Petition PE545, from Miss M McDonald, on behalf of the Glasgow campaign against housing stock transfer, calls on the Parliament to investigate the alleged invalidity of the ballot held in relation to the proposed housing stock transfer in Glasgow, and to urge the Executive to affirm debt write-off without stock transfer and to provide enhanced public investment in council housing. Sandra White is here to speak to the petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Housing Stock Transfer (Glasgow) (PE545)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McAllion Lab 20
- Sandra White SNP 10
- Dr Winnie Ewing SNP 8
- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 5
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
44 contributionsThank you for allowing me to speak on behalf of the petitioners. I am pleased to be back at the Public Petitions Committee, which I served on at the very beginning of the Parliament. The committee has gone from strength to strength, as I always thought that it would. I am here to support the petitioners because I have also lodged a motion asking for an investigation of the stock transfer ballot. I thought that I should state that at the outset. Those of us who are against the way in which the stock transfer has been handled see a great many anomalies in the way that it has been done, not just morally but financially. Around £300 million has been sent to the Glasgow Housing Association, but it is now looking for another £100 million. Given the fact that there was a very small majority for the transfer, and that people have not been told exactly what is going on at the moment or what will happen in future, an investigation and reballot of the tenants is the way forward.
The petition falls into different parts. The first part concerns the alleged invalidity of the ballot itself, and there is to be a court case concerning that.
Yes.
The campaign has taken legal action, has it not?
It has. Two of the campaigners are here at the moment, if you want to ask them specific questions.
At this stage, we have finished hearing from witnesses. I was hoping that you would help the committee out.
The case is in the process of being taken to court, and the petitioners hope very much that it will be successful. That is the first part of the petition, which concerns the ballot of the tenants.The second part of the petition concerns the moneys and the anomalies in the transfer of £300 million of taxpayers' money, followed by a further £100 million of taxpayers' money. We do not believe that people have been told the truth about what has been happening. The date for the transfer was 28 November, but that deadline will not now be met. The Executive knows that it will not be met and so does the GHA, so one of the terms and conditions of the ballot has not been met. That merits investigation, along with the financial irregularities.
The problem that will face the committee—Winnie Ewing is our legal expert—is that, because the case is before the courts, we will be unable to deal with that aspect of the petition. The same will probably be true during Sandra White's members' business debate; any mention of the case will be ruled out of order, because it is before the courts.
Do we not know when the action was lodged, what it was saying or when it is likely to come to court?
I am told that it has not been lodged, but that it is likely to be lodged during November, so it is not sub judice at this stage.
So it might not come to court for a while.
It is entirely up to the petitioners. If they lodge the action in court, that would probably stymie any investigation by the Parliament until the courts have dealt with it.
At the moment, it is not stymied.
Is it the same petitioners? I am a bit confused.
Yes, it is the Glasgow campaign against housing stock transfer that is likely to lodge the action. The action has not been lodged yet.
Why are those campaigners not giving evidence if they are here today?
It would be out of order to take contributions from the floor at this stage.
Because of the legal action?
No. We could continue our consideration of the petition to find out for definite when the action is being lodged.
I can tell you now, if you will allow me to speak to the petitioners who lodged it. They will give us an update just now, if that is permissible. Is that reasonable?
Yes.
From the petitioners' point of view, perhaps there is some advantage in the fact that we do not know what the situation is. If no legal action is taking place, there is nothing to stop us from passing the petition to the Executive. Perhaps it is better to act in ignorance in the interests of the petitioners.
Could we hear from the petitioners?
Not at this stage. We will get Sandra White to speak to them.
Phil Gallie is right. The case cannot be sub judice. We do not know whether the matter will be taken forward, so we can speak to the petition today and perhaps forward it to the Executive. I am here to help the petitioners, who have travelled quite a long way to be here. They have more facts and figures than I do in respect of the pending court case. The committee might want to hear that information.
At this stage, the matter is not before the courts and is therefore not sub judice—therefore, there is no problem with our discussing the matter. If it subsequently goes before the courts, that could change everything, but that is an issue for the petitioners rather than the committee.
That is correct. I want to mention another matter that I have just found out about and that will be new to the committee—the lodging of an amendment relating to a new section on local authority housing debt in the Local Government in Scotland Bill. The new amendment pertains to the petition. I received information about it from the Deputy Minister for Finance and Public Services, Peter Peacock. It will be discussed at stage 2 next week. I have tried to clarify things and have been told that the amendment is on a technicality. However, if it falls, debt could not be transferred to the Treasury. Should I pass the information about the amendment to you, convener, or read it out?
Would you read it? I do not know what you are talking about at the moment.
Would you read it slowly, please?
I will. As I said, the amendment relates to the new section on local authority housing debt. The Executive says:"This amendment will provide the Scottish Ministers with the power to repay local authority housing debt direct to the Public Works Loan Board (PWLB). This follows the agreement with HM Treasury that they would provide the resources necessary to deal with the residual housing debt of those councils who transfer their housing stock outwith the public sector."That information is new to me and, I think, to everyone who has been involved in the housing stock transfer. People have not been told the whole truth. If the amendment were to fall, there would be no legislation by which to transfer the moneys to the Treasury. That is why the whole Glasgow housing stock transfer process is deeply flawed.
Am I right in thinking that the amendment proposes that if housing is transferred from the public sector to the private sector, the Treasury will pick up the housing debt?
No. As I understand it, a local authority could still owe residual debt to the Public Works Loan Board after a whole-stock transfer to a housing association or whatever. It would appear that ministers do not have the power to pay off that debt and are now dealing with the matter under the Local Government in Scotland Bill. That suggests that the housing stock transfer went through without ministers having that power and that they are now amending the law to give themselves that power. That may call into question the nature of the stock transfer in the first place. I do not know whether it does—this the first time that I have heard about the amendment.
When was the amendment lodged?
It has not been lodged yet—it was proposed at a meeting attended by Peter Peacock last Thursday. The amendment was discussed with other Executive amendments. When I asked about it, I was told that it related to a technicality. There was no clarification. That is why I wanted to mention it today, as, apart from anything else, it throws a whole new light on the legality of the whole-stock transfer.
The petition calls for the Parliament to investigate a number of matters, including the validity of the ballot, and urges the Executive to affirm that it is prepared to write off debt without stock transfer and to provide enhanced public investment in council housing. We have also discussed ministers' power to repay debt to the Public Works Loan Board, which will need to be clarified in the light of what Sandra White has told the committee. I suggest that we write to the Executive on all of those issues and ask it to respond specifically to the petitioners' points. After all, the matter is not sub judice at the moment.
I should declare an interest, because I am one of the founder members of the Glasgow campaign against housing stock transfer. Even examining the matter objectively—whatever the outcome of any legal action—we should note that the Crown Office has already ruled that the use of the title "Glasgow Housing Association" instead of "Glasgow Housing Association Limited" on the ballot paper breached the Industrial and Provident Societies Act 1965.
The petition mentions that.
Yes, but that is one of the key points that we should raise with the Executive. We cannot seem to offer people apples when they are actually buying pears. There should be absolute clarity about the titles of bodies that aim to take over public authority housing in any future deal.We should also ask the Executive about the cost of propaganda in favour of the housing stock transfer that the petitioners claim amounted to £12 million. As with PE554 on the planning process, the protesters have received no help at all.
I thought that I had just said that all the points in the petition will be raised with the Executive.
Well, I was reading the suggested action list and—
We have abandoned that list because of the information that has been provided during the meeting. I am now suggesting that we should seek a response from the Executive to all the points raised in the petition. Nothing is sub judice at the moment.
Right.
We should also ask the Executive about the new amendment to the Local Government in Scotland Bill that will give ministers the power to repay debt to the PWLB. Furthermore, we must ask it to clarify whether ministers had that power when the housing stock transfer went through the Parliament. If they did not, the Parliament at least should have known that at the time.Do members agree to seek clarification from the Executive on all those points and continue the petition until we receive a response?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Nov 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 November 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 42
- New Petitions Petitions · 54
- New Petitions Petitions · 43
- New Petitions Petitions · 60
- New Petitions Petitions · 44
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.