Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Knife Crime (Mandatory Sentencing) (PE1171)

Tuesday 9 September 2008 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 58 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

58 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

The first new petition, PE1171, is an important one and has been submitted to the Parliament by John Muir, who is present this afternoon. It calls on Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce mandatory sentencing for persons who are found carrying knives or other dangerous weapons in public.I welcome John Muir to the meeting. I met him before the recess, when the petition was submitted. He is accompanied by three members of his family—please make sure that no fights break out, John. If any of you wants to contribute to the question-and-answer session, you can do so. John has three minutes in which to amplify the core of the petition.

John Muir
link

For quite some time, there have been many ways of trying to get rid of knife crime from the streets. Some have worked in part, but most have failed. Over the past five years, there have been knife amnesties, education campaigns and increases in sentences that courts can impose, but the rate of knife crime has continued to rise. We think the Government should consider something tougher.Mandatory sentences in Scotland are not a new idea that we are raising today: for example, there are mandatory sentences for possession of firearms. A person who is found to have a firearm illegally and without proper certification can go to jail for five years. The other mandatory sentence that most people either do not understand or do not know about is for people who deal in drugs. After their third conviction, those people go to jail for seven years. We are saying that if there are mandatory sentences for those crimes, then surely people who carry illegal weapons on the streets should be penalised to the highest and most severe degree. We are not saying for how long they should go to jail; what we are suggesting is that the courts should consider imposing severe sentences. "Mandatory" is perhaps not the right word in this instance, but we are seeking something along the lines of mandatory sentencing.If some feckless young boy takes out his big brother's scout knife and shows it to his pals, the judiciary must have licence to decide whether that is right or wrong—they must decide in court. We are trying to extend the arm of the police in their patrolling of the streets. A person in Scotland is three and a half times more likely to be accosted by a person wielding a knife, to be threatened with a knife or to be stabbed with a knife—especially in Strathclyde—than is the case anywhere else in the United Kingdom. That is disgraceful.In my letter to the committee, which members have a copy of, I said that Scotland has"led the world in many fields".Scotland has led the world in discovery, and we have been good at engineering, medicine and shipbuilding, but Scotland has more knife murders per capita than anywhere else in Europe. Leading the world in knife murders is some record.I hope that I can answer members' questions about where we are coming from. Thank you for your attention.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you very much, Mr Muir. That was powerful. Given the circumstances that led to the petition, mandatory sentencing for knife crime is a personal issue for you, and we must address the fundamental points that you have made.Members will now ask questions. You or the other members of your family should indicate when you wish to respond to questions.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Mr Muir for his statement.I want to ask about allowing sheriffs and judges to consider the crime that has been committed before they pass sentence. Are sentences currently too lenient? Are the courts not dealing with knife crime offences seriously enough?

John Muir
link

I do not think that the increased sentences for carrying knives that were introduced by the Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2006, which the Scottish Parliament passed—the maximum sentence was increased to four years—have been implemented. Every day, we read in our local newspaper of someone who had previously been found guilty of carrying a knife being back in court three months later facing a similar or more serious charge.Perhaps greater co-ordination between the parliamentary bodies and the judiciary is required, because there is a Pontius Pilate situation at the moment. One side says, "We're doing enough" and the other side says, "They won't let us do that." The situation is difficult, but you guys will have to sort the problem out. It cannot be done by the public, or by me as an ordinary elector—you guys are here to try to sort it out. The problems that we have are obvious if we go close to the scene of the crime.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We will get more evidence on your petition and we will write to various bodies, but I can almost guarantee that one of the responses will be that the judiciary should consider each case on its own merits and that we cannot interfere with the opinions of the judiciary. It is obvious that the issue is close to your heart, but what would you say to people who said that to us?

John Muir
link

I may, unfortunately, digress in answering your question, as it relates to our circumstances.The person who murdered my son got 17 years, but he got a reduction of two years as a discount for pleading guilty. We received a letter from the courts that explained everything—why the person got 15 years, the punishment part of the sentence, and the fact that he will be a life-sentence prisoner. We understood that. The Crown Office then wrote to us to confirm that.On 8 January this year, we received a letter from the Scottish Prison Service, which clearly said that there would be no parole for the person until 2022. That was fine—the Scottish Prison Service agreed with what was in the Crown Office's letter. However, the second paragraph of the Scottish Prison Service's letter clearly stated that under rule 15, I think, of prison rules, he would be entitled to work placements and home visits. In the best scenario, he could be entitled to them four years before the end of his sentence. Who's kidding who? The judges gave the person 15 years as the punishment part of the sentence, but the Scottish Prison Service has told us that he may have to serve only 11 years.I wrote to Lord Brodie, who wrote back to me. His two-paragraph letter said that the contents of my letter had been noted. The second paragraph of the letter said that the sentence was what the court decided fitted the crime and it was up to the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Prison Service to implement it. The letter was signed off on Lord Brodie's behalf. That does not bode well, and does not give great confidence. Other people must feel as upset as we do about the untidy way things have happened. We know that the guy will be inside for the next 11 years, so we have plenty of time to work with the committee again on sentencing. Today we are here to talk about knife crime, but I wanted to digress to let you know how we feel and where we are coming from.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. That was very helpful.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Thank you for your presentation, Mr Muir. I have a son, and I have been sitting here wondering how I would feel if I were in your shoes—if somebody had killed my son. I am struggling to think how I could possibly sit here, so I want to say that I admire your courage in coming to us and presenting the case so thoughtfully.From what you have said, I know that you appreciate that many issues arise. I would like to sort out in my own mind exactly what you are asking for and how we should consider mandatory sentencing. As I think you acknowledged in your introduction, if the term means what it says, we would be telling judges that they will have to do something every time. Leaving aside the constitutional position, I think that there is a general consensus that that probably would not be terribly wise, because every case has to be considered on its merits and we always have to consider the exceptions. Can you clarify that? How would the idea behind your petition be written? I am not looking for the precise words—we can let the lawyers worry about that—but what would be appropriate? You feel that sentences are insufficient at the moment, which I understand and accept, but how would we frame a provision that would be mandatory but would allow judges to retain some discretion?

John Muir
link

Judges have to have the final say, and the police should have the final say at the early stage of arrest. The police would realise whether it was right or wrong to proceed when there could be a mandatory sentence.I have written a note saying that it is important that some young, feckless and stupid people are not sent to prison when doing so would be inappropriate. The note proposes that the courts should have an opt-out—although by "opt-out" I do not mean that the courts would deny what had happened—if strong mitigating circumstances meant that they should refrain from imposing a custodial sentence. That right has to be given to the courts at all times.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I absolutely agree—society would be in trouble if we took that right away from judges. Is what you are really asking for a general raising of the sentence, to be applied across Scotland, when there are no mitigating circumstances and when people have just gone out with weapons? I am talking about people carrying weapons in general, not just knives, when they have no useful reason for having them but are just looking for trouble. Is it a fair interpretation to say that you are asking us to use whatever methods we have to ensure that the sentence tariff is raised?

John Muir
link

Yes, that would certainly be a fair assessment—although it would not stop petitions coming, because that would be pointless at this stage or at any stage. However, the rule of law, and the rules that are laid down by Parliament, have to coincide with what has to be done to ensure improvement in sentencing and to ensure the safety of victims.The committee is looking at four victims. We felt very sorry for ourselves at the time, but we soon got over that sorrow when we realised that we might be able to prevent some other family from going through what we went through. We have put our backs to the board and have pushed hard. We intend to push hard until we think we have got something that is sensible and appropriate. We will not be hard to persuade if that happens.I am thinking about where we come from. When you walk round the premises here and look at people, you ask yourself, "Are they at the sharp end of the boat?" No, they are not. We have attended meetings organised by councils and parent bodies, including one in Easterhouse, and we have met people whose daily lives you would not believe—because of people with knives—until you heard about them directly. I came home a very chastened fellow after the second meeting I went to because I had heard what people have to put up with: by goodness, it is dreadful.

Karin Forrest
link

Nigel Don talked about mandatory sentences for people carrying knives. The biggest issue is that there should be a deterrent to carrying a knife. The person who murdered my brother had a history. He was not scared of things like a community service sentence: it did not bother him and he did not stop carrying a knife. He was supposed to do community service and he was out on parole for other offences. That did not stop him carrying a knife and—sadly—killing my brother.For my family, the law needs to be stronger. If someone who is found with a knife has a reputation and the police know that that person will cause harm, they must be put away. My brother's life would have been saved if that boy had been jailed two or three years earlier, because he would not have done what he did to my family.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

We take the point about deterrence; many of us tear our hair out about finding effective deterrents.

Karin Forrest
link

The law must be much harder—it must be extremely hard.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

You are right. We are all well aware—Henry McLeish's report made it clear to anybody who was not—that prison is not a deterrent for many people: they keep going back. The problem is difficult to crack.

Karin Forrest
link

I know, but a person who carries a knife might be given community service that they do not attend and the police might not realise that they are out on parole. Such people are not controlled. My family wants something to be done. The person who was involved was going to cause problems with a knife. For us, anybody who carries a knife will cause harm. The lesson needs to be that if people carry a knife, they will be punished hard.We attended a save our streets campaign meeting in Edinburgh. My dad is campaigning for sentences of two years, but most people in the audience, when they were asked how long a sentence should be, said that it should be five years. People are fed up.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I understand. Many of my colleagues will have suggestions, but one thing we can do is refer the petition to the Government. If we do that, the Government will say that it is to establish a sentencing council. That will be a mechanism for discussion, so the hope is that it will at least be a productive way forward.

John Muir
link

I agree with Nigel Don. We have spoken to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice—not at great length, but we had a reasonable conversation. It was good to hear that positive moves are being made in considering violent crime, which is what we are talking about.The letter that I wrote to the committee explains a little bit. I gave"Some examples of prominent political and judicial representatives making statements on the crisis of knife-crime but seeming to take a … light-handed approach to solving the issue."Too many people are talking and not enough is being done.I also said:"I am sure you are aware of who made the following statements …‘I fear for my children'"was said by Cherie Blair, and"‘I feel uneasy and unsafe in our streets at night'"was said by Jacqui Smith, the Home Secretary. What they say on television is enlightening and annoying.I continued:"These comments are from people who live in a 24-hour police protection zone far away from that faced by ordinary people in the front line of this crisis."If one of those people walked to one of the bad places in Glasgow that we have been shown, I do not think that she would just say she was frightened—she would look for protection. The people in those areas are looking for protection by the law, which must be provided and be done democratically.We have a website, on which many people have left their names and comments. It comes across loud and clear to us that they want their streets back. They are scared and they want their children to be safe and they want to be safe. Keeping the campaign going is a daunting task for us, but an even bigger task is for you guys to sort out the situation communally. That is not something that one party should do; a cross-section of politicians should work collectively. I have told the Labour Party, the Liberal party, the Conservative party and all the parties that we have talked to, "We know you can sort it out. You're the only guys that can do it. We can make the noise, but you must do the simple thing of getting it addressed."

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Good afternoon, folks, and thank you for coming here, which must be pretty difficult after your experiences. I am pleased that you have said that although the judges or the courts are, on serious crime, the ultimate arbitrators on the sentences that are dished out, we must be assured that sentences are undertaken. The largest percentage of knife crime on our streets involves youngsters or teenagers—I read about that daily in the newspapers. Most of the time, knife crime is not perpetrated by hardened criminals, but by toughs on the street who aspire to be hard men. That is my concern. Most youngsters who are picked up for carrying weapons get community service or go in front of the children's panel but are back on the streets in a couple of weeks, as you are well aware. The judiciary or the police should take a stiff line with any individual who is caught carrying a knife or other bladed weapon, because if we could arrest the situation at the early stage, that might have an effect on the next generation—the 20-year-olds. What is your view on that?

John Muir
link

It is difficult to make a comparison on that. We have spoken with the violence reduction unit, which has a solution that should be eagerly sought by Parliament. The unit says that in order to get rid of knife crime over a period, we need to start with children at an early age in the school system and explain to them the damage that knife crime does. The daunting thing that the unit has to deal with is that, if it does not do that brainwashing or have those conversations with children, by the age of 12 they already carry knives. That is where the problem comes from. They then go out on the streets to make their mark. They want to become one of the tough guys.As I said in my letter to the committee, we have spoken to community councils and councils, some of which back our campaign 100 per cent. That is fine. We must be careful of the mantra about not criminalising the young. The majority of crimes are committed by the younger generation from the age of 15 to 21. That is a terrible indictment. If you go to the sharp end of the ship and meet the guy who has been caught and who is doing time or will do time for having a knife or stabbing someone, he is a junkie. When the police go to his home to speak to the parents, they are junkies. The police might think that the grandfather will take the boy under his wing, but they find that he is a junkie, too. So there is not one, but three generations to convert. That is how difficult it is.Karyn McCluskey rightly said that if someone is carrying a knife, they are a user. That must be applied whether or not the knife has blood on it. It is good if someone is caught with no blood on their knife, but when they are caught with blood on it, that is really serious.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

We need to curb that element among 12 to 15-year-olds and instil in them that there will be a prison sentence for someone who is caught carrying a weapon—not community service, but a custodial sentence. There should be no doubt that, if someone carries a blade, they will be put in prison.

John Muir
link

That is a fair comment from you as an individual but, collectively, we must start to get people to think the same way round in a circle to meet up with me. Doesn't that sound good—"meet up with me"? I do not mean it in that sense at all. We need a medium that will allow everyone to find a solution so that we can put the issue to bed.The final paragraph in my letter to the committee says:"We fervently appeal to our First Minister, his government colleagues and all elected MSPs to impose a bill giving a total ban and zero tolerance to the carrying of dangerous and offensive weapons. Knife crime results in more deaths per annum than deaths from firearms. A law was rushed through parliament that banned the carrying of firearms without licence. Why can it not be the same for knives?"It is as simple as that to the person on the street. They say it to me regularly at seminars and meetings. We have been going round Scotland listening to people. Honestly, some of the stuff that comes from them.Elected members—please go and speak to your electorate. They will tell you how difficult and bad it is, if they have not already spoken to you.

Bashir Ahmad SNP Glasgow
link

What would you say to the criminals who murdered your son, and to other people who are trying to do the same to others? What would you like us to do about them?

John Muir
link

This is where the water can go over our heads. If we ask for too much, we will not get it, and if we ask for too little, it will not start.I have made it quite clear that the courts' sentencing powers should agree with what the Parliament recommends as being a proper sentence. At the end of the day, we are lay people: we do not have the experience to know all the imponderables. We have heard so many different questions about how knife crime can be identified, and about the mandatory sentence.We were at a meeting a week past Wednesday and a special constable with 20 years' experience flung a question into the middle of the discussion like a hand grenade. He said that he has been called to domestic violence incidents in which the wife of the house had taken a kitchen knife and stabbed her partner. He asked whether a mandatory sentence should cover that situation. He also said that he had been at a fight in a pub where two guys were giving another guy a kicking. The guy stood up for himself, and when the police arrived, they arrested the three of them. When the first two had been taken into custody, the police started to take the other guy's details and they found a knife in his pocket, although no knife was used during the affray. Should that guy get a two-year sentence? It is very difficult. We are not in a position to understand all that.

Bashir Ahmad SNP Glasgow
link

That is very true. It is a very difficult situation. If three generations of junkies are living in a house, and one is sentenced, that is no punishment. We are giving them a comfortable life in jail.

Christopher Muir
link

Exactly. A prison should be a prison. Take away their PlayStations. If they are sent to prison for two years, they should be in there for two years. If they are sent there for 15 years, they should be in there for 15 years. It is prison, and this is the outside world. This is a great place to live: if they are on the other side of the wall—well, there you go. The old-age pensioner cannot afford heating, but the guy in the cell can ask for his cell heating to be put up to 68°. No—give them a blanket or tell them to coorie in to their cellmate. Make a prison a prison.

Christopher Muir
link

Yes, and then maybe people will realise and think, "No way am I going in there, and there's no way I'm going to carry a knife, or a broken bottle or a gun." We need to put an end to it.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am conscious of time, but we should explore two or three things for the benefit of the petition.Obviously it was unfortunate that you could not have Paul McBride with you today. I would be interested to hear about the kind of discussions that you have been having with him. You have touched on fundamentals today, such as how to interpret a set of circumstances. If you pay the money for a relatively good Queen's Counsel, they can interpret very differently the series of events that you saw with your own eyes. In talking with an experienced QC like Mr McBride about the nuances of sentencing, what kind of things has he shared with you that might be useful for us to think about as part of the next stage of the petition?At the moment, the problem with the debate is that people in extreme circumstances such as you are in feel powerless. Ordinary members of the public feel that we are not listening to their concerns about some of the most challenging neighbourhoods in Scotland. I represent a neighbourhood that is, statistically, probably the most challenging place in Scotland as far as knife crime goes, so I know about the damage that it does to communities and families. How do we get on the right side of that argument and demonstrate the message that will change generational attitudes of having no respect for the law or the difference between right and wrong? How do we get across to the 15, 17 or 19-year-old, who might or might not have the excuse of being involved in alcohol or drugs, that there is a consequence to their actions when they close the door behind them as they go out on a Saturday night?We can get tied up in the nuances of what lawyers tell us. You want to get beyond that to find out what is the right thing to put in place so that you, as a member of the public, feel that the right thing has been done through the justice system. Privately, you probably feel very frustrated, judging from some of the things that you have said.I am sorry that I took so long, but I wanted to get to the nub of what the committee needs to address.

John Muir
link

Our main consideration is something that is important to communities in all Scotland. We were at a meeting in Edinburgh, where knife crime is minimal in comparison with elsewhere. However, everyone has a problem on the streets at present. Our website shows clearly that there are problems on the streets in various locations throughout Scotland. We read stories and think, "Thank God we're not there." We hope that as a result of today's meeting, our petition will get referred to the Justice Committee. When we get to the Justice Committee, we might have been able to do more homework to find out how to proceed.The violence reduction unit, with John Carnochan and his team, seems to have everything going in the right direction. The team is superb to talk to and what it is trying to do is superb. We need to talk to them, just as we need to talk to solicitors and Queen's counsels and so on. We have the backing of a number of QCs. We also have the backing of the two national papers, as well as our local paper, so people are reading about us. People will see me again tonight on the television, without a song and dance. People will see us in the street and ask how it went and we will tell them that we went to Parliament and what the outcome will be. We trust that our visit here today will assist us to get to the next stage in Parliament, whatever that may be.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

The petition calls on the Parliament to urge the Government"to introduce mandatory sentencing for persons found carrying knives".I am getting the sense from the conversation so far that you would like those sentences to be custodial for the most part. Is that correct?

John Muir
link

Absolutely.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

But that is not what the petition says, so you are leaving it open for a conversation about whether the mandatory sentence would be custodial. The figures show that, at the moment, 30 per cent of those who are convicted get custodial sentences, 31 per cent get community sentences and 29 per cent get monetary sentences.I draw to the committee's attention my entry in the register of members' interests: I am a member of the Howard League for Penal Reform.Quite a lot of the people who are convicted will have been in prison before; they might have been released, but reoffended and returned to prison. A mandatory sentence could be 15 to 20 years. If nothing is done for the person who committed the crime during their time in prison, they will be just as likely to commit a knife crime when they come out as they were when they went in—although society will have been protected for 15 to 20 years.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I understand what Robin Harper is saying, but I do not think that the two debates are incompatible. We have to separate what we do to rehabilitate those who are sentenced, which is a massive, critical issue, from whether someone who carries a weapon, or takes it to someone else, should get a custodial sentence.What I think John Muir is saying—what I understand from the language of the petition—is that we need to think more critically about sending a message back to members of the public who, like him, have been dramatically affected by knife crime. Anyone in the public gallery or any member around the table today could face the same thing when their young son or daughter is out on a Friday or Saturday night in any part of Scotland—although there are more obvious hotspots, by the look of things.I am trying to separate the issues, as I do not think that they are part of the same debate. The current debate is about how we deal with the petition and what we do about knife crime.

John Muir
link

A senior official in the legal profession has said that some young people put a knife in their pocket as quickly as they put a mobile phone in it. That is quite damning if it is what is happening on the streets—a knife and a mobile phone together. It is terrible. If they have one, they generally have the other.I thank you for your attention today. Everyone here has been very kind to me. You have been very soft on me as well, convener. I was expecting to get a bit more of a bashing, but it did not come. Maybe it will be worse next time—I hope that there will be a next time.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

It is fortunate for you that I am a very gentle Glaswegian convener.You have raised some fundamental issues that we should address on your behalf. Many things still need to be done over the period to address your concerns. We have now reached the bit where we pull together committee members' thoughts about what we would like to explore.You have already received parliamentary support—I should have mentioned at the outset that your local MSP, Duncan McNeil, has been supportive of the petition. He has also written to us. I said that I would read out a couple of sentences that amplify what you have said. He writes: "custodial sentences would be a powerful deterrent to those knife carriers that their actions have consequences before they rob someone of their life."He adds that he"would support the will of the people for tough action against those who carry and use knives."I know that that dialogue has been had with Duncan McNeil in the past, when you presented the petition. Unfortunately, he is attending another committee this afternoon.We need to pull together the concerns that have been raised into a programme of exploration and action on the petition. I am open to committee members' suggestions as to how we should proceed.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I have not asked Mr Muir any questions, but I have been most impressed with what he has said. I agree with much of what has been said, as do my party colleagues, and I certainly think that we should take the petition forward.In the first instance, we should get in touch with the Scottish violence reduction unit and the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland. We might also contact Victim Support Scotland, which I presume has dealt with clients who have shared Mr Muir's experiences. I suggest that we start by contacting those three bodies.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

We should certainly push the petition to the Scottish Government. However, it calls on the Parliament to urge the Government to introduce "mandatory sentencing". We have established that that phrase does not mean quite what some people think it means in the context of the petition. The petitioner acknowledges the fact that there needs to be judicial discretion, although some people might feel that that is not what the petition is asking for. I therefore wonder whether, when the petition is sent off, we can include a covering note that conveys an understanding of what is really being asked for. Otherwise, we could get involved in unnecessary constitutional and theoretical discussions.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

It is clear from what the petitioner says that he believes that tougher sentences should be made available to the judiciary and sheriffs and that often, even when they impose tough sentences, the parole service gets involved and folk are allowed out earlier. I am therefore keen that we ask the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service for its comments on sentencing and the confidence of those who impose a sentence in how it will be delivered. As the petitioner said, the people who have the information in front of them and make a decision about the sentence that is passed down are not always in control of the actual sentence that is served. That is a critical point.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Nigel Don suggested presenting the petition to the Government. I suggest that we pass it to the Justice Committee or the wider Parliament.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I do not think that there is any purpose in sending it to the Justice Committee. Sentencing is not an area in which we have any locus. It would be interesting to know that committee's views, but it cannot do anything that the Public Petitions Committee cannot do.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

In that case, I suggest that we also communicate with the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland, because it is bound to have tremendous influence.

John Muir
link

We have been assured that if the matter goes to the wire, ACPOS will certainly put its hat in the ring.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I offer a big suggestion after having a chat with the clerk earlier. Given that the Sentencing Commission for Scotland's report is being considered by the Government and the Justice Committee's present commitments, is it beyond this committee's ken to pull together some of the folk who have been mentioned, to explore the issues? We did something similar on cancer drugs, which was in the public interest, and it worked well. It strikes me that it is clearly in the public interest to explore the issues in the petition because people have different ideas about what would be useful and effective.I am struck that there has not been an opportunity to get stuck into the matter and allow ordinary citizens to contribute to the debate and, I hope, walk through the process. I believe that if people are confronted with some practical issues they will arrive at sensible, intelligent solutions if information is shared with them, even if they start out being pretty angry. Is it beyond our ken to think about pulling together people who might help to influence that broader debate? Somewhere down the line the matter will have to go into the chamber or through the ministerial process to get a Government response, but the debate should be informed rather than partial. I throw that out for members to consider, as we did good work on the cancer drugs inquiry, which shifted the debate in the right direction. Perhaps the same could happen with Mr Muir's petition. I realise that my suggestion is a bit of a sidewinder.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Your suggestion might be really helpful because knife crime is a concern to lots of communities. Mr Muir talked about some of the folk who live at the sharp end and who live with knife crime on a daily basis. As well as speaking to the decision makers, it would be good to speak to—

John Muir
link

We do not live at the sharp end; we just happen to be part of—

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

But you did. You did not expect to be there, but the reality is that you were.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Mr Muir, you spoke in your evidence about the people who live at the sharp end daily, with the consequences and the fear. It would be good to speak to people from those communities to give us, who are lucky enough not to live in that situation, a better appreciation of what it is like.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do we want, in principle, to explore those suggestions? The clerk would have to come back to the committee with a fleshed-out model for our approach. It would be helpful to us to understand the nuances of the debate, because I am sure that if you were to put three Queen's Counsel in the room they would give us three different answers—at a price.

John Muir
link

If legal bodies sat with you and gave you advice about what can and cannot be done, a solution would be found much more quickly than would happen if the matter were referred to someone else.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I agree that we should move heaven and earth to put a stop to the rise in knife crime and, I hope, to reduce it considerably. The convener's idea of consulting further and our producing a report is excellent. I suggest that we add the Association of Directors of Social Work to the list of people we write to. My reservation is about how much mandatory sentencing can contribute to the debate.

John Muir
link

By the time we have finished, we will have you believing in it, like us.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Could we also write to children's panels? We have heard evidence that the carrying of knives can start very young. It is often young people who are involved; the adult services do not always become involved initially.

Bashir Ahmad SNP Glasgow
link

We read about the knife problem among youngsters almost every day. Most of the young people concerned are taking drink, which is so cheap and so easy to get. To me, drink is the main cause of the problem. Drink should be available to buy only after the age of 21. By providing for that, the Government is taking a very good step forward to deal with the knife problem among youngsters.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am sure that we will have a petition on that anyway, from people aged 18 and over. The evidence base for alcohol fuelling much of people's negative behaviour is available. It is a cultural and social thing that we in Scotland must deal with. How we deal with it is a debate that we parliamentarians will have over the forthcoming period, but there is a shared belief that the excessive alcohol culture does lead to some other excesses.There are also statistics that indicate that some folk, who are perfectly sober but have a very violent attitude, also go out weaponed. In my area, which is in the east end of Glasgow, people are not drunk when they make up the weapons that will cause the damage. They might be fuelled up three hours later, but they will have made up the weapons in their living room. That is the tragedy of a mindset according to which it is okay to graft three different implements together to create something that will cause maximum damage to another human being. Those people do not take it out just as a show weapon; it has a purpose, should it be required. The drink might fuel the event but the mindset is already there, and we need to try to deal with that.The benefit will come from the sort of work that John Carnochan is doing. He is looking at the links between family, social background and alcohol and drugs, and the combination of those elements that results in some of the tragedies that have happened to too many families. This is possibly the longest that we have spent on one petition, which indicates the seriousness of what you have raised with us this afternoon, Mr Muir. We have come up with some reasonable suggestions for where to go next. I will not kid you on, however—you are on a journey to get a sense of closure, not just personally but in the form of fairness and justice in Scotland. I am sure that you and your campaign will be doing other things to highlight the matter. I hope that today has been useful for that process. We will return with a report about what we want to do next. As the petitioner, you will be kept fully informed. Whenever the matter comes back in front of our committee, or when there are any further developments, you will be fully involved in a dialogue with us. We will spend time working through the issue, and I hope that that is of use and benefit to you and your family.

John Muir
link

I thank the committee for taking the time to listen to us. I say on behalf of the girls with me and my son that we look forward to hearing from you and meeting you all—or some of you—again.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you very much for your time, which we appreciate.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 9 September 2008 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 58
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 39
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 39
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. New Petitions Petitions · 25
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 46
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  26. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.