Good morning, and welcome to the 15th meeting in 2025 of the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee.?We will begin our proceedings in the hope and expectation that the deputy convener will join us.
The first item on our agenda is consideration of continued petitions. I highlight to those who are joining us or watching us online that we have a large number of open petitions to consider before the dissolution of the Scottish Parliament, with the last working week being week ending 26 March 2026. Our focus for the rest of the parliamentary session is now on identifying any areas where we feel that we can make progress during the time remaining, given that there are not many meetings of the committee ahead.
Our first continued petition is PE1865, lodged by Roseanna Clarkin and Lauren McDougall, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to suspend the use of all surgical mesh and fixation devices while a review of all surgical procedures that use polyester, polypropylene or titanium is carried out and guidelines for the surgical use of mesh are established. We are joined by our colleague Jackie Baillie, who has a long-standing interest in such matters.
We last considered the petition on 19 February 2025, when we discussed potentially closing the petition but ultimately agreed to write to the Scottish Government to seek more information on the points about data. We have received a response from the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health. Although committing to keep emerging evidence under review, the minister stated that the Scottish Health Technologies Group—SHTG—analysed the most relevant research on the use of mesh for hernia repair and that evidence published since 2021 aligns with the group’s advice on outcomes and patient follow-up.
The Scottish Government is further guided by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency—our old friends, the MHRA—which says that there is currently no evidence on which to base further regulatory action for surgical mesh. The minister also referenced the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence—NICE—which regularly reviews evidence to update its clinical guidance, including on hernia repair.
The minister’s response then highlights a series of programmes in progress, which provide data for medical devices, including pelvic and hernia mesh, both at a United Kingdom and a Scottish level. It also points to the open initiative of the evidence directorate in Healthcare Improvement Scotland, whereby anyone can propose guideline topics or request research to be considered in Scottish clinical guidelines.
The petitioners reiterate their view that the SHTG’s recommendations are based on incomplete and outdated data. They also believe that meaningful action has yet to materialise on clear patient pathways for hernia mesh-injured individuals and guidelines for the use of mesh, suggesting that there are still patients who are neither being offered non-mesh alternatives nor receiving fully informed consent.?
Before I invite Jackie Baillie to contribute, I will say that I have raised the mesh issue, particularly with regard to the two reports by the late Professor Alison Britton, which were commissioned by the Scottish Government, and the First Minister offered to meet me. He did so after the summer recess. He, the minister and all relevant officials were there. Subsequently, he has written to me with a very detailed outline of all the work that has been done to implement the findings of the two reports. I have to say that there are still some gaps, so follow-up evidence is required.
I am also going to London to pursue, with relevant authorities there, progress on the recommendations by Dr Henrietta Hughes on compensation for mesh.
