Petition PE853, by Ken Venters, on behalf of the Carronhill action team, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to introduce legislation that would require all proposals that relate to the closure or alteration of facilities and services for children who have special needs to be referred to it and which would, in the case of such proposals, require detailed consultation of parents of affected children and the implementation of a moratorium that would prevent the closure of special needs schools until such legislation is in place.At its meeting on 22 June 2005, the committee agreed to write to the Minister for Education and Young People and to Aberdeenshire Council. Responses have been received and circulated to members.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Children's Services (Special Needs) (PE853)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 11
- Sandra White SNP 5
- John Scott Con 3
- David Davidson Con 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
24 contributionsIt would be helpful if I knew what the minister had said in his letter. Might I prevail upon you for a copy of the letter?
It is on our website. I do not know whether we can get a copy to you at the moment.
I am quite happy to continue. I have supported the parents of children at the special needs school that is mentioned in the petition and others across Aberdeenshire. There is an issue with regard to the council's previous approach to special needs schools. The enveloping state of the council's thought was that it knew best and that all children would more or less fit into whatever provision it cared to offer. However, that is not the case. Some of the children, particularly those at the school that is the subject of the petition, have tremendous special needs, most of which simply cannot be dealt with in the mainstream system.A few days ago, I attended a meeting of the local area committee that covers the Carronhill area. Local councillors have unanimously supported the position of the parents and have sought to go to the full council, through its various committees, to recommend that the school be replaced on the same site with a building that is fit for purpose. The existing building has some failings, but the unit is good and the staff are unbelievably excellent. They support other base schools and attached units across the shire. Everyone acknowledges that the facility is superb but that, in time, a new building will have to be built so that capacity can be increased—there is a rising trend of need in the area. I congratulate the petitioners on the work that they have done—as members know, they have collected thousands of names. The issue must be taken back to the minister because, if councils are suffering from budget difficulties or whatever, they are not always best placed to make decisions on special needs education and support. Certainly, the children who have gone on to lead fulfilling lives after having attended the school have said that they benefited from the system and from the fact that they were not in mainstream education. Some children will enter the main stream but it is important that we preserve units such as Carronhill Special School. We need a clear signal from the committee—which could be passed on to the Education Committee—to encourage the minister to ensure that the parents' needs are listened to. If necessary, the Education Committee could visit the school, as other MSPs have.The pro forma that was returned to the committee states that the petition has been discussed with Fiona Hyslop and David McLetchie. In fact, the petitioners have done far more than that: they have discussed the matter with a range of MSPs from all parties, and I have not come across one MSP who does not support their position.
Mike Rumbles has also joined us. Mike, do you have any comments on the petition?
I apologise for not being here earlier. I was at a committee briefing on the forthcoming registration of members' interests bill.The petitioners asked me to tell the committee that they are—I am not sure how to put this—a bit disappointed that they were unable to address the committee personally when the petition was originally lodged. They would also have liked to speak to the committee today.I take issue with what David Davidson has said about the local council: the council did not take the position that it knew best, but consulted widely. As David Davidson said, the area committee of the council is 100 per cent behind the petitioners, which is good news for the petitioners.The letter from the minister's office states that"it is not the Executive's policy to require education authorities to close their special schools."It also states that"the 2004 Pupil Census shows that overall there are 32 more publicly funded special schools and units in Scotland now than there were in 1996."That is a positive response. On Carronhill and Stonehaven—which is in my constituency—and the wider issue of special schools, the petitioners are right; however, the issues are being addressed both by the local authorities and by the Executive.The petitioners would have liked the opportunity to address the committee, as part of the process. I do not question the ruling that was made, which was that the petition was similar to other petitions; however, the petitioners feel that it was not.
We discussed the matter when the petition first came before us. We have built up a wealth of experience on a lot of issues. Earlier, we considered a petition on maternity services; it was the fourth petition that we have received on maternity services and those petitions have not been identical. We do not consider the specifics of individual cases, but the generality and the process.The closure of a special needs school is the same issue as the closure of a rural school or any other school. The guidelines may be specific to special educational needs, but the process by which a decision is arrived at is exactly the same. The committee did not need to hear from the petitioners in respect of their individual concerns, because the general issue that they were addressing was dealt with by the committee in its handling of other petitions. We have built up a wealth of experience in that.Although I hear what Mike Rumbles is saying, I disagree. I am sorry that the petitioners felt that they were snubbed or in some way not listened to because they were not required—that is the word that we use—to give additional information. However, I felt that we did not require additional information from them. We understand the issue, as we have dealt with similar issues, and we have received a response from the Executive that explains the process and the Executive's thinking. Members have enough information to enable us to make a decision on what we should do with the petition, and we do not require the additional information that the petitioners felt that they had to give us.
It has been an amicable meeting up to this point, convener; however, I raised that matter with you and the clerk because I thought differently from you on the subject. I do not want to go over old ground—the procedure has been pointed out, and that is fine. I think that we should refer the petition to the Education Committee, which is looking into the issue at the moment. It would be good to refer the petition to that committee to let it examine the detail of it. Everyone whose child needs to attend that special needs school has a right to be heard by the Education Committee, so we should pass the petition to that committee.
Have the petitioners had the opportunity to comment on the responses that we have had?
They have not as yet, but it is usual for us to ask them to do so. We can certainly ask them for their response to the Executive's response. Do you want us to hold back referring the petition to the Education Committee until we get the petitioners' response? I am more than happy to do so.
We should make it plain that it is probably our intention to send the petition to that committee in due course, but it would be fair to give the petitioners the opportunity to comment now because they feel upset that they did not get the opportunity to make a presentation.
Do you want to decide now to send the petition to the Education Committee or should we wait until we have received the petitioners' response?
It might be January or February before the petition even reaches the Education Committee, which is considering school closures at the moment. I am not on the Education Committee, but perhaps someone else can help me in that respect.
The alternative is to send the petition to the Education Committee now and ask it to contact the petitioners.
That is a better idea.
That would bring the petitioners directly into the debate with the Education Committee.
I am not trying to challenge any ruling, but it is rather odd that although the petitioners are in the public gallery now—
We are not going down that road. We have discussed the matter before and we do not ask members of the public to come to the table just because they are here; no committee of the Parliament would do that, let alone the Public Petitions Committee.
link
I am conscious of the issue about speed. Why do we not just refer the petition to the Education Committee? Then, either through their MSPs or after what they have heard today, I am sure that the petitioners will respond directly to the Education Committee without an invitation to do so.
I would like the invitation to be issued anyway, because people are at liberty to write to their MSP regardless of what a committee says.
So members want to send the petition to the Education Committee and ask it to contact the petitioners specifically about it.
I would prefer that.
That would allow the Education Committee to consider the petitioners' response.
Okay. Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 7 December 2005 Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.