link
We move on to deal with the Civil Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment (No 2) Regulations 2007.
Official Report · Committee
Civil Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment (No 2) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/181)
link
We move on to deal with the Civil Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment (No 2) Regulations 2007.
The purpose of the regulations is to provide for taxation in proceedings in Scottish civil cases arising before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. The regulations are similar to those in the Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment Regulations 2007.Taxation is a process upon which disputes about fees charged are formally adjudicated. Unlike in criminal cases subsequent to devolution, express provision has been made in regulations for counsel's fees in civil cases that come before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. However, no express provision was made for taxation in such cases, as in criminal cases. In cases where civil legal aid is available, if any dispute or question arises between the Scottish Legal Aid Board and a solicitor or counsel about the amount of fees or outlays allowable to a solicitor or counsel from the fund, the regulations provide that such matters may be referred to the registrar of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.The fees for counsel for any work in relation to proceedings in the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council is 90 per cent of the amount of fees that would be allowed on a taxation of expenses between solicitor and client, third party paying, if the work that was done was not legally aided.A review mechanism has also been included so that anyone who is dissatisfied by a taxation decision of the registrar can lodge a petition that will be considered first by the board of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. I confirm that the regulations were made after full consultation of the registrar, who has confirmed that she is prepared to undertake taxations should they arise in such cases. The policy intention is that there will be a consistent approach in such cases across the United Kingdom as decisions will be based on the benefit of our expertise in the procedures and practice.As far as commencement is concerned, in order that a means for taxation to resolve disputes is provided in respect of all existing cases as soon as possible, the reference to taxation will apply to all proceedings commenced on or after 29 March 2007, and in respect of proceedings that are concluded before 29 March 2007 that are referred to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council after that date.
What will be the practical effect of the regulations? Civil legal aid is quite a hot potato just now, especially in family law: there is real concern that the level of legal aid is not sufficient for it to be viable for practitioners to take such cases, which has led to the many practices not taking legal aid cases. Do the regulations provide for practitioners to challenge the work that is done and for an increased provision of civil legal aid for areas such as family law?
I am well aware of the recent publicity about civil cases. The regulations are designed only to ensure resolution of disputes, so to that extent they will provide a mechanism of taxation. Far fewer civil cases than criminal cases are appearing before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, so it is recognised that there is a gap in the taxations that have been provided. The regulations are not designed to change the civil situation other than, for example, where a case arises that contains a unique point of law, is referred to the Judicial Committee, and counsel is employed. The regulations will, in such a case, provide a mechanism for resolving fee issues that might arise between counsel and a solicitor and, if the issue is not resolved directly between them, SLAB. That will be the limited effect of the regulations—they will not have a direct effect on civil legal aid or civil legal aid fees.
So it is a capping of legal aid. The applicant is entitled to the maximum legal aid and that is it. The question is about whether they achieve the maximum. Even if extra work has been done that goes over what is allowable under the maximum, there is no provision in the regulations to recoup the fees for that work.
I will let my colleague Ian Vickerstaff—who is more familiar with the issue—answer the question about how such a taxation would operate.
As Gillian Mawdsley explained, the regulations on civil fees make provision with regard only to Judicial Committee of the Privy Council proceedings. I think I am correct in saying that there has been only one civil case before the JCPC since devolution. We are not talking about a great many cases that will be affected by the regulations. There is provision in the principal regulations for payments for counsel to be made, unlike the criminal regulations, in which there was no provision before the current set of regulations was made.On capping of fees, the registrar would, in any taxation, assess the fee in accordance with the House of Lords practice directions. As Gillian Mawdsley pointed out, two recent cases were remitted to the registrar on that basis and counsel was quite content with the fees determination. We do not think that that will be a problem.
If every case that could appeal did so, it would still be a small number.
For civil cases, we are talking about such a small coverage—
And select issues.
That is correct.
If a civil case was referred to the registrar for taxation, the registrar, in seeking to make an award on the taxation, would have regard to the work that had been done. In other words, the advocate would be able to set out what he had done and there would be an assessment on the individual items of work, which would be put together and calculated. The advocate could say, "I've done X, Y and Z, and that's why I should be paid A, B and C." If you are asking whether counsel would undertake a case before the JCPC, there is no reason why he would not seek to do so, because he could say why he thought that his fees should be at a certain level. The registrar, having regard to cases in England and Wales, would be able to say whether that was reasonable. I hope that that gives you the background to the procedure.
Yes. That is helpful.
link
Is this becoming an issue now, particularly in relation to criminal cases, because of the number of devolution points that SLAB is now funding?
I do not think that that is an issue. I think that what you are trying to say is that cases can be referred to the JCPC on devolution grounds, so, as part of criminal procedure, devolution issues are arising that are coming before the JCPC and, once they are there, there can be disputes over the fees.
link
Do many more cases come before the JCPC because of devolution than was previously the case?
I do not think so. There have been more criminal cases before the JCPC than civil cases, but the JCPC hears between 55 and 65 cases a year, including devolution cases. We are talking about one or two devolution cases a year from Scotland.
link
We have no further questions. Your evidence has been helpful. Are members content to note the instruments?
Members indicated agreement.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.