I am an MSP for the Highlands and Islands.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Dave Thompson only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 29
- Willie Roe Highlands and Islands Enterprise 6
- Paul Jennings Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions 6
- Eddie Brogan Scottish Enterprise 5
- Paul Bush EventScotland 5
- Iain Herbert Scottish Tourism Forum 5
- Philip Riddle VisitScotland 5
- Carl Watt Scottish Museums Council 5
- Dave Thompson SNP 4
- Bernard Donoghue VisitBritain 4
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Iain Gray Lab 2
- Christopher Harvie SNP 2
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
Dave Thompson’s contributions
4 contributionsI am not sure where to start, as many points have already been made. I will kick off with a question that all three previous speakers might want to answer and I will restrict myself to just a few points. On marketing, are we making the best use of the international offices of the likes of Scottish Development International? Do we link with them as much as we could?Willie Roe talked about direct flights to the north and to Scotland in general. Flying is a problem for our carbon footprint but, if people fly directly into Scotland rather than via London hubs, less carbon will be emitted, because the leg of the journey from London to Scotland will not be required. Perhaps we can increase the number of international flights to Scotland, through the route development fund or other measures, so that the majority of businesspeople and tourists can come straight to Scotland rather than having to travel through Heathrow.Willie Roe mentioned that the growth aspiration is about value, not numbers. I welcome that, because the Scottish Tourism Forum has said that one difficulty that holds us back is the low pay, long hours, seasonal nature and low status of employment in the tourism industry. If we increased the value, I hope that it would be reflected in staff wages and hours of work. That is hugely important. If we are to expect people to welcome visitors with a smile, they must be well rewarded for what they do, be well trained and not be exhausted because they are working 70, 80 or 90 hours a week. It is a serious problem in the tourism industry at the moment.
I would like to be. I think that I can manage to boil an egg.Following on from what has been said, I think that training is probably okay for bigger organisations. However, many small businesses out there struggle to train staff who have not been sourced from elsewhere.Just as a point of information, I can tell the committee that the tourism course at Inverness College this winter has been cancelled because it could not get enough students to fill it. It is worrying if, in the heart of the Highlands, we cannot get enough students to take a tourism course.So, on my general point, how can smaller businesses be helped by the bigger ones? Could there be some kind of link through which bigger organisations with their own training programmes helped smaller local businesses to offer training to their staff? Are there any views on that?
I will follow up on Willie Roe's point about music. The skills and confidence that youngsters gain from being involved in music are particularly marked in Highland region. They are also marked in the fèisean—the Gaelic music festivals that have been developing over the past 20-odd years—and the Gaelic-medium units and schools, such as the new Gaelic school in Inverness, where the cultural and musical aspects of Gaelic are taught to youngsters. There is a very high music content in Gaelic-medium education, so the children come out of school singing and playing instruments with a lot of confidence. They are also bilingual in English and Gaelic. When they reach primary 6, they are taught a European language, such as French, in which they have a head start as they are already bilingual. Gaelic is underplayed in Scotland, especially considering the authenticity that was talked about earlier. In the Highlands, even the street signs and so on can ensure that people know that they are coming somewhere different, but there is a lot of resistance from people when we want to put them in Gaelic. They say that people will start crashing their cars because there will be both Gaelic and English. I do not know how those folk get on when they go abroad—I do not know how they ever find their way to anywhere. However, the Gaelic thing is beneficial for confidence, skills and authenticity.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 89
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 5
- Witness Expenses Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.