The next new petition to be considered this morning is PE831, by Catriona Leslie, on behalf of Portree community council. The petitioner is calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review its policy on public libraries to ensure appropriate provision in rural areas. Catriona Leslie is here to make a brief statement to the committee, which will be followed by a discussion. I thank her for coming along.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Public Libraries (PE831)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Catriona Leslie Portree Community Council 23
- Mike Watson Ind 12
- Michael McMahon Lab 3
- Sandra White SNP 3
- Phil Gallie Con 3
- Helen Eadie Lab 2
- Campbell Martin Ind 1
The record
47 contributionsThank you for allowing me to attend today's meeting to speak on an issue that is close to the hearts of people in Skye. Highland Council is insisting on closing Portree's very successful public library, which is in the centre of the village, and incorporating it into the proposed new high school, several hundred yards from the centre of the village, along a main road that is very exposed to the elements. We understand that the Public Petitions Committee may not be able to intervene in individual cases such as ours, but we hope that, even so, by bringing our problems to its attention we may help to prevent other communities from suffering the same fate.The removal of the public library from its current central position in Portree will not only inconvenience a large number of regular users, but will have a detrimental effect on shops and businesses, which already suffer from loss of trade due to the new out-of-town supermarket. Currently, the library is within easy walking distance of hotels, cafes, banks, shops, the medical centre and other facilities. That enables residents, people who work in the village and visitors to use its services quickly and conveniently. Primary school children use the library for study after school, and parents do not have to worry about them crossing a busy main road, which they would have to do in the proposed new location. People arriving in the village by car or public transport can combine a visit to the library with other activities. Many use it as a meeting place and somewhere that is comfortable, welcoming and free, where they can catch up on newspapers, meet friends before going home or wait for a bus.Combined school and public library services may work well in smaller communities, but we believe that a one-size-fits-all policy should not be applied and that the needs of each town or village should be assessed with full regard to its individual circumstances. In larger schools, there are bound to be conflicts of interest regarding such matters as opening times and opportunity for quiet study. In addition, security issues are raised when several hundred members of the public go in and out of a school each day. Recently, we have seen that two community schools in the Western Isles may have to ban members of the public during school hours in order to comply with national guidelines on security. In those schools, the library and swimming pool are not open to public use during the school day although, until now, the canteen has been a shared facility during school hours. The director of education in the Western Isles has stated that such schools would not be permitted today, yet Highland Council is insisting on shared facilities in many of the new schools that it plans to build. When a school is in the centre of a village, it might be more acceptable to share facilities, but in cases such as ours in which elderly or disabled people will have to use cars, taxis and buses to reach the library, many people will just cease to use it. The average visit to a library takes only seven minutes. How many people are prepared to get on a bus for a seven-minute visit to a library and then wait for up to an hour to get home again? Moreover, it would simply not be practicable for a worker who wanted to visit the library in their lunch hour.In tourist areas such as ours, many visitors use the library and its internet facilities in the summer months, which increases pressure on space. Such an attraction is important for visitors, but they are much less likely to visit the library if it is some distance from the village, especially in bad weather—as members might know, we have quite a lot of that weather in Skye. In addition, people on cruise ships or coach tours would not have enough time to walk to the school to use the internet or to look up something in a book.Even the nicest teenagers can be noisy, clumsy and intimidating en masse, and many older and disabled people and people such as my sister who have limited vision can find it intimidating to make their way through a crowd of lively teenagers to reach the library. We understand that, in some areas in Highland region where the public library has been placed in a school, the mobile library has had to be reinstated to accommodate people who are reluctant or unable to go to the school.Many of the high school pupils in Portree who use the library after school hours are adamant that they would not go back to school in the evening if they wanted to use the public library. The new public library in the centre of Stornoway has been a huge success. In that case, a conscious decision was made not to put the library into a school, with excellent results.We are aware that funding is probably behind the policy to incorporate public libraries in schools. As an article in The Herald has pointed out, cutting back on library spending is one economy for which Scotland will pay dearly in diminished quality of life. The country that housed the world's first Carnegie library ought to know that in its head and in its heart.
I think that you have already answered some of my questions. However, as far as transport, particularly for elderly people, is concerned, when I was in Portree a couple of weeks ago I did not see too many buses going back and forth. I wonder whether you can tell us more about that. Secondly, will you comment on the statement in our briefing note that the facilities will be open"some 365 days a year for up to 15 hours per day"?
At the moment, we have what is called the village bus, which, because it transports children to and from school, operates at fairly limited times of the day. Approximately once an hour, it goes around the village and out to the Aros heritage centre.I should also point out that there is a little walk up to the school, which anyone with a disability will find difficult. The bus will not drop people where the children are dropped, because on the plans for the new school—I must not go into them, but they are horrendous—the bus dropping area will be turned into a play area during the school day. As a result, people who get off the bus will have to walk up to the library in the rain and wind. When they come out of the library, they will have to wait perhaps an hour for a bus to take them home again.When I spoke to the director of education about that, he said, "Oh, well, you can just lay on minibuses." However, he did not say where the money for that would come from. In any case, a minibus with only two passengers is not economical.I am sorry—what was your second question?
Our briefing note says that the facilities will be open"365 days a year for … 15 hours per day".I cannot quite believe that. After all, schools close for school holidays, and we also need to consider certain safety aspects as far as the kids are concerned. How many hours will the facilities be open?
In the early stages of discussions about the school, the director of education said that the library would be open for the whole of the school day and in the evening as well. I tackled him about that after a planning meeting the other day and he said, "Oh well. Opening hours will have to be timetabled." To me, that suggests that the library will not be open for the whole of the school day.The current public library is not open for the whole of the school day, but it is open to a certain timetable all year round. People know that the timetable will not change because of school holidays. The facilities in Ullapool and Gairloch are often cited to us as being very successful, but the opening hours there are very limited during school holidays.We have been given many guarantees about the library that we know will not happen. As a result, I am sorry to say that we now do not believe any of the guarantees. We were told that the new library would be three times the size of the existing library, but in the current plans it is approximately one and a half times the size and will also incorporate the school library. I have not done the sums, but there is a net reduction in space, quite apart from the net reduction in the numbers of people who might use the library.
A difficulty that members may have with the petition is that the issue is really one for the local authority. As you said, we should not consider such issues as having a one-size-fits-all solution. Every community is different and that is why local authorities take the decisions.I am looking desperately for some way of widening the argument so that the Scottish Executive could become involved. The only one I can think of is that the Government is, I believe, in favour of community schools. Community schools are all embracing, covering issues such as libraries. Has Highland Council sold the library project as a community school project, in line with Scottish Executive policy?
Yes. The council has told us that it is Scottish Executive policy. In our opinion, the council has totally failed to consult people properly. The community council devised a questionnaire to put in the library to find out what people thought about the project, but the questionnaire was banned. We were told that it was biased.We have asked time and again for a public meeting so that people can at least ask council officials what will happen. However, the council will not hold such a meeting. We had 700 signatures on a petition asking for a public meeting, but the council paid no attention.
The role of a community council is to sound out public opinion and to ensure that the public are well informed. In my view, there is a statutory requirement on councils to fit in with community council requests if the purpose is to inform the public and to seek public opinions. However, you are saying that Highland Council will not co-operate with your community council; it will not even allow the details of your petition to be placed in the public library.
The council has decided that the library project will happen and that it does not matter what anybody thinks. That is the impression that we get. It is the council's policy.To a certain extent, the council blames the Scottish Executive. It says, "This is Scottish Executive policy and we must follow it." However, we find it hard to understand how Stornoway can get away with it but we cannot. Stornoway decided that it did not want its library to be out of town but that it wanted it in the centre. That library is working really well.Our current library building is old. It is in what were originally a supermarket and a garage, and it has problems. However, an alternative site, which is equally central, has been offered free of charge by a local hotel in exchange for the site of the current library. A local architect has drawn up plans that could incorporate the library with the museum service, which is also severely underfunded and cramped away in little corners. The council has not even bothered to come and look at the plans. It is completely blinkered.I appreciate that there may be nothing that the committee can do to help us. However, nobody else has listened, so we have come to you. The plans for the school will go to the Scottish Executive very shortly for approval. Because Highland Council will have to ask itself for planning permission, I believe that the application has to be approved by the Executive. We do not know whom to approach to ask for at least some more time or for something to stop this great thing rolling on without any proper consultation. A lot of people feel uninformed. If a public meeting was held and we were told what was happening, people would at least know what was going on.Even when we held a march in the village, people came up to us and asked what it was about—they had not heard. We have written to the local paper and have done everything that we can, but, as you know, community councils do not have money and we cannot afford huge campaigns or a referendum, such as Dingwall held on its high school, although Highland Council paid no attention. Indeed, the same thing is happening in Dingwall: its public library is being moved into the school, even though the residents of Dingwall do not want that any more than we do.
I understand that Highland Council has consulted on a public-private partnership to build around 10 schools in the Highlands. I wonder how much consultation there has been on the specific issue that you have raised of incorporating community facilities into the proposed new schools. What sort of consultation has there been on the specific issue that you are complaining about? You have made a strong case against incorporating the library into the school—or a new school—in Portree. Have you had the opportunity to make that case to Highland Council? If so, how did it address the concerns that you raised?
Before I was on the community council, I wrote to John Farquhar Munro—it is sad that he is not here—and Charles Kennedy about the library aspect, which is the subject with which I was first involved and in which I was first interested. Their replies enclosed the same letter from Bruce Robertson. It does not matter to whom one writes, the same letter comes back. Sometimes, the paragraphs have been moved, which can be done on a word processor, but the letter is the same. Highland Council has never approached the community council to discuss the matter.In the early stages, there was a small advertisement in the local paper, which said that there was to be a meeting about library provision. The advertisement did not say that the library was to be moved into the school; the subject was simply library provision. Seven members of Portree community council went to that meeting and made firm objections to what was proposed. Similar meetings were held in Uig and Dunvegan. Nobody attended the meeting in Uig and three people attended the meeting in Dunvegan, yet that is what Bruce Robertson has called public consultation. All it was was somebody in a room to whom people could talk; it was not a meeting.A public meeting was then held in the school on the whole school proposition. I was unable to go to the meeting, because I was away, but people who went to it said that about 250 people were there. No questions to the general meeting were allowed to be asked from the floor and people were divided almost instantly into separate groups and given presentations. At the end, people were selected—I am not sure whether they were elected or selected—to go on a steering committee, with different aspects of the village having representation. No one was chosen or invited to take part as a library user and no one was chosen because they were on the community council. One lady who was chosen to be on the steering committee is on the community council and is a part-time librarian, but she was selected because of her interest in the youth problems in the village. On one occasion, when she spoke about something to do with the library, she was told, "You're not here for that." She was also reprimanded by her superiors in the library for having taken part in our march and for participating in the petition. They said that, as an employee, she should not criticise Highland Council in public.
I am surprised to hear those last remarks, which seem to be a throwback to a bygone age. I have a couple of general questions. How far is the proposed site of the new library from the existing library?
It is not that far. It is probably less than a mile; it might even be about half a mile. The issue is not the distance. If one is in a village and the rain comes pouring down, one can pop into a shop or doorway, but there is no shelter at the proposed new site.
So it is quite outside the village and not in the suburbs.
Yes. Where does a village begin and end? It is closer than the supermarket, but it is not in the central part where everything is apart from the supermarket and the school.
At what stage in the process is Highland Council with the proposal?
The proposal was put into the outline planning permission for the new school—it involved demolishing the old school and building a new school with a public library and swimming pool. At the beginning of this week, we had the proper detailed planning application and we were told that the petition was not relevant because the application had already been passed in principle—we could not say at that stage that the library must not be incorporated.
I see. The proposal for the school has gone ahead.
Yes, and the school is to contain the library.
Are you proposing that the school should go ahead on the proposed site but that somehow the library should be detached and another site found for it in the village?
We certainly think that the library should be detached from the school. We would also like someone to listen to us about the problem of the school and the existing site, which is far too small—that is one reason why the library is not the size that we were originally told that it would be. The building is to be right next door to the existing school, which will go on being used, so, as you can imagine, the children will have to live, work and try to study on what is effectively a building site for two or three years.
We have had that happen in Glasgow and it is a considerable problem.
It is absolutely horrendous.
In response to a question from Campbell Martin, you said that you have written to your elected representatives but that you have not had an adequate reply. I am surprised that John Farquhar Munro is not here to deal with the issue.
We have had replies from our elected representatives.
What have they said?
They have asked Bruce Robertson, our director of education, for his comments and have just sent us copies of his letters. I did not hear it, but earlier this week John Farquhar Munro said on the radio that he was concerned about the situation and the lack of consultation. At least he has stated his worries in the public arena.
Will you be seeking a meeting with him to try to get his support?
I was hoping to see him today, but he is not here.
The petition states:"We have been told by Highland Council that it is Scottish Parliament policy to incorporate Public Libraries within schools."I think that you must mean Scottish Executive policy, but, nonetheless, the policy is not exclusive; it is an option. You have also given us the example of the Western Isles, although there is probably an aversion to taking on people from the Western Isles for various reasons, all of them positive. My serious point is that there can be an exception to that policy; it is an option. The proposed approach can be taken and no doubt there are places where it is suitable. You are saying that it is not suitable in this case and that Highland Council ought to accept that. Are there any other examples in the Highland Council area of a new school or library being built recently and not being under the same roof?
Not that I can find. The schools that have been built most recently are those at Ullapool, Gairloch, Drumnadrochit—Glen Urquhart High School—and Ardnamurchan and they all incorporate the library. We have been to look at Gairloch and Ullapool, where the school rolls consist of something like 200 kids. That is a completely different ball game. In Ullapool, the school is much more central.I am going to visit the school in Drumnadrochit next week. I understand that the school gets to use the library for two days a week and the public get to use it for three. The library is not open to both at the same time and the community has asked for the mobile library service to be put on again. The same thing happened in Fortrose.
Presumably the new library would not be an alternative to the mobile library. Is there still a mobile library that serves the many outlying areas on the Isle of Skye?
There is, and that service will continue for the outlying areas. Our problem is that people who live in Portree will find the new library difficult because of the timings, the distance, the weather and the sheer inconvenience.
There is concern that the library may be inaccessible to the general public during school hours for the reasons that you have given us.
That is of deep concern to us. The librarians tell us that, because of the spread of the island, the library is used most between 11 am and 4 pm, which is precisely when it will have to be closed for security reasons.
It can be appropriate to develop community-use schools—in my area, such schools have been developed powerfully over the years, although I accept Mike Watson's point that such schools are not appropriate in every instance. What has concerned me most this morning are two issues, the first of which is the style of consultation. It is appropriate for the committee to be part of the discussion about your representations to Highland Council. Most people would argue that it is not enough to place a small advertisement that says, "This is about provision of libraries." There should have been a fuller explanation—for example, a press release outlining exactly what kind of debate there would be. That would stimulate people to go along and it would avoid a situation in which just seven people turned up. There is a real issue there.The second issue that concerns me relates to Mike Watson's point about the part played by your elected representatives. I get the impression that all that has happened to date has been an exchange of letters with Charles Kennedy and John Farquhar Munro. There do not appear to have been any meetings between Highland Council and your elected representatives, encompassing yourselves as representatives of the community council. Will you clarify whether that is the case?
We have never had any meetings of that kind. Charles Kennedy and John Farquhar Munro have written to Bruce Robertson about the issue and they have sent me his written reply. There has never been a chance to sit round a table and no one has ever offered to come to the community council to explain their position. Scottish Water and the local housing association have taken the trouble to come to the community council to explain exactly what they are doing and to allow us to ask questions, but there has been no similar approach from Highland Council. Every time we have asked for a public meeting, we have been told that we might be able to have one once the plans are available. Such a meeting has never happened. I asked Bruce Robertson for a public meeting after the planning meeting and he said that that might be possible. However, it is too late—or it looks to be too late. The plans have gone through.
Convener, I suggest that we get views from the Scottish Library and Information Council, the Scottish Executive and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. Do other members agree that we ought to ask Highland Council for its views on consultation, because that is the general issue that arises from the petition? It is important that we ensure that every consultation, whether it concerns Greater Glasgow NHS Board or whomever, is appropriate and fully engages the public. Although consultation does not mean that we will accept the views of every community, at least it should be meaningful. I encourage Catriona Leslie to press Charles Kennedy and John Farquhar Munro to seek meetings with Highland Council on behalf of her community. If people do not get satisfaction after they have had correspondence with any organisation, they have to escalate matters and take things to the next stage, which would involve an MSP in this case.
Councillors have not been mentioned, but I would have thought that they would have been the initial link with Highland Council. Do they sit on your community council? What contact have you had with them?
Our councillor has been to one community council meeting in the past year. When I asked him in a public meeting whether he agreed that he should perhaps be representing the opinions of the people of Portree, he replied, "I am allowed to have my own opinion." He was elected unopposed, but he will be opposed at the next election.
That is good. I agree with Helen Eadie's suggestions. We should write to Highland Council. The Scottish Executive and the Scottish Library and Information Council have been mentioned, but Balfron High School has also rejected a similar plan. We are talking about guidelines; nothing is set in stone and there are examples of people rejecting the idea of having a public library in their school.
We have been told time and again that having the public library as part of the school is an essential part of the package and that, if we rock the boat or ask for something different, we might not get a school at all. That is blackmail.
We will write to the organisations that members have suggested that we get in touch with and will let you know what the responses are. I do not know your councillor and I do not know what his politics are or anything to do with the situation, but the code of conduct for councillors that the Scottish Parliament introduced under the Ethical Standards in Public Life etc (Scotland) Act 2000 does not allow a councillor to state publicly their opinion on a planning matter. If they do, they must absent themselves from any decision making. I must therefore say on the record that the councillor whom you mention might simply have been complying with the code of conduct. If the councillor was acting within the code, he was acting absolutely appropriately.
He said that he had to withdraw because he had stated his opinion before the most recent planning meeting. However, he stated his opinion in the press before the outline planning meeting but did not absent himself from that meeting.
We are not here to pass judgment on the councillor; I just think that it is important that we get on the record the fact that there is a code of conduct that he has to abide by. We will keep you informed of the responses that we receive and will ask you for your comments on them as we try to make progress on the matter.
Thank you. I am grateful for the chance to speak to somebody about the issue.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Apr 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 27 April 2005 Petitions · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 15
- New Petitions Petitions · 86
- New Petitions Petitions · 47
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 47
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.