Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Crofting (Shucksmith Report) (PE1201)

Tuesday 7 October 2008 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 51 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

51 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The next petition is PE1201, from Netta MacKenzie, whom I thank for her patience. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government not to adopt in any future legislation the main recommendations of the Shucksmith report on crofting, which include the breaking up the Crofters Commission, the permitting of non-crofters, by mere virtue of residency, to sit on crofting township development committees and the introduction of burdens that would reduce the value of crofters' homes, thereby rendering borrowing impossible.I welcome Netta MacKenzie to the meeting. As we are aware, a ministerial statement was made on the matter last Wednesday, so members should be familiar with the Administration's position on it. I invite Netta say a few words, after which we will have a Q and A session.

Netta MacKenzie
link

Thank you for inviting me into the lions den once more.My first observation is on the methodology of the Shucksmith report, which I suggest to the committee is flawed. In my view, that is one reason why the report resonated so poorly with people at the grass roots who were not represented at meetings. We should remember that the foot-and-mouth restrictions were in place when some meetings were held and the whole rural timetable was in chaos. Many people were expected to travel significant distances to make their voices heard. Too many non-crofting stakeholders were able to attend private afternoon meetings before turning up to put their views at public sessions, too.Crofters have said to me that the professor was protected by a ring of steel that was provided by the Scottish Crofting Foundation, the Scottish rural payments and inspectorate division and other stakeholders. The use of pre-posed questions and research companies whose staff asked opinion poll-type questions of anyone they happened to meet is not the best way to do such work. As you will know, the north-west of Sutherland was one of the important crofting areas that were not visited.I draw the committee's attention to the Crofters Commission, which I argued with the minister should be fully elected and to which policy-making powers should be devolved from Pentland house. To propose a partially elected commission, as the minister does, is a vote of no confidence in the ability of crofters to run their affairs. There is a wealth of talent in the Highlands and Islands. To deny crofters the right to secure their destiny is to use the same argument that those opposed to the establishment of the Parliament used—that Scots can never get on with one other. That was one of the warnings that the editorial in The Scottish Farmer highlighted this weekend.Crofters do not need the quango folk to keep them right and to lend experience; crofters can deal with Scottish Natural Heritage, the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and the rest in negotiations as and when necessary. It must be borne in mind that crofters' rights and agendas are often at variance with the opinion of other groups, as was vividly demonstrated at Poolewe last week. A Crofters Commission composed of crofters ought to be in place to negotiate with the minister and others on behalf of crofters. The leadership of the commission needs to be revitalised to give its talented staff the lead and direction they need. The present rules that govern the commission's remit ought to be revised to enable the commission to talk to grass-roots crofters and to gain their confidence. The commission ought to be treated properly as principal adviser to the minister. It should also have a role in the formulation of European Union law—directives and so on—so that it reflects our small-scale production and the nature of our disadvantage.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you. You will be aware of the Government response that was published last week.

Netta MacKenzie
link

I am aware that an 18-page document was published.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That will influence members' questioning. It is now essential to allow members to engage with some of the key points that you have made.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

How many people responded to the petition by signing it?

Netta MacKenzie
link

There were 861 responses. As an e-petition, the petition received only around 250 or 260 signatures, as people in the Highlands and Islands do not have sufficient access to broadband or computers. People in the crofting community do not have the facility to use computers—they are not comfortable with that medium. Paper copies of the petition went out to a large number of people, and signatures on paper make up the bulk of signatures. Many people phoned up when they read in newspapers that the petition had been launched; I sent out paper copies, which were returned to me.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I am sure that you are aware of the response that the Minister for Environment published last week, to which the convener referred. How does that affect the petition?

Netta MacKenzie
link

Although the devil is in the detail, the minister's response appears to be the Shucksmith report in all but name. The minister has changed very little—he suggests that local boards be renamed area committees, but almost all his proposals are the same as those in the report. He suggests that there should not be a burden on croft land with a croft house, but that there should be a burden on croft land that is decrofted, and that the commission should be broken up. I think that the commission should be strengthened, which cannot be done by giving its development department to Highlands and Islands Enterprise and giving the register of crofts to the Registers of Scotland—that is a vote of no confidence in the commission. The commission needs to be restructured and redirected, but it does not need to be broken up, as the minister suggests.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Would a restructured Crofters Commission, elected from the townships, have the expertise to regulate crofting as well as to carry out the development function?

Netta MacKenzie
link

There is a far greater wealth of talent among crofters than is suspected. I think that the approach that you suggest would work.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

This is not an area that I have specialised in, to be candid and honest. The Minister for Environment made his statement on 1 October, and there is to be further consultation. Could many of the issues behind your petition be addressed through that consultation process? Do you think that further exploration by the committee would assist?

Netta MacKenzie
link

I would hope so. Since the Scottish Parliament came into being, our local group and my husband and I have submitted many responses to consultations. However, we feel that they often fall on deaf ears and that our concerns are not duly listened to. That needs to be addressed, especially with regard to the Royal Society of Edinburgh's report on the future of Scotland's hills and islands, which mentions the Shucksmith report. Referring to how to take crofting forward, the RSE's report says:"We are less persuaded by the Inquiry's suggestions as to how this might be achieved."There are issues in that report that need to be addressed, especially when it comes to support for agriculture in the hills. Hill farming is in a desperate state, and that needs to be addressed.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I am probably speaking for most of us, with the exception of John Farquhar Munro, when I say that I do not understand crofting. The good news is that I know that I do not understand crofting. We occasionally discuss local councils. I knew one, and I have a fair idea about what most of them do, but crofting is territory that we are simply not familiar with. We therefore find it difficult to know how to proceed.That is not an excuse for doing nothing, but it is a plea for some alternative way forward. My colleagues and I are probably going to struggle to go through your petition, rationalise it in our minds and work out precisely what we should do. I am considering two possible ways forward, and I hope that you can help me out with them. One alternative is for the committee to write to everybody involved, including the Scottish Government, Highlands and Islands Enterprise, the Scottish Crofting Foundation and anybody else we might suggest, saying that we understand that there is a problem and asking them to advise us. The second option, perhaps the nuclear option, is to acknowledge the on-going consultation and the fact that the minister has been through a consultation process, however flawed you may feel that it was—I cannot possibly comment on that. Under that option, we might conclude that the committee does not represent the right route for you, so we must ask you and your colleagues, with all respect, to go through the consultation processes. I am looking for some help as to how we can help you, given that this is not familiar territory.

Netta MacKenzie
link

I understand that. The Shucksmith report is not resounding, and it has not been endorsed by crofters, because there was not sufficient crofting input into it. The Scottish Crofting Foundation is one voice, but it seems to be the only one that is asked to be represented at stakeholder meetings. NFU Scotland is another voice, but it is very much constrained by other members. I think that it is supportive of crofters, but it does not really go so far as to acknowledge the people with common grazings of large areas. Every time we consider less favoured areas, a large area depresses the subsidy. The single farm payment also covers common grazings and, again, that depresses what we get. That is the way in which things are organised; it is how things are counted.More crofters must try to take an active part and put forward their views. Many members of the Scottish Crofting Foundation have told me that they have stopped their direct debits because the SCF, acting as the authentic voice of crofting, welcomed the current proposals, which annoyed many people. At a Shucksmith consultation, I sat at a table of eight, which had four crofters and four non-crofting stakeholders. What crofters would like did not come through at the consultations. I was one of the 1,000 who were interviewed. However, if an interviewer asks a question, then asks which from a list of answers is the right one, that does not allow views to be expressed. That shows how blinkered the consultation was and how the Shucksmith inquiry lost it.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I am looking for your input to help us know how to go forward.

Netta MacKenzie
link

The Crofters Commission should make an annual report on crofting to the Parliament. Much more work needs to be done to bring people up to speed on what is happening. Crofting is an important part of agriculture, but it is also important for communities in crofting areas that people remain settled there. The danger is that they will not. For example, Stewart Wood drove up to the north the other day, then phoned my husband yesterday to say that there were no sheep. We said that that was what we were saying.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Our difficulty is not in supporting your view that the matters that you have raised are important, that the less favoured areas money matters and that NFU Scotland has disparate views, depending on what community someone comes from. However, I am still stuck with a problem. As I understand it, you are speaking about crofters who were effectively disfranchised from the consultation process. However, I have to find out how we can enable the crofters to express their important views to ministers. That is what we can do. It is no good persuading us, because we are not here to act as judge and jury. We are only a mechanism to get the right people to talk to Government. How are we going to do that?

Netta MacKenzie
link

The commissioners on the Crofters Commission should be elected crofters. There have been many changes over the past few years in the Crofters Commission, but the commissioners do not interact with crofters as we might expect. For instance, they were not at the Black Isle show talking in a tent to crofters. They could have talked about the rural development programme, which would have been excellent. However, the commissioners have been told that they are not allowed to go to such events. What is necessary is redirection on that sort of thing.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Right. In that case, although it will not be the whole solution, can you offer us a first step? Who can we write to or nudge and what can the committee do to enable crofters to have their voice heard in the right place? That is the kind of thing that we can do and what we would probably love to do, although I am not speaking for other committee members yet. Our problem is that we do not know how to do that.

Netta MacKenzie
link

It could probably be done through the Crofters Commission holding meetings in the crofting areas. Canvassing for information could be done in that way.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

So you would be happy if we wrote to the minister, who would presumably instruct the Crofters Commission. Is that the right line of attack?

Netta MacKenzie
link

Yes.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

The minister could instruct the Crofters Commission to consult more widely about the current proposals to ascertain whether they should be changed. We should work on the basis that although you know what the answer is, we should not presume. That would be the single best step to take.

Netta MacKenzie
link

It would be a step, certainly.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

What would the second step be? I think that we are making progress here. Is the convener happy with where I am going?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

All this talk of steps makes me think of an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting. It would be helpful if Nanette Milne came in now, then we could try to put together what the committee's response should be. The question is how we progress the issues that the petition raises.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I do not want to pre-empt anything that Nigel Don is saying. I took part in the debate on the Shucksmith report. I am not a crofter, so I do not have a huge knowledge of crofting. I took the report essentially at face value at that stage. It is clear that you are not happy with quite a lot of the report and, presumably, with the minister's response to it last week.I am happy to go along with anything that Nigel Don suggests. The minister recently made a statement about how he sees things progressing. We might not get the response that you are seeking from the minister and the Government. Do you think that what the minister is proposing is workable? Does HIE have sufficient resources to cope with its new responsibilities?

Netta MacKenzie
link

HIE's focus has changed. As far as I understand it, it is going for much larger industries than those in which small crofters are involved. Crofters will be very unhappy with that.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I was impressed by the RSE report. The issue of there being no sheep on the hills, to which you refer, is serious.

Netta MacKenzie
link

Yes, especially where pillar 2 is concerned. The UK Government has not addressed the problem.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

It is clear that we have to progress this.

Netta MacKenzie
link

Yes.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

There are issues outstanding, despite the minister's contribution last week. Referring even an element of the petition to the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee might not be applicable, because the bill is not in the legislative programme for the next year. It will be a considerable time before a crofting bill is lodged, which means that the consultation process on the bill is a long way away. Although we will be able to interrogate the issues that a consultation raises at that stage, it is perhaps worth raising with the Government and the agencies identified in the minister's statement some of the points that you have made. The agencies are meant to have the capacity to address crofting issues in the way that the Crofters Commission has done.I suggest that we ask the Government about the contribution that crofters and non-crofters would be able to make to the reformed Crofters Commission, which is one of your key concerns. We should also ask whether a new system of occupancy conditions is workable and how the Government proposes to develop it. We should ask whether HIE has the capacity to deal with the issues to which the minister referred in his statement. We should ask the Scottish Crofting Foundation what actions it thinks that the Government can take to address the points that you have raised. Those actions would keep the petition alive and allow it to be part of an on-going process, which is important to you and those who support your petition. It will also allow us to get a bit more information before the consultation concludes. That might help shape the discussion that will take place in the relevant parliamentary committee.Are members happy with that suggestion?

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I am happy to support your suggestion, although I find it strange that we cannot send the petition to the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee. Is there an impediment to our doing that?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

It is not that we cannot do it; we just have to consider whether it would be useful, given the timescale of the crofting bill.

Fergus Cochrane Clerk
link

I understand that the crofting bill is not expected to be lodged in the current legislative year, so the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee will not be considering it at this time. It is up to the committee whether it nonetheless wants to refer the petition to the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am not going to die in the sand over this. If members want to refer the petition to the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee, that is fine. If I were a member of that committee, I would not want to consider the petition for a while, because the bill is still some way away. There are issues that we can draw to the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee's attention. We can set out the issues that we identify in our correspondence in the next few months, so that it can include them in its consideration of the bill, when it is lodged. Is that okay?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

To refer to Nigel Don's observations, I believe that an early definition of a croft was that it is a very small plot of land entirely surrounded by a mass of regulations.A situation that confuses me and which must make it difficult for the Government to get an accurate idea of what crofters feel is that, although the Scottish Crofting Foundation has 2,000 members and another 700 crofters are in NFU Scotland—which is perhaps seen as representing crofters better than the Scottish Crofting Foundation—roughly 10,000 crofters are not represented at all. That is because they think that those organisations are irrelevant or that they do not represent their views. We should acknowledge that the situation presents a difficulty to crofters in knowing how to approach the 10,000 crofters whose views are not represented formally in any way.

Netta MacKenzie
link

I agree with that absolutely. I was unhappy with the Shucksmith report, so I started a petition. We have been asked to go and talk to crofters and we get a lot of comments. At one meeting, more than 60 crofters came to tell us what is going on. A large part of the issue is that the representation of crofters in relation to the report was poor.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

John Wilson can make a final point.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

We should further question the Scottish Government. I believe that it proposes to set up a federation of crofting boards, drawing its membership from seven to 10 local crofting boards. It would be useful to find out from the Government how those local crofting boards will be established, how the elections to them will take place and how they will fit into the Scotland-wide body that the Government is talking about. To refer to the issue that Robin Harper raised, I hope that the Government will also say how crofters will interact with the local boards and the national federation. It is worth while investigating that further to find out exactly what the Government intends and how that fits into the whole process.I am glad that the convener said that, in light of the timescale for the debate in the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee, this committee will try to progress the issue. The work that we are doing will not preclude submissions being made from outwith the organisations that we have suggested contacting. If we receive submissions from crofters who feel that the Shucksmith report does not address some of their real concerns, the committee would accept those comments, which would help us to deliberate further.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I think that Netta MacKenzie wants to make a final point.

Netta MacKenzie
link

The area committees that the minister suggested last week would be almost the same as the local crofting boards that are suggested in the report. There is a lot of disquiet and unease with that idea. People would much rather have the Crofters Commission in Inverness deciding on disputes than a local board. Local boards would be very divisive.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I have said "final" twice now, but I will allow you in as you were considerate earlier.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I just want to respond to John Wilson's query about how the boards would be elected. As I understand it, the area boards would be selected from the entire community, whether or not they were crofters, so there would be non-crofters on the boards. Crofters are dismayed about that because they think that the area boards might be overrun with people who have a different view of the community and crofting. That does not please them. If the Crofters Commission were democratically elected from the crofting townships, crofters would have far more respect for it. At present, whichever Government is in power places its people on the commission and many of them do not have the crofting system at heart.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We have had several suggestions about how to proceed. To explain, we will keep the petition alive. We recognise that the Government made a consultation commitment last week in the Parliament, but committee members have identified three or four issues to explore further. We will raise those issues with the Government, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and the Scottish Crofting Foundation. We will also take on board John Wilson's comments. We will pull that together and come back with further points for the committee. Netta MacKenzie will be kept fully apprised of the process. We will continue to interrogate the issues that her petition raises and I hope that the discussion has been useful to her. We will continue to explore the issues in the coming period.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 7 October 2008 Petitions · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 4
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 48
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 51
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 30
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 26
  10. New Petitions Petitions · 9
  11. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  26. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
  27. Petitions Process Inquiry Petitions · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.