PE2129, which was lodged by Elizabeth Spencer, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to require education authorities to adopt a uniform set of criteria and a standard consultation for assessing community demand for denominational schools.
We wrote to the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills after we last considered the petition on 19 February. The cabinet secretary’s response states that, when establishing a new school, local authorities are required to carry out a consultation under the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010. That consultation has to include at least 30 school days, engage with a specific list of relevant consultees and include a public meeting. Education Scotland also produces a report about the educational benefit of the proposal, and the local authority has to produce a final report summarising responses to that consultation. The cabinet secretary states that she has no evidence to support the view that the current arrangements for the establishment of new schools, including denominational schools, is unfair or inconsistent.
The petitioner has provided a written submission that states that, in the case of Aberdeen City Council, non-Catholic parents and grandparents were disregarded from the consultation. She calls for the committee to consider whether the criteria and consultations are being applied consistently and to examine whether the experience of Aberdeen families shows the need for national guidance and oversight.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?