Good morning. Welcome to the 13th and almost certainly final meeting of the Justice 1 Committee in this parliamentary session. We have received apologies from Stewart Stevenson.Item 1 on the agenda is consideration of our legacy paper. Interruption. The agenda that I have seems to be different from the one that everyone else has.
The agenda has obviously been revised.Item 1 is consideration of subordinate legislation. We will take evidence on two sets of regulations from Gillian Mawdsley, from the Scottish Executive Justice Department, and Ian Vickerstaff. I invite either Gillian or Ian to speak to the first set of regulations.
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
There were two policy objectives in making the Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment Regulations 2007, which amend the Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Regulations 1989 (SI 1989/1491). Neither at nor subsequent to devolution has express provision been made for counsel's fees in criminal cases before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council or for taxations in such cases. Taxation is a process in which disputes about fees charged are formally adjudicated. The new regulations provide for taxation and for a table of fees for counsel in such cases. That means that in cases in which criminal legal aid is available, if any dispute or question arises between the Scottish Legal Aid Board and a solicitor or counsel as to the amount of fees or outlays that are allowable to the solicitor or as to the amount of fees that are allowable to counsel from the legal aid fund, it may be referred to the registrar of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.Review provisions have been included, so that anyone who is dissatisfied with a taxation decision by the registrar can lodge a petition that will be considered first by the board of the Judicial Committee. The regulations were made in full consultation with the registrar, who has confirmed that she is prepared to undertake taxations in Scottish cases. That will ensure a consistent approach throughout the United Kingdom, as decisions will be based on her expertise in the Judicial Committee's practice and procedures.A table of fees is included as proposed new schedule 3 to the 1989 regulations. The table provides for fees to be paid at the same rate as for cases that originate in England and Wales, but the fees are only guidelines: higher fees may be paid to the Scottish Legal Aid Board when they are justified. If fees are not resolved by agreement with the board, the matter will go to the registrar for taxation. That was the first objective of the regulations.The second objective was to make several changes to criminal fees for counsel in first-instance cases. The Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment Regulations 2005 (SSI 2005/113) introduced block fees for counsel and adjustments to take account of the Bonomy reforms, that is, the High Court reforms.As the committee may be aware, amending regulations have been made to take on board several representations from the Faculty of Advocates. As a result of further representations that the faculty made following the continued monitoring of the solemn criminal reforms in the High Court, the Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment Regulations 2007 provide for several further adjustments, of which the most significant includes provision for increased payments for preliminary hearings. Preliminary hearings were introduced as a direct result of the Bonomy reforms, to encourage early preparation and resolution of cases in response to Crown disclosure of evidence.The regulations amend counsel's first-instance fees in relation to work done and outlays from 2 October 2006, which was the date on which the changes were finally agreed with the faculty. To introduce the changes to the benefit of the faculty, the regulations are intended to have retrospective effect.The committee may recall mention of the case of Shelagh McCall v the Scottish ministers, in which it was held that it was ultra vires to make regulations that applied retrospectively when their application caused unfair detriment to people whom they affected. In general, the regulations provide for an increase in fees to counsel for first-instance proceedings. To ensure that counsel cannot suffer as a result of retrospective application, a saving provision has been included, which will ensure that, in continuing first-instance cases in which counsel has undertaken separate preparation, the pre-existing higher fee can still be claimed, rather than that which the regulations provide. That situation might arise only very occasionally.Taxation to resolve disputes for existing cases is to be provided as soon as possible. The reference to taxation applies to all proceedings that are concluded before 29 March 2007 and are referred to the Judicial Committee after that date. The table of fees will apply to proceedings that are concluded after 29 March 2007.
Why are the two issues dealt with in a single instrument? Usually, an instrument is about a specific issue. We have dealt before with fees for preliminary hearings, which will now be dealt with in the regulations, which also concern proceedings before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
My colleague will be able to advise you in that regard. However, I can tell the committee that, in general, legal aid regulations are set out in principal sets of regulations. On this occasion, the principal set of regulations is the Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Regulations 1989. When seeking to amend those regulations, we usually try, where possible, to cover various policy areas in one set of regulations. Since amendment regulations were laid in 2005, further amending regulations have been made in respect of what we call cases of first instance, to take account of representations that we have received in various areas.Under the changes made in 2004-05, preliminary hearings were introduced in the High Court. The 2005 regulations cover payments for those hearings, and the regulations that are before the committee simply seek to increase those payments to reward advocates for the work that they have to carry out on what are a fundamental part of the High Court reforms.
The committee was involved in stages 1 and 2 of the Criminal Procedure (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill, which was based on the Bonomy reforms. Before we go any further, I want to be clear about the procedure. We have been asked to consider various sets of regulations on High Court reforms—I believe that, at one time, we dealt with what were called emergency regulations, and the previous set were described as temporary until further discussions had taken place with the Faculty of Advocates. Am I to understand that these regulations cover the discussions that you have had with the faculty on fees for preliminary hearings, and that we should expect other sets of regulations to emerge after you conclude discussions on the fees for the other aspects that have been raised with you?
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
I think that I understand your question. The Criminal Legal Aid (Scotland) (Fees) Amendment Regulations 2005 introduced the block fee system to which you have referred and made a number of adjustments to take account of contemporaneous changes to solemn procedure. You are absolutely right to say that the committee has already considered various amendment regulations, which were introduced in direct response to the faculty's representations.The regulations under discussion this morning contain a number of smaller changes to other areas, but I have chosen to highlight only the substantial change with regard to fees for preliminary hearings. As I have said, we are, at the instigation of the Faculty of Advocates, seeking to increase those fees to reward advocates and provide them with fair remuneration for their work. The process of monitoring the reforms is on-going, and we hope that, in future, the regulations will be part of a review mechanism. The regulations that are before the committee, however, are our response to a number of representations that have been made.
Does that mean that a future committee will have to consider further regulations on the specific points that we have been dealing with over the past year, or has the matter been resolved?
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
A number of representations that were made by the Faculty of Advocates have been taken on board. However, I cannot rule out the prospect of its making further representations, because the reforms will continue to be monitored. There are no plans to make further changes to first-instance cases, but there are plans to introduce a new table of appeals and to deal with changes in civil legal aid that the faculty has suggested. Those changes are a work in progress that will be taken forward by a new Administration.
I have to admit that I am somewhat confused about all this. However, in fairness to me and other members, I should say that the committee has had to deal with so many of these regulations that it has become quite difficult to follow things. Although the explanatory note sets out the intention behind the regulations, it does not provide us with any background information that would help us to understand their relation to the discussions that we have been observing over the past year or so.When giving evidence to the committee, the faculty raised the issue of being able to refer fees that are in dispute. The regulations deal only with fees for counsel and with proceedings for the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. Does that mean that the issue that the faculty raised with us is still outstanding and has not been resolved in relation to other criminal legal aid?
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
I am not sure that I follow you. There was previously no provision for taxation of cases that appeared before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, but there is now. That means that if a dispute occurs about fees that are payable to solicitors or counsel in cases that come before the JCPC, there is a mechanism for resolution, if the dispute is not resolved in the first instance by the advocate and the Scottish Legal Aid Board.
Yes, but am I correct in saying that when the dean of the Faculty of Advocates gave evidence to the committee, he expressed the faculty's view that it was dissatisfied with the system in general for fees that are in dispute? My recollection is that that was one of the problems that the faculty asked the Executive to resolve and that it was not just in relation to JCPC cases.
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
You are right that the dean expressed concerns about that matter, but the concerns were subsequently addressed by the passing of the regulations that we have talked about and the most recent concerns will be met by the regulations that are before the committee. They followed consultation of and discussion with the faculty—the matter was resolved on 2 October 2006, as I said in the note. That is why the regulations are retrospective.
I want to be clear about whether there are two new provisions. There is a provision to allow disputes about fees that are charged in civil or criminal cases to be resolved by the registrar of the JCPC. There is also a provision for taxation of such fees. Are those two separate provisions?
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
Where any dispute or disagreement about fees arises between the Scottish Legal Aid Board and counsel or solicitors, the latter can refer the matter for taxation. In High Court proceedings, the regulations provide that the questions will be referred to the auditor of the Court of Session. In sheriff or district court proceedings, the matter will be referred to the auditor of the sheriff courts for the districts in which the case is heard.
What happened was that a number of cases were resolved by ex parte agreement. Cases were taxed by the registrar on a kind of party basis, after it was agreed to take the cases to the registrar. Not many cases end up at the JCPC. I do not think that there are any outstanding civil cases. There are approximately 10 cases that will now be resolvable, if they are not resolved informally—they will now go to the registrar for taxation. She has confirmed that she is prepared to take existing cases that can now be referred. There is therefore an equitable remedy for both parties.
A clear path has been set down for people to follow, on which everything is transparent, open and accountable. That is very much to be welcomed.You referred to fees for counsel and said that preliminary hearings can now be taken into account, with payment provided. That is also to be welcomed. When the committee was working on the original bill, we realised that there would be front-loading of work and that that would have to be acknowledged. As the convener said, we heard from the Faculty of Advocates that the front-loading of work was not acknowledged, which was almost putting the system in jeopardy.I want to ask about retrospective provisions and about the charging of more fees. I take it that the savings provision will not impact on the client—in other words, that there will be no adverse affect on the person who has employed the Queen's counsel or solicitor.
Ian VickerstaffOffice of the Solicitor to the Scottish Executive
I will explain the point about retrospection and the savings provision—the savings provision is quite technical, but I will explain it as best I can.The amendments that we are making for counsel in first-instance proceedings provide, in the main, for an increase in fees. The retrospective effect of the regulations will therefore not cause detriment to counsel. However, in respect of the scheme for payment for separate preparation, we felt that a small number of cases might slip through the net of the retrospective effects, so we have provided a savings provision such that, in that small number of cases, the existing scheme for payments for separate preparation will remain in operation despite the coming into force of the new regulations.
In an earlier answer to Margaret Mitchell, you said that there had been no way of resolving disputes in the past, which was a gap in the provisions. Now that there is a way of resolving disputes, will there be an increase in the number of disputes, or will the new provisions be neutral in effect?
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
I do not envisage an increase in the number of disputes. The Scottish Legal Aid Board and the advocate or solicitor, where appropriate, will normally seek to resolve the issue of fees in a case. The case will be referred to taxation only if they cannot resolve the issue between them.As Margaret Mitchell said, the advantage is that we now have a transparent system with expertise that will work to benefit both parties. As I have said, I know of at least two cases that were referred by the parties, who were seeking to avail themselves of the expertise that was provided by the registrar.I do not expect more disputes; we have simply resolved the situation so that cases will not sit indefinitely when people do not agree. There will now be a forum for resolving disputes equitably, which should benefit all parties.
I want to add to what Margaret Mitchell said about provisions for preliminary hearings. The provisions are to be welcomed. The committee had been raising the issue and we are pleased with the changes to an important part of the procedure.A future justice committee might have to pick up on issues that are left over from the discussions that led to the regulations. That committee would benefit from a short note outlining how we arrived at this point, because it is not immediately obvious. Committee members have limited knowledge and we just pick up on the issues every so often—we do not know when other issues will arise because we are not party to discussions. It would therefore be very helpful for a future committee to receive a short note with any future regulations, so that it can be clear about the background.
Gillian MawdsleyScottish Executive Justice Department
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.