Agenda item 3 is current petitions. We will deal first with the ninth such petition, because we agreed an 11.30 slot for the minister to speak to the committee.Petition PE528 from MacRoberts Solicitors, on behalf of Glasgow Airport Parking Association Ltd, calls on the Scottish Parliament to conduct an inquiry into the consequences for transport infrastructure in Scotland of competition in the provision of on-site and off-site car parking at Scottish airports, and to amend such legislation as it considers appropriate. Nicol Stephen MSP, the Minister for Transport, has kindly joined us to take questions on issues arising from the petition. After the minister has made a statement, we will discuss the issues that have come up.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Scottish Airports (Access to Public Roads) (PE528)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicol Stephen LD 13
- Michael McMahon Lab 11
- Phil Gallie Con 8
- Caroline Lyon Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services 5
- Sandra White SNP 4
- Helen Eadie Lab 4
- Campbell Martin Ind 2
The record
47 contributionsI welcome the opportunity to discuss the petition with the committee. I understand that the provision of substantive responses to the committee has been delayed. The delays have been regrettable and I apologise to the committee for them. Members may have been given the impression that the Executive was being unhelpful about keeping the committee advised of the action that was being taken, but—as is often the case in relation to such issues—the delays in responding were not intentional. They were due to the nature of the issue, which is technically and legally complex.We had hoped to reach conclusions towards the end of last summer, but that did not happen because I sought reassurance and further information on a final issue that we needed to resolve with the British Airports Authority—that of disabled access—which took months, rather than a few weeks, to do. At the time, we should have increased and improved our communications with the committee, but we tended to do the opposite and to give verbal rather than e-mailed or formal responses. That situation led to my appearance before the committee today, which is unfortunate.I will get to the substance of the petition, as that will be most helpful to members. One issue is the byelaws; the other is the competitive aspects of the provision of on-site and off-site parking at airports in Scotland. The Executive has responsibility for the byelaws issue.PE528 asks the Scottish Parliament to conduct an inquiry into competition in the provision of on-site and off-site parking at Scottish airports. During consideration of the Transport (Scotland) Bill, the Enterprise and Culture Committee investigated that issue. Like members of the Public Petitions Committee, I have read the evidence that it took.As the committee knows, competition is reserved to the United Kingdom Government and does not fall within the competence of this Parliament. The Enterprise and Culture Committee, in its report as secondary committee on the Transport (Scotland) Bill, concluded that, on balance, it was not appropriate that the transport issue that is highlighted in the petition should be addressed by the bill. As the bill is at stage 2, any member who so wishes still has the opportunity to lodge an amendment to that effect for the consideration of the Local Government and Transport Committee, which is the lead committee on the bill. However, I believe that the Enterprise and Culture Committee's scrutiny of the issue was appropriate and addressed the substance of the petition in a fair and balanced way.As the petition states, the director general of fair trading has been approached by the petitioner for his assistance in resolving the alleged breach of the Competition Act 1998. It will be for the petitioner to advise on the director general's response, as such information is obviously not available directly to the Executive—nor should it be, when sensitive and confidential competition issues are involved. The Office of Fair Trading and the Competition Commission are the appropriate bodies to consult if petitioners consider that competition legislation has been breached.My responsibility as a Scottish minister has been to consider any airport byelaws that are submitted to ministers. As I indicated to the committee in my letter of 13 April 2005—it is important to specify the year, as the correspondence, unfortunately, trails back over several years—the Scottish ministers' powers over byelaws that have been made by another body are set out in sections 63 and 64 of the Airports Act 1986 and in schedule 3 to that act, which are all provisions that are excepted from reservation under the Scotland Act 1998.Designated airport operators may make byelaws for regulating the use and operation of the airport and the conduct of all persons while they are within the airport. In particular, byelaws may be made to secure the safety of aircraft, vehicles and persons that use the airport; to prevent danger to the public arising from the use and operation of the airport; to prevent obstruction within the airport by preventing vehicular traffic anywhere within it; and to prohibit or restrict access to any part of the airport. The clear aim of the byelaws is to ensure the safe and secure operation of the airports in question.The Scottish ministers must decide whether to confirm, reject or modify byelaws, but complex legal issues need to be considered before any such decision can be taken. In that regard, there has been a chain of correspondence between BAA and my officials, who have worked on the issue over a significant period.It is important that any objections to the byelaws are considered in a fair and balanced way that will stand up to appropriate scrutiny. During the Executive's consideration of the byelaws, every opportunity has been given to ensure that both the objectors and the airport operator have had adequate opportunity to make representations for further comment. The extent of consultation and input went further than is strictly required under the terms of the legislation, but I believe that it was appropriate in the circumstances. The Executive made every effort to seek a resolution of issues before taking any decisions on the byelaws.We have now confirmed the byelaws, but that confirmation has been subject to some modification of the byelaws. My single central point is that the byelaws have no impact on the ability of the airport operator—in this instance, BAA—to charge for access to the airport. That issue is not changed by the byelaws. The byelaws impact mainly on the aircraft side of the airport facilities, but they cover some aspects of the general operation of the airport, as did the previous byelaws that were in place for Glasgow airport.There are similar byelaws in relation to Heathrow airport. Because Heathrow is the largest and most significant of its airports, BAA wanted to get the Heathrow byelaws in place as a priority. It then intended to get similar byelaws in place for its other airports; that is why progress on the byelaws for Scottish airports started after the Heathrow airport byelaws. I am told—BAA will be able to confirm this—that it took around eight years for the Heathrow byelaws to be prepared and put in place. Therefore, although the process has taken a number of years in Scotland, we should consider the context.I understand that agreements have been reached with the off-site car park operators in relation to charging not for access but for facilities at the Scottish airports that BAA controls. However, that is not an issue for Scottish ministers; it is an issue for the operator of the airports and the private companies, in which I would not intervene. If concerns arose in relation to the dominant position of BAA, those concerns would be handled in another way and not through recourse to Scottish ministers.We have now confirmed that the byelaws will have no impact on the charging issue, and we are in the process of putting those byelaws into legal effect. We have not yet reached the final stage but we have indicated our approval for the byelaws, subject to the modifications that have been agreed through correspondence with officials and with the legal teams involved.I will leave it at that and await your questions, convener.
Thank you.
Most of the minister's comments were about the byelaws but, as far as I can see, the byelaws are totally irrelevant to the petition. Airports have special development rights, which I presume are built into the act that the minister mentioned.I would have thought that the ministerial involvement would be to encourage dialogue and agreement between Glasgow Airport Parking Association and the airport. Although you might feel that you do not want to get involved, I think that the Scottish Executive has a specific interest. Airports are all about economic development. The Glasgow area will receive a massive boost from Glasgow airport.I am sorry to have taken so long to get to my point, but there is a bargaining issue that the Executive could have used—namely the fact that Glasgow airport wants a rail link. Ministers, airport authorities and others with an interest in economic development could have bargained in order to secure the interests of everyone in the Glasgow area and not just the interests of the airport.
Glasgow airport is important to the development of the whole of the city and the whole of the west of Scotland. As was referred to in the aviation white paper, there are plans for significant growth. We plan to invest a very significant sum of money in a Glasgow airport rail link and BAA is co-operating with us on that. Strathclyde Passenger Transport is in the lead and a consultation is under way on the exact route and the exact technical and engineering specifications for the link. We believe that we can get it in place quickly. Of the major public transport projects that we are investing in, the rail link will be one of the first to be ready to open.I agree absolutely with Phil Gallie about the importance of the airport and the importance of improved transport links and public transport links. I also agree that we should improve all aspects of surface access, including road access, and that we should increase the availability of car parking.There should be far more opportunities for park and ride on the way into Glasgow city centre, by which I mean bus or rail park and ride. The car parking opportunities and the marketing and signage that encourage people to make greater use of park and ride on the way into Glasgow are simply not in place at the moment. Big strides could be taken in that regard, and I have no doubt that the off-site car parking operators could play a role. When Sir Michael Hirst gave evidence on behalf of the association to the Enterprise and Culture Committee, he made reference to the negotiations that have been taking place to try to encourage the use of the new airport rail link.Although all that is important, I am focusing my response today on the terms of PE528. People may think that my response is somewhat dry and legal, but I am focusing on the role of ministers in relation to the bylaws. It is important that we exercise that role fairly, appropriately and accountably in a way that is open to scrutiny.
I thank the minister for sticking to the issues that are raised in PE528. We are here to discuss not transport policy but a request from a petitioner on whether the minister can take forward an issue that relates to airport car parking. We must remember to be specific in our questioning.
I went round the houses on the issue because the petitioners asked us to ensure that they have a place where they can park their buses and pick up passengers at Glasgow airport. The minister referred to park and ride, yet that is often the service that is offered by those operators. From my reading of the petition, I am concerned that BAA does not provide facilities for buses to stop and pick up passengers. I may have got that wrong, but that is my interpretation of what the petitioners asked us to do.
PE528 calls for an inquiry into how such situations are operated. Although that gives us a bit of latitude, the petition specifically relates to the provision of car parking by car park operators either on site at the airports or off site in adjacent areas. We must be clear on the issue: we are discussing not wider transport policy areas such as how people get to an airport, but what happens when people get to an airport and who provides airport car parking facilities.
If we look at the issue in those terms, it is clear that BAA can do whatever it likes at its airports; there are no ministerial controls over whether other companies can operate on BAA land. What is the benefit of the Parliament debating or examining the issue further?
To be fair to BAA and, indeed, to the petitioner, reference has been made to other airports that BAA does not own. Glasgow Prestwick airport was mentioned, for example—Phil Gallie knows directly about the issues there.
My remarks would be the same in relation to Prestwick.
There will always be a difference of view between the airport operators and the people who seek to bring people to the airports or who seek to do work associated with the airports, as the operators of off-site car parks do. Inevitably, those people have to enter into commercial arrangements with the airport operator.Some of the issues and tensions that we are discussing apply not only to off-site car parking but to airport taxi services, for example. There is an issue about the availability of taxis and access to taxis that are operated by companies that do not have a contract that allows them to make pick-ups from an airport. Many of us will have seen long queues of people outside airports waiting for taxis. However, taxis that do not have a contract can only collect or drop people off at the front door and go back into town again; they are not allowed to pick up somebody in the queue. That is another area about which there will always be disagreements and frustration.We all want the best system possible to be in operation to ensure that Scotland is competitive with other EU nations and is as welcoming as other EU nations. That means ensuring that people do not have to walk far to get their bus to their off-site car park and ensuring that, when they arrive at an airport, a good-quality taxi is available even in the middle of the night if that is when their plane arrives. I am passionate about such issues and want them to be addressed.It is fair that the issues are discussed in the Parliament and that committees have the opportunity to consider them. For example, if the Local Government and Transport Committee were to consider that issue in the future, that would be entirely appropriate. However, I have had to be pretty restricted in my remarks this morning, as the inquiry is focusing on a technical legal issue in relation to the petition's proposal to conduct an inquiry into the consequences for the transport infrastructure in Scotland of competition in the field of on-site and off-site car parking at Scottish airports. I prepared my remarks with that in mind, and that is why I have been more restricted than I would perhaps normally be in responding to Phil Gallie's points.
I think that Phil Gallie understands that.
I will go on to specifics and perhaps pick you up on the issue of the Transport (Scotland) Bill and what can be done through that. You mentioned in your opening remarks that amendments and modifications had been made to the draft byelaws. Can you enlighten us as to what they are? Will the byelaws enable Glasgow airport to deny operators access to airport roads? You said that you had no control over the passing of the byelaws, which will come into effect in June. What modifications were made to the draft byelaws and will Glasgow airport be able to deny access to airport roads or charge for access to the public parts of the airport?
I am pleased that Sandra White has raised the issue of the byelaws. I talked about the tension that can exist between the operators of an airport and those who make commercial use of its facilities. One aspect of that to which I did not refer is the important role of the operator in ensuring that there are good-quality passenger facilities at the airport and that there is investment in public transport links, such as the new airport rail links that we propose to establish for both Glasgow and Edinburgh airports. The plane operators that use the airside facilities make a contribution to future investment in our airports and, indirectly, to the new drive that we all support for better public transport access to our airports. A central part of ministers' scrutiny of the byelaws is that we ensure that the byelaws are in place for the reasons that I have just described—to ensure that the airport is well managed, safe and appropriately developed—rather than to impose any unfair duties or burdens on the commercial companies that enter into contracts with BAA and others.I ask Caroline Lyon, who is the solicitor with the lead responsibility on these issues, to explain as clearly and as simply as she can the modifications with regard to airport byelaws.
Two principal modifications were made to definitions to ensure that the operation of the byelaws was as tight as possible. First, the definition of airport was modified to pick up a definition that is contained in the Airports Act 1986 and the Civil Aviation Act 1982, in order to ensure that the operation of the byelaws was restricted to the land, building and works of the aerodrome and not to anything that might be connected to its operation. The second modification was to the definition of private hire car, in order to be consistent with other definitions in the byelaws and with the definition of taxi in the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
What about the question of restricting or charging for access to particular roads?
The proposed byelaws do not make any amendments to the existing byelaws in that respect. Under byelaw 3/27, anyone who operates a private hire car needs an authorisation from the airport. However, BAA is already using that byelaw. In confirming the byelaws, we felt that such an approach was entirely reasonable; anyone can apply for an authorisation and the byelaws do not say that any charge can or must be imposed for such an application.Similarly, taxi operators must apply to BAA for authorisation to get taxis on to the airport forecourt or on to roads that are not public authority roads. Again, there is no provision for any charges to be applied for such an authorisation. As a result, any taxi or private hire car operator could apply for an authorisation and BAA would have to decide whether to grant it according to the criteria on which it bases such decisions. Any decision that it takes must have a reasonable basis, which means that anyone who is refused an authorisation would have normal recourse to the courts. Nothing in the byelaws enables the airport operator to impose such charges.
So no charges can be imposed under those byelaws.
That is correct.
Charges might be imposed as a result of a commercial negotiation between the airport operator and the taxi or private hire company. However, I believe that the byelaws that we are considering today do not affect that situation or any charging or commercial arrangements with regard to buses moving to and from off-site parking. Is that correct?
That is correct.
Thank you for clarifying that point. Prestwick airport, which is not operated by BAA, is considering charging people to come into the airport. As that is a major worry with the byelaws, I am pleased to hear that there will be no charging.BAA will charge GAPA members a levy of £5,000 to use Glasgow airport's facilities; I presume that that is what Phil Gallie meant when he referred to dropping off. I realise that the minister cannot do anything about that, but he suggested—perhaps suggested is the wrong word—that GAPA members should go through the Local Government and Transport Committee to address this matter.
The member is talking about what I understand to be a contractual arrangement that GAPA members and BAA have entered into freely. According to evidence that was given at the Enterprise and Culture Committee—by, I believe, a representative of the Scottish association—people in such situations would hope to pay less or hope for a better outcome for their organisation or association.On balance, the agreement that was struck was felt to be appropriate. The concern seemed to relate to the impact of the byelaws or to charges increasing. Separate concerns were raised about Prestwick.My response to all that goes back to Phil Gallie's original point. If there is a feeling that something is unfair or is damaging transport in Scotland, our future economic development or the development of individual airports, the Local Government and Transport Committee could consider the matter, if it gave it sufficient priority. Far be it for me, as Minister for Transport, to suggest what a committee should be doing. One of the central and most important roles of a committee is to scrutinise the work of ministers and ensure that the Executive is behaving appropriately. It is not the role of ministers to set the agenda for committees.
I point out that it was the Scottish Independent Airport Park and Ride Association that provided information to the Enterprise and Culture Committee.
I agree with the points that the minister made at the outset that the issue is enormously complex and difficult for us to get a handle on. My starting point is a Joe Bloggs member of the public who wants a taxi. The minister talked about the enormous frustration that exists with the great queues that build up when a major flight comes in from America. People cannot get a taxi, yet there are taxis that would like to pick people up but cannot because of the restrictions on them. To some extent, the petition is about how we ensure that such restrictions are removed and that rules that restrict members of the public from accessing a taxi service are not in place. The minister is right to say that the Executive's focus is on developing public transport infrastructure. If that means that members of the public can take a train to the nearest point to Glasgow airport and then take a taxi from the railway station to the airport—and do the same in reverse on the return journey—how can we cope with the situation in which they are then confronted with a huge queue?
I agree with all your concerns. The issues are complex. I know that the airport operators would argue that the arrangements and contracts that they have in place guarantee a high level of service throughout the airport's opening hours and that they have airport taxis available at a guaranteed level, which would not necessarily be the case if matters were left to the free market. They ensure that taxis are there into the evening when there are not so many flights. It is hugely frustrating for everyone—the taxi companies concerned, the airport operator and passengers—when there is a big queue outside an airport, yet empty taxis are going back into the centre of Glasgow, Edinburgh or Aberdeen. The byelaws that we are about to approve will not tackle that situation directly but will bring in regulation of private hire cars in a way that has not happened before. I do not know whether Caroline Lyon would like to comment on the legal implications or the consequences of the byelaws.Let me get to the heart of the issue. We might want to have separate discussions with airport operators, taxi companies and private hire companies on the matter. It is an important issue that causes a lot of complaints. It has an impact on the first impression that people get of Scotland when they arrive at Prestwick, Aberdeen, Edinburgh or Glasgow airports and want to get to the centre of town or to another part of Scotland. However, although the issue is important, we will not be able to address or resolve it in the context of the petition.
I will press you on that point. You have opened an important door in respect of the way in which we might take the petition forward. You are right to say that the petitioner is talking about what it perceives as unfair competition, but in all the correspondence that I have had—in e-mails and other forms of communication—the service to the public has been at the heart of the matter.I, for one, would be much happier if you could give a commitment this morning to the Public Petitions Committee that you will take forward the discussions between Glasgow Airport, BAA and the taxi companies to see how we can tackle the fundamental issue of preventing the frustration that can arise when passengers come off a plane. Such discussions are vital and are at the heart of everything that the taxi drivers have said. BAA's charge—the £5,000 per annum charge to recoup its costs—is part of the issue. In my opinion, as public representatives we must ensure that the public are at the heart of everything.
I am happy to correspond with BAA and the other airport operators on the issue and to copy the responses to the Public Petitions Committee and to the Local Government and Transport Committee.I should perhaps go into a little bit more detail about the final delay in the approval of the byelaws, which was to do with my concern about access for disabled passengers. Members will notice that in some of the papers that are before them there is reference to where buses are allowed to park and whether that is 101m or 99m from the airport entrance. Even in this age of tightened security and terrorism threats that affect all forms of public transport, particularly our airports, it is very important that disabled people have good access to check-in facilities. I wanted to see whether anything could be done in the byelaws to strengthen the rights of disabled people, so there was a final discussion about whether that would be appropriate. In the end, we did not—or could not—change the byelaws in that regard, but that does not mean that, as part of my wider responsibilities as Minister for Transport, I do not regard the issue as important. On disabled passengers and on the queues that build up outside airports when a lot of passengers are looking for a taxi at once because a big flight has been delayed or several flights arrive at the same time, I am happy to correspond with Scottish airport operators to try to urge improvements. I am sure that all members of Parliament would welcome such improvements.
I am pleased to hear you say that that will be part of your emphasis and that you will correspond on the matter. However, given that we are approaching one of the major times of the year for tourists coming to Scotland, I ask that as well as corresponding you perhaps hold a summit meeting, because this is an urgent issue that must be addressed. I have stood in queues at Glasgow airport, and it is not edifying for passengers to find taxi queues while empty taxis pass by. The situation is urgent. I hope that you will convene a major meeting with all concerned, as well as corresponding with the committee.
I am very conscious that the air route development fund has significantly increased the number of direct flights from Scotland and the number of people who want to come to Scotland. Many of those people are tourists, a point that is reflected in the tourism figures on people coming to Scotland, which have significantly improved over recent months. At the same time, many people come to Scotland for business purposes, and it gives completely the wrong impression of Scotland if there are lengthy queues and delays in moving from the airport to the city centre. I will discuss with officials the best way to pull together individuals from appropriate airports so that we get a meeting that is as high level as possible. I take on board Helen Eadie's suggestion.
The public perception, insofar as there is one, of airport byelaws is that they relate to safety and the security of aircraft and passengers. One of the issues that lie behind this petition is that the petitioner feels that, in this instance, BAA saw an opportunity to use byelaws to strengthen its own commercial position. Why were you persuaded that that was not the case?
I will ask Caroline Lyon to respond on that issue. However, the simple and central reason is that the relevant byelaws do not in any way affect the ability of the airport operators to charge—they do not empower charging and do not affect the level of charges. The byelaws are quite technical in nature and most of them relate to the issue of airside facilities in the more private, secure part of the airport. We have been very careful in our scrutiny of the byelaws and believe that they are fair and appropriate. They could not be used to increase or introduce charges in the way that has been suggested.
The byelaws are made under the Airports Act 1986, which provides the vires or powers for them. It is clear that the purpose of the byelaws is to regulate the use and operation of the airport and the conduct of all persons within the airport. There is an illustrative list of the type of things that may be included in the byelaws. As was said, they concern securing the safety of aircraft, controlling the operation of aircraft and preventing obstruction. There are also provisions related to the regulation of vehicular traffic.The byelaws do not impose any charges and the enabling provisions do not enable any charges to be imposed. We made the point to BAA very early in the correspondence that it could not use the byelaws as the basis for charging people for the use of any part of the airport. The byelaws do not attempt to do that. Therefore, it is difficult to see how the byelaws in any way benefit BAA's commercial interests.
One of the reasons that this petition is before us is to do with the petitioner's fears in that regard. However, I am grateful for the reassurance that the byelaws do not benefit BAA's commercial interests.
What do members think that we should do with the petition? The minister has given his very detailed response to the specifics in relation to the byelaws. The Enterprise and Culture Committee looked at the issue during its consideration of the Transport (Scotland) Bill that is before Parliament and stated that it was not appropriate for it to be addressed in the bill. Do members think that the Local Government and Transport Committee should consider some aspects of the issue?
I recognise the arguments on the byelaws. However, when I read the petition initially, the main problem identified by the petitioner was that Glasgow Airport Limited had reached an agreement with Flightpath NCP, which effectively took over a monopoly on off-site airport parking. It did that simply by limiting the ability of other people to pick up passengers in a reasonably convenient way from alternative off-site car parks.The minister said earlier that the issue comes under competition law. It probably comes under EU law as well. If we consider the decision on Charleroi airport—
I am trying to get to a point at which we can discuss what we will do with the petition.
From what I have heard, I am not sure that we have addressed the original point of the petition.
I do not know whether the Public Petitions Committee can address that; that is why I asked whether it would be appropriate for us to send the petition to a committee that can address it. The minister has spoken about his discussions with the airport authorities on the byelaws that apply, which the Scottish Executive can deal with. That issue has been considered by the Enterprise and Culture Committee, but that committee did not consider that the Transport (Scotland) Bill was the appropriate place to address it. However, we must consider whether it would be appropriate for us to refer the petition to the Local Government and Transport Committee to allow the petition to be considered in a wider context at a later date. We cannot address the point directly this morning.
Okay.
I appreciate very much the clarification that the minister has given us this morning; it has been really helpful. I applaud the Scottish Executive for developing the air routes that we now have. It is wonderful that we have great new air routes to parts of the world that we did not have routes to before—although that is bringing its own problems.The petition raises issues. In the third-last paragraph of the letter of 26 February 2004, BAA seems to rely, to a degree, on the byelaws—especially if we consider that paragraph along with the paragraph at the top of the same page.Perhaps we should send a copy of today's Official Report to BAA. We should also say that we have agreed with the minister that some issues remain outstanding. If we did that, we would cover some of the issues that the petitioner has raised.BAA seems to lack the will to take a comprehensive approach that would cover every taxi that passes the airport forecourt. BAA should take on board the concerns that we have raised this morning.
We should send the petition to the Local Government and Transport Committee. I was pleased with what the minister said about the byelaws, because that covered the basis of the petition. I am also pleased with what he said about GAPA and the facilities that are available for £5,000. It will be up to GAPA and others to write to BAA and try to organise a forum of sorts. The Local Government and Transport Committee should consider the issue in the long term.
We could ask the Local Government and Transport Committee to consider the issues that Helen Eadie has raised. If members agree, we will—
I am sorry, convener; I will try not to divert the discussion this time. When I consider the base requirement of the petition, I feel that the Enterprise and Culture Committee should be involved. We have talked about economic development at airports. The petitioner wanted to operate off-site businesses but was prevented from doing so. I wonder whether the Enterprise and Culture Committee would take a view on that.
We could certainly send the petition to the Enterprise and Culture Committee for information and ask it whether it is interested enough to look into the matter.I thank the minister for coming to the committee this morning and for his apology in relation to the communications difficulties. I think that I can say on behalf of the committee that we accept that apology.Members indicated agreement.
Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 27 April 2005 Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 15
- New Petitions Petitions · 86
- New Petitions Petitions · 47
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 47
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.