could ask what contributed to their success.
Would it be fair to ask whether the petitioners' human rights are being breached, under the European convention on human rights?
We can raise that issue.
It is entirely at the committee's discretion to take whatever action it thinks appropriate, but, for me, the kernel of the matter is to do with legislation that is passed by this Parliament. The local authority in question has been trying to grapple with its interpretation of the legislation, but we know that that interpretation is not shared by other local authorities. I suggest to Mr Butler that there is a broader public interest issue around the act, which needs to be clarified.
Perhaps Annabel Goldie would think it a positive way of proceeding if we asked the Government whether it thinks that uniform guidance is now appropriate, given the lack of uniformity and consistency across local authorities.
That is a very appropriate question, convener.
I hope that that is helpful. It is difficult for the committee to deal with the issue because of local government powers and the issues that have been raised. I hope that that will be helpful to Miss Goldie's constituents, and that we can make some progress.
Thank you very much, convener.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Oct 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 7 October 2008 Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 48
- New Petitions Petitions · 51
- New Petitions Petitions · 30
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
- Petitions Process Inquiry Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.