Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Housing Stock Transfer (PE829)

Wednesday 27 April 2005 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 86 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

86 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Item 2 is consideration of new petitions, the first of which is PE829, from Mrs Anne Ayres, on behalf of the Carntyne Winget residents association. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to consider and debate the impact of the housing stock transfer on Scottish communities. Anne Ayres is here to make a brief statement in support of her petition. She is accompanied by James McCullagh and Robert Marshall. After your opening statement, we will discuss the points that you raise.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Good morning. I am here to present to the committee, on behalf of our community, notice of why we believe the housing stock transfer to local housing associations has not worked and how that has affected our community. Because of the type of construction of the houses we live in, which are Winget houses, we find ourselves looking to Glasgow Housing Association Ltd, our new social landlord, for help and guidance with our housing problem—a problem that affects 700 GHA tenants and 290 home owners. Instead of receiving the expected assistance, we have come up against a wall of non-co-operation and misinformation from the company. Not only is that difficult to understand, but the policy has cultivated within our community fear and distrust of the GHA.We have concluded that the GHA is failing in the duties that were given to it as part of the housing transfer deal in a number of ways, which I list as follows: lack of democracy, transparency, accountability, understanding, compassion, effective consultation processes and co-operation. Although we are an underfunded association, we have on behalf of the community had to search out possible alternatives to demolition. We have done so successfully, but providing such alternatives should not have been our job—it should have been the GHA's. Should not it have considered the alternatives and used a competitive tendering process?We have had to issue a monthly news bulletin at our own expense to keep the community informed about what is happening. We have had to provide for proper public meetings for debate of the issue; again, that is not our job. We have throughout the process attempted to consult the GHA, while it has hidden behind a public relations agency. It appears to be making judgments based on a financial agenda that has no regard for the social or psychological demographics of the community, which concerns us greatly, because we are speaking about people's homes, lives and futures.The GHA carried out one social survey but, when it did not get the result that it wanted, it appears that it simply disregarded it. Ninety-two per cent of the residents want to stay in their homes in their community, but the GHA does not elect people from the community; it appoints people who are not always known to the community and people who do not represent, or even know, the views of the community. However, the GHA refuses to speak with a democratically elected association that has been elected by the community solely for the purpose of saving our homes. We find that disconcerting. We know that we will not agree on every single item, but at the moment there is little willingness to work towards alternatives other than demolition, even though both we and the GHA know that such alternatives exist. It concerns us that the GHA appears to have a single-focus agenda. As a community, we have lost confidence in the GHA and in the idea of the housing stock transfer's being for the benefit of the community. We are strongly of the opinion that the GHA has not handled the post-housing transfer process in line with Government expectations or thinking.Today, our petition to you is to make the GHA accountable, if only to assist Carntyne in Glasgow to survive as a good mature community, and to make the GHA explore with us every option that might allow us to save our homes. We ask respectfully that the committee call the GHA to account on behalf of the community that we represent.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I have worked with Anne Ayres and the Carntyne community, as have other MSPs and councillors. I congratulate members of the community on the hard work that they have done with very limited resources. I have pictures of the houses that the GHA wants to demolish; I shall pass them round so that other members can look at them.Paragraph 4 of the briefing on the petition states:"In November 2003, Glasgow Housing Association accepted a recommendation from Keystone Tenant Managed Homes that no more houses should be let on the estate."Were the tenants consulted on that recommendation? What is the current situation with the houses that are not being let?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Do you mean the houses that are empty?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Yes. The briefing states that in 2003 the GHA entered into an agreement with Keystone Tenant Managed Homes Ltd not to let any more houses. Was the community consulted?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

No. We were never consulted about that. The GHA will not speak to us.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

You also sent out a pack, which I mentioned to the clerk. The pack contains a 1999 report by Glasgow City Council that says that the Carntyne Winget houses were not going to be demolished. Has the GHA commented on that report?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

In 1987, the Winget label was put on the Carntyne houses, because something had happened down in England and every Winget house was labelled. In 1990, the council published a report by Tom Lucas, which stated that different agencies had been involved in looking into the situation and had concluded that the houses were fine.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

No.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

You said that the GHA has not commented on the report and that the houses should not be demolished.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

When the GHA took over, there was a big propaganda exercise to the effect that Carntyne was crumbling and falling apart. There was in the newspaper a photograph of one house and the head of housing for the area. That spread fear into the community; everyone was terrified. Twenty per cent of our people are old people who have put every penny that they possess into their homes. Carntyne works: it is a good community that is not crumbling or falling down. There was a scare campaign going on, but we knew that our houses were not crumbling so we sought out engineers who could come in and help us. We—not the GHA—sought out those engineers.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I was going to ask about that. You sought out the engineers.Did the GHA consult the community about how it was carrying out the appraisal of the Winget houses? You mentioned the traffic lights system.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Yes, there was an appraisal. The housing association brought in Hilland Ritchie Consultants, which brought in T L Dempster Ltd. It went round all the doors, asked many personal questions and tried to offer people new houses, which did not exist in the community. The survey showed that 92 per cent of people were happy and wanted to stay in their houses in Carntyne.After that, we were subjected to the traffic lights system. The clerk of works came out with big long spirit levels and went round all the tenants' houses to see whether there were bulges in the walls or anything like that. They branded the houses as red, amber or green, which terrified the older people. The housing association organised meetings—not a public meeting for the whole community, but meetings for small groups. We all got letters telling us to go along in groups to the meetings.If a house was graded as red, it was in a bad way. It is possible that other people came in after that to look at the red houses. If someone's house was graded as amber, they had a wee bit more time. If it was graded as green, they were all right for a wee while. We have challenged the GHA all the way on everything that it has done, and it keeps moving the goalposts. Our information tells us that all the red houses bar two suddenly went back to amber. No work was done, so maybe God is answering our prayers. The two houses that did not go back to amber were the two that the GHA had opened up for examination.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I appreciate your coming here and the work that you have put into the petition. I represent a different part of Glasgow, which contains many local housing organisations that are in the same position but have not had the problems that you outline. I am struck that you say that there has been no transparency and no attempt to consult people. As you say, consultation is an integral part of the housing stock transfer. Keystone will have a management committee: how are the community representatives for that committee selected? I think you said that they were selected rather than elected.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Keystone should be open to everyone in Carntyne to join; by paying £1, people should be able to join and get a share certificate. I tried to do that but got a letter saying that I could not join until I had been before a committee. I was singled out and told, "No, I'm sorry. You'll have to come in front of so many people from the committee before you can join." That did not mean that I would be able to join; it meant that I was to go and be assessed by a committee.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

Was that not to join the committee, but just to join the tenants' organisation?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

I was to do that just to get my share certificate. I was told that I would have to go in front of people from the committee before they would even consider me as a Keystone member.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I had not heard about that. It seems to be wrong.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Well, it happened to me.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I want the committee to write to Keystone asking it to explain that behaviour.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

The management committee should be open to everyone.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

In the area that I represent, the housing organisations send out newsletters and have public meetings. When there is a major change, they inform everybody and they usually do a press release. There is a big change on-going in Castlemilk at the moment and the housing organisation there has issued a press release about it—it has not just notified local people. In the case that we are considering, practice seems to have been completely the opposite of that. Are there no newsletters?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Occasionally, we get newsletters after the fact, informing us of how great the housing association is. We asked the association to come to both of our public meetings to see whether it could help the community and try to calm it down. At the most recent public meeting, we wrote to everyone involved, including Keystone, the head of our local area and Michael Lennon. Keystone delayed for a couple of weeks, then quickly sent a newsletter to everyone, then wrote to us to say, "Sorry, we don't need to come to your public meeting. The information is in the public domain."

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is worrying behaviour. To follow up on my previous question, how are the community representatives on the committee of Keystone Tenant Managed Homes chosen?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

It all happens behind closed doors. There is Keystone, and there is Carntyne Winget residents association. I have a letter with me from a resident who managed to get on Keystone, or one of its committees, behind closed doors. He was summoned and told that he must not tell anyone outside what was happening. How can people represent their community if they cannot speak to people about their views and let them know what is happening?

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

Minutes of the management committee meetings should be in the public domain.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

I know, but the resident whom I mentioned was told that he must not reveal anything that happened.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

No.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

Could you get copies of the minutes?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Yes, probably.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

There are certainly a lot of questions to follow up. The last issue that I will raise is a matter that Anne Ayres mentioned in her opening remarks. She mentioned a social survey, which she said produced the wrong result so the GHA tried again. Can you tell us more about that?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

The traffic lights system was used after that.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

What was the purpose of the social survey?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

The social survey was conducted by Hilland Ritchie Consultants, who employed T L Dempster. They went round the doors and asked a lot of questions. They asked whether people worked, whether they wanted to stay in the area, what size their house was and who lived in the house. They asked a lot of personal questions. They asked whether people would like a new house, although no houses were being built in the community to give to anyone. Ninety two per cent of people said, "We like it here. We want to stay here. We have a community that we love and we are happy. There is 2 per cent policing and people wait 20 years to come here. It works and Carntyne works." That was the result that they got, so they had to publish it, which is something else that we have mentioned. After we spoke to the press, the GHA had to make a statement and publish the figures: 92 per cent of people wanted to stay.

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

After that, they brought in what you call the traffic lights system.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Yes. We got the traffic lights system then. Two focus groups were organised. Hilland Ritchie, who were brought in by the GHA, organised a meeting for the people of Carntyne. Some people, including me, went along. When you went in the door you were given a raffle ticket, which was put in a box. Hilland Ritchie had an entourage of architects who work with them. There were to be 20 people in each group, but Hilland Ritchie said that they could take only 18 people because there was already in place a chair for each group. The chair was chosen behind closed doors up at the GHA on Edinburgh Road and one other person was already selected for the groups. There was no democracy. People were placed on the focus groups. If a person's raffle ticket was picked, they were on the group. There were 20 people on the group, but only 18 people could be chosen from residents because the chair had already been put in place by the people at Edinburgh Road and someone else was placed by the people from Edinburgh Road. There was a "rebuild" group and a "retain" group. I do not think that the GHA got the results that it wanted from that. The last meeting was held last week; that is the process finished. We got all the information from the groups about what was happening.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

Were there any concerns about the condition of housing in Carntyne when the houses were still owned by Glasgow City Council, or has the matter arisen since the stock was transferred to the housing association?Secondly, I know that I am asking you to speculate, but what is the reason for the actions of the housing association in respect of the condition of the houses in Carntyne?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

I am here to speak for the people in Carntyne. We feel that the agenda is demolition of the houses. We are on a prime site, if you want to put it that way, for housebuilding. No matter what it comes up against, the GHA seems to be trying to demolish our houses, build new ones and privatise part of the development. Perhaps people would end up getting new houses, but there are no new houses and there is no room for new houses. There is nothing like that in Carntyne at this stage. We feel that the GHA's agenda is just about demolition. The GHA keeps changing the focus. Whenever we challenge it, it changes the focus and brings another matter in, so we keep moving. The GHA always muddies the waters, if I can put it that way.

Campbell Martin Ind West of Scotland
link

Were any problems identified when the houses were owned by Glasgow City Council?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

The Winget label was applied to the houses in 1987. As far as I understand it, mortgages were still being given for them from the council. It has been said that nobody got a mortgage after 1987, but that is not true—people got mortgages from building societies. In 1990, a report came out that said that the houses were all right; I have given the committee that report by Tom Lucas. All of a sudden we were settled and happy. On many occasions money that should have been spent in the community was diverted elsewhere. When the stock was transferred to the GHA, there was suddenly all the propaganda. All of a sudden we were told that we would be losing our homes, that Carntyne is crumbling and that we have great problems.It has come to our attention that £33 million has been set aside for Carntyne Winget housing. We worked that out as being £47,000-odd per house for 700 tenants. The evidence that I gave the committee is frightening; it shows that although we can get our houses brought up to standard by engineers for under £20,000, Hilland Ritchie estimated the cost at £66,000 for some houses, including a lot of cosmetic stuff. The focus keeps changing. Our focus is on saving the community; let us deal with the cosmetics after that.The Glasgow Housing Association keeps focusing on the cosmetics and the consultant from Hilland Ritchie says that there is a shortfall. We know from what engineers have told us that it costs under £20,000 to fix the houses and bring them up to standard. I spoke to the consultant from Hilland Ritchie a week ago and he kept saying, "No. Even the house owners don't have enough money. Even if you could get a grant, £20,000 is the limit. You won't be able to save your houses for that kind of money." The cost is estimated by Hilland Ritchie way up at £66,000, compared with under £20,000.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I have just looked at some of the photographs that Sandra White passed round a moment ago. Many of the four-in-a-block houses look really good, but a number seem to have structural problems, such as damp and so on. When the houses were labelled as Winget houses, was that because there was a fundamental structural problem with them?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

I will pass over to Bob Marshall, the engineer, to answer that.

Robert Marshall
link

The question of Winget houses was brought up in 1987, but the problem occurred in England, not in Carntyne. Just after the war 60 years ago, a building system was introduced that consisted of constructing buildings using what is called a ring-beam. The floor is a ring-beam and the middle section is a ring-beam; they are connected by metal rods that interlink. In England one of the buildings bulged at the front and buckled. The Government subsequently investigated and said that it would not use that system any longer but, given that the houses would not fall down, would let them continue to be used until the end of their lifetime.The Carntyne association asked me to consider the residents' predicament, because they were making inquiries but were not getting information. Engineering in housing has moved forward since 1987—we are working on affordable houses that have steel structures and which we are able to build and make available to the public for less than £60,000. It seems crazy to knock down housing stock that is well able to be repaired using modern technology.If you walk around the Winget housing estate, you will see houses that are worse than those in the photographs. That is down to the building system. When one builds using a ring-beam, the concrete block that is used is 18 in sq and is placed on the base. The next block slots into that and the next one slots into that, so we end up with a grid of criss-crosses. If the building is not maintained, water gets in and bursts through the space between the concrete blocks. It looks terrible; if you look at the worst-case pictures of Winget houses you will see that that is the case. All the cracks run vertically or horizontally along the beams. They are not structural problems; they are problems to do with lack of maintenance by Glasgow City Council. If the council had maintained its buildings properly, there would never have been water ingress.When we were asked to read the report we said, "Maybe the Glasgow Housing Association is correct." That was our first refuge. We then went to find out what the Glasgow Housing Association was examining. We came up with something called the Curtins report, which was commissioned in the late 1990s—1998 I think—on Winget housing for the former Glasgow District Council. Winget association got a report from the Curtins group. Curtins Consulting Engineers plc is a very large organisation. It reported back to Glasgow City Council stating that nothing was wrong with Winget housing that maintenance would not repair. A copy of that report can be accessed by committee members. We are talking about the same steel pin problem that caused big slabs to fall from tower blocks. Although Winget housing had a question mark over it and needed to be watched, the photographs that have been supplied to the committee show that some of the houses have been repaired and look rather nice. They have insulation problems, similar to the problems in Easterhouse, Hillington and other places where houses were built without inter-house insulation, but residents have learned to live with those problems. They have learned to stop making noise at 9 o'clock, helped by good neighbour agreements, which is how the problem has been handled to date. Anybody living in a Winget house would have a problem if their neighbours stamped about—I live in a four-apartment house in Hillington, so I know what I am talking about.My company took a fresh look at the problem. It is a modern engineering company that has built thousands of houses all over the world, and is currently contemplating building 20,000 rapid-build affordable houses in Sri Lanka for the Sri Lankan Government.The Winget houses in Carntyne are repairable. In a worst-case scenario, insulating inside and outside the house to an insulation value of 0.17—twice as good as current insulation standards—a block of four houses could be repaired for £40,000, which is £10,000 per house. One of my company's sister companies has submitted a bid to the GHA via A Balfour and Company to carry out such repairs. We have offered to build a prototype and a pilot, and that is being considered by A Balfour, the GHA and Hilland Ritchie. We do not know whether they want a demonstration, but we will hear from them in due course.I will produce chartered engineers' signatures to verify what I am saying. The important point for the committee to understand is that the houses are repairable affordably. There is no reason to take them down.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I am not making any judgment on what Mr Marshall has said, but I will play the devil's advocate. The photographs that have been sent round show that some of the houses look quite bad, although it appears that many thousands of pounds have been spent on roof renewals and the installation of double-glazed windows. Some of the houses look well but others show signs of dampness and water penetration. In such circumstances, housing experts and architects often say that it is cheaper to demolish and rebuild, and get a better home at the end of the day.One of the key Executive programmes, operated in partnership with the private sector, Scottish Gas and others, is the warm deal insulation programme for residents with cavity wall insulation problems and other problems. Has work under that programme been undertaken in the Carntyne area? The programme is a major step forward in helping to provide warmer homes, as part of the programme for government.

Robert Marshall
link

I will take the questions in reverse order. We approached the solution for Winget housing understanding clearly the insulation needs. My company is currently cladding half of Glasgow using its own insulation systems. It has already done work for Glasgow City Council and the GHA. Almost every company that clads a building with new cladding systems, which also waterproof buildings, uses systems provided by my company. We manufacture the systems in our factory in Glasgow. Other companies do not see our name, but they use our systems.When we clad a house, we put a steel frame outside and inside and insulate both so that the energy saving is 25 per cent. We put two walls in and pin them together; we sandwich the existing wall, which ceases to have any function because the entire house is now held up by a steel girdle. To insulate the house, the steel girdle is then clad in the same way as houses are all over Glasgow and, from the outside, it looks like a brand new house because it is harled and finished in that manner. The only penalty that the owner pays is that the inside of the house loses 20mm and the outside width expands by 60mm, so the window ledge will increase on the inside by 20mm. Otherwise, it is not possible to tell that the house has not been newly built.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

I am grateful to you for that technical explanation, but my question was about the cost-benefit analysis of demolishing a house to rebuild. You have given a good description of the technical side of it, but what are the economics of doing what you describe versus pulling down and rebuilding?

Robert Marshall
link

I answered that in response to a previous question, but perhaps you did not pick up on it. We have provided the GHA with a fixed quotation for repairing a four-in-a-block set of houses of £40,000. That is £10,000 a house, which is a long way short of the £40,000 about which the GHA is talking. That quotation is fixed and comes from a reputable company; we can guarantee it and deliver it.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I have a question for Anne Ayres. Keystone Tenant Managed Homes no longer lets homes in Carntyne. Until it stopped, was there a demand for homes? Was there any problem with letting?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

If you are asking whether there was any problem with people getting homes in Carntyne, the answer is no, because people were coming into Carntyne and renting houses.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Yes, and there is still a demand; people still want to come to Carntyne to live. There always was a demand and people were always coming in. The GHA stopped that and started to allow the houses to lie empty.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

It is a waste of public money if houses are lying empty and unused.There seems to be no doubt at all about Mr Marshall's figures. At £10,000 per house, there is no argument about the cost compared with new build as long as we end up with a reasonable house. What is the capital valuation of the houses after the repairs have been carried out? What is the lifespan of the houses from completion of the repairs?

Robert Marshall
link

In the quotation that we provided to the GHA, we confirmed that we have Building Research Establishment certificates. Anyone who wants to mortgage a house will go to an insurance company, which will go to the BRE and ask whether the house is fit for mortgage. The houses that we repair are fit for a 30-year mortgage and have a lifespan of more than 60 years after repair. We guarantee that by insurance.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Did Sandra White want to ask another question?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I am happy with the responses to Helen Eadie's and Phil Gallie's questions, as I wanted to ask about the valuation.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Mrs Ayres, I have one question before we recommend what to do with the petition. You said that there was an agenda to privatise—I think that that was the word that you used. By "privatise", do you mean taking the current stock and handing it over to a private company or do you mean emptying the houses to give them over to a private developer who would develop new housing on the ground?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

I believe that the GHA wants to demolish Carntyne. It might rebuild part of it for some Carntyne people, but I believe that it will also privatise a part of the area with private developers to bring in more money for the GHA.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

So the houses would simply be given to a private company to run in the private rented sector.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

We believe that part of the development would be done in that way and that some houses might be rebuilt for people, although I cannot really say what will happen.Bob Marshall has spoken. We have two engineers on board with two different designs for the GHA, which is important. The top engineer in Britain has submitted a design to the GHA, so it has plenty to consider. I am told that they are waiting for the GHA to okay a pilot scheme. Similar prices have been agreed. It should be remembered that the pilot scheme will take in everything—from the largest thing to the smallest thing—that could go wrong and so the costings will be overestimated. However, people are still coming up with the same prices.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Mr Marshall can say something before we discuss what to do with the petition.

Robert Marshall
link

If it would help the committee, I would be happy to print out and send the bid documents, drawings and other things for members to consider so that they can see what we are saying.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Having that information would not do any harm. It could help our considerations.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I would like to clarify matters. Anne Ayres mentioned privatisation. Does she mean that houses will be demolished and that the land will be built on? Furthermore, engineers have submitted bids. Has the GHA commented on the bids from Bob Marshall, Adams Engineering and the others? Has the GHA been accommodating in letting people into houses to examine structural aspects?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

What do you mean by structural aspects? Are you asking whether the GHA's engineers have been into the houses?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

Has the GHA been accommodating in letting engineers who have submitted bids go around houses?

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

The engineers have been taken into an empty house and have been allowed to look at it. Hilland Ritchie Consultants did that. We are not all engineers, but members of the committee are peers of the people in the GHA and, if they look at the figures, they will see that they are figures for knocking down the houses and building new ones. A consultant from Hilland Ritchie Consultants has admitted that it would be dearer to put up new houses—when I spoke to him two weeks ago, he mentioned a figure of in the region of £100,000 by the time that all the extra costs are added. We think that the figures have been overestimated by £60,000. For example, the list that has been provided shows a figure of £4,800—almost £5,000—to fix a garden the size of a postage stamp. Even if it does so after we are here, will the committee consider those frighteningly high costs? There is a big case for decantation. The top-line figures stop at a certain price that is not too high, but the costings can jump from £17,000 to £57,000, which is frightening and needs to be questioned.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Phil Gallie may ask one final question before we discuss recommendations.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

I have an observation to make rather than a question to ask while Mr Marshall is here. I presume that if the residents were successful and there was a determination to go ahead and repair the houses, any repair work would be put out to tender. If that happened and Mr Marshall's papers were passed to the committee, they would become public information, unless they were held confidentially. I wonder whether Mr Marshall could mark any papers that he sends us as confidential, given the possibility of future tendering.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

That is entirely a matter for Mr Marshall. If he wants information to remain confidential, he will have to instruct the committee about that. If papers are provided as evidence, they could go into the public domain.

Robert Marshall
link

I can answer that fairly simply. Robert Marshall Associates is a firm of design engineers. The systems that we use are used by Powerwall Systems and other companies and it is extremely unlikely that Robert Marshall Associates would ever bid for the contract. One of our sister companies, Powerwall, provided the bid and would want its information to be kept within the committee. As this is a closed committee, I presume that that is what will happen. The matter is not of particular concern, because when the building—

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I should clarify that this is not a closed committee. Phil Gallie asked whether certain information could be made available, but information that you send to members of the committee can go into the public domain. If you want information to remain confidential, you must specify that and mark the information as confidential, so that it can be kept out of the public domain on the ground of commercial confidentiality. I must make it absolutely clear that this is not a closed committee. Everything in the committee's briefings that can go into the public domain will do so.

Robert Marshall
link

Everything that I say to the committee can go into the public domain, at the committee's discretion. We are hiding nothing from anybody. Indeed, my preferred route for the Winget houses would be for us to assist a local company by providing encouragement and training in utilising the systems. That would create employment in Carntyne. Through the Construction Industry Training Board and Glasgow Metropolitan College—the new college of building in Glasgow—we have arranged for special courses to be run should that ever happen. We would ask local companies whether they wanted to make a bid to be involved in the repair of Carntyne houses and, if they did want to be involved, we would be happy to train them to utilise the system.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

I invite recommendations from members on what to do with the petition.

Helen Eadie Lab Dunfermline East
link

The discussion has been interesting. In the interest of ensuring that we maximise the information that we have before we come to a view, can we send a copy of the Official Report of today's meeting to Communities Scotland, the Scottish Tenants Organisation, Shelter Scotland, the Property Managers Association Scotland and the Scottish Executive, and ask them to consider the issues that the petition and the discussion raise and to give us their views?

Mike Watson Ind Glasgow Cathcart
link

I agree with Helen Eadie's suggestion. However, I suggest that we do not write to the Executive yet, because Communities Scotland is an executive agency and can speak for the Executive. If the worst comes to the worst and we have to write to the Executive later, so be it, but a letter to Communities Scotland should cover the matter now.I also want to know the views of the GHA and Keystone Tenant Managed Homes. Although we cannot get too far into the specifics of the case, the way in which those organisations are operating—or not operating, given what we have heard—gives me great cause for concern. We need answers to the questions that have been raised.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow
link

I was going to mention the GHA too, so I concur entirely with what Mike Watson has said about Keystone and the GHA. Can we also ask the GHA about the £33 million that was apparently set aside? Anne Ayres said that the money was earmarked for the Winget houses.

Phil Gallie Con South of Scotland
link

The committee has been given a lot of technical detail. I am sure that Keystone's management committee has reasons for its decisions. Can we ask what research it carried out and what its proposals are for the houses, given that they are not currently being let? For example, can we have the costings for new build or repair, if such costings have been produced? Given that we are talking about a public body, such information will not be commercially confidential.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

Absolutely. We will write to the organisations with specific questions. Mrs Ayres is indicating that she wants to comment.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Do you want to know where I got the figure of £33 million from?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

You can hold back on that until we get a response from the GHA. Thank you for bringing the petition to the committee. When we have received responses from the organisations, we will inform you about them and take the matter forward.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Will you get all the engineering reports?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

We will ask all those questions.

Anne Ayres Carntyne Winget Residents Association
link

Thank you for letting me speak to the committee.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 27 April 2005 Petitions · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 15
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 86
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 47
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 3
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. Current Petitions Petitions · 47
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.