Petition PE900 is by Jade Allison, on behalf of the save Dalkeith park campaign. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to ensure that the proposal for the Dalkeith northern bypass is comprehensively and properly assessed with 2005 data and that the results are published and consulted on before any contract is let. Before being formally lodged, the petition was hosted on the e-petitions site; from 25 October 2005 to 30 November 2005, it gathered 1,135 signatures and 17 comments. The usual e-petitions briefing has been sent to members. An additional 467 signatures have been submitted in hard copy.I welcome to the meeting Jade Allison, who is accompanied by Elizabeth Robertson and Colin Howden. Jade will make a brief statement in support of the petition, after which we will discuss its contents.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Dalkeith Northern Bypass (PE900)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jade Allison Save Dalkeith Park Campaign 15
- Michael McMahon Lab 8
- Colin Howden 7
- John Scott Con 7
- Jackie Baillie Lab 6
- Rosie Kane SSP 5
- Elizabeth Robertson Save Dalkeith Park Campaign 3
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Mark Ballard Green 2
The record
55 contributionsI thank the committee for the opportunity to speak to the petition. I represent the save Dalkeith park campaign group, which is concerned at the fact that the proposed route for the Dalkeith northern bypass will sever Dalkeith park.Many people probably do not know the park. Its current designed landscape dates from the 1720s, but there has been a park in the area since the 1630s. Historic Scotland's inventory of gardens and designed landscapes shows Dalkeith park stretching from Dalkeith High Street to the A1 at Whitecraig. The park is part of the Edinburgh green belt and is a well-used recreation area for local people and people from further afield. The proposed route will cut through the park, causing irreversible environmental damage and destroying some ancient woodland.This bypass has been under consideration since the 1950s. The first local public inquiry on the issue was held in 1992; at the time, the park was not used to the extent that it is now and few people objected to the proposal. Permission for a single carriageway was granted in 1993. A second local public inquiry that was held in 1996 looked solely at changing the single carriageway to a dual carriageway. In its 1999 strategic roads review, the Scottish Executive concluded that the A68 Dalkeith bypass was one of several schemes that, although reasonably worth while, should be held in abeyance. It was stated:"future appraisals will be conducted using a multi modal approach which will allow potential trunk road schemes to be considered alongside other potential transport improvements in the area."However, no such appraisal, which should assess possible public transport and traffic management alternatives, has been carried out prior to proceeding. The research justifying the road was conducted in the late 1980s and early 1990s and does not take into account the A7 Dalkeith bypass, the dualling of the A1 and the proposed Borders rail link. Moreover, since then, there have been many changes in infrastructure, transport planning and environmental policy. However, any fresh evidence that was collected in the recent Executive-commissioned studies cannot be used to challenge the decision, because the Executive is not prepared to consult on such evidence or to revisit its original decision. With such out-of-date information, how do we know that the road is the best way of dealing with Dalkeith's traffic problems? In fact, a document that was obtained under freedom of information legislation and which outlines recent local traffic studies suggests that that is not the case. Aspects of the old studies have already been proven wrong. For example, it was predicted that, by 2000, 139 cars would be queuing from Dalkeith High Street back to the Sheriffhall roundabout. That has not happened. Building a new road does not solve pollution problems; it simply shifts them elsewhere.Given the lack of any local public consultation; the fact that the current local plan, which was produced in 1998, is out of date; the lack of any full environmental impact assessment with public consultation; and the failure to carry out a multimodal study, despite the Executive's commitment to do so, it is clear that the Scottish Executive and the Minister for Transport will not engage with the public. As a result, we need the help of the Scottish Parliament. The petitioners ask the Parliament to write to Scottish ministers and the appropriate committees to ensure that the issues are addressed before any contracts are let.
I open the matter up for discussion. Do members have any questions?
I declare an interest as a supporter of the campaign who has signed the petition.I want to pick up on a number of interesting facts that you mentioned. First, how were people invited to be involved in the initial consultation? Secondly, can Colin Howden suggest examples of recent road construction projects for which improvements in traffic were promised? Perhaps he can explain whether those new roads have been successful in dealing with traffic problems.
The local public inquiry took place in 1992—I was not in the area at that time, so I did not know that the park existed—but I think that it was simply announced routinely and in the regular way. I think that people were invited to respond to the consultation and that information was made available in local libraries.
My feeling is that, as you said, many of the decisions were made back in the 1950s, when we had very little knowledge of the environmental effects and other negative impacts of road construction. In that era, I think that the consultations on planned roads did not include the entire community. Do you agree that the community has probably changed quite dramatically since then?
The community has changed very much since then. Also, the use of the park and people's appreciation of green spaces in which they can enjoy their recreation time have changed significantly since 1992.
On the process issue, the multimodal study that Jade Allison mentioned should have been carried out. When the Executive published its trunk roads review in 1999, it said that it would conduct multimodal studies to consider alternatives to road building and perhaps to consider alternative road projects to those that were already on the books.Over the years, the Executive has engaged in good practice on the central Scotland transport corridor studies, which were widely consulted on and considered all the options. Those studies reached the conclusion that the M8 and M80 should still be widened, but that that would do no good on its own because additional investment in public transport would also be required. In that one instance, the Executive has carried through on its own policies.There has also been bad practice—I think that that is what Rosie Kane was getting at—in projects such as, not surprisingly, the M74 northern extension. The Executive decided to proceed with the M74 without carrying out a multimodal study. Indeed, it was decided that the study would be done alongside the building of the road. That is completely unacceptable under the process, as the study needs to happen before the Executive decides to proceed with a project.
In advance of the construction of the M77, promises were made that the road would result in less traffic, more jobs and an improved community. In your experience, has the introduction of a motorway through Pollok reduced or increased traffic?
My understanding is that no follow-up study on the M77 has ever been done. We never get to see whether the job and traffic benefit claims that are often made for such projects can be demonstrated afterwards. That failing affects the whole range of Executive transport policies, but that is a broader issue. As far as I am aware, the local experience is that the M77 has tended to increase traffic levels.Since the public inquiry into the Dalkeith northern bypass in the 1980s, the architecture of transport policy has changed. Neither the Standing Advisory Committee on Trunk Road Assessment report that found that new roads tend to generate increased traffic levels nor the findings on the impacts of transport on the economy were available when the new road was given the go-ahead. We believe strongly that such issues have to be taken into account as a matter of Executive policy before the Executive supports such schemes.
Do you want account to be taken of the SACTRA finding that new motorways simply generate new traffic, such that surrounding areas might find themselves in a much worse situation?
Not all new roads will generate increased traffic levels. A new road that is built in a remote area might not generate more traffic, so the issue is not quite so clear cut. However, SACTRA's 1995 report concluded that the construction of new trunk road capacity in areas that are already congested will tend to generate new traffic. That finding has not been taken into account in the Executive's decision to proceed with the Dalkeith northern bypass.
Some parts of the case are quite confusing. Our briefing note states that in 1993—before the Scottish Parliament existed, obviously—permission was given for the construction of a single carriageway. In 1997 additional land was purchased for a dual carriageway, but in 1999, by which time the Scottish Parliament existed, the Scottish Executive said that the scheme should be held in abeyance and considered again in the future, possibly as part of a multimodal study. I find it strange that the Executive has not done that study and that nobody has had any correspondence from the Executive on the matter.You have been involved from 1999 to the present day. Has the Scottish Executive explained why it decided to go ahead with the bypass? Have you had any meetings with ministers or any indication of why they changed their minds?
We have had no meetings with ministers, but we have made a lot of freedom of information requests and the matter has been discussed in the Scottish Parliament. Basically, it boils down to the fact that the money is available. When the M74 case went to the High Court, there was money left over. Through written questions, Fergus Ewing established that the scheme was given the go-ahead because the money was available.
I wish that that would happen in other areas. You have had no meetings with ministers and have received no explanation other than the fact that the money was available. Has an environmental impact assessment been done?
The Executive says that it is updating the environmental impact assessment and conducting further traffic studies, but we were told that we cannot get hold of those studies because they are in progress. Basically, the road has been decided on and the studies are being done to justify it.
In the 1990s, two public inquiries established the need for the bypass. Are you saying that, because of strategic road improvements and other transport improvements in the area, a bypass is no longer needed?
It is possible that there is no need for the bypass, or perhaps other measures could be introduced, such as a weight restriction on vehicles through Dalkeith and improvements in public transport. We need a multimodal study to establish whether a bypass is needed and whether it is the optimum solution. There is probably a need to sort out traffic problems and pollution in Dalkeith, but we need to find the optimum way of doing that. I am not sure that research that was done in the late 1980s and early 1990s can tell us the best thing to do.
I see that your petition has 1,500 signatures. What is the population of Dalkeith? Do you think that you represent the views of everyone in Dalkeith?
I am sure that I do not represent everybody. We held a public meeting in Dalkeith, which was well attended by about 300 people. The upshot of that meeting was that, although people felt that something needed to be done about the congestion in Dalkeith, they were not prepared to lose Dalkeith park. They wanted further investigation to determine whether the construction of the bypass was the right thing to do. I think that we represent the vast majority of people in the Dalkeith area.
link
Mr Howden, are you from the Dalkeith campaign or do you have a particular interest in roads and transport?
I am from TRANSform Scotland, but I was asked to come along today by the save Dalkeith park campaign. TRANSform is the national sustainable transport alliance.
link
I thought that I recognised you from somewhere. I just wanted to establish that.I am curious. There have been two local public inquiries, which is a higher degree of scrutiny than many communities achieve. What did those inquiries not cover that gives you such cause for concern?
The second local public inquiry examined only the dualling aspect. There was considerable representation from people who opposed the road altogether, but their concerns could not be heard because of the remit of the inquiry.I am sorry—I have forgotten the rest of your question.
link
Did the inquiries consider the environmental concerns or any aspects of the dualling that related to the original concerns?
The first and second local public inquiries had environmental impact assessments carried out, but they were non-statutory environmental impact assessments that did not comply with the European directives. It was felt that the bypass would be far enough away from the site of special scientific interest—the ancient oak wood—for it not to warrant such assessment. No public consultation was done as part of the environmental impact assessments, and the use of the whole park was not properly considered at that time.
link
Does the fact that the Executive has indicated that it will go back to baseline environmental information and put in place measures to mitigate against the effects of the road give you any comfort at all?
No. There needs to be a public consultation.
Given the fact that the decision to build the road has been made and that the project is going ahead, I question why further assessments are being done. Surely, assessments and research should be done first, to work out whether the project is the optimum thing to do, before it goes ahead. I have no comfort in those things being done after the event—after the decision has been made.
I reinforce Jade Allison's comments. Things have changed. The evidence that has been submitted mentions infrastructure changes in the construction of the A7 Dalkeith western bypass and the Executive's proposals for the construction of the Borders railway. Frankly, I would like to know what the impact of the Dalkeith northern bypass will be on the viability of the Borders railway, which is something that we strongly support but which I fear that the Dalkeith northern bypass will damage.On top of that, there have been changes—I will not go into them in depth—in transport policy and environmental policy, with the Executive's commitments to tackle climate change and the changes in national planning policy over the period. The policies that were set in 1992 belong to a different era.
link
To balance that, we must recognise the changes that have taken place in the profile of transport usage and the fact that car ownership has increased substantially in the same period.
I concede that.
The committee is joined this morning by Mark Ballard. Mark, do you have any questions that you would like to ask?
I have some comments. As an MSP for the Lothians and a campaigner on transport and environmental issues, I understand that the Dalkeith bypass was held in abeyance after the 1999 strategic review, which was conducted by Sarah Boyack. As has been said, a multimodal study was to be done to assess the potential benefits of the proposed northern bypass against the benefits of other—also, I presume, costly—investment in transport infrastructure in the area. I was, therefore, surprised when it was announced in June that the bypass was being taken out of mothballs.I have received a great deal of correspondence from local people—not just in Dalkeith, but in the wider Lothians—who are users of the park and who consider it an important area of green space. Many of those correspondents expressed their surprise that the public inquiry took place as long ago as 1992 and commented on how much the area and the usage of the park have changed since then. Like everybody else who is involved in the debate about the park, I am frustrated by the lack of up-to-date information on the impact of the proposal on the environment and the lack of a multimodal study. That makes it impossible to conduct the needed public debate about this £40 million to £80 million proposal.I urge the committee to take what steps it can to make that information available so that there can be a proper public debate on the potential benefits—or otherwise—of the proposal. That is the light in which the committee should look at the issue. Whatever side members take, in opposing or supporting the scheme, it is necessary to make that debate possible; at the moment, it is not.
The more that I have heard, the more confused I have become. I do not know the Dalkeith area or the history of the project—I have not been involved in it at all. Is there a problem of congestion in Dalkeith that has to be addressed? Would you support any project to address the issue, or are you saying that there is no problem and, therefore, no need for a bypass?
There may be a problem of congestion in Dalkeith: some times I have found traffic queues; other times I have not. The issue has not been researched properly. We are confused as well, convener, because research has not been done to show what the problem is.Recently commissioned reports, which have been released under the freedom-of-information scheme, show that congestion happens only with westbound traffic. That traffic would not be affected by the Dalkeith northern bypass. A report that we read talked about people trying to avoid the Edinburgh city bypass at Sheriffhall roundabout by travelling along Salters Road and going west through Dalkeith. We need to establish what the problem is in order to solve it.
How big is the park?
About 1,000 acres. It goes from the A1 at Whitecraig and along Salters Road, and from Sheriffhall roundabout to near enough Dalkeith High Street.
So it is 1,000 acres and you are objecting to one road going through it.
Yes.
The road will bisect the park. That is the concern: it is not a road going through one corner of the park, but a road that will drive a wedge right through the middle of the park.I want to pick up on the convener's question. I have been concerned with congestion in Dalkeith, but there is a feeling that only one shot of Executive money will be available to solve that congestion. At the moment, it is not clear whether the northern extension would be the most effective use of that public money, or whether more effective ways of tackling pollution and congestion in Dalkeith town centre could be found. It is impossible to debate the issue because the facts are not in the public domain.
I want to ask Mr Howden—or Mr Ballard—a question. There has been debate recently over the route of a bypass to address congestion in Aberdeen. No one argued that there was no congestion in Aberdeen; the argument was over the route of the bypass. Is the situation in Dalkeith similar? Are you concerned about the route of the bypass, or do you think that no bypass is needed?
You asked initially whether there was congestion in Dalkeith. At times there is, but the question is whether the best way to address it is to spend £40 million on a new road. Would we support any road proposal? Perhaps—but only after alternatives had been investigated.I am from Aberdeen, so I know a little about the terrain there. Broader concerns have been expressed over the Aberdeen western bypass than just the concerns over route choice. If you have missed hearing about the other objections, I am pretty certain that you will hear them when the public inquiry is held in two years' time. If you have £400 million to spend—that is the figure that is proposed for Aberdeen—people might feel that it would be better to spend the money on addressing the radial flows of commuters into the city at peak hours, rather than on a circumferential route. A circumferential route will not do much to cater for commuting trips into the city, because of the constraints on road capacity once commuters hit the built-up area.The Aberdeen and the Dalkeith proposals are different beasts.
I want to ask another question about Dalkeith park. The Meadows in Edinburgh is bisected by a road, and some might suggest that, in a similar way, such a road would give access to the Dalkeith park. Would you not see that as a benefit?
There would be no access off the road and into the park. In fact, the road would cut through many of the tracks and paths that people use at the moment.The Meadows is quite different. It does not have much by way of wildlife; it has no deer, badgers or kingfishers, for example. Building a road through Dalkeith park would disturb a wildlife corridor. The River Esk valley is a listed wildlife site and it will be bisected by the road. In the Meadows, the road probably offers better access, but that would not be the case in Dalkeith park.
The park is probably 50 times the size of the Meadows.
Yes.
Do members have any suggestions on how we should deal with the petition?
We should seek the views of the Scottish Executive, Midlothian Council, TRANSform Scotland and Friends of the Earth Scotland. We could also seek views from a wildlife organisation. Could anyone assist me with the name of an appropriate organisation?
The Scottish Wildlife Trust.
The Woodland Trust Scotland would be another option.
link
Do we need to request the views of TRANSform Scotland, given that they have been stated so eloquently today?
There would be no harm in writing to TRANSform Scotland to get an official response. Jackie Baillie's question is legitimate—in the past, representatives of organisations have spoken to petitions and we have said that, given that they came along to the meeting, there is no need for the committee to receive a written response from them. However, given the wider implications of the issue, it might be useful to get the organisation's views rather than those of an individual who is assisting a petitioner. That gets us round the problem of setting a dangerous precedent.
May I make another suggestion? It might be worth speaking to Whitecraig community council, which feels that it has not been consulted. The issue has been dealt with in Midlothian, but people in East Lothian will also be affected.
There is no problem with that. That is a good suggestion. We will do that.We will discuss the matter further when we get the opportunity. We will let you know what the responses are from the various organisations and seek your views on them. Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 7 December 2005 Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.