Our next petition is PE1030, by Owain Robertson. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to support an investigation into Chinese human rights abuses, such as those that are allegedly committed against Tibetan refugees, and to support a boycott of the 2008 Olympics in Beijing. Before being formally lodged, the petition was hosted on the e-petition system where, between 3 November 2006 and 22 January 2007, it gathered 80 signatures. On the face of it, petition PE1030 appears to advocate a boycott of the 2008 Beijing Olympics because of alleged human rights abuses against Tibetan refugees. In the supporting text, the petitioner raises two principal issues surrounding alleged human rights abuse in China: the treatment of Tibetan refugees and forced evictions to make space for the Olympic village.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Human Rights Abuses (China) (PE1030)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 6
- Sandra White SNP 5
- Helen Eadie Lab 3
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
15 contributionsObviously, the petition is on a matter that is reserved to Westminster. Given that the petitioner feels strongly on the subject, it would be appropriate to refer him to his Westminster MP. The matter should go before Westminster. I suggest that we close petition PE1030.
I have read the petition and have also been active in asking questions on the issues involved. China's human rights abuses are absolutely appalling. Even the Scottish Parliament has commented on the matter, as have Westminster and the European Union. I am aware of the reserved nature of the issues that the petition raises, but the Scottish Parliament should be concerned that the Executive has a strategy of stronger engagement with China. Jack McConnell is actively involved in the strategy: he has visited China and has encouraged people from China to come to Scotland—he is active in developing the partnership. When he was in China, Jack McConnell raised the issue of human rights, for which I commend him. It would be a wasted opportunity for the Parliament and Executive if we were to close the petition. After all, given the Executive's strategy, Jack McConnell—or whoever will be First Minister after the election—can continue to raise human rights issues in China, which could go some way towards stopping the abuses that are taking place. People are being murdered. That is an absolute disgrace—
If you do not want us to close the petition, what do you want us to do with it?
I would like to send it to the Executive and to the First Minister, asking for his comments on it. He has visited China under the strategy. I would even advise the petitioner to take the petition to Europe, from where a stronger case could be made. However, as we are involved, I would like to have Jack McConnell's comments on the matter.
link
I do not want to take issue with members over this, but I am conscious that we are not talking about sending the petition to the one place that has responsibility for the issue—Westminster. Although I am always engaged with the power of the Public Petitions Committee, my view is that simply keeping the petition open will not effect the kind of change that we all want. I have no problem with our sending the petition to the Executive and the First Minister for their information, but I think that we should also send it to the appropriate committee at Westminster. We should close the petition, recognising that dealing with the issue is wider than simply keeping a petition open.
I agree.
I support that. We can write to the First Minister, letting him know about the petition and all the information that it contains, and he can use that in any further discussions that he has. If we send the petition to Westminster, the MPs there can also use the information that it contains. I do not know what would be the purpose of our keeping the petition open. If information came back to us, what would we do with it?
Basically, the reason that I put forward for keeping the petition open is that I want to find out exactly what the Executive and the First Minister are doing through the strategy. That is where the petition links to the Scottish Parliament. I do not want to cause any disruption in the committee, but I sincerely care about what is happening in China—as Jackie Baillie says, we all do. I am trying to think of the best way in which to get information, not for us but for the petitioner. Would the petitioner get an answer back from the First Minister if we wrote to him and closed the petition? I am looking for a way to get information—that is what worries me.
It is important for the petitioner to get answers, but I feel strongly that the petition raises questions to which the Westminster Parliament is there to provide us with answers. No one is denying that the issue is important; we are simply saying that, if people want something changed, they should go where the change can be proposed most effectively. I therefore strongly support the view that has been expressed by the convener and Jackie Baillie that we should send the petition to Westminster. Committees at Westminster have a lot of power. We should ask specifically for the Westminster Parliament to engage directly with the petitioner on the matter.
I understand what members are saying. If the First Minister is engaged on the issue, the petitioner should get some information. However, I do not want to use the committee to raise people's hopes about things that the committee cannot address. There is absolutely nothing that the committee can do about the petition. We cannot get involved in organising a boycott of the 2008 Olympics. We must focus on what the petition asks us to do. It states clearly what it expects us to do, and we cannot do that. Therefore, it would be wrong to raise the petitioner's hopes that the committee can do what the petition asks for.There is a wider issue concerning human rights abuses and the treatment of refugees and others in China. We cannot address that here, either. We can pass the petition to people who might be able to do something about it, for their information, but, beyond that, there is nothing that the committee can do with the petition. Therefore, keeping it open would serve no purpose. If information came back to us, we would still not be able to do anything with it except pass it on to the petitioner. If we send the petition to the First Minister and to the relevant committee at Westminster, we can ask them to write back to the petitioner, which would be constructive. However, the Public Petitions Committee cannot do anything with the petition.
I take on board what you say. The point that I am making is that the Scottish Parliament, the First Minister and MSPs are involved in creating a sustainable, stronger engagement with China. If you are saying that we should send the petition to the First Minister and the relevant committee at Westminster, asking that they send the petitioner information based on the questions that are asked in the petition, I will go along with that rather than cause a disruption in the committee. Are you saying that we will ask the First Minister to answer the questions that the petitioner has asked?
That is exactly what I am suggesting that we do. I appreciate that you are trying to enable the committee to reach a consensus—that is what I want, too.The committee always considers what a petitioner is asking for. In this case, the petitioner wants us to get involved in a boycott of the 2008 Olympics, which is an issue over which the Parliament has no authority and in which we cannot get involved. It would be wrong to raise the petitioner's hopes by suggesting that we can do something about the petition, when those of us who are sitting here know that we cannot. It would be more honest of us to explain to the petitioner that we cannot do what he asks, but that we have written to the First Minister and to the Westminster committee that considers such issues, to ask them to tell the petitioner what they are doing about the matter. Is that okay?
Okay.
Do members agree to take that course of action?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 31 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 31 January 2007 Petitions · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 32
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 15
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.