The first new petition is PE546, regarding tolls on the Erskine bridge, which is from Mr Alan Douglas on behalf of Argyll and Bute Council, Renfrewshire Council and West Dunbartonshire Council. Mr Douglas and Councillor Danny McCafferty should be here to speak to the petition, although I see that there is only one person at the table. Is it Mr Douglas?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Erskine Bridge Tolls (PE546)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Councillor McCafferty 16
- John McAllion Lab 10
- Phil Gallie Con 5
- John Farquhar Munro LD 4
- Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind 3
- Rhoda Grant Lab 3
- Councillor Daniel McCafferty West Dunbartonshire Council 1
The record
42 contributionsIt is Councillor McCafferty. Mr Douglas is sitting in the gallery; there will be only one speaker.
The usual rules apply. You have three minutes to present your case, after which members of the committee will ask questions.
It is established that it is our council's policy to oppose the continuation of tolls on the Erskine bridge. That policy has all-party support within the council; it also has the support of Renfrewshire Council and Argyll and Bute Council, as well as a substantial number of other bodies. The petition seeks an examination of the practice and rationale behind the current policy. We ask that the Parliament carry out that examination as a matter of public interest and in order to resolve the issue once and for all. If we do not resolve the issue, it will come up every five years ad infinitum. The renewal orders that are currently used are a rather artificial mechanism.As the committee knows, the original order started in 1971 and was continued in 1991 and 1996, then reinstituted in 2001. At the very least, there has to be a definition of what "temporary" means. The Erskine Bridge Tolls Act 1968 set the tolling power for 20 years from 1971 and said that the power would be temporary thereafter, if required. Renewing the power every five years almost automatically is not temporary, and using that provision as a mechanism for permanence is misleading and unfair.The rushed-through legislation in 2001 did not allow time for detailed examination of the need or otherwise to renew the order at that time. More emphasis was placed on passing the bill than on examining the reasons for and against the tolls being continued. The Erskine Bridge Tolls Act 2001 provided for the extension of tolling for a further five years. In effect, the act—by way of correcting an error—removed the rights that the public and the local authorities would have had to challenge the renewal order.Under normal circumstances—if renewal had not been effected by an act of Parliament—our local authority would have asked for a local inquiry into the renewal order, but since renewal was enshrined in the act we were denied that opportunity. An important safeguard for the public was removed as a result of the need to rectify an Executive error. We do not consider that such an error justified the removal of our right—or, for that matter, the Parliament's right—to consider fully the arguments for and against the renewal of the tolls for another five years. We believe that if our petition is accepted and discussed at the Transport and the Environment Committee, that situation can be rectified and the Parliament can consider the issues involved.The petition should be referred to the Transport and the Environment Committee. We would like a study to be done of the direct and indirect consequences for the social and economic well-being of our communities.Since the Erskine Bridge Tolls Act 2001, Greater Glasgow NHS Board has been given consent by the Minister for Health and Community Care for a major reconfiguration of services, which will necessitate increased use of the Clyde tunnel. That was not considered when the tolls were reintroduced in 2001 and it will affect us in the future. We want the Transport and the Environment Committee to take into account the necessity, if the NHS board's plans go forward, of having a congestion-free tunnel. In addition, since the 2001 act, Loch Lomond Shores—a multimillion pound tourist complex—has opened up and the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park has come into being. It is ironic that although we say that we want to enhance Scotland's tourism base, we promote the myth of the penny-pinching Scot by charging overseas visitors to cross the bridge from Glasgow airport. In effect, we are saying, "Welcome to bonnie Scotland; gie's your 60p before you can travel any further." That is hardly a great advert for Scottish tourism.Clydebank is part of the major regeneration of Clydeside. With the "Clyde Rebuilt" report, we are trying to gather investment in excess of £500 million. We are saying to the world, "Come and invest in the regeneration of Clydeside." The fact that the Executive cannot forgo a fraction of the bridge tolls money to encourage inward and business investment in our local communities is a bad signal to the world. We think that that should be examined.All that we are saying is that we want honest answers to simple questions to put the issue to bed once and for all. Will tolls ever be abolished? If so, when will that happen and can a date be set? If not, why not, and can we stop pretending that anything other than permanence is involved? People require honest answers to honest questions, and, as the tolls are in place until at least 2006, there is substantial time for the issue to be examined. The Executive could then reach a reasoned judgment in the context of what the tolls mean for the west of Scotland and West Dunbartonshire in particular.
Thank you
I am glad that you mentioned the hospital reconfiguration, because I made a note about that last night. Have you approached Greater Glasgow NHS Board as part of your plans and petitioning?
Not directly, but as leader of West Dunbartonshire Council and a member of Greater Glasgow NHS Board, I am on record as saying that the point about the accident and emergency unit requires further discussion. I was pleased that the minister said that it would be reviewed in two years. That review should be done in the context of an examination of what the reconfiguration will mean for the Clyde tunnel and the Erskine bridge. It will be an ideal opportunity to examine those two points together. Personally, I want three accident and emergency units, but that is an aside.
That was a major point in the opposition to the hospital plans. People feared that lives might be endangered or even lost in the Clyde tunnel.
We will never know unless we do a study. I am not asking for a yes or no, but simply for a study.
Have you done any work to find out what funding would be required to abolish the tolls on the bridge?
According to the last figures that we had, the Executive takes in £5 million per annum. That is not just for the bridge, and we must know where it goes. The £5 million per annum is in the retained income for the general motorways and trunk roads. The Erskine bridge is unique. It is the only toll road in Scotland that is a trunk road. The bridge is the responsibility of the Executive, which takes the £5 million and puts it into the general pot. We need a breakdown of that £5 million to see how much the bridge costs and how much the Executive is using for other purposes.
So you have no figures for the maintenance of the bridge or the staffing costs?
No. I would hope that the Executive would supply the figures to the Transport and the Environment Committee, because it does not have the information either. Only the Executive can provide the information in justifying its argument for tolls.
How many people work on the bridge collecting tolls? How many people's jobs would be involved?
I have no idea how many people's jobs are involved, but I would not anticipate a loss of jobs. Whether or not there were tolls, we would still need some regulatory mechanism for health and safety reasons. Sometimes people can be paid to do health and safety regulatory maintenance jobs; they do not have to be collecting money. It is a fact that something like one third of all tolls collected are taken up by administration costs.
Thank you, and good morning.I want to mention at the outset that in my constituency we have the bridge with the highest tolls in Britain, if not in Europe. That is the famous Skye bridge. I note in your submission that it is your understanding that when a toll route exists, there must be a suitable alternative means of travel. I suggest that finding an alternative to the Erskine bridge would not be a tremendous problem. However, there is no alternative to the bridge to Skye, and yet we have the highest tolls in Britain. Do you consider the tolls on the Erskine bridge to be excessive?
I do not think that the tolls are necessary, so it is not a question of whether they are excessive. The tolls were introduced to pay for the bridge when it was built. The bridge has been well paid for and the tolls are being used for different purposes, which was not the intention of the act.I have a great deal of sympathy with the Skye bridge; I have travelled over it to Skye, which is a beautiful place. I do not think that one bridge should be set against another. I dispute the fact that there is an alternative route; the Erskine bridge is the only trunk route.
I applaud your sentiments and I am supportive of the petition simply because of the principle. When the tolls on the Erskine bridge were debated in the Parliament some months ago because the paperwork had been found to be defective, I admit that I voted for the reintroduction of the tolls simply because of the tolls that were imposed on other bridges. If my constituents are paying high tolls, I see no reason why tolls should not be paid on the Erskine bridge.
If I had a vote, I would support you as well.
Is it your opinion that the Erskine bridge is part of the trunk road network?
The Scottish Executive recognises it as such and defines it as part of the general motorways and trunk road network.
I have argued about this in the past and I was advised that, prior to the toll order for the Skye bridge, no trunk road in Britain had a toll imposed on it and that it was illegal to have a toll on trunk roads. I was told that the Forth, Tay and Erskine bridges were not part of the trunk road system. Perhaps that has been altered unbeknownst to me.
As far as I know, the Erskine bridge is part of the trunk road network. The fact that we do not know whether that is correct shows why the Transport and the Environment Committee has to examine the matter.
Do you agree that if the tolls were lifted on the Erskine bridge, the Scottish Executive would be duty bound to reconsider tolls on other bridges, particularly the older bridges across the Forth and the Tay?
That is entirely for the Scottish Executive to determine. I am afraid that I am arguing only about the Erskine bridge for West Dunbartonshire and the surrounding communities. If the Scottish Executive wished to consider tolls in their entirety, I certainly would not be opposed to that. I am not making a case for the Executive to reconsider tolls on all bridges.
I want to ask about the revenue implications for the roads budget. Do you agree that if the tolls were to be removed from the Erskine bridge and the Scottish Executive concluded that it had to act on the toll bridges across the Forth and the Tay, there would be a cumulative build-up in revenue loss? Do you agree that that would have to be taken from the budget for road maintenance and the provision of services elsewhere?
Not as long as the Executive continues to have a £643 million underspend at the end of a year.
That is a fair point.
The Tay and Forth bridges are not run by the Executive; they are run by joint bridge boards that have representation from the local authorities in the respective areas. In a sense, any decision by the Executive on the Erskine bridge would not necessarily have a knock-on effect on the Forth and Tay bridges. Is that the case?
I do not have expertise in that.
I know about the other bridges because I was previously a joint convener of the Tay Road Bridge Joint Board. The bridges are run by local authorities, so their maintenance costs have to be borne by local authorities. That is why a toll continues to be charged on the bridges. You are arguing that, given that the Erskine bridge is part of the trunk road network, its maintenance costs should be met from the normal spend on the trunk road network.
I would certainly argue that. The questions that I have been asked show that there is a need for the matter to go to the Transport and the Environment Committee, because those questions should be asked there.
At the time of the debate on the Erskine bridge tolls, the minister said that the people who use toll bridges should be made to pay for them and that the cost should not fall on the general taxpayer. What do you make of that argument?
That is all very well if someone does not live in West Dunbartonshire. Some 1,200 people commute to their work every day from West Dunbartonshire and 1,000 commute every day from Renfrewshire to West Dunbartonshire. People have to pay by virtue of the fact that they live on either side of the bridge. People who commute every day to and from Glasgow and Lanarkshire do not have to pay a toll, because although they travel a similar route, the road is not a bridge. People are paying for the bridge because of its geographical location in relation to their employment. There is an incredibly high level of unemployment in both West Dunbartonshire and Renfrewshire. Although £300 to £400 a year might not be a great deal of money to some people, to others it is the cost of putting clothes on a child's back, feeding a child or taking a child on holiday.
The minister also argued that dropping the tolls on the Erskine road bridge would lead to an increase in traffic using the bridge and therefore add to pollution and environmental damage. How do you answer that criticism?
Perhaps we should reverse that argument. The traffic in Glasgow's urban areas is causing greater pollution in built-up areas. Even my very limited evidence shows that there tends to be less pollution when people travel on motorways and more when they travel through built-up areas. By discouraging traffic from using the Erskine bridge, we are probably only transferring the problem and causing pollution in other areas. That argument proves that Parliament needs to examine the case in depth instead of taking a superficial look at it.
Thank you for your evidence. The committee will now discuss the suggested action for the petition, and you are free to listen to the debate.Members will see from their papers that the Executive appears to have a very clear position on continuing the tolls regime on the Erskine bridge, given the emergency legislation that was passed last September that authorised the levying of tolls on the bridge until 2006. However, we might wish to agree to write to the Executive and seek its views on the specific issues that the petition raises. We should seek confirmation of the Executive's position with regard to the Erskine bridge tolls regime and an indication of whether its policy is likely to be continued after 2006. We should also ask whether it will consider alternative measures to allow the toll regime to be replaced with a funding regime that recognises that the bridge is a vital element of the Scottish trunk road network.We should also ask the Executive to comment on the council's claims that the grounds for temporarily establishing a toll regime on the bridge in 1971 have been met and that revenue generated through the tolls is now being used as a means of funding the general motorway and trunk roads programme. Finally, we must find out details of the Executive's position on the council's claims that the use of the emergency legislation procedure failed to provide the opportunity for adequate consideration of and effective consultation on the issue.Do members have any other points that we should raise with the Executive?
I wonder whether it would be better if we passed the petition directly to the Transport and the Environment Committee. The questions that the petition raises about the Erskine bridge have much wider implications. I imagine that everyone who was involved in the three-mile tailback on the Forth road bridge today feels that that bridge is part of the trunk road network. Moreover, if they had come the other way through Kincardine, they would have faced roadblocks. I do not know what the alternative is, particularly for people from Fife, but the petition raises a massive question that cannot be ignored. Perhaps the Transport and the Environment Committee should consider the wider issues that have been raised.
The alternative to the Forth bridge is certainly not rail travel. My train journey was delayed because of a fire at Kirkcaldy and we had to go on a round trip all over Fife.We would pursue initial inquiries with the Executive in order to facilitate passing the petition to the Transport and the Environment Committee. A copy of the petition will be passed to that committee in any case, but the issue will not get onto its agenda until several weeks from now. In the meantime, we could seek a response to certain questions from the Executive, which we would then pass on to the Transport and the Environment Committee. That would do that committee's early groundwork and allow it to get into tackling the matter. Otherwise, nothing will be done. I am suggesting not that we deal with the petition—after all, it is a matter for the Transport and the Environment Committee—but that we deal with initial inquiries to the Executive and find out its position on certain questions.
Okay.
I agree with the convener's approach. In the long run, the petition must go to the Transport and the Environment Committee, but first we should hear what the Executive has to say.Also in the long run, the petition should be sent to the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee because, as the petitioner has made clear, jobs and tourism are involved. In fact, there might even be a European dimension. As a result, it might be worth making inquiries to the transport committee of the European Parliament, because the toll rates on the short stretch of the Erskine bridge—if we regard it as a trunk road—are excessive compared with rates on major toll roads in Europe. That sort of unpleasant introduction to Scotland on a short stretch of road that leads to Loch Lomond and other famous tourist attractions is not doing us any good. As Councillor McCafferty pointed out, it is like saying to tourists "Welcome to Scotland—where's your money?" Perhaps it would be possible to call on Europe in the interim, as we are not referring the petition directly to the Transport and the Environment Committee, or to consider referring it to the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee.
When we refer the petition formally to the Transport and the Environment Committee, we could recommend that that committee consult the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee on the implications for tourism. In the meantime, we could ask the Executive for its comments on the likely impact of tolls on local enterprise and tourism in the area. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Nov 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 5 November 2002 (Morning) Petitions · 2
- New Petitions Petitions · 42
- New Petitions Petitions · 54
- New Petitions Petitions · 43
- New Petitions Petitions · 60
- New Petitions Petitions · 44
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Convener's Report Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.