I am the member of the Scottish Parliament for East Lothian.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Iain Gray only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 29
- Willie Roe Highlands and Islands Enterprise 6
- Paul Jennings Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions 6
- Eddie Brogan Scottish Enterprise 5
- Paul Bush EventScotland 5
- Iain Herbert Scottish Tourism Forum 5
- Philip Riddle VisitScotland 5
- Carl Watt Scottish Museums Council 5
- Dave Thompson SNP 4
- Bernard Donoghue VisitBritain 4
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Iain Gray Lab 2
- Christopher Harvie SNP 2
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
Iain Gray’s contributions
2 contributionsI suppose that our primary concern as a committee is to examine what the Government and the public sector should and should not be doing to support the industry. Two points emerged strongly from the discussions on tourism that we had at our away day, and they have come up again today. One is a barrier and the other is an opportunity. I would be interested to hear more from colleagues about them.Philip Riddle said that the piece of legislation that he would introduce would be one that would make it easier to invest and expand. The speakers on tourism from whom we heard on our away day both spoke a great deal about the difficulty of planning and how long it takes to get through the planning process. I suspect that that is part of what Philip Riddle was referring to.I want to explore that issue a bit further. It is a difficult area for politicians, who either set the legal framework or get involved in local decisions, because there is a tension between making it easier to develop and allowing an ease of development that could destroy the very aspect that is being exploited or sold. I do not know how we get the balance right. If people have ideas about how we could do things differently, that would be helpful.The positive point was about destination management and marketing, which both the speakers on tourism at our away day spoke about a great deal. They made a good case that destination management and marketing are an important way forward. When Willie Roe talked about destination management, it seemed from the examples that he gave that one of the advantages of such an approach is that it is quite business led. The project at Loch Ness, for example, essentially involved a group of businesses that had come together and put some money into it.My question is about balance. Should we encourage the public sector bodies that are represented here to impose a strategy of destination management, or should we sit back and wait for businesses to realise that it represents an opportunity and something that they might want to get into. How do we avoid the situation in which Scotland becomes a plethora of destinations of dubious value and credibility all competing with one another? One of the speakers at our away day issued a challenge, which was to find a city anywhere in the world that did not have a jazz festival. The concept of a jazz festival has become devalued to the extent that no jazz festival is worth much because every city has one. How do destinations avoid arriving at such a position?
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 89
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 5
- Witness Expenses Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.