We have been developing our work programme by hearing presentations from individuals from the economy, energy and tourism sectors—we started doing that during the summer. The purpose was to invite thought-provoking evidence on the difficult issues that face Scotland in the three areas on which the committee might consider undertaking formal work. In the past few weeks we have considered energy and tourism—our discussions are publicly available in the Official Report. Today we tackle the economy.I am pleased to welcome our panel of witnesses. We have tried to make our evidence sessions as informal as possible. We genuinely want our invited guests to pitch in on any area on which they want to comment. The aim is to pull together themes that you think are essential for the committee to consider as part of a future inquiry on the Scottish economy.For information, after the October recess—which starts when the schools go out in some parts of Scotland on Friday—the committee will hear from the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth and the Minister for Schools and Skills. We hope to hear from the chair of the new council of economic advisers in November.We are interested in the witnesses' thoughts and ideas on the enterprise networks, the skills strategy and the wider economic forum that the Government has established. I invite members and panellists to give their initial thoughts on issues that the committee should consider in relation to the future of our economy. It would be good to hear first from CBI Scotland, so I invite Iain McMillan to start the discussion.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Tavish Scott only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 42
- Stephen Boyd Scottish Trades Union Congress 5
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 5
- Dr Lowe 5
- Iain McMillan CBI Scotland 4
- Antonia Swinson Scottish Social Enterprise Coalition 4
- Liz Cameron Scottish Chambers of Commerce 4
- Christopher Harvie SNP 4
- Andrew Watson Federation of Small Businesses Scotland 3
- Jim Lee Co-operation & Mutuality Scotland Ltd 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Dave Thompson SNP 3
- Iain Duff Scottish Council for Development and Industry 2
- Steve Dunlop British Waterways Scotland 2
- Dr Marriage 2
- Dr Janet Lowe Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 1
- Dr Howard Marriage University of Edinburgh 1
- Stephen Imrie Clerk 1
Tavish Scott’s contributions
42 contributionsDoes Antonia Swinson want to comment next? It will make for a nice juxtaposition if we hear from the Scottish social enterprise coalition after hearing from CBI Scotland.
That might chime with Stephen Boyd's thoughts.
Try a couple for now.
Thank you. You raised an interesting issue about the consistency of the European Commission. We may want to deal with that wider point.
Okay. Would you like to throw in the Federation of Small Businesses Scotland's perspective, Andrew?
Does someone want to kill that mobile phone? Sorry—I should have said before we started that mobile phones should be switched off.
Thank you, that was helpful. I will bring in Howard Marriage. Will you say a little about what you do? You have the title "entrepreneur in residence", which is probably the most intriguing title of anyone here.
Thank you—that was fascinating. Our discussion began with Iain McMillan talking about building blocks and I can think of no one who has to spend more of his day-to-day job on linking the public and private sectors and everything in between than Steve Dunlop. I ask him to talk about that side of things.
That was helpful. I should stress that Steve Dunlop is not here just because I put money into his budget when I had some responsibilities for that. I open up the discussion to anyone with contributions to make. Committee colleagues with questions to ask and themes that they wish to pursue with our experts should pitch in whenever they like. We have had a lot of important points and contributions already, and I am grateful for that.
You do not need to answer all of that at once. In fairness to Brian Adam, the issue that Christopher Harvie raised is a serious and substantial one. I suggest that our witnesses think about it and come back on it later.
Lewis Macdonald has asked a good question on productivity and Brian Adam put a good one on the black economy. Does any other member have a question to put before I bring our panel members back in?
It may be interesting for the witnesses to know that, when we had presentations from our economists, we could not get them to agree what the right target was and what the measurements should be. The witnesses should not feel that Gavin Brown's question is loaded by any means; he is quite right to ask it in that context.
Dave Thompson, David Whitton and Christopher Harvie all want to ask questions. Perhaps we could deal with that first tranche of questions first before we come to them. Otherwise no one will remember what all the issues are—me included.
That is most reassuring, Mr McMillan.
Thank you. Would any other guests like to talk? Liz Cameron?
Sorry to interrupt, Liz, but as the issue has been raised I should say that because we are in exactly the position that you describe, we commissioned some research into the matter, which we will share with you.
Thank you, that is useful.
I take it, for the record, that you meant Lewis Macdonald rather than Lewis Moonie.
That is all right. Our Lewis is not quite in the House of Lords yet, but he might be any day now.
I just did not want the Official Report to get that one wrong.
I am aware that David Whitton, Dave Thompson and Christopher Harvie have been waiting patiently to speak.
Thank you, Christopher. You mentioned various subjects for our expert guests to think about. I would like to finish by half past 11. If people wish to pick up on any of the points that the three committee members made, I am happy to hear comments.
That is helpful.
We cannot have agreement all day; that would be boring.
Indeed.
I thank all our guests for coming to the meeting. Your thoughtful and considered contributions will assist us in our considerations. Over the next week or so, I hope that we will sort out how to pull together all the evidence that we have heard and that we will draw up the precise terms of the inquiry. I am sure that we will look for your thoughts on that in due course. The session has been very useful. We will have a five-minute break. No doubt, members need to use their mobile phones.
Ladies and gentlemen, let us reconvene the meeting. On reflection, that was probably the best session that we have had in terms of how thoughtful the guests were in their contributions. Item 4 is consideration of the work programme, for which Stephen Imrie and the clerking team have pulled together a paper. I will have a first cut at what our overall approach should be. I appreciate that this will worry people, but I think that I have been Jim Mathered—I know, I know—as I was mind mapping throughout that presentation. Blimey, I will have to get the software next. However, the conclusion that I took from the session was that we could take one of our principal areas of responsibility, such as tourism, and then take the legs off it—as we did today and in previous evidence sessions—by considering the issues such as inward investment, contribution to growth, business models, regulation or planning, skills and leadership management. For example, I remember that we had a presentation about the hospitality school when we were up in Pitlochry.For the sake of argument, let us say that we constructed an inquiry around the central principle of the growth numbers—growth in value rather than in the number of people—for tourism. We could take the legs off that and allow individual members to pursue their particular interests. For example, I have a strong focus on the skills agenda, on which we heard a lot today. We could construct an inquiry on that basis.I throw that on the table, but I am keen to hear whether members completely knock it down or whether they think that there is merit in that approach. My suggestion would allow us to take an industry that is part of our remit, look at the different legs of that industry and—as many people today and in previous sessions, both publicly and privately, have recommended—get involved in a bit of the decluttering agenda. We can look at how things join up and how they are pulled together. As Lewis Macdonald asked today, what things are we not doing right and how can we address those? That is my suggestion, but I am happy to take others.Does Brian Adam want to have a first cut at it?
You are quite entitled to do that.
That is not inconsistent with what we propose. It is fair that it should be part of the analysis that we must carry out.
I totally accept that we need to look at energy. We need to choose which inquiry will we carry out first and which will follow.
Okay, we have a classic split in the committee—a good old cross-party split, which is extremely helpful for me. I am relaxed about which inquiry to hold first, but based on what we heard at our away day at Pitlochry, I am clear that we should do both. Dave Thompson and Lewis Macdonald argue that the Government has announced significant changes to the infrastructural environment in the past few weeks. If we considered tourism second, we could pick up those changes six months down the line and they could feed into our deliberations at that time. We could also look at the planning issues with a post-six months perspective.Stephen Imrie will keep me right, but there are no particular constraints on considering energy now as regards what we might expect from the Government. We could just get on with it. I make the political observation that a bit of an energy mix will be proposed that will lead to a clear difference of opinion—I am thinking of nuclear—so the first thing the committee will do is divide on that point. Some of us might listen to the evidence and then reflect on it, of course. I am sure that we will all listen and reflect, but you know what I mean—let us be real about politics. We might want to weigh up that consideration too.I am comfortable if the committee's thinking is to consider energy first, because infrastructural changes have just been announced and we should wait six months before we consider them. I do not have a strong view either way.
Okay. Stephen Imrie has just suggested the helpful compromise—I do not know why I did not think of this—of running the two inquiries vaguely in parallel. That would depend on our not taking the proposed interest (Scotland) bill—my firm view is that that is not our bill to take, anyway. We could start with the tourism inquiry and overlap it a bit with the energy inquiry.
Okay.
Of course, ultimately, it is for the bureau to award—if that is the right word—bills to committees. Let us deal with the other issue first, then come back to that point.Are we broadly agreed that we will go with a tourism inquiry and an energy inquiry in a phased fashion?Members indicated agreement.
I refer to paragraph 15 of the paper on our work programme. Is the committee broadly comfortable with the remaining elements of the work programme, such as the budget scrutiny, the one-off hearing and so on? Certain dates are set out in the programme.
You make an entirely fair point, which is true whether you have been in this place eight years or eight days. November is a busy month and we will simply have to adjust our programme accordingly. We cannot do everything that is set out in one month. It has been suggested that the spending review announcement in Westminster might be made on Monday, which will trigger the budget and so on. All that is in the mix. We will keep the committee up to date with that.
I will do so at the first meeting after the recess.I refer to paragraph 8 of the paper, which sets out subjects for further research. Since the away day at Pitlochry, Christopher Harvie has consistently made the point about the black economy. I do not want to be flippant about it. We thought that it was important to stimulate research through Stephen Imrie and the clerking team. That will come back in due course. We are not losing sight of that at all.
Quite. Are all the other recommendations fine?Members indicated agreement.
The only other issue is the interest (Scotland) bill. I take Brian Adam's point. Ultimately, the bureau will decide whether we get the bill, so there is not much point discussing it. My clear view is that it will be a justice bill led by the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and drawn up by the justice department of the Government with justice civil servants. Saying that we should consider a bill because we do not have anything else to do is not a particularly good argument. We demonstrably have a lot else to do. Parliament decided to have one Justice Committee and that committee may now have two bills. I presume that the Parliamentary Bureau, in taking the decision to have one Justice Committee, reflected on the expected workload that the Government will bring to the bureau to be dealt with by appropriate committees.
I suspect that we will not agree on the matter—I could take a diametrically opposed view.
We will not agree on the matter. I appreciate that members have firm views and I thank them for expressing those. Ultimately, the Parliamentary Bureau will decide on the matter.If colleagues are content that we have dealt with the issues on the work programme, I ask Stephen Imrie to give the committee a feel for the approach. I presume that we hope to have a proposed remit for our tourism inquiry for sign-off after the recess.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Oct 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 3 October 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 105
- Petitions Petitions · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.