Agenda item 2 is consideration of new petitions. Petition PE899, by Hazel Reid, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review the operation of the victim notification scheme to ensure that the victims of serious violent and sexual crimes are given the right to receive information about the release from prison of an offender who has committed a crime against them, regardless of the length of the sentence that was imposed.Before being formally lodged, the petition was hosted on the e-petitions site; from 25 October 2005 to 30 November 2005, it gathered 883 signatures and six comments. Members have received a copy of the e-petitions briefing for the petition.Hazel Reid is here to make a brief statement in support of her petition; she is accompanied by Norma Anderson. I welcome you both to the committee. You have a few minutes to make your opening comments and then we will discuss the issue that you have brought before us.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Victim Notification Scheme (PE899)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hazel Reid 12
- Michael McMahon Lab 6
- Sandra White SNP 5
- Jackie Baillie Lab 3
- Campbell Martin Ind 3
- John Scott Con 2
- Norma Anderson 2
The record
33 contributionsThis time last year, I wrote to the victim notification scheme to ask for information on the release date of my husband, who had attempted to murder me. I also asked whether he was eligible to apply for a day-release scheme under which he would be allowed into the community before the end of his sentence. My main concern was about the possibility of his being eligible for day release as that would mean that he could turn up at my home or my work and I would have no knowledge that he was free on any particular day. Naturally, I believed that he had admitted to a serious crime and therefore I expected to be given information under the victim notification scheme.The Scottish Prison Service replied to my request by stating that, as my husband had received a sentence of less than four years' imprisonment, I was not entitled to any information under the scheme. I was devastated. For three days I could think of nothing else and I cried constantly. I was living in a state of fear. For years, I had been told by my husband that I was worthless, and in court I felt that I was not worth while, especially as my husband's advocate stated several times that his client was not a danger to the public but only to his wife. The victim notification scheme reiterated that I was of no account.Contrary to statements that have been made recently by the Executive, the scheme has been running for a lot longer than a year. It began on a trial basis in 1997 and became more formalised in January 2001, when the "Scottish Strategy for Victims" was published. That document contained three key policy objectives, one of which was to improve the availability of information for victims of crime. The scheme then passed into legislation under the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003, which supposedly gives victims or an eligible family member the right to receive information about the release from prison of the offender who committed the crime against them. The Executive has stated on numerous occasions that the scheme is under review, but what does that mean? How long does a review take?That has been my experience, and I am not alone. I urge the Executive to rectify as soon as possible the ludicrous situation whereby the VNS will release information to the victim only when the perpetrator receives a sentence of four years or more, no matter what crime has been committed. Arbitrary sentencing should make no difference to a victim's right to know or to be consulted, and that right should apply to all victims of serious crime, be they women or men. If I had had the information, I would have known when and where I needed to ensure greater awareness and protection of myself.It is too late to change the law for me, but many victims of violence, domestic abuse and sexual abuse are likely to face the same situation, because sentences for those crimes are often lenient. Those victims' safety is compromised through lack of information. Nobody—least of all a person who has just gone through the trauma of an assault—should be disregarded in that way; they have suffered enough. Thank you for granting me the time in which to speak to you.
Thank you for your opening comments. I understand that you have been through a traumatic experience, and I am sure that members will be as sympathetic as they can be in their questioning. If you find it difficult at all, please let us know and we will take appropriate measures.
Good morning. You have my sympathy for the dreadful experience that you have gone through. You will appreciate that the timescale for victim notification has been drawn up with the best of intentions, although you are not content with it. Are you suggesting that a special case should be made for domestic violence, as opposed to other crimes? Or are you suggesting that the victim should have a right to information if the sentence is three years or two years? What would you like to happen?
I would like any victim of an assault to have that right, whether they are a man or a woman, and whether the incident is domestic or non-domestic. Also, attempted murder should be viewed as a serious crime. My husband admitted in court to attempted murder—that is what he was sentenced for. However, I was told that it was not a serious crime, as he did not receive a sentence of four years.
So, you suggest that the type of crime should determine whether there is automatic notification of the victim.
Yes.
Thank you for coming along and being so brave as to give evidence today. The committee listened to what you said, and I hope that we will be able to do something about the situation.I want to ask about information that you may have received before your husband was sentenced. Did lawyers advise you that, if the sentence was less than four years, you would not receive notification? When did you find out that, if the sentence was less than four years, you would not be told about the release date or whether your husband would go into a day prison?
This time last year, when I wrote to the VNS asking for information, I did not know. No one had told me before then that I was not entitled to that information.
So, lawyers do not advise victims of that. Victims receive no information—even from the legal profession or the courts—about what is happening: it is left up to them.
The witness protection scheme said that there was something set up and that I could apply for that information. I knew that, but no one said that there was a time limit and that the offender had to have received a sentence of four years or longer.
You mentioned the witness protection scheme, which seems to be in two parts. When you were told about that, you assumed that you might be given knowledge, but you actively had to seek out the knowledge—nobody gave you it.
Correct.
link
I am clear that you want the nature of the crime and the level of severity rather than the length of the sentence to be the determining factor—I appreciate that sentencing varies. I want to take you to the beginning of the process—the point at which the perpetrator was charged. The news articles with which we have been provided suggest that the fact that he pled guilty to the charge might have led to a lesser sentence. Have I picked that up correctly?
That is my belief. A house-breaking charge was dropped because he pled guilty. There was a plea bargain. He said in court that he had a knife in his hand because he wanted to slip the lock and that he climbed in through the window because he was unable to slip the lock, but he actually threw a brick through the window and then came in and stabbed me immediately. He was in possession of the knife before he came into the house, but that was not how it was seen in court.
link
I am not a lawyer, but I would have thought that if the action was shown to be premeditated, rather than done in the heat of the moment, that might have carried a higher tariff. That illustrates that what happens at the beginning of the process might not be helpful for the victim notification scheme.
Correct.
Obviously, few of us in the room could even begin to imagine what you went through. I seek clarification on one point. It is ridiculous that you were not told when your husband was to be released. You described the sentence of four years as arbitrary, which is exactly what it is. Every victim of the sort of crime of which you were a victim should be notified when the perpetrator is to be back on the streets. Do you know whether the police are advised or forewarned when someone like your husband is put back on to the streets?
The police are told only if they ask. In Hazel's case, the police were told, because her domestic abuse liaison officer took the time to find out. They wrote to the Scottish Prison Service to say that, in their opinion, Hazel would be endangered if he was released on day release, which is why the SPS actively vetoed that.
Hazel, am I right that your situation was exacerbated by the fact that your husband kept contacting you from prison?
Yes.
You asked for the matter to be checked out, but if it had not been, he would have been back on the streets and neither you nor the local police would have known.
My daughter visited him about three or four times when he was in prison. He boasted to her that he would be getting out in some way. She thought that he meant an open prison—she did not know exactly what it was. She told me about it, so I made inquiries, because I was unaware that prisoners could get out on a day-release scheme, two thirds into their sentence. I discovered that in about November or December last year. Because my husband got out of jail in August, he would therefore have been eligible to apply for the day-release scheme in January to start in February. I was concerned, because I felt that I had until August to get prepared, but suddenly I had only until February. As it happened, he was not granted day release, but I did not have any information on whether he would be granted it, so I had to take safety precautions; in fact, I had to take them six months before I was ready to take them.
You may have no knowledge of what I would like to know, but I am just trying to get as good a picture as I can of the problem. We have heard about your specific situation and your individual problem, but do you have any evidence, either empirical or anecdotal, of how widespread the problem is of a victim being recontacted by the perpetrator of a crime against them in situations in which they were not entitled to be notified that that person was being released? Does that happen predominantly with women victims? Do you have any information or evidence on that?
I do not, although I have been told by various agencies that women get very upset because the situation that I am in is not unique to me. Especially with sexual assault, an offender does not tend to get a sentence of more than four years. Many sexual assault crimes are committed by someone who is known to the victim. When you know the perpetrator, there is always a fear that they will come and seek you out once they have been released from jail. When the victim notification scheme refused to give me the information that I wanted, I was at my lowest ebb.
I think that a woman is killed every three days by a violent former partner and that, often, criminal proceedings have already been taken against him.
That is the kind of evidence that I was interested in, because it helps to give us a wider picture. We have heard a good explanation of Hazel Reid's individual circumstances, but I am trying to get an idea of the wider situation.Concerns have been expressed around the table. Do members have any suggestions on how to deal with the petition?
link
For me, there are two issues: the differences that we know exist in sentencing practice and the fact that changes can be made to the initial charges that might ultimately reduce the sentence that is handed down. I suggest that we write to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, the Scottish Executive, the Scottish Prison Service, Victim Support Scotland, the Parole Board for Scotland and Safeguarding Communities-Reducing Offending to bring the terms of the petition to their attention and to seek their views on a review of the notification scheme with a view to changing it.
I agree entirely with what Jackie Baillie said, but I would also like us to contact the police. I am surprised that the onus is on the police to ask whether such people are to be released and that they are not notified automatically. We should ask the police about that.
Should we ask the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland? There are a number of police bodies and I am not sure which of them it would be most appropriate to ask.
ACPOS is probably the most appropriate body to ask.
As there are no further suggestions on how to progress matters, I thank Hazel Reid for bringing the issue to our attention. We will get back to you once we have received responses from the organisations to which we have decided to write. At that point, we will discuss matters further and decide what more we can do. We will keep you advised of the responses that we receive and we will seek your views on them when we obtain them.
Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Dec 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 7 December 2005 Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 33
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 19
- New Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 29
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.