I want to shift the conversation slightly by posing the question, "Where does economic growth begin?" At our away day, Donald MacRae made the interesting suggestion that Scotland would be far better investing more money in early years education than in university education. He also suggested that nursery education should start at a younger age and be targeted at specific groups. For example, it might start at the age of two in areas of multiple deprivation. I would quite like to hear people's views on that.I was quite taken with Janet Lowe's comments about our universities not targeting where future skills demand will come from. That issue certainly interests me. For example, we do a lot of trade with Europe, but the growing global markets are in China, India and so on. What are we doing about language skills in Mandarin Chinese and Urdu? Spanish is another possibly global language. At what point do we start teaching those languages? Should they be more readily available?If we are to focus on what Scotland could be good at, renewable energy presents many opportunities that the committee has heard much about. Not that long ago, however, the SCDI produced a paper that highlighted the shortage of science graduates who could contribute to that sector of industry. That brings us back to Janet Lowe's point about whether universities properly target the areas of opportunity that will exist for future workers. Are we doing enough to encourage our schoolchildren into those fields? Perhaps the new skills agency's job should include illustrating to students how they could have a really exciting job in such industries. It might need to say, "Do not be put off by the fact that physics and chemistry seem boring subjects because, by learning this science, you can go into this industry." I do not think that enough of that is done. We should perhaps look at that issue.On productivity and planning, in a previous life I worked with a company called Ross International Ltd, which is run by Stuart Ross who is a kaizen expert. He goes into companies to show them how they can improve their productivity and he has had some amazing results. I have always thought that more companies should make use of his skills, but he is now moving into the public sector. For example, he turned around Aberdeenshire Council's planning department by helping it to cut its turnaround time by 60 or 70 per cent within a short period. However, he did that—Stephen Boyd made this point—by involving the workforce in asking how improvements could be made. It might be worth considering how companies can be encouraged to sit down with their workforce and ask, "How can we make improvements?" As Jim Lee said, if we make improvements, we all get the benefit. That issue should also be considered.On planning, I worry a bit about the extent to which economic growth might depend on local authorities. I know that, in my area, East Dunbartonshire Council has a shortage of planners. I just wonder—this is a skills issue—whether enough people are being encouraged to become planners if planning is so vital for economic growth.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing David Whitton only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 42
- Stephen Boyd Scottish Trades Union Congress 5
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 5
- Dr Lowe 5
- Iain McMillan CBI Scotland 4
- Antonia Swinson Scottish Social Enterprise Coalition 4
- Liz Cameron Scottish Chambers of Commerce 4
- Christopher Harvie SNP 4
- Andrew Watson Federation of Small Businesses Scotland 3
- Jim Lee Co-operation & Mutuality Scotland Ltd 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Dave Thompson SNP 3
- Iain Duff Scottish Council for Development and Industry 2
- Steve Dunlop British Waterways Scotland 2
- Dr Marriage 2
- Dr Janet Lowe Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 1
- Dr Howard Marriage University of Edinburgh 1
- Stephen Imrie Clerk 1
David Whitton’s contributions
3 contributionsI echo what other members have said. I support the view that we look at tourism first, because it embraces everything that we have heard this morning and affects all of Scotland—it does not focus only on the north or south of Scotland; tourism is a Scotland-wide business.To answer Christopher Harvie, I guess that people are going elsewhere because the economy has improved, people have jobs and they are using the money that they earn to go away. We have to improve the tourism industry here so that there is inter-UK as well as foreign travel. At our away day, we identified certain areas of weakness. Scotland plc has to understand better how it can be a more welcoming place on the tourism map.
I hesitate to force the question to a vote. We have agreed that we want to look at both areas. Although I accept the points that Dave Thompson is making, I still think that the tourism inquiry embraces more of the things that we have heard about in our round-table discussions; the energy inquiry is more specific. We would be better kicking off with the tourism inquiry—because it brings in all the things that we have been considering—then moving on to the energy inquiry.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Oct 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 3 October 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 105
- Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.