Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Surgical Mesh and Fixation Devices (PE1865)

Wednesday 2 February 2022 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–11:00 Petitions 10 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

PE1865, by Roseanna Clarkin, Lauren McDougall and Graham Robertson, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to suspend the use of all surgical mesh and fixation devices. I apologise for the fairly long preamble. The petition has had something of an airing in the Parliament in connection with the bill on compensation for transvaginal mesh surgery that was recently passed. The petition calls on the Parliament to suspend the use of surgical mesh and fixation devices while a review of all surgical procedures that use polyester, polypropylene or titanium is carried out and guidelines for the surgical use of mesh are established.

10:45

The petition was last considered on 17 November 2021 and at that meeting the committee agreed to write to the Minister for Public Health, Women’s Health and Sport and to the Shouldice hospital in Canada. Responses have been received from the minister, the Shouldice hospital, Sling the Mesh campaign and the petitioners.

I am delighted that Jackie Baillie is still with us this morning and I welcome Carol Mochan MSP, who joins us online; both members wish to speak to the petition. Before I bring in my colleagues, I will provide a little bit more of the background, which I apologised for the length of a moment ago.

In 2019, the Scottish Health Technologies Group carried out a review into the use of mesh in primary inguinal hernia repair in men. The review concluded that, compared to non-mesh procedures, using mesh resulted in lower rates of recurrence, lower rates of serious adverse events, and similar or lower risk of chronic pain. The advice for NHS Scotland was, therefore, that surgical mesh should be used in elective repairs in inguinal hernia in adult males.

The SHTG review was subsequently expanded to include women, examining the outcome of mesh versus non-mesh surgery in a variety of groin or abdominal wall hernias. The Scottish Health Technologies Group concluded that current evidence supports the continued availability of surgical mesh for elective repair of primary ventral hernias, incisional hernias, and primary inguinal hernias in adults in Scotland. The group recommends, however, that consideration should be given to patient preference and that patients should also have access to alternative hernia treatment options such as non-mesh—suture and natural tissue—repair.

The chief medical officer has also undertaken a number of activities relevant to the petition, including: writing to the board chief executives and medical directors to draw their attention to the SHTG report’s findings; asking health boards to consider the availability of non-mesh surgery within their health board, and how any skills gaps can be addressed; asking health boards to consider the development of local clinical groups and broader clinical networks for the management of complex cases; and asking medical directors to remind clinicians of their obligations under the principle of realistic medicine, of informed consent and of the importance of recording both the content and outcome of such discussions.

With regard to the issues raised about the quality and authenticity of certain materials being used, the minister states that the Scottish Government contacted the Medicines and Healthcare Regulatory Agency in 2018, which confirmed that there was no new evidence to prompt regulatory action and that the products in question remained acceptably safe when used as intended.

The committee also wrote to the Shouldice hospital in Canada, as the leading experts in natural tissue repair. In what I thought was a fascinating submission, Shouldice states that in its own practice, surgical mesh is not used unless absolutely necessary and that has led to it being used in less than 2 per cent of cases. The hospital specialises exclusively in abdominal wall hernia repair. It states that where the body’s natural tissue is strong enough to support the surgical repair, natural tissue repair should always be used and where underlying patient tissue is poor, surgical mesh may be necessary in some femoral and large incisional hernia repairs. All the hospital’s surgeons are trained to do a natural tissue repair as their first choice; natural tissue repair should be the first choice for all primary inguinal hernias, most recurrent inguinal hernias, most femoral hernias, most epigastric and umbilical hernias, and small incisional hernias.

Shouldice also notes that since mesh was introduced in the 1980s, the recurrence rate for inguinal hernia repair—more than 85 per cent of most of its hernia repair—has not improved. There has been a staggering increase in post-operative complications not seen prior to mesh. Chronic and debilitating pain and other severe complications such as mesh shrinkage, mesh migration, and related nerve entrapment are widespread. There are no side effects of tissue repair if it is done correctly. Training for surgeons on the natural tissue technique ranges from three months for an experienced fellowship general surgeon to six to nine months for an inexperienced general surgeon.

The Sling the Mesh campaign shared the results of its recent survey of its 9,300 members with experience of vaginal, abdominal, pelvic, rectal, hernia mesh and mesh following mastectomy. It notes that one in four have considered taking their life,?six in 10 suffer depression, one third have been forced to give up their work, one in four now need a stick to walk, and one in 14 now need a mobility scooter or wheelchair.

In their submissions, the petitioners welcome the information contained in the Shouldice hospital submission and ask for further information to be sought on the use of protacks, which are devices used to fix mesh to soft tissue. The petitioners believe that there is evidence to suggest that a considerable sum of money has been spent recently procuring hernia mesh and other fixation devices and they feel that that money could have been spent on investigating and teaching natural tissue repair. The petitioners also query why mesh is still being bought and why clinicians are not yet accurately and systematically recording the effects of such material on patients.

We have gathered quite a lot of evidence since we last considered the petition. I invite both Jackie Baillie and Carol Mochan to contribute ahead of comments from committee members.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Many thanks to you, convener, and to the committee for allowing me to speak to the petition. Given your detailed knowledge and interest in the area, I feel as though I am pushing an open door.

I have been contacted by one of the petitioners, Roseanna Clarkin, and she shared with me the evidence from the Shouldice hospital in Canada. I know that the committee has seen that evidence.

In the past week, I have also been emailed by a number of men and women across Scotland who have experienced post-operative complications after the use of mesh. Their stories are heartbreaking. They are living in excruciating pain. Many of them have had to give up work. Their fears are somehow being dismissed as psychological and not physical. Some have had to go private because the national health service is refusing to help them. Some have been so low they have considered taking their own life. You will appreciate, convener, that those stories are remarkably similar to the stories that we heard from women who experienced difficulties as a consequence of transvaginal mesh. The evidence of problems with mesh appears to be increasing, not just in this country but in other countries around the world.

I am astonished that on 25 January, the Scottish Government signed a deal with mesh providers to provide more mesh for more mesh surgeries for the next 24 months at a cost of £3.5 million. Equally, I am not aware whether it is a matter of routine for alternative surgeries to be offered and I wonder whether that is something that the committee would consider exploring.

Given the experience of the transvaginal mesh campaigners, I ask the committee to ask for an independent review—not an internal review—and get the data to understand the scale of the problem that is starting to emerge here. The committee should also consider asking the Scottish Government for mesh removal and other mitigations for those affected.

Carol Mochan Lab South Scotland
link

I am quite new to the subject matter and I want to put on record that I am interested in the way the matter has progressed. Similar to other members, I have been involved in the mesh debate with women in relation to transvaginal mesh. It is important that we use the evidence that we have from other areas.

I support the overall sentiment of the petition: it is a perfectly reasonable request that a review is held and that guidelines around the surgical use of mesh are established. The petitioners have brought evidence to the minister and the committee has gone over other evidence. It is incumbent on us to ensure that reasonable requests are respected; it seems reasonable for the Citizens Participation and Public Petitions Committee to take action and at least further scrutinise what can be done to support the petition.

Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak today. I hope to keep an eye on what is happening around mesh for those people.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I am grateful for that. Do any members of the committee wish to comment?

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am amazed at what has already been achieved through the campaigns in the past, but looking at the current situation, it would appear that lessons have not been learned. There is a real similarity between what happened to the women and what is now happening to the men. The Shouldice hospital report is eye-opening; it is important for us to have that information and to collate some of the issues that have been raised.

We need to seek more clarity on all of it. We should at least be writing to the chief medical officer in Scotland to ask what is happening with the process. Ms Baillie has some very strong views about what is taking place and the funding that has been provided. If we do not take some action, are we just saving up more problems for individuals in the future? I want us to write to the chief medical officer and also to ensure that the minister for public health comes back to the committee and gives us more updates on what is taking place.

I would have hoped that, following the whole debate and debacle with transvaginal mesh, we would have learned some lessons, but it would appear that we are repeating some of the failures and we are putting individuals through the trauma that some women experienced in the past. We need to get real clarity on all of that and we should continue the petition on those grounds.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I support what Jackie Baillie said about the submission from Roseanna Clarkin. It was quite shocking to learn that the vendor, Covidien UK, was supplying Parietex mesh, which has been subject to Food and Drug Administration restrictions in the United States because it has been directly linked to postoperative complications and adverse effects in patients. Perversely, we are in a position in Scotland where we have fewer medical clinical protections for patients than in the United States. I am sure that if you asked the average person in the street which jurisdiction they think offers more protections to patients, they would say Scotland, when as a result of the Government’s decision, that is not the case.

It is critical that we pursue the issue. The submission from the Shouldice hospital offers an insight into an alternative model that is quite compelling. In light of that remarkable evidence, it would be worth asking the health secretary to engage with it directly and perhaps look at the opportunity to set up a pilot project in Scotland with a particular hospital or surgical centre, to see whether we can adopt those methods. We could use the pilot as a control against standard procedures and see whether it produces demonstrable effects that could improve patient care.

Ruth Maguire SNP Cunninghame South
link

I am thankful for the evidence that we have been given. It has certainly been eye-opening. I think that one person in pain and distress and not being believed is one too many. That said, it is important that we understand the scale. Based on what has happened previously and our experience of what happened to the women, I would like to invite the minister to come and give evidence. It is important to start that dialogue. It is almost too big to just write and ask for some information. We should have an evidence session in the first instance.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We took evidence from the minister prior to your joining the committee, but there is every reason to suggest that we might wish to have the minister back.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I am like my colleagues in that I am very interested in the petition as somebody who has been there from the very start in relation to the mesh cases. It is important that we get to the bottom of the matter. Rather than write to the chief medical officer, could we ask him to give evidence? We could invite somebody from the hospital in Canada to give evidence to the committee, too, so that we could ask questions. Let us just push the petition on and make progress on it.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

The associated concern of hernia mesh was referred to from time to time during the progress of the committee’s dealings with the mesh petition previously. There was an immediately united, informed body of women who drove the transvaginal mesh petition forward. The issue of hernia mesh was understood to be there but did not have the same profile.

What is depressing is that the pathway seems to be exactly the same: a lack of any subsequent follow-up to establish whether issues have arisen, a denial of the association of any issues with the mesh that has been fitted, and the calling into question of the motivations or understanding of those who are themselves feeling pain and that pain being dismissed as not real but imagined. Even during the debates on recent legislation, I was reluctant to conflate the two issues because I felt that we did not have the same body of evidence. As a consequence of our pursuit of this petition, the wider body of evidence is beginning to emerge. Therefore, I think that it is very much an issue that the committee should pursue further and that we should leave the petition open.

11:00

I would very much like to welcome the minister back to the committee. The minister should have the opportunity to properly consider the evidence that we have received from the Shouldice hospital. Taking evidence from representatives of the Shouldice hospital would be slightly problematic in terms of timing because they will not be working to the same clock as our committee—I imagine that they are all fast asleep at the moment—but we could think about that.

I would like to hear from the chief medical officer and the minister. I would certainly like to understand that evidence and flag up in advance the procurement of the particular mesh material because I do not understand why that has happened. All the issues look broadly similar. When we heard from the minister previously, the Government was working on informed consent procedures. That seemed fair enough, but we have been here before.

We can assume that there is now a broader body of men who have concerns. However, a number of men have contacted me to say that they have had perfectly successful mesh procedures and it has made a huge difference. I want to understand the volume and the relationship between those who feel that they have had successful mesh procedures and those who have had unsuccessful mesh procedures. In the case of transvaginal mesh, the balance was fundamentally on the side of those who had experienced serious health consequences. That may have to form the basis of any informed consent in the event that there is an argument for the mesh process proceeding.

Are we content to take and consider further evidence from those parties that have been suggested?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 16
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  8. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  10. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  15. 11:15 New Petition Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.