I am struck by the extent of agreement round the table among a wide range of people. In the past, those same people might have taken diametrically opposing views about where the economy ought to go. That development is extremely positive.We need to focus on competition, productivity and how to manage change, whether that is about management or the need to work co-operatively throughout the workforce. There has not been much focus on R and D this morning, other than the particular area that was highlighted. We discussed ownership and acquiring assets. All those things are important. Some of the issues are to do with what we do after skills training—whether it happens in colleges, universities or otherwise. I think that how we best manage the skills and knowledge that we have to make the change and to get the growth is an area that we could move along. I was particularly intrigued by Steve Dunlop's contribution. A couple of weeks ago, we visited Glasgow and went down the Clyde on a boat. What struck me about that boat trip was that ours was the only boat on the river. Steve Dunlop was absolutely right in what he said: we have stunning assets, particularly on the west coast. I spent some time this summer on the east coast of the States, where I saw boats everywhere and very busy harbours. We are just not cutting it as far as that is concerned. I am not sure about the extent to which that is due to a lack of public drivers to make the private sector viable, or indeed whether we can transform that overnight, or whether we should focus on it. However, if we have an underutilised asset, we should use it. I have a challenge for those who represent the various business interests, which leads on from a point that our colleague Professor Christopher Harvie has raised. Is the current lack of success in terms of growth in the SME sector caused by, or partly caused by, the crowding out of the sector by the black economy? Perhaps the FSB representative has something to say on that. Do we not have an acquisitive private sector because it is being crowded out by a variety of substantial economic activities? I am talking not only about the illicit drug trade but about other such activities that may be crowding out the SMEs.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Brian Adam only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 42
- Stephen Boyd Scottish Trades Union Congress 5
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 5
- Dr Lowe 5
- Iain McMillan CBI Scotland 4
- Antonia Swinson Scottish Social Enterprise Coalition 4
- Liz Cameron Scottish Chambers of Commerce 4
- Christopher Harvie SNP 4
- Andrew Watson Federation of Small Businesses Scotland 3
- Jim Lee Co-operation & Mutuality Scotland Ltd 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Dave Thompson SNP 3
- Iain Duff Scottish Council for Development and Industry 2
- Steve Dunlop British Waterways Scotland 2
- Dr Marriage 2
- Dr Janet Lowe Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 1
- Dr Howard Marriage University of Edinburgh 1
- Stephen Imrie Clerk 1
Brian Adam’s contributions
3 contributionsI am quite happy with that general approach, which is in essence what I was asking for before. There was general agreement that we want to seek to grow the tourism industry by 50 per cent within a fairly short timescale, but I was never convinced that we had heard how we would get there and what barriers would need to be overcome. The issues that the convener has listed are certainly significant.Dave Thompson asked about the role of planning. We could explore planning issues, but this might be a wee bit early given that new legislation has only just been put in place and we do not know what kind of impact it will have.I would be content to move down the line the convener has suggested. The inquiry would focus on a specific industry in the economy and address all the issues that were raised at the away day.
The interest (Scotland) bill is another matter altogether. I do not have any strong views on whether we hold the tourism inquiry or the energy inquiry first. I tend to support David Whitton's view. Given that, as I understand it, we are unlikely to get the proposed energy efficiency and micro-generation (Scotland) bill, because the Government is going to take it on board, it is difficult to argue that we should not take the interest (Scotland) bill. I certainly think that we ought to take it, because we agreed that we would have only one Justice Committee in the Parliament and, as I understand it, that committee will have two bills. The Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee is the next most appropriate committee to consider the interest (Scotland) bill. However, I do not know that we will have desperately much say in the decision, because that is up to the bureau.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Oct 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 3 October 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 105
- Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.