Item 2 is new petitions. Our first new petition is PE1020, from Councillor Paul Melling, on behalf of his constituents in Portlethen South—ward 60 in Aberdeenshire—which calls on the Scottish Parliament to consider and debate the safety issues in relation to the requirement to construct a deceleration lane for access to the Bruntland Road junction in Portlethen South from the A90. Councillor Melling will make a brief statement to the committee in support of his petition.I welcome Councillor Melling. You will have a few minutes to make a statement, after which we will discuss the petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
A90 Deceleration Lane (PE1020)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Councillor Melling 11
- Michael McMahon Lab 8
- John Scott Con 4
- Helen Eadie Lab 3
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Councillor Paul Melling Aberdeenshire Council 1
- Mike Rumbles LD 1
- David Davidson Con 1
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
32 contributionsGood morning, convener, and thank you for allowing me to speak in support of petition PE1020, which was handed to you on 8 November 2006. The petition requests the Scottish Parliament to consider and debate the safety issues in relation to the requirement to construct a deceleration lane for access to the entrance to Portlethen South at the Bruntland Road junction off the A90 dual carriageway.I have a copy of the petition that I handed you on 8 November. I will go through the concerns that the petition raises and the reasons why I am here. I also have enlargements of the photographs that accompany the petition if anybody wishes to have a copy.
The clerks can arrange that and we will circulate the information to members as the debate continues.
Thank you. Various letters have been sent to the various bodies to ask for a review of the junction, but to no avail. We also have letters in support of the petition from Aberdeenshire Council's Kincardine and Mearns area committee and so on. It may be seen from the photographs that the junction is very bad. It is a staggered junction across the A90 dual carriageway with bus stops on either side. Access is provided to a cottage on the northbound side of the carriageway, where a slip road to local farms was also recently constructed. When that happened, I expected a slip road to be constructed on the southbound carriageway into Bruntland Road, but that did not happen.I have lobbied the Scottish Executive for a review of the junction for more than three years. I have the support of the local roads department and I presented a motion at the Kincardine and Mearns area committee on 10 October asking for its support in lobbying the Scottish Executive to provide a deceleration lane for vehicles that are leaving the A90 on the south side to enter Portlethen South at Bruntland Road. A copy of the letter is with the petition.I have sent a detailed report and various letters and I have had a consultation with the manager of BEAR Scotland, which is the trunk road authority. More than three years ago, I was assured that the junction would be given the highest priority. I have constituents who are afraid to turn in at the entrance because of the intimidation from the large 40 to 50-tonne trucks that bear down behind them. In that situation, my constituents feel safe only if they proceed to the flyover at Newtonhill, which is approximately a mile from the junction that they are trying to access. They return to cross the A90 at Bruntland Road, which is a precarious manoeuvre when the A90 is full of traffic.We are forever being told to put safety first. Will the Scottish Executive help me to make the junction safe by providing a deceleration lane before we have more serious injuries or another fatality? One car has already gone into the ditch at that spot and other minor accidents have occurred. Another accident occurred on Tuesday 19 September 2006; it involved a motorcyclist and a car. How many more accidents must occur before we have action?The most recent letter that I received from the Minister for Transport, which is dated 15 June 2006—it is enclosed with the petition—says that the Executive is aware of the need for a deceleration lane but considers it a low priority. With more than 250 signatures on the petition and support from my constituents, I hope that we can make it a high priority, especially as another entrance to Portlethen has closed.As I have said, in the past three years, I have asked for the junction to be improved before anyone is killed. I am sad to say that, since I handed the petition to the convener, the motorcyclist who was mentioned in the supporting information has died while being treated in hospital for his injuries. I appeal to the convener and the committee to take the petition forward before any other road user is injured or killed as a result of this very bad junction.
Thank you, Councillor Melling. Has your local authority calculated the cost that would be incurred by providing a deceleration lane? How far would it run, and what would be the cost of building a lane of that length?
To my knowledge, the authority has not costed the proposal. However, the roads engineer to Aberdeenshire Council has presented a variety of scenarios for the junction. Unfortunately, the briefing is not included in the petition, because I received it only after the petition had been submitted, but it shows the options that are available. I would like options D and E to be adopted. I understand that it is rather early to cost the proposal. If the committee is minded to support the petition, the authority will have to examine the engineering content of what is proposed. I am asking for a deceleration lane of sufficient length to enable the traffic on the inside lane of the A90 to slow down there—as the word "deceleration" suggests. At the moment traffic slows down on the A90, which means that there is a danger of large lorries up-ending or having other vehicles go into the back of them.
Thank you for bringing your petition before us today. Presumably you have discussed the issue at length with Transport Scotland, which is less than sympathetic to your proposal.
That is correct. As I said, a number of years ago the manager of BEAR Scotland came to my house, where I gave him photographs of the junction and expressed my concerns about it. When he left, he said that he would raise the issue. It came up at a meeting of the area committee at which the Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning Department was represented, but nothing has happened yet.
Do you feel that your proposal is being turned down on grounds of cost or because it is not necessary?
I do not know. I refer to the letter that I received from the Minister for Transport, which said that he was well aware of the proposal and that it was being considered but that he did not think that it was a priority. I cannot say whether it is not seen as a priority on grounds of cost or because it is not necessary.
Do you have figures for the projected increase in the volume of traffic on the road? The current situation may be bad, but is it projected that the volume of traffic will increase?
A large development is under way at Portlethen. I do not want to confuse the committee, but I would like to give members an indication of the development's scale. The sheet that I am holding up shows what is to be built at one of the junctions that are currently closed. When I was trying to interest the Executive in my proposal, we had a series of traffic problems at another junction, the Badentoy turn-off, where we had to build an additional slip road. We were hoping to get a further slip road built because of the danger of increasing traffic coming in at the south end of Portlethen, given that the north entrance is shut and the junction in the middle is somewhat congested. When the development has been built, traffic will increase in the vicinity of the entrances to and exits from Portlethen.
Good morning, Councillor Melling. In your presentation, you mentioned that the second entrance into Porthlethen was closed. Could you explain why that entrance was closed?
It is all part of the development that we are getting in Portlethen. The entrance was shut while an extra lane was developed to help to mitigate traffic problems. That junction, which is not the Bruntland Road one, is the major access into Portlethen and the immediate community, shops and so on for traffic coming off the A90. Because of the anticipated increase in volumes, it was decided to put in an extra lane at the junction, so it was temporarily a restricted entrance into Portlethen.The slip road that takes the traffic over the bridge to the Badentoy industrial estate directly across from the A90 is now open and running. It is under review and I understand from the council roads department that a technical audit will be carried out. I have been extremely concerned about that slip road. I am not a roads engineer, but in my real life I work in design so I see things that are brought to the department's attention. We have had a lot of discussions, and I was assured that the modelling for the junction works, so the authority had to accept it. However, it is up for a technical review even though it is running.
I notice from the papers that you have made representations to Nicol Stephen, who was Minister for Transport at the time, and Mike Rumbles, who is here this morning. Were those representations in the form of meetings or letters? My second question is about the development that you are talking about. Have you met the developers and planning officials to consider whether there might be any scope for the developers to be involved in financing a slip road? I know that that regularly gets done in Fife. When we need access to a new housing development, part of the negotiations is that the developer has to finance a new slip road. To what extent have such negotiations happened?
My correspondence with Nicol Stephen is in another A4 binder at home. My concern when I wrote to him was the development of the Aberdeen western peripheral route—we are going back three or four years now. I wrote and spoke to him to raise my concerns, and I presented what I felt was a good case for developing the A90 from Stonehaven to Aberdeen and giving it motorway status or something equivalent.At that time, we had planning applications for the current development and for a business park a wee bit further north, at Marywell. Both developments were going to bring more traffic and add to the congestion of the A90 in the immediate vicinity of Portlethen. As I am a local councillor, that gave me great concern for my constituents and for people who could end up as my constituents in future by living in the Hillside development. I tried to alert the Executive to the planning applications that were coming through, and I expected that all the slip roads, entrances and exits in Portlethen would be catered for by contributions from the developers, the Executive or whoever. That is the point from which I have been pursuing the issue. Now we all know that there is a possibility that, when the AWPR is built, there will be a spur that will help to alleviate direct traffic heading north or south on the A90. In some respects, that will improve the traffic situation and take care of my suggestion for motorway status for that part of the A90. However, none of us can tell how much traffic all the business parks and housing that are being built will generate. One of the entrances that is currently shut will be reopened, but there are no concessions on the entrance to the Bruntland Road development.
I apologise for being late; I made the mistake of going out of the building and could not get back in. That may be the fault of all the security that we have today, or it may just be me.I know that when councils propose traffic crossings and so on they use a set of criteria, such as the number of fatalities and accidents that there have been at a particular spot. Do you have figures for fatalities, accidents or incidents at the Bruntland Road junction? Does the council or Transport Scotland have such criteria?
The figures that you seek are included in the petition.
Has cognisance been taken of the figures that you have provided for incidents and accidents?
Yes—they are included in consideration of the proposal. There have been a number of accidents and a fatality at the junction. I appeal to the committee to help me to prevent that from happening again. I am particularly concerned by the danger that the bus stops on the junction pose. Members can see from the photographs that have been provided that there is also a house entrance at the junction. Because it is a staggered junction, at times it is congested with vehicles trying to get in and out. The photographs show vehicles and buses trying to get in and out at the junction. That is quite a concern for me.
This morning, the committee is joined by Mike Rumbles and David Davidson, who are local MSPs who have an interest in the petition.
I want to add to what Paul Melling has said. People have lived with the junction since the A90 was built, and over the years the volume of traffic has increased tremendously. The junction is so dangerous that I never use it when travelling into Portlethen. As Paul has described, if someone travels south from Aberdeen and turns into Portlethen at the southern entrance, they must slow right down and take a sharp left turn off the A90, which is a dual carriageway. All the traffic that is travelling at 70mph, at least, behind them must break or transfer lanes; the problems are horrendous.The solution is simple and straightforward, and I cannot understand why it has not been implemented. There is an open field right beside the junction—there are no houses there. There is plenty of room for a simple deceleration lane at one side of the carriageway. In my view, the only issue is cost, because BEAR Scotland and everyone else concerned accepts that the lane should be built, but it is not "a high priority".When Paul Melling handed the petition to the convener at the end of last year, both he and I said that we really wanted the committee to take action and that this was the only route that was left open to us—Paul had tried everything else. We wanted the committee to help us to tackle the problem, because we did not want anyone to die before that was done. Unfortunately, as the committee has heard, an individual has died since the petition was handed in.The problem could not be more serious, but the improvement and solution are straightforward. It is a question of road safety. In the end, it must come down to priorities, as I know that whoever controls the budget has to prioritise, but this is what the Public Petitions Committee is for. Paul Melling has done the correct thing in bringing the problem to your attention.I will close by saying that I hope that the committee will recommend that the Parliament take the petition forward in some way. I know that one way is to refer it to the Local Government and Transport Committee and, as a member of that committee—the convener of this committee is also a member—I think that that would be useful. Obviously, it is entirely up to you how to take it forward, but the issue needs action.
I am delighted to support Councillor Melling. He has been talking this morning about what he has been doing since he became a councillor in 2003. I had a meeting with Lewis Macdonald about a series of junctions, including the one in question, about two years before that election. There has been a continuous spate of accidents on a stretch of road that is about 5 miles long and includes the junction that Councillor Melling is talking about. There is a lot of cross-traffic, and children are taken to school across the dual carriageway. People where I live, which is about 6 miles away, will not use that road or junction to get into Portlethen even if they want to go there. Instead, they go further up the A90 to use the flyover, go back into the middle of Portlethen and then work their way to where they want to be.I was there the other day. With one junction currently closed for works, everything is pushed to use other junctions that are not safe. The problem runs from Aberdeen into Stonehaven, and I have raised the issue using the traffic figures that BEAR has supplied. I have met Transport Scotland and three ministers, all about improving road safety. The easiest and cheapest way to save lives on that stretch of road is to build proper deceleration lanes with the correct surface. One or two have been added further south, but they are still not adequate.The A90 is going to be upgraded in the next few years once—if—the AWPR spur is built, but that will not solve the problem. Traffic comes south, Charleston is just down the road, and hundreds of new houses are being built. Councillor Melling talked about another 800 houses being built, and the story goes on. We have to ask what the value is to the Parliament of preventing a death or serious injury. There have been so many. I ask the committee to take the petition forward in whatever way it can.
Okay, I will ask members to suggest how we can take it forward.
Road safety is paramount, and it is dreadful when we see the sheer carnage and loss of life that there was at the weekend. There seems to be a window of opportunity when developers move into an area. If we write to the Scottish Executive, we could ask it to consider in particular the fact that there are developers in this area and that there may be a window of opportunity for shared resources to be used. I appreciate that the Executive has to have priorities and budgets that fit them and that the junction in question might be low on the list. However, when a developer is in the neighbourhood and such needs are expressed in a community, that should be accounted for and there should be a system for flagging up in the Executive that the developers are there. That point could be made to the Executive if we write to it, and we could write to Aberdeenshire Council to make the same point. It seems to be an issue in a number of communities across Scotland. We could also write to the RAC Foundation for Motoring to get its views on the issues that have been raised. It would be helpful to do that, because we are deeply concerned about such issues, especially when lives are lost.
link
I do not disagree with any of that. I have considerable sympathy with the petition, but I am conscious that we are not considering it in the context of other pressures that may exist. It does not take me to tell the committee that roads elsewhere may represent a greater danger in terms of the number of fatalities. Although it does not diminish the petition before us, we need to understand that.I agree with Helen Eadie. If there are other opportunities, let us look at them, but I also want us to inquire of the Executive where the issue that is raised in the petition fits and when it envisages getting round to doing the kind of work that the petitioner is looking for.
I have an additional suggestion. It might be interesting to have the views of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents. We could write to it and ask what it thinks of the priorities of Transport Scotland or the Executive and whether their assessment of the road is correct.
John Scott mentioned Transport Scotland. It is worth writing to it directly to find out whether it has any useful information about the road.Councillor Melling, we will write to all those organisations with the questions that have been raised this morning. Once we have collected all the responses, we will let you see them. We would then welcome your comments before we consider the petition again at some point. I say to Mike Rumbles that, depending on those responses, if the committee cannot progress the petition, it is probable that we will refer the petition and the responses to the Local Government and Transport Committee.
Thank you for that, convener. Mike Rumbles spoke about coming off the A90 at the Bruntland Road junction, but I omitted to mention that I do that quite regularly. As Mike Rumbles says, it is not possible to come off at the junction at a greater speed than 20mph—drivers have to decelerate on the A90 to no more than that speed. When the junction was clear one day, I tried to come off the road at 25mph and ended up going across the white line at Bruntland Road. That is the sort of speed drivers need to keep to in order to access the junction at present.
We include the Official Report of meetings with the correspondence that we send to organisations so your points will be contained in that. I am sure that they will take your comments on board when they respond to us. Thanks very much for bringing your petition to us this morning.
Thank you.
As the next petitioner has not yet arrived, with the committee's agreement, we will skip to our third new petition this morning.
In this meeting
Everything on 31 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 31 January 2007 Petitions · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 32
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions Petitions · 39
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 15
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.