Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 10 June 2003 Finance Committee Procedure 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Fergus Ewing only · show everyone

Fergus Ewing’s contributions

11 contributions
Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I do not want to talk about the budget process, but about another subject that I think we should incorporate in our work programme. Would it be in order for me to make that suggestion at this point?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

The committee's remit includes a duty"to consider and report on … any other matter relating to or affecting the expenditure of the Scottish Administration".The Finance Committee's third report 2003 includes a section about cross-cutting reviews and a recommendation in paragraph 11, which says:"We recommend to our successor committee that similar reviews are undertaken in future"and that such reviews may be carried out on specific policy or budget areas or institutions.I suggest that, over the next four years, the committee should consider the expenditure and operation of quangos, as it seems to me that that is an area that, although it was not entirely neglected in the first session, has not been the subject of specific focus. In particular, I suggest that one specific quango should be the subject of an inquiry by the committee—namely, Scottish Water. It has recently been the subject of huge controversy because water prices have risen by 94 per cent over the past 10 years, because the cost to consumers in Scotland is substantially more than that to consumers in England and because jobs are in danger because of a 500 per cent rise in some business water bills. Of course, the Federation of Small Businesses and the Forum of Private Business have both expressed their concerns and made detailed representations.My view is that it may well be found in the course of an inquiry that we could make substantial savings in Scottish Water's budget and divert them into the money that is spent on senior citizens, our health service and our education. Perhaps that is where our priorities should lie.I understand from recent publicity that Scottish Water's boss and the water industry commissioner, Mr Sutherland, have been at daggers drawn. They have been blaming each other in public. That is unseemly and an indication that we require an in-depth analysis of the sector. Even if it means that we have to meet weekly, rather than fortnightly as formerly, we should get our sleeves rolled up and find out what is happening at Scottish Water, whether the water industry commissioner is carrying out a useful function, whether we are getting value for money for his approximately £2 million annual costs and what we can do to try to find savings in the sector that could be put to far better use.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

That certainly comes under the role and function of the Finance Committee. Over the past four years, when I sometimes attended the committee as a non-member, representatives of the corporate body regularly appeared before us. We obtained an assurance, I think in March this year, that the costs of the project were going to be £338 million.I believe that the First Minister indicated during the election period that he is to promote an inquiry into the project. We have heard that the matter has exercised the First Minister considerably over the past few days.Given the fact that it is the legal responsibility of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body to deal with the Holyrood project, and being mindful that it is our parliamentary duty and job to scrutinise the role of the corporate body, I suggest that we write to the First Minister, inviting him to specify his plans. First, what is the remit of the inquiry into the Holyrood project that he proposes? Secondly, by whom, in his opinion, should such an inquiry be carried out? Thirdly, will the inquiry have untrammelled, open and complete access to all the documents, so that the First Minister can fulfil the pledge that he made before the election, that no questions shall remain unanswered?Can we obtain from the First Minister a detailed exposition of precisely what his plans are in relation to this important matter, which I am sure is of concern to all MSPs? The First Minister has no legal responsibility in this regard, but we do. Therefore, as I presume the clerk will confirm, and as the convener said to me before the meeting began, we have an obligation of scrutiny on this matter. I assume that we will take the matter very seriously, and that we will write to the First Minister, asking him to give full clarification on all these matters. I suggest that we secure that clarification before we have members of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body before us as witnesses next week, so that we are absolutely clear about what the First Minister is proposing.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Convener, I presume that a letter will be sent to the First Minister along the lines that you have suggested. I hope that some of the points that Wendy Alexander and I have raised will be incorporated in it. I agree with Wendy's comment that the procurement and specification processes in the contract have not been optimal, although I might use a slightly different word in that respect. There is common ground as far as that matter is concerned. However, it might equally be said that reaching such conclusions might prejudge the outcome of any inquiry. In order to find some consensus on this issue, I think that the committee would welcome the First Minister's early clarification of aspects that the convener has mentioned such as the remit, scope and process of the inquiry and who will carry it out. If we send a letter to the First Minister along the lines that the convener has suggested and make it clear that we would appreciate a very early response, we could build a consensus around such an approach.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I agree with John Swinburne that heads should roll, but with the caveat that there should be a fair trial first—call me old-fashioned. The issue is complex and I am sure that John Swinburne would agree that, before we line anyone up against the wall and carry out a summary execution, there should be some kind of investigation into what happened. Some of us might feel that we know what happened in relation to various aspects of the project, but that is another matter.I also share John Swinburne's sense of urgency. The project has been a complete fiasco and the Scottish people would endorse what has been said about the sense of anger that was felt during the election. Convener, could we ask the First Minister to reply to the committee promptly, certainly before our next meeting?I believe that we have a job of work to do; we should be prepared to meet weekly, not fortnightly, so that we can do that job. That is particularly important if we are to be serious about inquiring into how quangos spend their money. I notice that no one opposed that idea, so I hope that it will be supported. The Sunday Mail certainly believes that such an inquiry should be carried out, as does the SNP. However, if we are going to do that, we must have a weekly cycle of meetings. Convener, can you confirm that the next meeting will be next week and that, prior to that meeting, we will invite the First Minister to make clear his plans and his response to the sense of urgency that committee members have rightly expressed?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I want to pursue the issue and try to find some sort of consensus. You have quite rightly said that we need to know what George Reid and the corporate body say. We must have that before us before we can move on. We need to be able to analyse the information that they gleaned from today's important meeting with the Holyrood project team and the consultants—particularly the cost consultants, who have some explaining to do—as well as Bovis Lend Lease Ltd.I remind members that we were promised that the report would be made available to the Finance Committee today or tomorrow. My understanding, from press reports and other advice, is that the information will be made available very soon, although the clerk may have other information for the committee. However, waiting for the report is not a reason for delaying our consideration of the matter. I am sure that none of us would want to be seen to be kicking the issue into touch. I am not suggesting that we decide today that the work load of the committee dictates that we should have a weekly rather than a fortnightly schedule of meetings. However, in view of the anger that is felt on the Holyrood issue, I suggest that we meet next week to discuss the matter. We will have the corporate body's report long before our scheduled meeting. I also suggest that we ask the First Minister for an answer next week. The issue is whether we have a meeting next week, rather than leave the matter for a fortnight, and I am prepared to push that to a vote.We should show Scotland that we are taking the issue seriously and that we are trying to push on before the summer recess. We are all aware that the matter could quite easily not be finalised until after the summer recess. If that were to happen, it would be most unfortunate. We should be ready to put our shoulder to the plough.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I have listened carefully to what the convener and Wendy Alexander said about waiting two weeks so that we have the full information. However, given that we have waited four years but still do not have the full information, there is no guarantee that it will be available in two weeks' time.Press reports and advice that I have received privately suggest that we will have a report from the corporate body within 24 hours. The effect of postponing our next meeting until 24 June would be to deny ourselves a role in the First Minister's inquiry until after the recess. I am sorry if other members feel that the matter can wait 14 days; I feel that it is a priority. The spiralling cost of Holyrood is scandalous. We are paying nearly £400 million for a building that was supposed to cost £40 million. I think that we should have a meeting next week and I am prepared to push the matter to a vote if members do not agree. I would be happy to meet you, convener, along with the convener and deputy convener of the Audit Committee and the Presiding Officer. I will make myself available in that regard during the next few days. We should give total priority to the issue. It demands nothing less.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I would like to respond to one or two of the points that have been made. I appreciate that we are all trying to find a solution, but I remind members that all that I am suggesting is that we should meet next week. That seems to me to be a remarkably modest proposal. I would like to respond to some of the specific points that have been made, particularly by Wendy Alexander, who argued that there is a need for clarity about the process. Having read the Auditor General's report of September 2000, the Spencely report and the Auditor General's report on the Flour City fiasco, I feel that there is total clarity. Wendy Alexander asked who is responsible for stewardship. Under the Scotland Act 1998, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body and the Presiding Officer leading it have the legal responsibility for stewardship. They are the paymasters—there is absolutely no lack of clarity about that. This committee has a prospective function and the Audit Committee, as is in the nature of audit, has a retrospective function. There is no lack of clarity in that. We can have a paper on those matters by all means, but those of us who have been very much involved in trying to hold those responsible for the Holyrood fiasco to account over the past four years have a perfect grasp of the process. I do not think that that is a reason to delay. Jeremy Purvis has said that we do not want to rush into a decision. I am not suggesting that next week we determine a remit of the inquiry. I am suggesting that we exercise our scrutiny function, which, as the convener confirmed to me before the meeting began, is our role. We should schedule a meeting next week and the Holyrood project should be an agenda item for that meeting. I am inclined to push that to a vote. I am sorry if I cannot take all members with me, but the matter is important, as Mr Brocklebank and Mr Swinburne, as well as the SNP members, have argued.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

It is not a question of still being keen. I have been keen from the outset to ensure that we make progress. Frankly, I am a wee bit amazed that members are not willing to meet next week to take the matter forward.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

The serious point is that we have already been promised that there will be a report from the SPCB within 24 hours. Kate Maclean's point is therefore irrelevant and I propose that we schedule a meeting for 17 June at which the Holyrood project is on the agenda for discussion by all members.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Am I right in thinking that your feeling is that, if the information is made available, the meeting should be next week?

  1. Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 10 June 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Interests Procedure · 9
  3. Convener Procedure · 5
  4. Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 59
  6. Budget Adviser Committee business · 46

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.