Under agenda item 2, we will take evidence on the Justices of the Peace (Scotland) Order 2007 from Richard Wilkins of the Scottish Executive's Justice Department and Stephen Crilly of the Executive's Legal and Parliamentary Services. I welcome them to the Justice 1 Committee and thank them for coming along. Do they want to say anything about the order before we move to questions?
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
I have prepared a brief opening statement, although it covers some of the same ground as the Executive note. Would you rather move to straight to questions?
The Justices of the Peace (Scotland) Order 2007, together with the Criminal Proceedings etc (Reform) (Scotland) Act 2007, creates the statutory framework within which the Scottish Executive's reforms to lay justice can be implemented. In particular, the order provides a statutory basis for the committees that will oversee the recruitment, training and appraisal of justices within each sheriffdom. We intend to start establishing those committees in late April and May of this year. That is why the provisions of the order will come into force on 23 April.The order makes it clear that ministers can appoint someone as a justice of the peace only if that person has been nominated for appointment by a justice of the peace advisory committee. The order also makes it clear that such JPACs must follow procedures that have been approved by the Judicial Appointments Board for Scotland. The board has set up an implementation group with sheriffs principal, the Scottish Executive and the District Courts Association. That group is considering what recruitment procedures should be followed in recruiting JPs in future. The overall intention is to ensure that JPs throughout the country are appointed by a process that is fair and transparent.The order also sets out the functions that the training and appraisal committees will be required to perform. For example, training committees will be required to produce an annual training plan and an annual report on the training that has been made available to JPs in their areas. Appraisal committees will be required to produce a scheme for appraisal in their areas and must set out, among other things, the time intervals at which JPs will be appraised and the process by which JPs can appeal against the outcome of an appraisal. As with recruitment, the intention is to ensure that the committees in each sheriffdom fulfil certain national standards while still being able to take local decisions.The members of the committees will be appointed by a panel chaired by the sheriff principal. That is consistent with the provisions of the 2007 act, which gave the sheriff principal responsibility for the efficient administration of the business of any JP court within their sheriffdom.The order also provides that all new JPs must undergo a course of training approved by the Lord President before they are appointed as JPs and that all current JPs must attend a training course approved by the Lord President within two years of their taking up their new five-year appointments under section 67(7)(b) of the 2007 act. As with the other training provisions, the intention is to ensure a degree of national consistency in the arrangements for providing refresher and induction training for JPs.Finally, it might be worth saying something about the consultation process that we used in preparing the order. The drafts have been discussed in some detail by the court unification and lay justice reference group and its successor body, the lay justice planning and delivery group. Those groups included justices of the peace and legal assessor representatives from the District Courts Association. They also included representation from the Judicial Appointments Board for Scotland, the Judicial Studies Committee, sheriffs principal, the Sheriffs Association, Victim Support Scotland, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the Scottish Court Service and the Lord Lieutenants Association. It is also worth mentioning that all sheriffs principal—not just the sheriff principal representative on the lay justice groups—have been consulted on the policy content of the order. In addition, the Lord President has approved the contents of the order, as is required under section 69(4) of the 2007 act.I hope that I have set out the policy background to the order but members are welcome to ask any questions that they have.
I seek some clarification. It is envisaged that the vast majority of JPs will serve on the bench but a number will remain just signing JPs. Where do signing JPs fit into the equation?
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
Various bits of the drafting might look complicated, because they take that situation into account. When we establish the committees, any JP will be able to stand for membership of a recruitment, training or appraisal committee. In practice, if a JP is unlikely to be eligible for appointment from December onwards, the panel is highly unlikely to select them, as they would be able to be a committee member only for a few months until December. However, under the 2007 act, such JPs are allowed to stand for appointment.Members will notice that the requirement to advertise the vacancies is worded in a specific way. For example, article 7(5) of the order refers to article 7(4)(a)(ii), which says that, for a vacancy that arises "before the specified day","In making appointments to the JPAC, the sheriff principal … shall bring the existence of a vacancy to the attention of … all full justices appointed for a commission area any part of which falls within the sheriffdom".Article 7(5) makes it clear that "full justices" are those who have been on the court rota in the preceding year. We will need to write out to advertise the vacancies only to justices of the peace who have been on the court rota and who are eligible for reappointment. The expectation is that those JPs will apply. I say, without pre-empting selection decisions, that they are by far the likeliest people to be selected.
I have not a question but a general observation. I welcomed the 2007 act. As a previous justice of the peace, I was interested in the provisions on justices. One issue that I pursued during the scrutiny of the bill was training. The order will address the problem that training of justices in some parts of Scotland has been abysmal and almost non-existent. After the order comes into force, every justice of the peace will be trained to the same standard, which is extremely positive and can only be good for the justice system and for the performance of justices of the peace in the JP court. The order is extremely welcome.
Richard Wilkins concentrated heavily on how JPs who do not serve on the bench fit in with the appointment process. Where do they fit into training? I presume that they do not have to undergo training, because they do not serve on the bench—they merely sign.
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
Such JPs do not undergo training. From December 2007 onwards, signing justices will not exist. On the training requirement, article 12 says:"Every JP shall, during each term of appointment, undertake at least such minimum period of approved training as is set down from time to time by the Lord President."In practice, we expect the Lord President to set down the period of approved training that is required so that it applies from December onwards, when JPs will take up their new appointments. Therefore, the training requirement will apply only to full JPs who sit on the bench. In effect, it will not apply to signing justices, because they will not be justices from December, when the Lord President's requirement is likely to be imposed.
I declare an interest as a JP, although I do not serve on the bench as I am an MSP. I understood that the 2007 act provided for MPs, MSPs and councillors to remain JPs.
That was also my understanding. I know councillors who are signing JPs, which is a good function. However, what Richard Wilkins says suggests that they will be barred.
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
Yes, under section 76 of the 2007 act, all councillors can sign documents and have signing powers in the manner of a signing JP.There is no statutory provision in the order for training, but the District Courts Association has a signing manual for JPs. We have had discussions with the Judicial Studies Committee about updating that signing manual so that it can be made available to councillors as well as JPs.
What you are saying is contrary to my understanding of the 2007 act. I understood that people who had been bench-serving JPs and who were elected as MSPs or MPs would no longer be eligible to serve on the bench but would retain the signing function. I thought that the bill contained a provision that would allow them to continue as signing JPs, although that would not be opened up to councillors. How many councillors will be elected in May? Being a signing JP is quite an onerous function and under the old system the councillors who were fully serving JPs were closely vetted.It is quite contrary to the vetting procedure if someone is eligible to function as a signing JP and can therefore sign very important documents just because they are elected. They will not have gone through any particular vetting procedure. I ask you to check the position, please, because what you are saying is entirely contrary to my understanding of the 2007 act.
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
It is absolutely definitely the position. Section 76(1) of the 2007 act says:"A person who is a JP or a stipendiary magistrate may not exercise the judicial functions of office (but may exercise signing functions) if the person is— (a) a member of a local authority, (b) a member of the Scottish Parliament, (c) a member of the House of Commons or the House of Lords."That might be the provision that you are thinking about. It means that, under the new system, if someone is appointed as a full JP and is then elected as a member of a local authority, they will not automatically lose their JP office straight away. They will not be able to sit on the bench but they will be able to perform signing functions. In other words, under the new system, people who are appointed as full JPs and are then elected to office will only be able to perform signing functions, although they will keep their JP office.
So you are not saying that everyone who is elected to a council or Parliament can perform the signing functions. That would mean that 129 people were eligible to sign, in the case of the Scottish Parliament, and that so many MPs would be eligible to sign. They would have to be appointed as a JP, or—
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
No. Section 76(2) says"A member of a local authority, despite not being a JP, may exercise signing functions in the same manner as a JP."All local authority members will be able to exercise those signing functions.
Margaret Mitchell is saying that if a bench-sitting JP is elected to public office, they will not be able to sit as a JP but their signing function can continue.
The numbers do not stack up quite like that. There is a reasonably even geographical spread of a large number of councillors who are able to sign. There are about 1,100 councillors in Scotland at the moment, and although I am not sure exactly how many there will be under the new system, the number will be roughly the same after the May elections. All those councillors, who are fairly evenly distributed across the country, will have signing functions.About 1,900 justices of the peace are on the supplemental list at the moment, as are a further 800 justices of the peace who were full justices and who will no longer hold office as a JP because they do not sit on the bench.The number of people with signing powers will reduce as a result of the provisions of the 2007 act; we are gaining some councillors but losing some people who currently hold office as JPs. However, although the supplemental list has been abolished, the provisions guarantee that a large number of people—fairly evenly spread across the country—will be publicly available and able to perform signing duties.
The order covers a lot of ground but, from what I have read, it seems quite straightforward. Ministers cannot appoint someone who has not come through the appointments process, but can they reject someone who has?
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
A person can still be appointed with a five-year term at the age of 66 or 67. The person would then serve just three or four years of the term and retire at the age of 70.
Why is that necessary? Why can people not fulfil their term? I presume that the situation will not be all that common. Why are people forced to retire at 70? Is that provision compliant with age discrimination law?
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
It is compliant with age discrimination provisions, which do not prevent the setting of retirement ages. Asking people to retire at 70 is consistent with what happens with the rest of the judiciary. All professional judges in Scotland retire at 70, so High Court judges retire at 70, sheriffs—
I am sure that that is right. I raise the point simply because, in this day and age, I find it surprising. Perhaps it is because I am getting older, but I am surprised how many people are still working and functioning at that age.Perhaps in future you will have to review the situation. Someone can be elected at that stage in life but then not be able to complete their term of office because they are forced to retire. What difference would it make if you let people go a year or two beyond 70?
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
Our current feeling is that we would like to retain a standard age across the judiciary. However, as you can imagine, the issue is raised from time to time by justices of the peace as they reach the age of 70. I imagine that we will keep the issue under review.
Committee members do not seem to have any further questions, so it only remains for me to thank you very much for coming to the committee. I can see that you have done a lot of speedy work since we signed off the Criminal Proceedings etc (Reform) (Scotland) Bill, so well done.
Richard WilkinsScottish Executive Justice Department
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.