Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 10 June 2003 Finance Committee Procedure 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Des McNulty only · show everyone

Des McNulty’s contributions

23 contributions
Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Agenda item 4 is consideration of our work programme. Members should have before them the relevant paper from the clerk.The first issue that is raised in the paper concerns the annual budget process. It is important for members to be aware that, due to the election in May, the normal cycle of budgetary consideration has been suspended for this year. As the paper sets out, that means, in effect, that the stage 1 process has been forgone and that scrutiny of next year's spending decisions will not begin until publication of the draft budget, which is expected to be in August. The clerks will prepare briefings for us as soon as possible after that and I would hope that the committee would be in a position to issue guidance to the Scottish Parliament's subject committees on what their approach to their examination of the spending proposals should be.Do members have any questions?

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

To be blunt, given the pattern of elections to the Scottish Parliament, the initial cycle of examination of the budget—stage 1 of the budget process—which takes place between March and June, will be overtaken by the election process every four years.In the previous committee, I initiated a review of the financial scrutiny process and members have a copy of the report that was produced as a result. There was some concern within the previous committee that the three-stage budget process was, perhaps, over-onerous and that we needed to find ways of streamlining the process to ensure that we were not repeating ourselves and that we had time to get into the figures and decisions in more depth.The position is complicated by the fact that, not only do we have to contend with the four-yearly election cycle, but we have to deal with the Westminster spending rounds. In a sense, every other year differs from what we would think of as the normal process. Over the next few months, I would like us to consult the Executive to agree on an effective cycle of budgetary review that takes account of the variations. That would allow us to channel our energies in the most effective way. The clerk, the committee's previous adviser and the Executive have been in on-going discussions on the matter and I think that we are close to concluding that process. I hope that proposals can be brought to the committee for discussion relatively soon.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Before you do, I would like to say one more thing in relation to the financial scrutiny process. We should consider having a committee away day to give us an opportunity to consider the budget process. It would be useful to have that after the recess, in late August or early September. If members are agreeable to that, I suggest that the clerks contact members to identify a suitable date and venue and prepare an initial agenda.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

The detail of the budget process is quite complicated. Most members of the previous committee found an intensive briefing from experts in the field to be particularly useful to the committee's work. With so many new members on the committee, it would be useful to have such a briefing. Are we agreed that the clerks should take that suggestion forward?Members indicated agreement.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

The issues will be discussed at a future meeting. I anticipate that we will have a preliminary discussion at our next meeting. That will cover our receipt of the paper that was passed on to us by our predecessor committee, which makes some recommendations about the kind of cross-cutting review that it might be appropriate for us to undertake. It will be for the committee to make its decisions based on a series of options. That is the pattern that the committee has adopted in the past.I remind Fergus Ewing that the management of Scottish Water comes under the remit of the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Ross Finnie. By implication, scrutiny in that area would, in the first instance, be a matter for the Environment and Rural Development Committee. We should be careful not to encroach directly on the affairs of another committee. Having said that, I am not hostile to examining infrastructure issues. Those could include Scottish Water in a cross-cutting way. However, the time for a discussion on that is once we have a paper in front of us suggesting options and alternatives. That is how I intend to take things forward.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

In its last year, the predecessor committee adopted a practice of selectively considering financial memoranda in some detail. The criticism that was applied to the previous process, under which the Finance Committee did not consider the memoranda in sufficient detail, did not apply in the last year of the previous session, when the committee subjected a number of bills to detailed criticism and went on to make recommendations at stage 1.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

We will work with the Executive to establish such a timetable.Do we agree to consider the future work programme as an agenda item at our next meeting? Any suggestions that members may have for topics for the committee to investigate can be forwarded to the clerk. We will discuss them at our next meeting and perhaps at our away day if we deem that necessary. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

One further issue that I would like to raise is the Holyrood building project. I have written to the Presiding Officer, alerting him to the committee's interest and role in relation to the project, and I have received an indication from him that a written report will be made available to the committee. Members might still wish to take evidence from the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body at the next meeting. Does the committee agree to contact the Presiding Officer, asking that members of the SPCB make themselves available on that basis?

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

My understanding is that the legal responsibility in relation to the Holyrood project lies with the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body; it is responsible to the Parliament. The agreement that was reached at an earlier stage in the project was that the committee would receive quarterly reports that focused specifically on budgetary issues. It would be appropriate for us to seek clarification from the First Minister. We could perhaps remind him of the committee's role in the process and gather information about the process, conduct and timing of an independent inquiry.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I have proposed to write to the First Minister to signal the committee's role, to highlight our specific remit and to seek information from him on his announcement of an independent inquiry. I presume that he will respond appropriately; his response might even cover all the issues that have been raised. However, it is not up to me to give him a shopping list of information that he should provide. After all, he is accountable to Parliament for what he does as First Minister. We are responsible for scrutinising the SPCB's activities, and we also seek some clarification about the inquiry that the First Minister has proposed.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

We will carry out our role in that regard. Obviously, the Audit Committee also has a role in examining the more retrospective aspects of the issue. Our focus is on budgetary issues and on holding the corporate body to account over its financial proposals.We seem to have reached agreement. I will write to the First Minister and the Presiding Officer in the terms that I have suggested and we will discuss those issues at our next meeting.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Any budgetary matter or expenditure issue is within the committee's remit. It is therefore open to the committee to consider that aspect in the same way as it considers any other.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I can confirm that the proposed next meeting of the committee is on 24 June. On the Holyrood issue, it is perfectly reasonable that we give George Reid—who, I understand, is seeking answers from the contractors—sufficient time to gather information and present us with a written report, which in turn we must have time to consider. Therefore, I do not think that there is an argument for holding an additional meeting before 24 June. I will certainly include in the letter to the First Minister a request for a response well in advance of 24 June so that we are clear about the terms of the independent inquiry that the First Minister has proposed.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

That is fair. Once we have received a response from the First Minister, members will be able to consider what input they want to put into the process.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

That is a welcome suggestion. The other issue is that the corporate body might wish to hold further discussions at its meeting next Tuesday. The information that is made available today might not be the final information that we will receive—the corporate body might find that it has other questions to ask.There is no lack of urgency in the route that I have proposed. I want to ensure that the Finance Committee receives all the information that it needs to enable us to have a full and frank discussion. From our point of view, there is no sense in starting out with only partial information. I would rather that we followed the normal procedures, which are that the clerks receive information and circulate it several days in advance of our meetings. I want the committee to have as much of the information as possible.Members can be as searching as they want to be, but their questioning and debate needs to be based on the information that they receive. I urge Fergus Ewing to accept that we will have a thorough discussion and progress the issues with the corporate body and the First Minister's inquiry. Members will have the appropriate opportunity to raise and thoroughly discuss all the issues at our meeting on 24 June.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I would like to make a suggestion that ties together the various strands of the discussion. The date of the next meeting is partially dependent on information that we do not have at this point. I suggest that we get in touch with the Presiding Officer to point out that members of the committee expressed an interest in getting the information from him and having an opportunity to question members of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body as soon as possible. We could ask him what the earliest date for that might be, consistent with our having as much information as possible. If it were possible to have that information before our meeting next week, that would be fine. If the Presiding Officer judges that it would be better to have that meeting on 24 June or at a later date, we would follow his advice. The important consideration must be that we have the information that will enable us to do the job properly. Wendy Alexander suggested that I should speak to the Presiding Officer and the convener of the Audit Committee. I could speak to the clerks to the two committees to clarify the situation and then bring back a statement of the respective roles of the committees. There have been a number of misunderstandings and it is important that we are clear about our remit and about the remit of others. The new element in the equation is the independent inquiry that the First Minister is proposing. We will obviously need information about how that will impinge on our role and on the roles of other people. That needs to be fed into the process, so I shall write to the First Minister and ask for that information as well.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

There is no question but that it is an important matter; the issue concerns the practicalities of the situation. Fergus Ewing is arguing that we should schedule a meeting for next Tuesday. My suggestion is that I liaise with the Presiding Officer to determine whether a meeting next Tuesday would be appropriate or whether it would be appropriate to have a meeting by 24 June at the latest. The objective is to ensure the fullest possible scrutiny. The committee must have the fullest possible information before it does the work. It is also crucial to establish that the witnesses are available.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I think that Fergus Ewing is still keen to propose that we meet next week.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

That is absolute rubbish. We are absolutely clear that we wish to take the matter forward. However, I am concerned to ensure that we do so in the most sensible way, with all the information in front of us. If it is appropriate to have a meeting next week, bearing in mind what members have said about the urgency of the issue, I am happy to facilitate that. My suggestion is that, if a meeting next week is not appropriate—if we would simply be wasting our time and dealing with the matter partially or inadequately—the meeting should be deferred to the next suitable date. The important point is for the committee to deal with the matter properly. I would like to find out whether members agree with that proposition.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

The question is, that we agree to meet next week. Are we agreed?

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

There will be a division.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0. That is a majority against meeting next week. My intention is to speak to the Presiding Officer to ensure that we get the earliest possible date for a suitable meeting.

Des McNulty Lab The Convener · Clydebank and Milngavie
link

If we can secure all the information that is required, we will have a meeting next week.

  1. Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 10 June 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Interests Procedure · 9
  3. Convener Procedure · 5
  4. Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 59
  6. Budget Adviser Committee business · 46

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.