link
The petition raises an issue of fairness. There is possibly room for a review of the system in Scotland. I accept the minister's point that, if we moved immediately to the levels that exist in England, the spending increase would be around £35 million. However, there is a case for making a slight and perhaps incremental increase to a maximum of £20,000 and then having a review of the kind that Rhoda Grant suggested and considering basing the payment on years in the house or something else that better reflects the distress that is caused. I accept the minister's point on the policy choices that have been made and the budget within which he is working, but things can be done within the current budget that might address the petitioner's concerns.