For our final new petition today—I should be courteous here, because he can determine whether I am on my best behaviour in the chamber—I welcome Alex Fergusson, who has joined us in his capacity as a constituency MSP. Presiding Officer, I am not offering any quid pro quo, but I will show tremendous courtesy, as we are meeting prior to question time this Thursday.PE1180, by Tom and Josie Wallace, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that students with complex needs are supported in achieving further education placements and that appropriate funding mechanisms are provided to enable such placements to be taken up.Given that we have been joined by the Presiding Officer—as always, I am his humble servant—I ask him whether he wants to comment on the petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Further Education (Students with Complex Needs) (PE1180)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 12
- Alex Fergusson 5
- Robin Harper Green 2
- John Farquhar Munro LD 2
- Nanette Milne Con 1
- Bashir Ahmad SNP 1
- Claire Baker Lab 1
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
The record
25 contributionsConvener, it is good to know that you know which side your bread is buttered on, but let us see how this goes. I am grateful to you for allowing me to comment briefly on the petition.Mr and Mrs Wallace, who are constituents of mine, drew this problem to my attention some time ago. They are by no means the first constituents to draw the issue to my attention. I should point out that Mr and Mrs Wallace have made the long journey from Wigtownshire to be here today and I am sure that the committee will want to welcome them. They are in the public gallery with their daughter.Mr and Mrs Wallace have a son, Thomas, who is now 19 and has very complex educational needs. During his school education, he was provided with a considerable amount of support, which is what we all agree should be the case. Like all children with complex needs, he went through a process of assessment for his further needs. During that process, the steer given—if I may put it that way—was very much that, on leaving school, Thomas would benefit best from residential educational facilities and support. Indeed, it was with that expectation that his parents went forward.On leaving school, all children, but particularly children with complex needs, undergo a transition from being under the umbrella of an education department to falling under that of a social services department. It has become obvious to me and, vividly, to Mr and Mrs Wallace and the others who have contacted me about the issue, that there is a great difference in the support that is available and the assessment procedures when people leave the education department and come under the social services department. In Thomas's case, the assessment that was put in place suggested that local facilities were adequate to attend to his needs and, in effect, all thoughts of residential accommodation were put to one side.Whatever the rights and wrongs of the procedures, the result is that a set of parents who expected to receive a certain sort of support, including educational support and access to facilities, in this case residential, had their expectations dashed by the procedures in social services. They were left to fend for themselves, whereas previously they had been given every reason to think that they would be supported and helped through the process. That is a real issue. There is certainly an issue about local government departments not communicating properly with one another. That could be addressed locally, but the Government could take a lead on ensuring that cross-communication between departments takes place and that parents' expectations and hopes are not dashed in that way. Obviously, Mr and Mrs Wallace will do everything that is humanly possible for their son, but I like to think that the system could have done an awful lot more and did not have to put them through the heartache that they have been through.With those remarks, I leave the matter to the committee's deliberation. I hope that members will take the petition extremely seriously.
That clarified your experience of the process that you went through on behalf of your constituents. In the petitioners' additional submissions to us, they clearly set out the processes that they experienced that made it almost impossible, if not impossible, for their young son to continue his educational experience, which should be a right for everyone in Scotland.We want to explore a couple of issues. We need to find out about the mapping exercise. I note with interest that several elected members have been addressed on the issue, which raises the question why we have not been able to encourage local authorities to share expertise and opportunities. One local authority might find it difficult to find resources, but why cannot there be a willingness to exchange? In exceptional circumstances, the costs could be shared equitably if there was a mechanism for that. In all my years of public service, I have not seen a case quite like the one that the petitioners have raised. I am sure that that is true of most other members. It is unfortunate that a young boy has been denied access to FE when he could cope with it perfectly well if he was given the right support.Members want to explore a couple of issues.
I find the case disturbing in this day and age, when we are trying to provide equal opportunity for all. A couple of years ago, the Equal Opportunities Committee produced a lengthy and significant report on disability and access to education and other opportunities in life beyond school. I wonder whether there is anything in that that might be of help. I do not recall the detail of the report, but it might be worth looking at it.
I ask Alex Fergusson about his experience of dealing with the local authority. Was the situation basically driven by cost?
Without any doubt.
So the issue was not that no practical experience was available; it was that putting together a package would have been too costly for the authority within its budget.
I can safely say that, when the matter came within the social services rather than the education budget, cost became a considerable factor.
We will have to interrogate that issue. Cases such as this are exceptional, but any big budget within an authority could absorb the costs if they could be allocated within the structure. It can be a case of getting a nod and a wink from various folk at different budget levels within government, to say that things can be done without much difficulty. That has been people's experience.
The usual expectation of a student going to university is that they will get residential accommodation. I cannot remember the exact figure, but hundreds of thousands of students automatically get residential education, but here we have a case of one student who desperately needs a residential education but is being told that none is available. We should take this issue very seriously indeed.
More than one case exists; I have three cases similar to this one. The set of circumstances here is not unique. The facilities are there, but it is a question of resourcing the placements at those facilities, which is expensive.
The petitioners have raised extremely concerning issues. What shall we do next?
Can we not find out why such a difference exists between the provision in different local authorities? One would think that there would be a yardstick that would apply to all local authorities. A lottery should not decide who gets funding and support and who does not.
An additional complication for local authorities might be location and isolation. However, two or three authorities in reasonable proximity might come together and say, "We will share the burden, so that whenever any family in our areas requires residential support, one of us will be the host but all of us will share the cost equitably." Government could then respond to that, recognising that flexibility would be needed within social work budgets when there were exceptional circumstances. It is not beyond the wit of people to sort this out if they want to. We will have to ask people in Government, directors of education and directors of social work about the efforts being made. Reports tell us that people are supposed to be sharing knowledge and expertise more and more. This type of issue is surely a key example of where expertise has to be shared. It is quite right that a child should get support at school, but why should it be that, as soon as he or she hits 16, support is not allowed? That is not equitable.Mention has been made of the Equal Opportunities Committee's report that covered special needs. We can explore what the previous Government did, and what the new Government is doing, on the recommendations in that report.
Education, education, education—that was the motto of the previous Government, wanting to educate the nation. When a student has needs for their education, our Government should do its best to provide whatever that person needs, so that they can get the education that they want.
The clerks have told me that, not that long ago, there was a funding mechanism whereby some costs could be absorbed when local authorities and training boards were in partnership. Some felt that, from an educational point of view, that was not the best model and I understand—although I will apologise if I am wrong—that it has fallen by the wayside. A mechanism was there but is no longer there, and no alternative has been developed. We are therefore in limbo and people are not getting the support that they should be getting. We will need to unravel that.We will take on board what members have said, but someone should be able to pull together a grouping of folk to try to find a way forward.
This will not be the only area in which much would be gained if small groups of local authorities got together to provide services that would be too expensive for a single authority. Several authorities could combine to provide high-quality services of the kind required.
So they should aim for a version of the historic concordat with each other.
link
We have identified one of the big issues, which is about financing the courses. The other issue raised by the petitioner is about whether there is sufficient provision in Scottish colleges. I understand that in the petitioners' case the son will have to go to the north of England for the quality of setting that he requires. I see from our notes that there has been a mapping study of the further education available to students with profound and complex needs within Scotland's colleges. When we agree to write to the Scottish Government and other agencies, we should also ask about the level of provision in Scottish colleges and what steps will be taken to make progress on improving it.
We have pulled our ideas together and will contact the FE and college sectors about provision and liaise with the Government and other agencies including the Association of Directors of Social Work and the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, as the matter falls between those two agencies' areas of concern.
What about sending a note to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities?
Yes, there has been a mapping exercise in local government so we can ask COSLA whether it is issuing any guidelines or recommendations on taking a collegiate approach, whereby local authorities share the cost of a single resource within a reasonable geographic distance that meets the needs of that part of Scotland—as Robin Harper mentioned.Alex, do you want to suggest anything else?
No, I am grateful for the committee's deliberations and for what you propose to do. I will point out only one thing: we all know about the educational facilities that exist through the colleges and other means; it is support outwith the residential educational facility that is lacking. I am grateful to the committee for the time that it has given the matter.
Can we write to the voluntary sector groups? In my area, such groups help people get into work and provide one-to-one assistance. A voluntary sector group that has a view on the matter is probably out there. It might have an answer to our questions, but we need to find it first.
Okay, we have identified a range of individuals to approach. I thank the petitioners for their patience this afternoon. As they know, it is a journey and a half to get here. We will not hesitate to raise your issues through the petitions process and I know that your constituency member will be assiduous in pursuing them on your behalf too. Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Sep 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 9 September 2008 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 58
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 25
- Current Petitions Petitions · 46
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.