PE1895, which was lodged by Gary Wall, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make it mandatory for NatureScot to explain its conservation objectives in decision-making within the framework of the Scottish regulators’ strategic code of practice and Scottish Government’s guidance, right first time.
The committee wrote to the Scottish Government seeking information on the application of test 2, including whether assessing licence applications on the basis of there being no satisfactory alternative, as opposed to no other satisfactory solution, is likely to lead?to a different outcome.?
The Scottish Government sought advice from NatureScot and responded to state that
“The terms ‘no satisfactory alternative’ and ‘no other satisfactory solution’ are considered to be analogous.? This view is supported by the European Commission’s recently updated guidance on the strict protection of species, which refers to birds directive case law for the interpretation of test 2”.
The petitioner highlights that although NatureScot references European Union Commission guidance, the rejections that he has received in relation to licence applications have been on the basis of actions that are not challenged by the EU Commission in other countries. He states that the
“Scottish Government recognise that ‘proportionality’ is one of the foundations of regulation and yet in ten years of license refusals it has never been explained to me what factors have been considered in relation to ‘proportionality’.”
The petitioner concludes by stating that
“at least a citizen should be able to expect clarity in what the conservation objective is in refusing a license.”
Do any members wish to comment?
