Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Assisted Suicide (Opposition to Legislation) (PE1031)

Wednesday 31 January 2007 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 24 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

24 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Our next new petition is PE1031 by Professor Donald M MacDonald. It calls on members of the Scottish Parliament to oppose the introduction of any legislation that would permit assisted suicide. Professor MacDonald will make a brief statement to the committee in support of his petition. He is supported this morning by Canon Donald MacKay and the Rev Alex J MacDonald. I welcome you all to the committee. You have a few minutes to speak and then we will discuss the issue that you have brought before us.

Professor Donald MacDonald
link

Good morning and thank you, convener, for the opportunity to address your committee. Just a year ago, there was an unsuccessful attempt to introduce a member's bill to legalise assisted suicide. Many of us are concerned that such a bill might well be introduced in the new session. The petition is to request MSPs to oppose the introduction of a member's bill that would legalise assisted suicide for people who suffer from incurable or terminal illnesses. I will highlight just a few reasons why we oppose such a bill. The principle of the sanctity of, or utmost respect for, human life has been basic to our civilisation. It is upheld not only by the Christian religion but by all the major world religions. It is also supported by the ancient Hippocratic tradition, which lies behind modern medicine, that the doctor's duty is always to care and not to kill. We are convinced that that principle demands that we do not deliberately end anyone's life, even at a time of suffering. Rather, we should do all that we can to relieve that suffering and to give support to the very end. That is why we emphasise in our petition the importance of the wide availability of good palliative care. As members know, Britain—Scotland, in particular—has been a world leader in provision of palliative care. It has been shown that, where good palliative care is available, the number of requests for euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide is greatly diminished. However, when euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are legalised, as in the Netherlands and the state of Oregon in the USA, palliative care suffers and is not well developed.As well as the principle of the sanctity of human life, there are various pragmatic reasons for opposing physician-assisted suicide. If it were legalised, it would alter fundamentally the doctor-patient relationship. The doctor would no longer be seen as the person who will support and care for someone at all costs, but as one who might well end life. That should be resisted.There are also practical dangers. Someone might be wrongly diagnosed as being terminally ill. Depression is common among patients who receive such diagnoses and they might well request assistance in ending their own lives. If the depression were treated, they would not request such help. There is also the danger, if physician-assisted suicide were introduced, that there would be pressure on people who were terminally ill, or that those people would request—perhaps for financial reasons—that their lives be ended because they felt that they were a burden on others. If physician-assisted suicide were legalised, it would have the overall result of diminishing our respect for human life at its weakest and most defenceless.I want to end on a personal note. I have an illness—multiple sclerosis—that is slowly deteriorating, and I may well have a slow and lingering death. I do not want that process to be shortened in any way, but I want all necessary facilities, care and support to be available to me. I fear that if euthanasia or assisted suicide are legalised, people will prefer to take the easy way out and will lose the desire to provide support and help, which is often burdensome and wearing, both to those who care and to the person who is dying. To ensure that people die with dignity, it is better to give them all the support that is needed, through palliative care, than to end their lives summarily by giving them a lethal substance. I call on MSPs to resist such legislation.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Thank you, Professor MacDonald. I invite members to put questions to the petitioners.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

Good morning. I notice from the papers that are before us that the British Medical Association appears to have changed its stance on assisted suicide. Last year it was neutral, but now it is opposed to it. Does the same apply to any of the other professional organisations? Would you like to expand on that matter?

Professor MacDonald
link

Even before the BMA changed its position, the professional associations for palliative care, general practitioners and geriatricians were opposed to physician-assisted suicide; they have never had to alter their stance on the matter. Only the BMA temporarily had a neutral stance, although it did not support physician-assisted suicide. However, at its annual general meeting last year, it opposed physician-assisted suicide—much less than 40 per cent of doctors support physician-assisted suicide.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

You have a disease that is slowly degenerative, for which you have my sympathy, and you want to live regardless of the disease—that is your choice. You have such a disease and you choose to continue to live, but is it right to remove the choice of someone else who has the same debilitating disease, who is of sound mind and who wishes to end their life and not live with the disease for 20 or 30 years? Should that person have the choice?

Professor MacDonald
link

The problem with the idea that people should be able to decide when to end their lives is that it is based on patient or personal autonomy. As a Christian, I resist that, because I believe that our lives are in God's hands. However, even those who do not believe in God have a duty not only to themselves, but to society in general—to other people. Nobody lives to himself or herself alone. Another person's life is important to me, as my life should be important to them. My deciding to end my life would not mean that another person had a duty to aid me in that.It is wrong to put a burden on doctors and the medical profession to have a duty to end someone's life; the doctor's duty is always to care for and support someone until their life naturally ends. I do not accept the patient autonomy argument that people should have the right to decide to end their lives with help. There is no doubt that if a person decides to commit suicide, they are at liberty to do so. That is not and has never been a crime a crime in Scotland, although it is of course to be deprecated and we do not encourage it. We should certainly not encourage people to help others to commit suicide.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

You will know that Jeremy Purvis's bill was dropped because not enough MSPs supported it. Did you lodge the petition to ensure that no similar bill is introduced in the next parliamentary session? No similar legislation is proposed at present.

Professor MacDonald
link

That is correct. We believe that Jeremy Purvis or somebody else may well try to reintroduce such a bill. At the Westminster Parliament, further attempts may be made to legislate for the whole United Kingdom. We want to pre-empt that by persuading people now.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I will pursue that point. Scots law is clear: euthanasia is unacceptable and is considered contrary to law. The bill proposal that our Liberal colleague Jeremy Purvis introduced fell because of insufficient support from MSPs. Does anything suggest that that level of support will change so that a proposal from a similar quarter would be supported?

Professor MacDonald
link

I know of no evidence and I have heard of no movement among MSPs that would change the position. However, we want to make our views known.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Absolutely—but perhaps you should take some comfort from that position.You suggested in your introduction that the prospect of Jeremy Purvis's bill returning is live. Is that the case or is that just a fear for the future?

Professor MacDonald
link

I have not contacted that MSP, but I believe from press reports that he intends to reintroduce such a bill, although I know of no definite plans for that to be done.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Notwithstanding any individual's persistence, given the current crop of MSPs, it is unlikely that such a bill would attract more support.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

The committee is joined by Alasdair Morrison MSP, who has an interest in the petition. Do you want to comment before we deliberate the petition?

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

I thank the convener and his clerking team for their assistance. I distributed the petition throughout my constituency in a few weeks, during which some 2,500 people supported it. All members have a copy of the petition, which simply says that"we have a moral obligation to preserve our own life and the lives of others"and"we believe that the concept of physician assisted suicide has no place in our society".That view has enjoyed support throughout my constituency. It is not my duty or responsibility to articulate the views of other residents in Scotland, but given the number of signatures that it attracted in a number of weeks—a relatively short time—the petition certainly enjoys the support of a fair percentage of my constituents. I am grateful to the reverend gentlemen who have come along to contribute today.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I should probably declare an interest in that I am the convener of the Parliament's cross-party group on palliative care, so I obviously have an interest in the subject. Just for the record, I have been involved in the group for almost eight years since the inception of the Parliament, during which I have been amazed at the progress that has been made in palliation and the hospice movement. Only recently, for example, agreement was reached on developing another hospice in Lanarkshire, although there is still much more work to be done. We have seen new hospices for children, and hospices have been developed in the Highlands and elsewhere as palliation and the hospice movement grows, but much more positive work can be done.It would be useful to know from the Executive its views on the general issue and what more progress in palliation it envisages and is willing to support. I have had some discussions with Jeremy Purvis because of my position on the cross-party group. He has attended the group on occasions to talk about his proposal; he intends, if he gets the opportunity to do so, to continue to press his argument. Even if that is not done through a bill, he certainly wants to keep the issue live.Given the petition, it would be useful to seek the Executive's views and to write to the Scottish Partnership for Palliative Care, which is the umbrella organisation for all the charities and organisations that are involved in palliation and the hospice movement, to seek its views on what progress is being made and can be made in the near future. That might address some of the issues that have been raised by the petitioners this morning.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I would support that action. Today's discussion has been valuable—I was not aware that Britain has been a world leader in developing palliative care. That is new information to me and I am pleased to hear it and that Scotland is playing an important part.It was especially interesting to note in the petitioners' papers that the Netherlands, where euthanasia is allowed, does not have a well-developed system of palliative care. That is informative. I am pleased that the petitioners have brought their petition to Parliament because it helps the debate, which I know is controversial. I did not support Jeremy Purvis' member's bill.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

Given the gentlemen's responsibilities in various parishes across the country, would it be appropriate to ask them about their professional experience and how they interact with parishioners?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

If either of two reverend gentlemen wants to make short contribution, they can.

Canon Donald MacKay
link

I am very happy to be associated with the petition and the convener's comments about palliative care being highly developed. That is great news, as is the news that the Scottish Parliament does not seem to be heading swiftly down the road of supporting assisted suicide. I do not think that palliative care and its development would rest easily with a country that also supported assisted suicide.Suicide is always seen as a tragedy, and to try to give the term a positive spin does not work. I also do not think that it is fair to make universal laws out of individual cases that can be emotionally suggestive. We have to understand the whole issue of life and death, which is inevitable for us all. The individual and the country or the state must have a principled and intellectual relationship with that and must accommodate it in how we live.Another matter is that people should be able to live with dignity. I have seen many more people living without dignity than dying without dignity. Everybody whom I have seen in 30 years of attending people at their death beds has died with dignity, but I have seen many people who have not been given much of an opportunity to live with dignity.

The Rev Alex MacDonald
link

I will give one example. A man suffered a stroke. To begin with, it was clear that he was so frustrated and depressed that he was not eating. A person in such a situation could feel suicidal. However, after a little while, with care in the hospital and with the support of friends and so on, he is making a recovery and is much more positive, although he has limited communication. People may undergo a stage of feeling that they want physician-assisted suicide, but with the right care, that can pass.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Okay. Will we write to seek the responses of the Executive and the SPPC to the issue that the petitioners have raised?Members indicated agreement.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I thank the petitioners for presenting their petition.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 31 January 2007 Petitions · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 32
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 24
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 39
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 19
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 15
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  10. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.