We suspend consideration of item 2 and resume item 1, which is continued petitions.
The final continued petition, for which we have been joined by the petitioners, is PE2099, which was lodged by Lynne McRitchie. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop the planned downgrading of established and high-performing specialist neonatal intensive care services across NHS Scotland from level 3 to level 2, and to commission an independent review of that decision in the light of contradictory expert opinions on centralising services.
We last considered the petition on 11 September 2024, when we agreed to write to the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health, and to undertake a visit to explore the issues raised in the petition. Since then, members of the committee have visited the neonatal intensive care unit at the University hospital Wishaw and have met the petitioner, families with experience of neonatal intensive care, Wishaw staff and NHS Lanarkshire staff. We thank those individuals who took the time to meet us. A tremendous number of people turned up; those of us in the committee who were present really valued the personal exchanges that we were able to have, not only with people who have been effected but with a considerable cohort of staff who also turned up to speak to us.
Hearing the perspectives and experiences of families with direct experience of neonatal care—some of which had happy outcomes and some less so, so it was a highly charged discussion—helped with our understanding of the issues raised in the petition. We are also grateful to the staff at NHS Lanarkshire and University hospital Wishaw for their work to arrange the visit, which was a first-class operational opportunity for us all. A note summarising the issues raised during the visit is available in the papers for today’s meeting and has been published on the petition’s website page.
Since we last considered the petition, the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health has provided two written submissions. The first submission reiterates that the recommendation was based on evidence that outcomes, including survival, for the very smallest and sickest babies are best when they are cared for in units with high volume throughout and where there are collocated specialist services. The response states that the review team visited all 14 health boards and met teams from maternity and neonatal services. The Scottish Health Council led a programme of service user engagement across all national health service territorial boards in Scotland, which was supplemented with bespoke service user events. The submission states that more than 600 staff and 500 service users contributed to the review process.
The minister’s most recent written submission notes that, although the principles underpinning the changes are supported by the Scottish executive nurse directors group—SEND—and by the directors of midwifery, concerns were raised about the implications of the change for maternity services. The submission says:
“The Directors of Midwifery highlighted that additional data and evidence gathering was required for maternity services to inform maternity capacity implementation planning.”
It states that a national-level data collection is under way to understand the impact of the neonatal care remodelling on maternity services.
10:15
Bliss Scotland has provided a written submission that details its support for the new model of care
and shares its view that the volume of babies born needing intensive care in Scotland is
“far too low to sustain more than three NICUs in Scotland.”
The submission shares concerns that
“progress is stalling”,
with a lack of clear communication about the task and finish groups’ priorities, work plan and progress to date. Bliss believes that
“Ongoing concerns regarding resourcing have not been addressed, including adequate staffing at the designated three intensive care units.”
I should say that there were issues raised in regard to Bliss by those who attended the visit that the committee held at the hospital.
Monica Lennon MSP is unable to attend the meeting this morning and has instead provided a written submission. The submission states that a
“truncated process amounts to tokenism, leaving families, clinicians, and local representatives feeling betrayed.”
Ms Lennon’s submission calls on the committee to consider recommending that an
“independent, multidisciplinary review be undertaken before Scottish Ministers reach a final decision”
regarding the future of neonatal intensive care services.
It is important to remember that the recommendation was not necessarily to have three NICUs; it was for a reduction in the number of service centres, and that it would have been perfectly possible for the award-winning unit to have been retained.
Meghan Gallacher had hoped to join us this morning for the consideration of the petition but was unable to do so. Jackie Baillie is still with us, and she would like to address the committee.
