Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Holyrood Project

Tuesday 3 October 2000 Audit Committee Evidence session 298 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

298 contributions · showing 1–200
Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Good afternoon. Welcome to this, our second meeting dealing with the costs and management of the Holyrood Parliament building project. Our witnesses today are Mr Paul Grice, the clerk to the Parliament—who, I believe, has risen Lazarus-like from his sick bed to be with us this afternoon—and Mr Martin Mustard, who is the project team manager. Last week we heard evidence from the permanent secretary and principal accountable officer of the Scottish Executive, who was the official responsible for the project in the period before 1 June 1999, at which point client responsibility passed from the First Minister to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. Since that date, Mr Grice has been the project owner and is the most senior official responsible for the successful delivery of the project.As we did last week, we will ask questions in five main areas: evidence about the state of the project at the time of the handover to the SPCB; project management arrangements more generally, including the interaction between project management and the corporate body as a client; arrangements for cost reporting for the project; managing project risk; and the current state of the project and its prospects over the two years to the forecast completion date of December 2002.Mr Grice, I have been apprised of the fact that you do not intend to make an opening statement. Would you like to go straight into questions?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes. However, I will first introduce Martin Mustard, the project manager, who was referred to last week. I had in any case planned to bring him with me, as I thought that that would be useful.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Before we get on to detailed questions, I would like you to provide us with some background. What was your role in the Scottish Office before you took responsibility for the SPCB?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I was a senior member of the constitution group. My principal responsibilities were the referendum legislation and running the referendum. I then took over responsibility for what became the Scotland Act 1998. I had other general responsibilities. As a senior member of the constitution group, I have had contact with the Holyrood project throughout. I had no responsibility for it, but during the designer selection process, for example, I gave support to the designer selection panel and provided input to the user brief, as requested. That input was based on the emerging conclusions of the consultative steering group. My principal responsibilities were legislation and, more recently, setting up the organisation for the Parliament in the temporary accommodation. However, the Holyrood project has been a major factor throughout the period. I had contact and involvement with it, but not responsibility for it.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

If you have read the evidence that we took at last week's meeting, as I am sure you have, you will have seen that Muir Russell said of the project:"There was a lot about it that was pretty firm and credible. That is why I think the project was viable and in good health when it was handed over."—Official Report, Audit Committee, 26 September 2000; c 359.What were the procedures for the handover of the project in June 1999? What information on the key aspects of it did you and the corporate body receive from the Executive at that point?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The most important point to make is that the entire project team was transferred across from the Scottish Office to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. That was the main plank of the transfer. In the early days of the corporate body's business—bearing in mind that it had many other things on its plate—its members were given extensive briefings by both the project team and the design team. There was a formal handover meeting that the First Minister attended with one or two of his senior officials to discuss wider contextual and political aspects of the project. A series of meetings and presentations took place, but the handover was founded on the fact that the team responsible for the project transferred en bloc to the corporate body.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

In his evidence last week, the permanent secretary told us that he had handed over a doable and robust project that could have been completed for £62 million. During the period immediately after handover in June 1999, many things took place. What was your view of the state of the project when you became responsible for it in June 1999?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

There is no doubt that it was a difficult project, but it was in reasonable shape. I had no reason to doubt anything that the permanent secretary said last week in that sense. When the SPCB presented its report to Parliament last April, it came to the view that it might have been possible to build the project for the then budget—I stress that it said "might have been", not "would have been". There must be a degree of uncertainty. If we had set off to build the project as it was handed over to us, I would be able to say something more definitive, one way or the other. The fact is that quite quickly, especially after the decision to redesign the chamber, we went down a different path. The project was difficult and challenging, but it was in reasonable shape in the sense that there was a reasonable budget and we were reasonably close to getting a settled design at that stage. Adding those two points together, we thought it reasonable but by no means a certainty.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Should you have been handed a completed design at that stage?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Ideally, we would have had a completed design. As I understood the permanent secretary's response last week, he too would have liked a completed design, but the transfer order that required the project to be transferred on 1 June prevented that. A completed design would have given us a better baseline, but the decision to reopen the issue of the debating chamber was prompted by the briefings that the design team gave to members, as well as by the debate in Parliament. With hindsight, I believe that the process of unravelling that design and redesigning it would have happened anyway. To that extent, I am not sure what the value would have been of a completed design other than that it would have given us a firmer baseline to look back on.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Are you happy that the fact that you were not handed a completed design did not leave you in a position where you had to redesign virtually from scratch?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We did not redesign from scratch. The SPCB was in a difficult position, as it is required under law to provide the services that the Parliament requires. It does not have a choice in that. It was clear to the SPCB, from the feedback that its members were getting from their colleagues, that the chamber was not adequate. The chamber of a Parliament is its centrepiece—it is not a minor part of the building—so it was the centrepiece of the Parliament that was unacceptable. Later in the year, in autumn, it became clear from the immense amount that we had learned from running a Parliament—even for a few months—that the building was not big enough either. The SPCB had no choice but to order a redesign. That would have happened, whatever state the project had been handed over in. Things that only the SPCB could learn, having worked in a real Parliament as opposed to a theoretical Parliament, caused it to make those decisions, which were the only ones open to it.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How much did the revised design of the chamber change the forecast construction costs? Can you put a figure on it?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I am afraid that I cannot. The biggest impact that it had was that for about three months it diverted the senior designers—the senior people, if you like—away from the project, as they were concentrating on finding a solution to the design of the chamber. Again, with hindsight, that was a critical phase in the project. From June to September 1999, when we might otherwise have been engaged in trying to sign off stage D and test it against a £62 million budget, we were redesigning a fundamental bit of the chamber. That certainly had an impact on programme. As you will know, an impact on programme inevitably brings an impact on cost. I cannot say whether the redesigned chamber is any more expensive than the previous chamber would have been. To minimise the increase in costs, there was a firm instruction from the SPCB that the designers had to work within the existing footprint. However, taking the leading members of the design team off to redesign a fundamental part of the building will inevitably have cost penalties both through programme and the fact that they cannot spend that time working on other important matters.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I was curious, Mr Grice, when you said that the SPCB does not have a choice in these matters. Presumably, the SPCB could go back to the Parliament.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That is true, and, in fact, it did so. The SPCB went back to the Scottish Parliament in April.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

But that was a considerable time after the Parliament arrived in these buildings in May 1999. I wondered what advice the SPCB was getting. Do you advise it?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes. The judgment on when to go back to Parliament is a difficult one. The point is that, formally, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body is the client—that is clear in law and is important to understand—and it is for it to decide. It seeks a steer from Parliament as it sees fit. The first steer that it got was from the debate in the chamber—initiated by the Executive—in June last year. The end result was a direction from the Parliament to get on with building the Parliament. The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body had always intended to go back to the Parliament from time to time. The question is at what point that should be done. When the SPCB went back to Parliament in April 2000, it had a design that it was confident was adequate to meet the needs of the Parliament, a budget that met that and a plan to establish a progress group. A number of things were in place. In an ideal world, that would have taken less time, but that was the point at which to go back to Parliament. As the committee knows, one cannot arrive at fine decisions in a debate in a plenary session of a Parliament. One ends up with big decisions, one way or another. The SPCB had to be careful to go to the Parliament with a package of reliable information. It felt that the next point at which it could reasonably go back to the Parliament and invite it to make a decision based on sound data was April 2000.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Mr Grice, you suggested that the redesigned chamber may not necessarily have cost any more than the original design. Did I hear that correctly?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes. I could not put a figure on it, although I would like to. Some of the engineering became a bit more complex, which might lead one to think that the construction costs would be higher. The point that I was making was that the main impact of the redesign was the redesign process, which took the principal architects off the project for a while. If that design had come up first, I do not know whether it would have cost any more or less than it did.

Martin Mustard Holyrood Project Team
link

The main impact of redesigning the chamber was vis-à-vis programme. Of course, delay in programme equals cost—although not a cost in terms of the actual product. Like Mr Grice, I think that there would be almost a negligible difference between the cost of the chamber as designed previously and as the design stands now. Nevertheless, costs were incurred, including programme costs and disruption costs to the design team, which resulted in increased fees.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

The redesign might explain part of the increase in fees, but it does not explain in any way the increase in the cost of construction, which seems to have escalated significantly. The implication of what you have told us today is that the £50 million or the £62 million—or whatever the figure is—cannot be broken down to show the cost of various elements of the project, such as the debating chamber, the committee rooms and the MSP accommodation. You do not appear to have access to those costs, which seems to be one of the major difficulties in getting to the bottom of what happened and when it happened.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

You raise an important issue, and I would like to say a little about it. I want to explain to the committee as best I can how the £62 million became £108 million. We have access to those costs, and I studied them so that I could report to the committee. As the Auditor General's report makes clear, one of the principal reasons for the rise in cost—accounting for about half of it—is the fact that the parliament building will be bigger by between 6,000 sq m and 8,000 sq m. That has incurred a substantial increase in cost, and gives rise to the figure that we ended up with in April rather than the figure that we inherited in June 1999.Because of the problems that we encountered when we stripped the plaster off the walls in Queensberry House and realised what a poor state that building was in, a couple of million pounds were added to the cost. The rest of the increase is down to what might be called increased specification, a major element of which is the amount of security advice that we had to take on board to cover eventualities such as bomb blasting. That has had a major impact on the cladding of the building.I could not nail down every penny, but those elements identify reasonably clearly where the cost has come from over that period.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

In written evidence to the committee, could you give us a broad-brush breakdown of the costs, to the nearest million or whatever? That has not been forthcoming so far. Could you also tell us when the decisions were made on each of those elements?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I would be happy to do that.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

I remind you that the debate in June 1999 took place at the behest of Donald Gorrie and me, not at that of the Executive.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Sorry.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

That is quite all right. However, that makes a difference, as the debate took place in the Parliament. I presume that advice was given to the Executive on how to handle those two stroppy back benchers.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I would not know.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

Was that advice to the effect—to use your words—that the project was in good order? Was the advice against undertaking what Donald Gorrie and I were asking for—a moratorium to review the project—which would have been in line with what the Auditor General said should have happened when the project was handed over? No audit was undertaken.My second question goes back to what you said at the start about having had an input into the choice of architect as part of the competition. On what basis did you form the judgment that Señor Miralles could handle such a complex building?

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am sorry, Margo. The choice of architect does not fall within Mr Grice's remit.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

He told us that he had contributed to the process—that is why I asked the question. The choice of architect impacts later, on the design changes that I presume relate back to the design brief that the architect was given during the competition and the changed brief that was presented to the client by the architect. Mr Grice must have had an input into both those parts of the project.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Grice, you are answering questions as the accountable officer from 1 June 1999. However, are you happy to answer that question as a point of background information?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Of course, but thank you for reminding the committee of the basis on which I am here. I provided support to the designer selection panel; I did not choose the designer. You would have to ask the designer selection panel any question about the designer.I was the adviser to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body at the time of the debate in June 1999. I did not advise the Executive, so I cannot tell the committee what advice was given regarding Margo MacDonald or Donald Gorrie. I recall that the corporate body took a fairly neutral stance, as one would expect—it had had responsibility for the project for only about two weeks. The advice that we received from the corporate body was simply to present it with as much information as we could in a short time, relating to the design as it stood and all the other aspects. As I recall, the corporate body took instructions.I take the point about who initiated the debate, but I recall that the First Minister spoke in it. Members of the corporate body may have spoken, but they were not speaking in advocacy; they were seeking to explain their role.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I would like to ask about the changeover and the type of contract. We heard evidence from Mr Russell last week that a construction management approach was adopted. He claimed that there were advantages in that, because it allowed you to let the project progress in parts and to have several contracts. However, the risk was greater, because it would fall on the owner of the project. On the other hand, there might be no difficulty in renegotiating a single contract. At what point did you become aware that what Mr Russell described as an "innovative" form of contract was in operation? Was it 1 June, was it sometime afterwards, or were you told in briefings beforehand?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

You are testing my memory. We had a long discussion with the corporate body that summer—my instinct tells me that it was after the debate, but perhaps not that long after the debate. I remember a long discussion with the corporate body—which was obviously very interested—about the nature of the contract. I recall that it was not that easy to grasp—at least, I did not find it easy to grasp immediately. The discussion inevitably began with the corporate body asking whether a particular cost could be guaranteed. Under construction management, the short answer is, "No, it can't." I think that you explored the reasons for that with Muir Russell last week. After that, there was a long discussion about the pros and cons, and the flexibility, of this type of approach, and about the fact that one manages the risk oneself. Looking at it the other way, one sees that the advantage of a contract with a guaranteed maximum price is that it is exactly what it says it is. However, there is no such thing as a free lunch; it has to be paid for in some sense. I recall quite a long debate within the corporate body, and I would guess that it might have been in July or August, although I could not swear to it. I certainly remember that we discussed the issue at some length. I was learning alongside the corporate body at that point.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

The key question is this: did someone from the Scottish Executive explain this type of contract to you before you took over the project or prior to the discussion that took place within the corporate body? Was there any report, any exchange of letters, or anything that said, "Look, we have chosen an innovative route: these are the advantages, but these are the disadvantages"?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I think that I was briefed at the same time as the corporate body.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Grice, would you have had any choice? Was it possible for the corporate body to revisit the whole thing and decide to do it under a different regime and not go with the construction management approach?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We have considered that seriously, even recently; having learned about the types of project, one should always ask oneself that question. As members know, we passed a major milestone in the project early this year when we achieved stage D in design terms, the cost plan, and so on. At that point we asked ourselves that very question: "Is this the right project?" We had no choice in what we inherited. Under a transfer order, we took on all the liabilities relating to the project; we had no choice at all in that. However, there is always an option, and we did consider that. The view that we came to, and the view that the corporate body has stuck with, is that the premium that we would, in effect, have to pay to the contractor—Bovis Lend Lease (Scotland), in this case—to accept our risk would be very high. A contractor is not going to take on the project without a very large premium, because they would be being asked to take the risk. The judgment was that that premium would have been of a higher value than if we managed the risk ourselves. The further on that we have got with the project, the less benefit there is in handing it over.Last summer, we had instructed the design team to redesign the chamber, and not long after that the team was instructed to redesign the building to find more space. If, at that point, we had tried to hand the project over while looking for a guaranteed maximum price, I suspect that the contractor would have asked for quite outrageous sums of money, because that was a risky time for the project. The answer to your question is yes, we have considered this matter on at least a couple of occasions, for the obvious reasons that I think you are alluding to.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We will probably come back to this line of questioning later.

Karen Whitefield Lab Airdrie and Shotts
link

I would like to take you back to the stage at which you inherited the project. Last week, the permanent secretary said that the project was doable and robust. When you inherited the project, what steps did you take to ensure that it was as robust as people claimed it was? It has fallen from being seen as a robust project into, some would say, a project in a state of disarray. Who is responsible for that? When did that happen? Did it happen before or after you took over the project? Was the project robust?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I do not accept that the project is in a state of disarray, although I accept that there is a perception that that is the case. "Inheriting" is a nice term—one thinks of an inheritance as something that leaves one better off. When we inherited the project—inherited is the right word—our first step was to arrange for the corporate body, as the new client, to be briefed quite intensively. The steps that we instituted ranged from giving briefings about the design, examining the costs and holding meetings at a senior political level. We also held long discussions with the members of the corporate body last summer on their responsibilities as the client and we introduced them to members of the project and design teams. We prepared them for the project through that intensive period of briefing. I have already tried to answer the question about whether the project was doable. I rest with the line taken by the corporate body: it might have been, but I cannot say that with any certainty.

Karen Whitefield Lab Airdrie and Shotts
link

Did you do any work to assess whether what you were being given matched what you were being told, or whether the targets that you were given for the next stage of the project could be achieved?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The committee should bear in mind the fact that we inherited the entire project team. The situation would have been different had we set up our own project team, as we would certainly have crawled over the project with a fine-toothed comb. However, I inherited the entire project team, from project sponsor all the way down the line. The members of that team were comfortable with what we inherited, which I took as a pretty good reassurance. They had lived with the project for the previous two years and that seemed to me to be a pretty reasonable basis on which to start.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Paragraph 1.18 of the Auditor General's report refers to the identification in August 1999 of"serious difficulties with the project".There are a number of bullet points in that paragraph. Is it possible to identify, in relation to each point, the extent to which they were either new problems or inherited from the Executive's earlier period of stewardship and control?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Do you want me to go through them one at a time?

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Whichever way is more comfortable. Going through them one at a time might be more useful in providing clarification to the committee. I think that you have covered the first bullet point, which deals with delay.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes, I think that we did.The issue of Queensberry House straddled the handover. I understand that, as one would expect with an old building in a poor state, Queensberry House has been—Interruption. I will check with Martin Mustard whether we stripped off the plaster after we inherited the project.

Martin Mustard Holyrood Project Team
link

Yes.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We took the plaster off the walls and that was the point at which the building's true state of disrepair was revealed. As I recall, the Scottish Office commissioned a report from James Simpson and Brown, which said that the building was basically structurally sound. However, that report did not have the advantage of an invasive investigation, which we were able to conduct.Queensberry House was in no worse condition when we got it than when the Executive had had it, so, in a sense, that is a problem that we carried over from the Executive. However, we did not identify the disrepair until we were able to take the plaster off the walls. The issue over the 4,000 sq m emerged over the summer—in other words, after we had taken over the project. It came first from the design team—that is, it was not instructed. Muir Russell made it clear that the Executive did not manage to achieve stage D sign-off. Indeed, convener, you have already asked me questions on that. We could not achieve stage D sign-off either, although Muir Russell thought that we were within weeks of doing so. The advice that I received was that we were reasonably close to stage D sign-off, but that it had to be put to one side the minute that we reopened the question of the debating chamber and other issues. Martin Mustard might have something to say on the next bullet point, which is more detailed. It begins:"Some works packages had been let".

Martin Mustard Holyrood Project Team
link

That particular point goes back to diverting design team resources during the summer. With the principal architects otherwise engaged, there tended to be a lack of direction in the information being produced for work packages that were about to be let. In the report, the Auditor General points out the fact that there was a fear that construction information from the design team would dry up. It did not quite dry up, but the design team was finding it increasingly difficult to hit the design programme dates set by Bovis.

Martin Mustard Holyrood Project Team
link

Because the principal members of the design team were otherwise engaged in examining the redesign of the chamber.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I would not dispute anything that the final bullet point says. There was a great difficulty. There was a crunch meeting at the end of August last year at which the principals—the leading members of the design team and of the project team—got together to try to resolve the situation, but it was not resolved. There continued to be an insistence—rightly, from a project management point of view—that there was a budget of £62 million, which had to be stuck to. It is however only fair to say that the design team did not feel that the project could be done within that amount. We must also add in the fact that there were an extra 4,000 sq m and it was not clear where they had emerged from. I agree with the Auditor General's assessment that that was a critical point. There was a design team facing a major redesign and, at the same time, a fundamental disagreement about what could be achieved. We tried to get round that by sitting down with the design team and the cost consultants to plot a way ahead. It was agreed that there should be immediate examination of where the critical 4,000 sq m had come from and a value engineering exercise to reconcile the figures as far as possible. That is the action that resulted from a meeting of, I think, 30 August last year, which followed on from what is set out in the final bullet point of paragraph 1.18 of the report.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

If I understand correctly, the design team took its instructions from the corporate body and produced the extra 4,000 sq m that were needed. Is that the way round it happened?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No. As I understand it, when the design team produced a set of drawings at the end of the summer, which were costed by the cost consultants, they noticed that there were 4,000 sq m in addition to what had previously been briefed, which most certainly was not instructed by the corporate body. That was the problem. It had emerged uninstructed. Two immediate action points were therefore instructed. The first was to find out where the space had come from. The second was to initiate a value engineering exercise to reconcile the latest cost projections from the cost consultants and the budget.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did you find out where the 4,000 sq m had come from?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We were in the process of finding out when that was overtaken by events. That was at the end of August, spilling into September. The sequence of events was that, around the middle of September, the design team came back with a redesign of the chamber, which the corporate body accepted and, I think, reported to MSPs on. The value engineering exercise was proceeding at that time, as were investigations into where the 4,000 sq m had come from. By November, we had reported to the corporate body that there were quite significant pressures on space, because we were learning a huge amount about what was needed to run the Parliament—we needed more clerks, more researchers, more reporters and more IT people. All that translated into demands that simply could not be met. On that basis, the corporate body accepted our advice that we needed more space. It could not be managed by simply stretching the buildings upwards or sideways; it needed a fundamental re-examination. The design team was sent away to do that. Once it was decided to do that, the other information was not relevant—we were moving into a different phase altogether.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

This 4,000 sq m was moving around space. I will put this in layman's terms that will be understood, because people will be confused that we cannot account for this extra square metrage. What happened was that a design brief was given and the architect changed the design brief. As the Parliament built up experience and knew more about its practices and facilities requirements, it asked that those requirements be added. Therefore, what was a complicated design became all the more complicated. I go back to my original question about the choice of architect and the fact that—

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We have covered that point Margo.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am sure that there is a question in there somewhere, Mr Grice. Was the design team prescient in realising that you were going to need more space, or did it produce 4,000 sq m that were not asked for, but which subsequently you found you needed anyway?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It is an unfortunate coincidence that the numbers are the same. I do not think that you could credit the design team with prescience. The additional space that was commissioned in November was separate from the extra 4,000 sq m. In fact, you do not commission extra space; you send the team away and say that you have extra demands to be met. That is what happened. It just so happens that the numbers were the same. It was not that over the summer the design team had looked ahead and said, "We think you need this extra space." It was different from that. The space was space that the team could not satisfactorily account for, so it was sent away to work with the project team and cost consultants to explain it in a satisfactory way or take it out.There were separate lines of events, which Margo MacDonald alluded to, from which we learned a great deal in a short period of time about what it takes to run a Parliament. On that basis we explicitly instructed the design team to undertake a feasibility study on what it would take to accommodate new demands. That led the team to produce the design that is the one that we have before us.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

You are suggesting that the bulk of the extra 4,000 sq m is a consequence of decisions that were made after the handover. Did any of that space result from decisions, considerations, observations or whatever took place prior to the handover?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I do not think so. I think that the extra space was the result of a decision taken by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body in the autumn. It is pretty clear that decisions were taken around the autumn of last year that led to the extra space, and they were based on lessons that we had learned from running the Parliament.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I refer you to paragraphs 3.56 and 3.57 of Mr Black's report. Just before the handover of the project in May 1999, the cost consultants had estimated the construction costs to be £89 million. Were you and the SPCB made aware of that information at the handover?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

If you had been made aware of it would your view about the robustness or otherwise of this project have been different?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That is a hypothetical question. I do not know. An explanation has been offered, which is plausible in many respects.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

That is a matter of opinion.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The whole thing is a matter of opinion. It is a hypothetical question. I do not know. We were not told at the time, and therefore—

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Do you feel that you should have been told?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It is important to understand the nature of these projects. One gets a lot of cost information all the time. You employ a project team to handle that information, along with a lot of other information, and advise accordingly. As I said, we inherited the same project team as the Executive had, and on that basis I was happy to rely on the advice that the team gave. They had worked with the project all the way through.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

With hindsight, were you being offered good advice by the project team?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It was clear in the advice that the project team gave that the budget excluded risk allowances, contingencies and so on. It never hid the fact that there were other factors to be counted up. It never quantified them, which is a fair comment to make, but the advice that went to the SPCB made it clear that the £62 million excluded risk allowances, contingencies, fit-out, VAT, fees and so on. It did not hide that from the SPCB—or me. A fair point is that they were not quantified, but they were not hidden.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Should it have been spelled out in more detail? The project team had a contingency of £6 million, which was clearly a gross underestimate of the position.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The SPCB insisted that we discussed and reported costs in gross terms. That is where the £109 million came from, which relates to the £62 million. That separately identified items such as contingency and fit-out. The contingency is generally a percentage of the base construction estimate, so when the construction estimate was £62 million, the contingency was £6 million. The contingency is now at £11 million, which relates to a base construction estimate of £108 million. The contingency is in line with Treasury guidance and has moved up accordingly.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Many other elements were excluded. The reasons for exclusion were provided by Mr Russell and his colleagues in the appendix to the report. Do you accept that those reasons are valid?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I have discussed that with the project team. Its advice to me is that, for the most part, those risks did not materialise. Other risks have materialised since.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Given that the total figure of £109 million ended up above £200 million and was reduced to £195 million, do you not think that somebody did not get this right? Part and parcel of this exercise is to find out what went wrong, how it went wrong and how we can now go about it. I am finding it difficult to get concrete answers to questions about what went amiss, how it was quantified, when it happened and who did it—not for the sake of nailing someone to a wall, but to find out what went wrong.We have heard that the £62 million was robust and was based on reliable information. The information was not reliable because it did not add up. The figure was given as £50 million, £62 million, £89 million and so on. We ended up with a cost of £195 million. That cannot all be accounted for by an increase in space.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I can only explain what happened under my stewardship of the project. You will come to a view as to the £62 million handover figure. I do not think that I have ever used the term robust.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Looking back, do you agree with the Auditor General for Scotland's suggestion that there should have been an independent audit of the state of the project for the SPCB at the point of handover?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That is a reasonable suggestion to make with the benefit of hindsight. I am trying to think back to how it was in June 1999, when Parliament had just voted to continue with the project. There has always been a huge amount of politics around this project, which has not always made it the easiest place for officials. That aside, the Parliament had instructed the SPCB to get on with it. I am not sure that it would have been feasible for the SPCB to say, "Notwithstanding what you have told us, we will stop and undertake an independent review of the project." The SPCB felt that it was incumbent on it to get on with this to deliver what the Parliament had asked it to do.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Was it within the powers of the SPCB to do that?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Absolutely. It was, and remains, the client.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes, it considered that in the summer.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Are you asking whether the corporate body considered having a completely independent audit?

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I am asking whether at the time of handover the corporate body considered having an independent audit.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It considered whether it should have independent advisers either on the corporate body or advising it separately.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Could you provide us with written evidence of that?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I can write to confirm that.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

There might be something in the minutes. I am telling the committee that on more than one occasion the corporate body considered whether it should have independent advice—not an independent audit, but something equivalent to what the Holyrood progress group now has.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

So you will write to us to confirm what you have said and to indicate that the corporate body considered this in June 1999.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It was more likely in July or August. I will write to the committee to confirm what I have said if you would like.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Yes, please.There seem to have been three major areas of change or additional work. We are still having some difficulty establishing the authorship of those changes, which were instructed last year on behalf of the client and have added about a year to the design period. What other options did you have that might have avoided the long delays?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I am sorry, but I am not quite sure of the question.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I am thinking about the redesign of the chamber last summer which, as you explained, took three months. Three months is not a year. I am also thinking of the value and cost review, which took place in the autumn, and the additional feasibility work that was done to find more space and was instructed last November. What other options did you consider? The problem was not just with the overall cost, but with a very significant delay. What options did you consider to regain time that might have been lost as a result of major changes and additional work?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

One cannot do anything without a design that people agree meets the needs of the client. We did not have it. We did not get it until well into this year.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Given that 10 per cent more space was added in November last year—

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That is not right. In November last year the corporate body instructed the design team to institute a design feasibility study to accommodate the extra space. It came back in January or February this year with proposals. As the Auditor General's report makes clear, that study required 75 or 80 per cent of the entire project to be re-examined. This project is not like a supermarket or Victoria Quay, where one simply adds another bit on to the end or another floor. It required a fundamental redesign of the building. That is what took the time.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

In paragraph 2.33 of his report, Mr Black covers the points that you are making. The report suggests that by November 1999 10 per cent more space was required. Did the team consider leaving the existing design untouched and finding the additional space somewhere else, rather than trying to rejig the whole thing? Did you consider moving some of the activity to another site?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

If you are building a new Parliament building and you have a site that can accommodate the extra space, setting out to accommodate some staff on a remote site does not seem to me to be a feasible option. That is fine if a site has been filled up and, 10 years down the track, more space is needed, but all we had was a set of designs. The purpose of a new Parliament building is to provide a complex in which members, their staff and the Parliament's staff can work together. As long as the option of providing that exists, it would seem right to pursue it. It is not a long-term solution to say, "Well, we'll leave it as it is and have some other people up the road." It would be different if we had built it, or even begun to build it, but, as was proven to be the case, the design team was able to come up with a solution that could accommodate the extra space on the site.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Surely there must be a value-for-money exercise. I accept your point that, ideally, you would want to have everything on one site, but considerable concerns had been raised by that time about the significant effect on the time scale and cost. Surely other options, including the possibility of using another site for part of the facilities, should have been considered and put to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body for a decision. Was it an absolute part of the brief that you could not provide some of the services from somewhere else?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The corporate body was clear that it wanted to have the parliamentary complex on that site as far as possible. If the design team had come back to us and said that it could not be done on the site, that would have been the point at which the corporate body would actively have explored other sites.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I understand that that might have been your motivation, but surely the time problem and the cost problem were also factors. At that point, those who were making the decisions ought to have been informed of the consequences of going ahead. Was there any discussion between the project team, or you as the accountable officer, and the corporate body about the options, consequences and knock-on effect on time and costs of that 10 per cent increase in space?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

There was certainly discussion about the time it would take to redesign, but what we could not quantify for the corporate body was exactly how much longer it would take. It may be stating the obvious, but if one sets about redesigning the project in quite a fundamental way, that will take time.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Did any members of the corporate body raise the possibility of an alternative to having it all on one site?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I cannot honestly remember, although I am happy to come back to you on that point. We were aware that there are a lot of developments on the north Holyrood site. We also realised that the interim accommodation is not big enough. As you may be aware, we have recently taken accommodation at St Andrew Square for some staff. We considered north Holyrood as a possibility for extra interim accommodation, but St Andrew Square has provided a better option. We therefore had cost data at official level on the costs that might be involved.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

But that information was not passed to members of the corporate body to help them form a judgment.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That information was sought in a different context—the context of providing additional interim accommodation. I cannot honestly say off the top of my head whether the corporate body ever discussed that as a long-term solution. My strong instinct is that, even if it did, it would certainly have stuck to the view that the whole point of building a new parliamentary building must be to try to get all the accommodation on the site. To set out at the outset to build a new Parliament building that one knows is not big enough, on the ground that one could rent some accommodation elsewhere, calls into question, in my judgment, the whole point of building a new parliamentary complex. That is not the game that we were in.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I would like to move on, as time is pressing.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I am coming to my final question. The report is critical of the control procedures. What control mechanisms were in place to manage and report cost changes arising from requests to alter the design of the buildings?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We had an informal change control process in place. What we did not have was a settled design. Until there is a settled design it is not possible to have a cost plan, and until there is a cost plan it is difficult to quantify the effect of additional changes in design. The way we approached it, therefore, was to get the design to a position in which the corporate body felt that it met the requirements of the Parliament. As soon as we had such a design, we costed it and brought in Spencely to verify those costs. At that point we took it to the Parliament. We now have a cost plan. We are now in a position to evaluate how changes in design will affect cost, but we were not in that position last autumn.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Do you regard that as satisfactory?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It is an inevitable consequence of the state the project was in at the time.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Is that in terms of not having a fully agreed design and cost plan in place at the time of the handover?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

You are right, we did not have that. We did not manage to reach that point until this spring. Is that satisfactory? I would have liked it to have taken less time. I am not saying that that period was desirable and so, to that extent, it is not satisfactory. However, it is important to understand that the project has moved into a new phase in the past few months, in which we can undertake such analysis. That was not possible last autumn. Without a fixed design and a cost plan associated with it, it is very difficult to undertake the incremental reporting to which you refer.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

In practice, what arrangements were put in place to ensure that the corporate body was told of the consequences of the changes that it was seeking?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I have described those arrangements. The corporate body was left in no doubt that making the building bigger would make it more expensive.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

When the corporate body made the decision, was it told how much more expensive it would be?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No, for the reasons that I have outlined. The corporate body did not institute the construction of a bigger building; the SPCB instituted a redesign—on paper. The SPCB did not commit to building that until after the proposal had been taken back to the Parliament in April. If the SPCB had set about building a bigger building, you would be making a fair criticism, but the corporate body did not do that. Rather it asked the design team to come up with a new design to meet the requirements. That design was then costed, subjected to the Spencely review and put to the Parliament. Only then did the corporate body go ahead. Those were the arrangements.It is a difficult matter, particularly with such a complex building. If someone is building a supermarket and they are asked what an extra 1,000 sq m would cost, they could answer pretty accurately. The new Parliament building is not like that—it has lots of modular shapes. It is very difficult for anyone to say how much it would cost to provide space for another dozen clerks and so on. It was clear that, in November, we crossed a threshold and required quite a fundamental rethink to achieve the extra space. The corporate body did not begin building; the corporate body asked for a redesign and when it got that back, along with indicative costs, it requested an independent review. John Spencely came in and carried out an independent review. The SPCB then went to the Parliament to get its view on whether to proceed.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Can you do the same exercise for us as Mr Muir Russell promised? Can you provide a breakdown of the costs that you feel were the responsibility of your team and the corporate body after June and those costs that where the responsibility of the team operating before June?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I cannot answer for the team before June 1999. I can write to the committee and set out how the figure of £62 million increased to £108 million; in terms of the full project costs those figures are £109 million and £195 million. That is my responsibility and I am happy to write to the committee about that.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That would be very helpful. I am going to pull this section of questions to a close. I want to move on to the project management phase because I expect many issues to flow into that from the handover phase.I intend to spend half an hour on the project management questions before we have a brief adjournment.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I want to ask about the skills base of the project team that you inherited. Last week, Mr Russell gave evidence on the people involved in the project team. The committee raised questions about the apparent absence of a really senior construction professional. What is your view of the skills of the project management team that you inherited? Did you notice any gaps? Furthermore, did you at any stage identify the problems that the Auditor General has highlighted?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No. I do not entirely subscribe to the Auditor General's view, although it is perfectly valid. There were no obvious gaps. We had a project sponsor and even the Treasury guidance makes it clear that the project sponsor does not necessarily have to be a construction professional. Nevertheless, our project sponsor was an experienced administrator with some construction experience. Our project manager, Martin Mustard, had a great deal of construction experience; his two assistants were construction professionals; the client adviser, John Gibbons, was an experienced architect; and there was a range of other people in the team. The team certainly seemed well balanced and well qualified.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Did you come to that conclusion over a period of time, or did you assess the project management team on the day that you inherited it and decide that you were covered?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I did not do that on 1 June, because I was doing a lot of other things. Indeed, I should put my hand up and say that I was doing a lot of other things over that period, and a fair criticism might be that I did not pay enough attention to the situation. However, I certainly took a bit of time over the summer to assess the team with the project sponsor and, even with that more mature consideration, I did not find any obvious gaps.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Would it have helped to have had some kind of assessment of the project team at the point of handover? As you explained, the handover procedure seems to have been fairly informal. Although that seems to have been a key element of the project management team, there was still no status report, audit of skills or anything like that for you to consider on 1 June.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That certainly would not have done any harm. I never thought to seek that at the time.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

So there was no written assistance about the skills mix in the project management team. You seemed to say earlier that, at that point, you were not particularly aware of the nature of the construction management contract and so perhaps were not fully aware of all the risks that might have arisen during the project. A lot of the problems seem to stem from what happened at the handover. Is it fair to conclude that, at handover, you had no status report to work from?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

With the benefit of hindsight, perhaps I should have asked for such reports, as they might have made me more aware.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Is it also fair to say that those reports might have crystallised some of the potential problems and reduced the delays that were inevitable as you went on a voyage of discovery of some of the risks that you had been left with?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I agree with you up to the point where you take me on a voyage of discovery. I know that you do not mean that maliciously, but it is not a very fair representation of the situation. It is important to bear in mind the fact that the project team was striving hard both to keep the project moving forward and to respond to the client's needs. If you want to represent that as a voyage of discovery, that is fine; however, it was clear to me before we embarked too much on such a voyage that the type of contract that we had allowed us to do so. If we had had a fixed design that was to be built for a lump sum, we would have been in far deeper trouble.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Are you quite happy with the present project management team's mix of skills? Are there any problems with personnel or the general skills mix that you might need to address?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The project team is an excellent team, and has done a very good job in difficult circumstances. I have restructured the team. You could read that back to me and say that perhaps I should have thought about that earlier—I would accept that as a fair point.I have reduced the project sponsor role a little—to define it more narrowly, down to a more traditional project director role—and I have added two more people to the mix. One is the person who acts as secretary to the Holyrood progress group. That person has taken on the communication role, and has handled much of the inevitable raft of parliamentary questions and other matters, which are important but, none the less, a huge distraction for the people who are trying to manage the project.I have also put in place a financial controller, who is also our principal finance officer. He supports me in my role as accountable officer. He worries not so much about whether the project is finished, but about ensuring that the money is there and that the systems are in place.Those fair points were alluded to by the Auditor General and, with the benefit of hindsight, I might have instituted the changes earlier. That is where I have got the team to now and, as members know, we have just recruited a new project director, who starts in November. Altogether, I have never been unhappy with the project team; I am happy that we have a good balance of skills and experience and a rather better division of responsibilities than we had previously.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Would you characterise what you have described as fairly major or significant change?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I would describe it as significant; it is more than just marginal change, yet I would not describe it as major.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

You had to make all the changes in the light of the experience that you gained. You had no crib sheet to work from at the start. You had to gain the experience of knowing where additional skills were needed before you were able to institute the changes.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes. I have certainly gained a lot of experience on this project—that is for sure. I am not sure whether a crib sheet would have highlighted the need for additional skills in this case. It would have been a help to have thought of that sooner, and something might have stimulated me to think about it sooner—a crib sheet might have set me thinking.

Euan Robson LD Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

As you said, you had a lot of other things to think about in June and July last year. At that stage, everything was new for us all, and we might all be forgiven for forgetting to do one or two things at that time. In any case, it is interesting that you had to make those changes.I think we can now be fully assured that the skills that are there will be enough to see us through to 2002.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Yes, and if the Holyrood progress group is added to the mix, we have the political control, the independent advice and the project team. There are no guarantees with this project; only a fool would sit here and give guarantees, but a good management set-up is in place.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

The Auditor General recognised the wide range of responsibilities that you have as the clerk to the Parliament. Euan Robson has also just acknowledged that. With hindsight, do you think that the responsibility for the client role and for the Holyrood project should have rested with you? Should an officer have been handed the responsibility, with a duty to report to you?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The Auditor General's comment was very fair, but I have thought about that question a lot and the answer is no. We tried to bring together the needs of the Parliament as an organisation, for which, it is correct to say, I am responsible, and to deliver a building to house it.I accept the Auditor General's points, and perhaps it has been a matter of sticking with the least worst option. However, the danger of going down the other route, as suggested by Cathie Craigie, would have been that someone was responsible—was in complete official authority, so to speak—for the building and someone else was responsible for the organisation of services in the Parliament. In my view, there would have been a bigger risk in that case of ending up with a building that was neither adequate nor proper.Especially in the autumn, we learned a huge amount about what the Parliament required to make it run. Getting that information into the project brief in a controlled manner was a huge challenge. This comes back to some of the questions that Brian Adam asked. It was very difficult, but as the person responsible for both sides, I tried to bring them together. Whether I did that effectively, or as effectively as I should have, is for others to assess.The Auditor General makes a fair comment, but on reflection I still think that, had another officer been made responsible for the Holyrood project, there would have been greater danger of the Parliament building and the parliamentary service running on parallel tracks. Perhaps it took us too long to get there, but at least at the end of the day we got the two things to converge.I was able to play a role in bringing that about, particularly by the beginning of this year. I felt that I was able to pull together the key people in the parliamentary organisation—the clerks, the reporters and the information centre—and the Holyrood project team. Sometimes that required the authority of the chief officer—not that I had to bang heads together very often. If responsibility had been shared by two people, they could have ended up arguing and blaming each other. There would also have been a greater risk of their passing the buck.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Are you saying that it has been advantageous to have one person overseeing the whole service and being able to draw together all the competing interests?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The Auditor General made a fair comment, but I believe that the balance of advantage was with the set-up that we had.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

What arrangements did you make for reviewing and monitoring the management of the programme?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The Holyrood project sponsor was a member of my senior management team, which meets every week. The project featured on some agendas, but not on others. Every week, I meet each of the directors individually to review progress in the directorate of clerking and reporting, the communications directorate and so on. I had weekly meetings with the Holyrood project sponsor to review progress on the project. At a general level, I kept in pretty close touch with what was happening.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

How much detail were you given at those weekly meetings?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Not a huge amount. As a result of this process, I have delved into the detail of the project more than I would normally. A balance must be struck between allowing someone at director level, who is a pretty senior person, to get on with their job without undue interference, and satisfying oneself that one knows enough. The meetings were at a fairly high level.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

How often did you meet, and report to, the corporate body?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Somewhere between once a fortnight and once a month; it varied. The SPCB aimed to set aside a meeting every fortnight just to discuss Holyrood. Usually that proved not to be feasible, because the corporate body had a huge number of things on its agenda. However, the corporate body would normally consider Holyrood issues once a fortnight. It certainly never went more than a month without discussing the project, apart from during recess periods. I would say that, on average, Holyrood was discussed once a fortnight.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

With hindsight, do you think that the corporate body, with all the other interests and work that it had, was the right group to have responsibility for the project?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The corporate body is a very able group of people. However, we have learned from the Holyrood progress group that if people can devote a day every fortnight—which is a huge amount of time for an elected member to set aside—to Holyrood and nothing else, that makes it much easier to deal with. The members of the progress group have certainly found that, and it has been tremendously helpful from our point of view.The project is not easy, and it is no easier now than it ever was. To be able to spend two or three hours asking and trying to answer questions, rather than to have to knock things on the head in an hour, has been a great benefit. In no sense is that meant to cast aspersions on the corporate body, which had a huge number of other responsibilities. The progress group is able to worry just about Holyrood, to brief itself better and to spend more time on the issue. Spending a whole day down on the site allows the group really to get to grips with the project and to keep asking questions until it is satisfied. That means that the project is able to develop better. The progress group has been a big help, as the corporate body had to wrestle with a range of issues of which Holyrood was only one.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Before the progress group was set up and before the Spencely report was published, was the corporate body starting to think that it did not have enough time to devote to the project and that it needed to consider other forms of accountability?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

As I said in response to a question from Brian Adam, as early as the summer of 1999 the corporate body considered whether it should have independent advice. It also considered whether it should set up a sub-group to manage the project, even though the Scotland Act 1998 did not provide for that. The members of the corporate body rejected that suggestion on the grounds that the project was such a big responsibility that they should all share it. They felt that it would be unfair to delegate it to one, two or three of their number. When John Spencely came up with his proposal, the members of the SPCB signed up to it pretty readily, seeing it as a sensible move forward. It is human nature for people who have been given a responsibility to want to take it on and make a success of it, rather than to try to offload on to someone else. The SPCB had thought about different structures, but it was keen to take on the responsibility and to deliver what the Parliament had requested of it.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

You said that a large part of the difficulty that you encountered in managing the project resulted from the fact that there was not a settled design. Last week, Dr Gibbons told us that the architects"had a responsibility for the development of the brief."—Official Report, Audit Committee, 26 September 2000; c 341.In retrospect, given the time that they were taking to finalise briefs and so on, would it have been a sanction on the architects if, as part of the construction management contract, they had shared some of the risk? I know that their fees were agreed beforehand. That meant that there was no incentive for them to ensure that they did not take so much time developing the brief and changing the design.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Before you answer the question, Mr Grice, could you say what responsibility or ability the corporate body had to renegotiate the architects' fees?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

We inherited a contract. As members know, one can renegotiate only bilaterally. The fee was calculated on a percentage basis. Obviously, the corporate body took an interest in that. In defence of the design team, I should point out that the extra design work that it did was real extra design work. It was not like adding an extra 1,000 ft to an office block or a supermarket. The Auditor General has confirmed that 75 to 80 per cent of the design had to be re-evaluated. That is a huge amount of work. The design team also made a huge number of presentations to the corporate body, members and others, which is not regarded as part of a design team's normal work. We were getting value from the architects outwith their work on the design.I have no reason to believe that the design team deliberately spun out the process to increase its fees. Nothing that I have seen during the time that I have been involved with the project suggested that the team acted in anything other than the best interests of the project. It is not credible to suggest that Enric Miralles or Brian Stewart would spin out the process for their benefit. They were completely committed to producing a good design for the project. That is a personal view, but I have formed it after seeing those people in action for more than a year.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

I did not accuse either the late Señor Miralles or RMJM of spinning out the process to enhance their percentage fees. I was suggesting that, perhaps at the outset, as part of the management organisation of the project, it would have been better for the design team to share the risk, because it was responsible for the development of the brief. The brief kept developing, and the architects were part of that.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I see what you mean.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

I want to make quite clear what I am saying. Basic mistakes were made and, like everyone else around this table, I am trying to work out why the mistakes were made, who made them and whether they are likely to be repeated.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is a good point on which to bring this part of the meeting to a close. We will resume at a quarter to four.

Meeting adjourned.

On resuming—

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We will move on to aspects of cost reporting. Mr Grice has, to a greater or lesser extent, answered some of the questions that arose over cost reporting, so I ask members to keep their questions fairly brief. Mr Grice, if you feel that you have already answered a question, please feel free to say so. We will try to gallop along. I would like to bring the meeting to a close at half-past 4, as several members have indicated that they have other commitments.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Mr Black has described this project as being uniquely challenging and important, so we would expect that the cost reporting would be of a very high standard. Exactly what arrangements were in place for cost reporting to the corporate body? In practice, what cost reporting took place?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

Forgive me if I am repeating myself, but this project has been in two phases. Since achieving a settled design, at stage D, with a budget and cost plan to match, we have been able to report—as we are doing now, via the progress group—whether tenders coming in are above or below what was expected, and to say what remedial action we will take. The process is detailed and, I like to think, quite sophisticated.Before that stage, we were in a rather more difficult position. All that we had were occasional estimates from the cost consultants—I think that there had been two or three. The cost reporting to the corporate body in that period was very different: it was more by way of a debate as to what might push a cost up and what might be done to bring it back down. We got a more detailed report on costs when we commissioned a value engineering exercise.The cost reporting was more intermittent in the earlier phase, compared to the regular and frequent cost reporting that we now have, but which we are able to do only because we have a design and a cost plan to report against.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Do you therefore agree with the statement in Mr Black's document that the cost reporting was not systematic? Do you feel that the corporate body was left in some difficulty because of that?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It was not systematic because it was not possible to be systematic. I do not think that the corporate body was left in difficulty. It would have been essential for the body responsible to have accurate, regular and frequent cost reports if we had been—as we are now—constructing the project at a rapid rate. However, that was not the case last autumn: we were instituting a redesign. When you are redesigning, there is little to report cost against.I accept what Mr Black is saying—as a statement of fact it is hard to dispute. However, the context at the time was very different, and I do not think that the cost reporting left the corporate body disadvantaged. Had we been working on a more routine sort of project, we might have been able to produce better guesstimates of the effects of incremental changes. That would have been nice, but we were never able to do it. With hindsight, I like to think that we could have done it; but the clear advice that I had from the project team was that we could not. The team was not saying that because it wanted to leave the project team in the dark—you have to be responsible when you produce cost estimates.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

So you believe that it was not necessary to have systematic cost reporting.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I believe that, at that time, it was not possible. It is possible now, and it is being done.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

You are saying that it was not possible?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

It was not possible, because we did not have a settled design and we did not have a settled cost plan. There was no basis on which to do the cost reporting, as there now is.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I would like to take you forward to the second half of 1999, when various estimates from the cost consultants prompted an immediate review of the health of the project. Why did you not advise the corporate body of the figure at that time?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

I will explain that decision, which was my personal decision. When the project team came to me with that figure, my first reaction—and I still think this—was that it was completely unacceptable. My second reaction was to ask where the figure had come from. Two issues arose. The first concerned the almost mystical 4,000 sq m. The team informed me that 4,000 sq m in the cost report were unaccounted for. That is a huge amount of space, and potentially a huge amount of money. I immediately sent the team away to find out where it had come from. The second issue was the value engineering exercise that we instituted, the conclusion of which was that the cost figure was unacceptable and unreliable.It all comes back to the judgment that you have to make, and I do not claim always to make the right judgments. In a sense, the easier thing to do is to dump the problem in the lap of the clients—to report to the corporate body and say, "This is your problem." The course that I chose to take, on the advice of the project team, was to go to the corporate body with solutions as well as problems. In other words, I wanted to be able to say how reliable the figure was, where it had come from, what it comprised and what we had in hand to reconcile it with, or bring it closer to, the budget figure.We told the corporate body that we had had cost reports and that they were unacceptable. We did not hide from the corporate body the fact that there were cost reports. It is true that we did not reveal the figure, but I felt that that would have been, in a sense, almost irresponsible: it might have prompted the corporate body into action that was inappropriate. That is why I made that judgment at that time.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I want to be clear about this. You decided that it was not necessary to advise the corporate body—the body of politicians that is, in effect, responsible to the Scottish Parliament for the issues around the Scottish Parliament building—that costs were escalating?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No. We told the corporate body that we had had unacceptable cost estimates. The corporate body was in no doubt that we had significant cost pressures. I set about clarifying the basis of those costs and taking action to deal with them, so that I could report to the corporate body at a future date with information about where the figure had come from and whether it was reliable. On the basis of the advice that I had, I had no confidence in the figure. It was only proper to have some action in hand. That was overtaken by the feasibility redesign, which took place in November. The judgment that I made was made in September.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Did you say that you had no confidence in that figure?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

That is correct. I did not.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

So we paid specialist cost consultants £2 million to research the costs, but you were not confident about that figure?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

There is a difference between lacking confidence in one cost report and lacking confidence in the firm of cost consultants. I have great confidence in Davis, Langdon & Everest, which is a good firm of cost consultants, but I did not have confidence in that figure. The firm can cost only what it has been given, which returns to the point about the state of the design. The design was not settled, and the cost consultants can quantify only what they have. In particular, there was an additional 4,000 sq m in the drawings, which the firm costed, but for which nobody could account. That was a huge disparity.I do not mean to say that I was not confident. I was confident that the firm had identified the figure, but I was not confident that it accurately reflected the cost of building the project as it then was. We told the corporate body that we had had unacceptable cost estimates and we told it that we were taking action, but I did not reveal the number, for the reasons that I gave. That is a judgment call, and I accept that, with the benefit of hindsight, people might look back and say that that was not the right judgment. For what it is worth, even reflecting on the decision now—it would have been nice to come here today and tell the committee that I passed the information on to the corporate body—I still think that the judgment was probably right. It was a judgment call, but I think that I took it for good reasons at the time.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Excuse me. Mr Martin is still asking questions.

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

We now move on to August 1999, when the costs were predicted to be as much as £115 million. That prediction prompted an immediate review of the health of the project. Why did you not advise the Parliament then, when you had specific information?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

What would we have advised the Parliament? We would have had to advise it that the design had become less fixed—John Spencely picked up that point. At that time, we were just reaching the end of the chamber redesign. Clear pressures were coming through that the building would not be big enough, and we had a cost report that had a problem and reflected some uncertainty. I do not think that returning to the Parliament with a lot of questions and maybes would have been responsible. We owe it in the first place to the corporate body, which owes it to the Parliament, to go to the Parliament with some certainty. You may say that it took a long time to achieve that certainty, but that is what the corporate body came to the Parliament with in April this year. Then, the corporate body was able to say: "Here is a design that we think is good enough. Here is a budget that we think is appropriate. Here is a set of structures that we think will deal with the project." In August, the design was extremely fluid and was becoming, if anything, less certain. I honestly think that we were not in a position then to know what to advise the Parliament. Part of our responsibility is to have some answers and some confidence in the figures that we are punting around; otherwise, we would just have been offloading the problem.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I am sorry for staying on the same point, but it is important. Did the corporate body know at that time? Did it raise any concerns about the fact that you had not advised it and not conveyed the information to it?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

The corporate body did not ask specifically what the number was.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

That raises another question, into which I will not stray. Did the corporate body raise concerns with you later about the fact that you had not reported that information to it? Are there any minutes to which you can refer us?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Are there any conversations to which you can point?

Paul Grice Clerk and Chief Executive, Scottish Parliament
link

No. I told them what I told them at the time. The corporate body and I have not returned to that. Obviously, in the context of the Auditor General's report, I have discussed matters with the corporate body, as you would expect me to. I explained again to it why I took the action that I did, and it accepted my explanation. I am not saying that the corporate body agrees 100 per cent with my explanation, but I gave my reasons again, more recently, and I think, or at least hope, that it understands why we took the action that we did.

Nick Johnston Con The Deputy Convener · Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Paragraph 3.50 on page 41 of the report says:"Later, during the second half of 1999, project management did not report various estimates from the cost consultant to the Corporate Body as the client."It appears that you were aware of the anomalies in the costing. What hat were you wearing at the time?

  1. Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Tuesday 3 October 2000 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Holyrood Project Evidence session · 298

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.