Good morning and welcome to the third meeting of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, which I managed to completely misname in Aberdeen yesterday when Brian Adam and I were at the "Offshore Europe" conference. I am quite glad that the committee's name is written down in front of me so that I cannot call it anything else.I am pleased to welcome those who have come to the committee to represent different aspects of tourism. The committee is in the initial stages of looking at areas that it wishes to explore during the next year or so, after due consideration and discussion. One of the ways in which we wanted to develop our ideas about the most useful subjects to look into in detail was by having a series of round-table discussions. My objectives today are to ensure that the session is as informal as it possibly can be, given the constraints of a parliamentary committee and the Official Report, and that we have a full discussion.It would be useful to go round the table to begin with so that everyone knows who everyone else is and what their respective organisations are.This afternoon, Alex Salmond will make a speech on the legislative programme for the next year. Of course, every Government does that and it will be our equivalent of the Queen's speech. So when you are saying who you are, if you have an idea about legislation or something that you would like to see happen, you should feel free to mention it. That invitation is not to the politicians; I am not going to allow them to respond to it because they will have plenty opportunity to do that later this afternoon. It is a request just to our good friends who have come in to give us their thoughts on the industry.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Tavish Scott only · show everyone- Tavish Scott LD 29
- Willie Roe Highlands and Islands Enterprise 6
- Paul Jennings Association of Scottish Visitor Attractions 6
- Eddie Brogan Scottish Enterprise 5
- Paul Bush EventScotland 5
- Iain Herbert Scottish Tourism Forum 5
- Philip Riddle VisitScotland 5
- Carl Watt Scottish Museums Council 5
- Dave Thompson SNP 4
- Bernard Donoghue VisitBritain 4
- David Whitton Lab 3
- Gavin Brown Con 3
- Brian Adam SNP 3
- Iain Gray Lab 2
- Christopher Harvie SNP 2
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
Tavish Scott’s contributions
29 contributionsYou are probably not allowed to say what legislation you would like. I think that we could all guess.
My name is Tavish Scott and I convene this committee. Following on from David Whitton's comment, I will claim that my constituency, Shetland, is the nautical capital of the world or something. Perhaps Willie Roe can help me with that.I am open to a discussion of any subjects that either committee members or our visitors might want to stimulate debate on. The committee has had initial thoughts on two areas. The first is the target for 50 per cent growth in the number of visitors, with which Philip Riddle will be familiar. We would like to talk about how attainable that is, whether that is the right number and the barriers that there are to that being achieved. The second area relates to skills and services in the tourism industry, about which we all have stories to tell. Indeed, when the committee met to discuss its work programme, we stayed in a hotel in a Scottish town and had reflections to share on that particular experience.Could I have people's views on the 50 per cent target?
Thanks for that; we will return to the skills theme later in the morning. Gavin Brown wishes to speak, but I will come back to him. I heard Jan Bebbington of the Sustainable Development Commission on Radio Scotland this morning. She said that there should be no more route development fund and that we should cancel all road projects. There are some interesting balances in there—I suspect that we all have our views. I invite Bernard Donoghue to reflect on the wider VisitBritain perspective and what is happening internationally.
I ask Willie Roe to give us a far-north perspective on those matters.
Okay. As I said, we will come to that issue in the second half of the meeting. I am conscious that some people have not yet had the opportunity to pitch in.I welcome Paul Jennings, who was not here at the start of the meeting. It is good to have you here. Thanks for coming. In this first cut at it, we want to look at the barriers to growth and the point that Dave Thompson just made about growth versus value and where the numbers should be. Would you like to add to that?
They would be in management consultancy.
We will ask Eddie Brogan about that after we have heard from Iain Gray.
We could ask Iain Herbert to have a crack at answering that from the perspective of the Scottish Tourism Forum but, before we do so, I ask Eddie Brogan to deal with Paul Jennings's point about the role of the public sector in involving business.
Will Iain Herbert respond to Iain Gray's important questions about destination management and the planning system?
Okay. Half an hour on tripadvisor.com would tell you quite a lot about how people see the product.Before we move on to talk about skills, does anyone want to pitch in on the point about destination management that Iain Gray raised? As David Whitton pointed out, we talked about that a lot at the away day last week. I am conscious that there must be a tie between destination management and event management, but I will let David Whitton go first.
I would have thought that the chairman of Highlands and Islands Enterprise would be first down the downhill on a mountain bike.
How would you answer Iain Gray's point about demand management in localities, and some of the other reflections from other colleagues about there potentially being a plethora of such companies throughout Scotland?
Yes.
Carl, do you want to pitch in from the perspective of the museums and galleries?
I would like to move the discussion on to skills. Chris Harvie might want to start.
That is why I like having Christopher on the committee—lots of thought-provoking ideas. We will have the Church of Scotland and the Catholic church in next week to deal with that.I ask Philip Riddle not to deal with the secular point, which would be most unfair, but to deal with the important point that Chris made about Edinburgh and Pitlochry—although the point could have been made about anywhere you could name in Scotland.
Perhaps Bernard Donoghue will speak about London in the same context. As the Olympic games are coming to London, part of VisitBritain's job will be to ask, when potentially hundreds of thousands of people will come to London, how it can ensure that the rest of the country, including Scotland, benefits.
That provides a beautiful link to skills. It is an unfair line, but someone used the line the other day that you can tell an extrovert Scot because when he speaks he looks at your shoes rather than at his own. Marilyn, do you want to kick off in this area, given your knowledge and experience?
Your points are very sound. All members will have noted that many of the staff in the Aviemore complex, for example, which has been used a lot for political conferences over the past couple of years, are very well trained and able, but do not actually come from Scotland.
Good point. I wonder whether Iain Herbert will give us a Scottish Tourism Forum perspective.
So, celebrity chefs—discuss. David, are you a celebrity chef?
I do not want to stop other people, but do Paul Jennings and Iain Herbert want to come back on the questions raised by David Whitton and the latter point raised by Dave Thompson? Paul, do you want to have a crack at the idea of an international hotel school and the questions of practice versus theory? What are our people being taught in our educational institutions?
That is a fundamental point that we will come back to.
Absolutely. In our part of the world, if you do not have a fiddle festival, you are not alive.
I am keen to pull the discussion together, so I will ask our guests whether they have a view on the particular aspect of tourism on which the committee could best spend its time. If they could express that view this morning or write to or e-mail us through our clerks in the next couple of weeks, it would be extremely helpful. Philip, do you want to kick off? As I said, I am happy to take comments in writing if that would be easier.
Sure. Carl, do you have anything in particular to say?
A good and fundamental point was made on the skills side of the equation and why other countries appear to find it easier to encourage their younger folk in particular to be part of an industry. We would want to reflect on that.
Thank you very much. We appreciate your time this morning. It has been extremely helpful in allowing us to gain a better take of the issues that you would like us to have a look at, and we will now reflect on them. We will pause for a couple of minutes to let everyone clear before we deal with two small final items.Before we knock through the last two agenda items, let me say just in passing that I thought that the discussion was useful. Once members have had a think about it, if there are areas that they think that we managed to draw out more substantially, they should let the clerk know and we can have a cut at them both formally and informally in the coming weeks, especially once we have had the energy and economy-themed days.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 89
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 5
- Witness Expenses Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.