Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 10 June 2003 Finance Committee Procedure 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Wendy Alexander only · show everyone

Wendy Alexander’s contributions

3 contributions
Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I should declare what may be a relevant interest, which is that I am a visiting professor in the business school at Strathclyde. That is a generic declaration of interest.The complexities of the Holyrood project are not lost on any of us. We should focus on what there is unanimity about: that the procurement process has not been optimal and the specification process has not been optimal but has changed through time, as has responsibility for the project. In process terms we must take into account the role of the SPCB and understand the role of the Executive. The inquiries that have been the most, shall I say, revelatory in another context have not been assisted by having three parallel inquiries. It is typical for important lessons to be learned by means of an authoritative investigation.I am not clear whether scrutiny by the SPCB or the investigation that the First Minister has proposed will provide that focus. Before we delve into any detail, it might be helpful to try and understand the respective roles of the SPCB and the First Minister. It would also be helpful if the clerk could provide a paper that detailed how the First Minister's inquiry would proceed, the decisions that the SPCB will no doubt make later today on how it intends to pursue the matter and any implications that such processes would have for the committee's scrutiny role.Although I am not suggesting that we have no role in this matter, I think that the only way forward for us in an issue that will clearly be of public interest over the next year is to understand our role in the inquiries that will be pursued by the First Minister and the SPCB. It would be excellent if the clerk could provide some clarification on process by the next meeting; however, our foremost duty is to clarify our role in the two parallel inquiry processes. If that requires two meetings, so be it. The danger is that, instead of providing some depth to one of the two inquiries that are already under way, we might create the impression that there will be a third parallel inquiry.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I hope that we can avoid having a vote on the issue. I want to propose a way forward. The discussion has focused on the First Minister's inquiry and on its remit and role. It is clear that the focus of that inquiry will be retrospective, as it will examine what happened in the past.The members of the corporate body are now responsible for stewarding the project, but part of their discussions today will look backwards to matters that overlap with those that are the subject of the First Minister's inquiry. More important is the fact that the corporate body will look forwards. As Fergus Ewing hinted, the Finance Committee might need the appropriate resources to fulfil its role, too, of looking forwards. The Audit Committee has a role to scrutinise the First Minister's inquiry into what happened in the past and the Presiding Officer's investigations.I seek to uphold the stewardship role of Parliament, the Presiding Officer and the corporate body. Although I am not opposed to having a meeting next week, if it is felt that that is appropriate, I believe that the Presiding Officer and the conveners of the Finance Committee and the Audit Committee have to have time to sit down together to establish the process.As Fergus Ewing said, the report might be published tomorrow. We might find that there are no difficulties of overlap between the Finance Committee, the Audit Committee and the corporate body; if that is the case, that is fine. However, it is not in anyone's interest to compel the Finance Committee to hold a meeting next week, when the Presiding Officer and the two conveners might not have had a chance to establish the respective roles of the two committees. I ask Fergus Ewing to agree to leave the matter to the discretion of our convener, who will discuss our respective roles, responsibilities and the process for taking the matter forward with the Presiding Officer and the convener of the Audit Committee this week.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I want to be clear about what I am proposing and why. I am not saying that we should meet in two weeks. I am saying that the public correctly perceive that there is a lack of accountability in relation to the project. They want clear lines of accountability from now on. Accountability consists of at least three dimensions. First, who stewards the project operationally through to its completion? Secondly, who makes the decisions about additional expenditure that might be required? Thirdly, who exercises the backward scrutiny, in relation to the moneys that have been spent so far and the nature of the contracts entered into? If we are to have accountability from now on, our moral obligation to our colleagues is to clarify those matters of accountability before we plunge into the melting pot as the fifth body examining the project.As I said, there are a variety of different forms of accountability, even in relation to the future progress of the project. We have to invite the Presiding Officer to sit down with the conveners of the Audit Committee and the Finance Committee to try to reach agreement about accountabilities—no doubt, that will include an agreement about who will scrutinise the Executive's actions. At that point, I would expect the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, the Audit Committee and the Finance Committee to sign up to those accountabilities. I simply do not believe that it is possible for us to make decisions about accountabilities in isolation from those two other arms of the parliamentary process and to meet next week to do so would be disrespectful to our colleagues. There is genuinely no desire to cause a delay. I believe that our convener will expedite the process that I have described, as I cannot believe that those sentiments are not shared by the Presiding Officer and the convener of the Audit Committee.

  1. Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 10 June 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Interests Procedure · 9
  3. Convener Procedure · 5
  4. Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 59
  6. Budget Adviser Committee business · 46

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.