I resume the meeting to consider PE1175, from Dr Robert Grant, on behalf of Glenrothes Area Futures Group, calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to improve and upgrade the A92 trunk road immediately, in particular between the Prestonhall roundabout and Balfarg junction, in order to reduce the number of hazards and accidents and bring about improved benefits to the local and wider economy.I welcome Ronald Page and Jayne Smith to this afternoon's meeting. There is keen all-party support for the petition, so I also welcome several parliamentarians who represent different parts of Fife and who will contribute in due course. I thank those members for their patience during what has been a lengthy meeting this afternoon.The members' business debate on 3 September was on the subject of the petition, so members will be aware of how matters stand to date. I invite Ronald Page to say a few words in case he wishes to add to the original petition, after which we will have a question-and-answer session.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
A92 Upgrade (PE1175)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ronald Page Glenrothes Area Futures Group 9
- Frank McAveety Lab 6
- Nanette Milne Con 3
- Claire Baker Lab 3
- Jayne Smith Glenrothes Area Futures Group 2
- Ted Brocklebank Con 2
- Robin Harper Green 1
- Tricia Marwick SNP 1
- Bashir Ahmad SNP 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Nigel Don SNP 1
The record
30 contributionsI am told that our two papers of background information were circulated to all committee members. Our second submission was headed by a soundbite from me that the A92 at Glenrothes is "the forgotten three miles". Of course, it is not forgotten in the days of the current by-election campaign when lots of people are using that part of the A92.
You have perfect timing, Ronald.
Yes. I am absolutely certain that the vast majority of people in the Glenrothes area are much more interested in the outcome of this meeting about the A92 with the Public Petitions Committee than they are in what is happening in the by-election, which focuses the mind.The Glenrothes Area Futures Group was set up almost exactly a year ago. There were mutterings about something that was happening locally and community councils and churches were moaning and groaning about it. The outcome was the formation of the Glenrothes Area Futures Group, which brings together all the various moans and groans, with a view to some kind of action.There were four particular issues, but the A92 became the burning issue, and it is still on the go. Yesterday, I got an e-mail from the chief executive of Transport Scotland, which confirmed that the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change, Stewart Stevenson, has agreed that two of the hazards will be looked at—Cadham and Balfarg junctions—and their assessment will go back to Transport Scotland.That is the nature of our problem, however. Our documents show that Fife Council says one thing, and Transport Scotland says that it has not heard from Fife Council. We go back to Fife Council and are told that it is nothing to do with it. The last communication I received from Fife Council says that the A92 is a trunk road, so it is the responsibility of the Scottish Parliament and its agency, Transport Scotland. I am certain that people present petitions to the Public Petitions Committee because of the ping-pong game that goes on between local authorities and the Scottish Parliament. I will not say anything more about that. It also leaves me, as a retired teacher of history and modern studies, to ask who runs the country and the local authority. I go back to a famous programme that I used to recommend to my pupils: "Yes, Minister" was about who runs the country.There is no lack of support. Jayne Smith and I have had meetings with our three local Labour, Conservative and SNP MSPs. We have maximum support from MSPs, who were at the meeting that the convener referred to, and from the Glenrothes local councillors, every one of whom from all parties has endorsed the campaign. So, where do we go from here? Where does the committee go from here?We have support from local councillors, MSPs, bus companies, hauliers, the big Tullis Russell Papermakers Ltd factory, and small businesses. We have almost 3,500 signatures, and I am sure that we could produce 10,000. If we stood outside all the polling booths on 7 November, we would pull in another 40,000 or 50,000 signatures.I believe that 99 per cent of people support the campaign to upgrade and improve the A92, but 1 per cent, or perhaps less, say no and we believe that it is Transport Scotland. The Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change raised issues at our meeting with Transport Scotland. It emerged that Transport Scotland deals with criteria such as statistics about deaths, serious accidents, serious economic blockages and so on. However, we all know that during recent years the number of accidents on Scotland's roads has gone down everywhere, including on the A92.After our discussion with him, the minister asked Transport Scotland if it considered people's quality of life and wellbeing, and the answer was that there is no way to measure that. What about the hundreds of people in north Glenrothes who go to work in the direction of Kirkcaldy, Edinburgh or Dundee, and avoid those two junctions? Transport Scotland says that it cannot and does not measure that. Hundreds of people avoid those junctions. What about the possible economic benefits? Transport Scotland says that it does not examine the future. We are stymied.I assume that the committee has read our documents, so there is no need for me to say much more. There is a map of the Glenrothes area from the early 1990s that shows a proposed dual carriageway, which most people think is the answer. The plans existed, but they have somehow been lost: we got a letter from Transport Scotland saying that the 1996 plans had been lost and we recently received a letter from Fife Council informing us that it had lost its response to the Scottish Government on a 2007 matter. Strange things are happening.Where do we go from here? Two of the junctions are being assessed, but we do not know whether, after that assessment, they will simply be patched again. There have been various patches in the past, but they are just a form of make-up. The fact is that, although a lot of make-up is attractive, it simply disguises things and does not really get at their very base.
On that point—not the point about make-up, but the point about where we go from here—it might be useful if, with the help of you and Jayne Smith, members can pull together an approach in a series of questions.
I should say that I, too, am a retired teacher of modern studies and history.You said that the Scottish transport appraisal guidance report was sent to Dr Malcolm Reed on 17 September. Are you able to tell what was contained in the report or does it have to remain under wraps until it has received a response?
In our research, we discovered that Transport Scotland expects local authorities and so on to submit STAG reports, which are highly technical documents that deal with transport in general, including roads. Very recently, a member of our group who is pretty well acquainted with transportation submitted on our behalf an intensive 12 to 14-page STAG report in which he suggests a variety of improvements to transportation in general and the A92 in particular. That shows that we are trying to co-operate with Transport Scotland. I am delighted that the agency has taken one step, but we have passed the ball back in the hope that it will consider our document in the same way that it would consider a similar document from a local authority.
We would be very happy to send the committee the 14-page STAG report. Its contents are not that sensitive; it primarily highlights the need for improvements on the A92, in the light of the fact that the rail infrastructure around Glenrothes is not fit for purpose. It is our only other fallback.Two other questions need to be asked. First, as Ron Page said earlier, the criteria for improving trunk roads are reduction in road accidents, the safety statistics and wear and tear. Given that the number of road accidents across Scotland is falling—which is fantastic—the question is whether the criteria are still fit for purpose. Should we return to that issue?Secondly—and just as serious—although our group is new, the issue is not. It has been on the cards since the early 1990s. Quite frankly, we have been disillusioned by the fact that Fife Council and Transport Scotland seem to have mislaid the relevant material on dualling the road. We need that material, but where is it? Why did it go missing?
I do not know the road that you are talking about very well but, as someone who has been campaigning to get something done about the A96, I sympathise fully with your comments.In 1999, the Scottish Executive decided that the plans on the table were somewhat excessive and felt that lesser action was required. Do you think that such an approach would be enough, or is dualling the only serious option?
We submitted an alternative or two in our original paper, but dualling seems to be the accepted answer to all the problems. The previous Scottish Executive dropped the dualling plan, but we want to resuscitate it. Instead of a big dualling process, we got a few patches. They have helped to cut the number of accidents, but we do not want more patching. That is what might happen at Cadham and Balfarg junctions.I know that there are requests for road upgrades here, there and everywhere, but what we propose is resuscitation of a plan. On that basis, we would like our proposal to be acted upon.
I welcome the Glenrothes Area Futures Group to the Scottish Parliament. The group has done an enormous amount of work in the past year or so to try to move the A92 up the political agenda. The issue fell off the agenda in 2000, when the Labour-Liberal Executive decided not to go ahead with the dualling that the Conservative Government promised in—I think—1995. From 2000 until last year, apart from one or two voices, the issue of the A92 and its dualling was stilled, so it is good to see it back on the agenda. I have always supported the dualling of the A92.The group is right to say that some patches of the road have been dualled, but there is no doubt in my mind about the condition of the road. Many members will be hotfooting it to Glenrothes, Balfarg and Cadham in the next four weeks and will see for themselves how difficult it is to negotiate the road. Many of us contributed to Ted Brocklebank's members' business debate on the matter and I was grateful to the minister, Stewart Stevenson, for confirming that he would consider the matter again and assess the two junctions at Cadham and Balfarg. He followed that up by holding a meeting with three MSPs and Transport Scotland.There is no doubt that the road is extremely dangerous. It is only because people know how dangerous it is that we do not have more accidents—Ronald Page and Jayne Smith made that point. The road is simply not fit for purpose. I would not turn down a proposal for work to be done at Balfarg and Cadham junctions, but in the long term somebody has to grasp the real problem. We can patch the road and realign junctions as we have done I do not know how many times, but eventually somebody will have to come to a sensible conclusion. They will have to either put in a roundabout and try to redirect the traffic or dual the A92.It is fortunate and unfortunate that, since the petition was lodged, the campaign has moved on quite a bit. We had the members' debate and we have commitments from the minister and Transport Scotland, so some of the options that would have been open to the committee might now be closed. However, I look forward to listening to the committee's deliberations. I urge you to make recommendations to the Government—we will see whether together we can progress the matter more quickly.
link
I have a few questions for the witnesses. You said that the number of accidents in Scotland has been reducing, and we know that the A92 does not have the fatality rates of other roads in Scotland. Jayne Smith talked about whether the criteria for deciding where to improve trunk roads are fit for purpose. If it is not upgraded, what dangers might there be on the road in the future?
There is no doubt that there will be dangers. The petition has been signed and supported almost universally on the A92 as it is at the moment. Next year there will be a major retail development in Glenrothes town centre, which will be followed shortly by yet another major retail development. People will come to those developments using the A92—from the Prestonhall roundabout into the heart of Glenrothes. No one denies that they are major positive developments. With the Scottish Parliament's endorsement, the Tullis Russell paper factory is changing to biomass energy, which means that there will be about 200 lorries per day on the A92. Accidents are such as to lead people to sign the petition at the moment, but in the next year or two the A92 will be swamped with additional traffic, which is a matter of concern. We can come back to the committee in two years with another petition, but we do not want to look backwards. Jayne Smith is right to ask about the criteria for upgrading.
As Nanette Milne may not know the road too well, I point out that the 200 lorries going down the A92—which is dualled to a certain extent—will come to a large roundabout and be funnelled into one lane. That is the biggest danger that we face, although not the only one.
link
We know that trunk roads are a responsibility of the Scottish Government, rather than local authorities. You mentioned that you have the support of councillors in the Glenrothes area and you referred to discussions with Fife Council. What discussions have you had with the council? What support has it given to your campaign?
It has given verbal support. On 29 August, I had a meeting with the convener of Fife Council's environment, enterprise and transportation committee, who wrote to me on the matter. In his letter, which is cited in our written evidence, he states:"I would like to confirm our support for your campaign for awareness raising for upgrades to the A92 in Glenrothes … As acknowledged, the A92 is a trunk road and under control of Scottish Government through their agency Transport Scotland. Any improvements should be sought through Transport Scotland."That is the crux of the matter.
I welcome the representatives of Glenrothes Area Futures Group. As the petitioner generously remarked, I led the members' business debate on this subject. There was a fairly thorough airing of the issues that have been raised today. There is cross-party representation at today's meeting, but I point out for the record that back in 1997 Lord James Douglas-Hamilton recommended that the then Tory Government should dual the A92 around Glenrothes. In the event, the Conservative Government was not around a year later and the idea was dropped.When we talk about the number of accidents on the A92, we must be careful to identify on what part of the road the accidents occur. So far we have talked about the part around Glenrothes. We are right to have done so, because that is an extremely serious issue, but the A92 goes all the way up to Dundee, and beyond Dundee as far as Stonehaven. There has been difficulty identifying the number of accidents that happen on specific parts of the A92; we are gathering that information at the moment.Overall, the number of accidents on the A92 appears to have gone down, but that does not mean that the road has suddenly become much safer. In terms of the overall number of accidents, the A92 is the second most dangerous road in Scotland, after the A9, but what are we talking about? Are we talking about the A92 all the way from Glenrothes to Stonehaven or about the bit around Glenrothes? I invite the representatives of Glenrothes Area Futures Group to address that question.Other sections of the road further north, particularly the section that runs past Freuchie up to Melville Lodges—another 5 miles—are viewed as being even more dangerous in terms of the number of accidents that are caused there. Are you interested simply in the bit around Glenrothes, or are you considering that extra 5 miles up to Melville Lodges?
Our submission states categorically that we are considering the whole of the A92 from the Forth bridge to the Tay bridge. One would imagine that in the 21st century, the whole of the A92 would be a dual carriageway, but it stops short of Glenrothes for some reason. Ideally, the dual carriageway should go right up to the Tay bridge and beyond, but it does not, which is why our petition concerns the Glenrothes area in particular.
link
As the petitioners can see, we try to operate on a cross-party basis with regard to this issue, but my colleagues have told only half the story. It is known that when the Conservative Government made the transport plans, there was not enough money in the budget for 1999 and tough decisions had to be made on where transport priorities lay. It is accepted that the road was not recognised as being a priority at that time—the decision was based on other priorities.I think it was Jayne Smith who spoke about the inadequacy of rail provision around Glenrothes. The A92 is your key campaign area, so it is obvious that you view it as the main transport priority for Glenrothes. Have you, however, considered other options? Why do you believe it is the main priority for improving transport and economic links in that area?
There is no direct rail link to the town of Glenrothes, although there are rail connections at Markinch and Thornton. That is why our parochial focus—if you want to call it that—is on the A92 road, because it is the direct means of transportation into Glenrothes.
I took the A92 when I went from Dunfermline to Glenrothes. I count myself as a good and experienced driver, but when I reached the part that we are talking about, where the road goes from dual to single carriageway, I was really confused. That bit of the road should be well done, well prepared and well planned for the future.
That is why our petition asks Parliament virtually to instruct the Government to do something about it. Everybody agrees on it.
At this point, perhaps it would be useful for committee members to indicate what they want to do with regard to the petition, and which recommendations we wish to take forward. It is in the hands of members. What would you like to do?
Given that the A92 is a trunk road, we have to ask Transport Scotland whether it will upgrade the road, whether it recommends that the road should be upgraded and if not, why not, and what actions it proposes to upgrade the road short of extending the dual carriageway, which would not, I hope, be the case. We might need to do some work on that.
There have been allusions to a number of developments in the past couple of months—those have nothing to do with the intensity that may or may not emerge over the next month or so, but there are issues of timescale in relation to some of the commitments. That is probably of marginal importance to the petitioners' overall demand, but it would be useful to know the timescale and the commitments. It would also be useful to clarify the relationship between Transport Scotland and the maintenance company BEAR Scotland, in terms of the initiatives that they can take. I know that members are keen to make recommendations on a couple of other things.
From the evidence that the committee has heard, I am particularly interested in Fife Council's response. Ronald Page mentioned the new retail development. I am interested in the discussions that Fife Council's planning department has held on the traffic that will go into that development and in the council's representations to Transport Scotland to try to alleviate the problems that may be caused there. It would also be useful to contact other local authorities that cover the A92 in order to find out their views on dualling the road all the way up to Stonehaven. I am particularly interested in developments—particularly retail developments—that will result in increased traffic and how that increase will impact on the area and the local plan for it.
I take John Wilson's point. Should we talk to the Tay Road Bridge Joint Board, as distinct from Dundee City Council, about the impact of dualling the A92, because it has responsibility for traffic on that bridge? I also wonder whether we should ask Transport Scotland for something explicit about the criteria that it uses, if those criteria are not known. We have heard anecdotal comments, if I may say so, about things that are and are not relevant. It would be good to have those criteria written down if they are not already written down.
In view of what Ted Brocklebank said about the length of the A92, finding out where and how many accidents occur would be interesting, although I do not know whether we would find that out from the police or Transport Scotland. It would also be interesting to find out whether more accidents are projected as a result of developments in the area and what the increases in accidents might be if nothing is done about the road.
I may be able to be of assistance in that respect. I understand that the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change is looking into that subject, but the problem is that the A92 runs, of course, through various police force areas, so trying to co-ordinate all the figures and give an overall picture is a little difficult. However, I gather that work is being done on that at the moment.
We should also seek the views of a couple of motoring organisations on motorists' experiences of the A92.Members have made several suggestions that will be of use to the petitioners, who I am sure will conceive possibilities over the next three or four weeks to heighten the debate on the commitment that they are seeking. The next three or four weeks is probably the best time to do that. I will leave that matter in their capable hands rather than necessarily in ours.I recommend that members become familiar with the route of the A92, because a number of us may say that we support improving it. If that happens, I am sure that there would be positive benefits for the election candidates. I do not hope that SNP members will have difficulties in finding its location. That is an encouraging thought.We want to progress and explore on the petitioners' behalf the issue that they have raised, which has been a concern in the area for years and has never been made the priority that the petitioners want it to be. I hope that the discussion has been useful and that we can continue it over the next period. Good luck to the petitioners with their endeavours.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Oct 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 7 October 2008 Petitions · 1
- Interests Procedure · 4
- New Petitions Petitions · 48
- New Petitions Petitions · 51
- New Petitions Petitions · 30
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 6
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 19
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
- Petitions Process Inquiry Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.